Post New Article

AI Is a gun, not a nuke

Original Article

Posted By: DVC, 9/14/2023 11:33:53 AM

It’s in vogue, as Artificial Intelligence becomes more sophisticated, to compare AI systems to nuclear weapons. Such analogies have come from traditional media like Bloomberg, niche internet microcelebrities, and the world’s most famous AI doomer, Eliezer Yudkowsky. But this comparison does not hold up to scrutiny. Game Theory -- the study of how rational actors interact with each other -- shows us why AI is not the threat it is made out to be. AI is more like a gun than a nuclear weapon. Nuclear weapons are unlike all other weapons because of their destructive power. If two nations have a nuclear exchange, both sides lose: Missiles will be in the air,

Comments:

This writer makes an excellent point, AI in the hands of everyone means we are all safer than if it is in the hands of only government or malevolent forces. He takes AI at closer to it's reality, that it is software that can sort through lots of pre-existing information and perhaps make useful connections of that information that haven't been previously made.

Post Reply

Reply 1 - Posted by: Jesuslover54 9/14/2023 12:36:54 PM (No. 1555953)
I read that the cost of AI is one out of four or five jobs. Like the courses you go to where they say look to your right and look to your left, one of you won't be here at the end of the semester. That's sort of the effects of AI.
0 people like this.

Reply 2 - Posted by: IowaDad 9/14/2023 12:53:46 PM (No. 1555963)
GPT-4 is an amazing product -- but it is only useful to add pleasantries to routine communications. Anybody who believes the frothy language that it generates so easily deserves to be fooled.
1 person likes this.

Reply 3 - Posted by: kono 9/14/2023 1:01:47 PM (No. 1555966)
AI is almost intelligent. More like almost almost intelligent, anyway. More accurately, though, it's automating ignorance, dumbing down the populace even further than the post boomer education system.
3 people like this.

Reply 4 - Posted by: DVC 9/14/2023 2:26:30 PM (No. 1555996)
The word "intelligence" has two meanings. And we have not been making it clear WHICH we mean when we are talking about AI. And the salesmen of AI are mixing the two meanings up all the time, probably out of ignorance, perhaps because they think they can sell it better if people think it is something that it is not. The first meaning of intelligence is like the old sense of the Central Intelligence Agency....intelligence is the result of putting together existing information to understand what a national adversary may do, or is doing. There is open source intelligence from publicly available sources and secret source intelligence...from non-public sources - like spies. The second meaning of intelligence is like the human ability to just "invent" or "imagine" things 'from nothing'. This sort of "intelligence" is almost a magical thing, we don't really understand exactly at it is, or how it occurs. Humans have intelligence in varying degrees, measurable with IQ tests. Animals have some sorts of it, but clearly a lot less than most humans. This second kind of intelligence includes self-awareness. The first kind of intelligence....gathering information and connecting it up useful ways - THAT kind of AI is very real, and can be very useful. This is how a computer wins at chess. The computer looks at all the possible moves and all the possible countermoves and chooses the most likely move to win. But it has little or nothing in common with the second form of intelligence, the kind of almost magical invention of things never before thought of that is actual human intelligence, and self awareness that machines cannot do or have.
3 people like this.

Reply 5 - Posted by: Laotzu 9/14/2023 2:27:12 PM (No. 1555997)
AI is a threat to the establishment, their propaganda infrastructure, and the firewalls they have established to maintain status quo. Hence, they want you to believe it's a threat to you. It's not. Nor was the invention of the transistor, the integrated circuit, the microprocessor, the desktop computer, or the internet (packet switched data). But when those things were invented, we did not have the seemless joinder of big business and government we have today.
3 people like this.

Reply 6 - Posted by: New Mexico Rider 9/15/2023 9:54:11 AM (No. 1556500)
I proudly wear my 'Artificial Intelligence is no match for Natural Stupidity' tee-shirt.
0 people like this.

Below, you will find ...
Most Recent Articles posted by "DVC"
and
Most Active Articles (last 48 hours)
Most Recent Articles posted by DVC"
Driverless Cars and, Oddly Enough, California's
Legislature in Harmony with its Voters
6 replies
Posted by DVC 9/15/2023 11:17:20 AM Post Reply
Two big questions (and lots of little ones) are on my mind today. The first big one is, how often is a bill practically unanimous in a state legislature? There’s a bill in California that seeks to ban driverless trucks over 10,000 lbs. Since cargo trucks can usually weigh as much as 80,000 lbs total (that’s counting everything – the vehicle, the cargo, the driver, a full tank of fuel, etc.), this bill covers everything from straight trucks to semi-trailers and similar big rigs. The ban – through at least 2031 – passed the state assembly in Sacramento back in May, 69 to 4.
CNN Hammers New Mexico Gov. Michelle Lujan
Grisham, Reads Constitution to Her
11 replies
Posted by DVC 9/14/2023 6:12:32 PM Post Reply
CNN’s Poppy Harlow interviewed New Mexico Gov. Michelle Lujan Grisham (D) on Tuesday and cornered her, reading the New Mexico Constitution to her on-air and asking if her ban on concealed carry violates the Constitution. Harlow read from Article II, Section 6, of New Mexico’s Constitution, saying, “No law shall abridge the right of the citizen to keep and bear arms for security and defense…No municipality or county shall regulate, in any way, an incident of the right to keep and bear arms.” She then asked Grisham, “Are you not in violation of both the U.S. Constitution and your state’s Constitution?” Grisham responded, “I don’t believe that we are.”
Climate Eugenics 4 replies
Posted by DVC 9/14/2023 12:49:23 PM Post Reply
Suppose the world was in the grip of an Armageddon-type crisis with the finest scientific minds from around the world working at a feverish pitch in an international collaborative effort to find a solution. So much so that medical and scientific journals were dedicated to keeping pace with the latest developments. No, I’m not talking about climate change. I’m talking about eugenics, the early 20th-century belief that there were too many of the wrong people in the world. One hundred years on, though, eugenics has fused with climate change for the perfect anti-human storm.
AI Is a gun, not a nuke 6 replies
Posted by DVC 9/14/2023 11:33:53 AM Post Reply
It’s in vogue, as Artificial Intelligence becomes more sophisticated, to compare AI systems to nuclear weapons. Such analogies have come from traditional media like Bloomberg, niche internet microcelebrities, and the world’s most famous AI doomer, Eliezer Yudkowsky. But this comparison does not hold up to scrutiny. Game Theory -- the study of how rational actors interact with each other -- shows us why AI is not the threat it is made out to be. AI is more like a gun than a nuclear weapon. Nuclear weapons are unlike all other weapons because of their destructive power. If two nations have a nuclear exchange, both sides lose: Missiles will be in the air,
The inevitable EV implosion 17 replies
Posted by DVC 9/12/2023 5:21:35 PM Post Reply
The electric vehicle honeymoon is over. Don’t expect the marriage itself to last much longer either. The mass conversion from internal combustion engine vehicles (ICEs) to electric vehicles was never more than a Democrat/environmentalist hallucination anyway. It was the most ill-conceived government policy objective in modern history. The transition should have been a non-starter. It’s riddled with numerous deal killers. It’s like having a dozen fatal diseases all at the same time. Any goal as massive as a total conversion from ICE vehicles to EVs requires careful planning and infrastructure preparation. It would necessitate a rapid doubling of electricity generation and grid expansion.
In order to save the whales, we must kill
the whales
4 replies
Posted by DVC 9/7/2023 3:57:55 PM Post Reply
That's how The Science™ works, boys and girls. Respect it, or be made to answer to the Department of Homeland Security, bigot. If you live on the East Coast of the U.S., chances are you've seen and/or heard tell of the increasing-in-frequency local news reports on the dead-whale-washing-up-on-shore phenomenon. Via Michael Shellenberger: "A new documentary, 'Thrown To The Wind,' by Director and Producer Jonah Markowitz, proves that the US government officials have been lying. The full film, which is at the bottom of this article, documents surprisingly loud, high-decibel sonar emitted by wind industry vessels when measured with state-of-the-art hydrophones.
In Huntington Beach, they're ready and
waiting for the COVID mask enforcers
3 replies
Posted by DVC 9/7/2023 3:52:22 PM Post Reply
The City of Huntington Beach, also known as "Surf City," situated between Los Angeles and San Diego on the California coast, could see the mask mandates creeping up on their political spyglasses on the horizon. So, they got proactive, according to this report from KTLA: Huntington Beach voted to ban mask and COVID-19 vaccine mandates across the city on Wednesday as cases continue rising across the state. Council members approved the ban 4-3 following an hours-long meeting that began on Tuesday night. The motion introduced by Mayor Pro Tem Gracey Van Der Mark was met with both supporters and detractors
A Renowned Vaccinologist and the Placebo-Controlled
Clinical Trials That Weren’t
7 replies
Posted by DVC 8/26/2023 4:28:13 PM Post Reply
What do you think of when you hear “placebo-controlled clinical trial?” Most people familiar with the term will understand it to be the standard way many drugs are tested in order to determine efficacy and safety before they are licensed and marketed to the general public. It’s usually understood to involve a pharmacologically inactive or inert pill with no active ingredient producing no medical effect as part of a control group used to draw a comparison between it and the experimental drug under inspection. But if you thought that this is what is used to test the safety of vaccines, you’d be wrong.
Button up Your Overcoat 11 replies
Posted by DVC 8/25/2023 6:40:02 PM Post Reply
The idea that carbon dioxide (CO2) drives global warming or “climate change” now enjoys unquestioned authority and near universal approval. As burgeoning public policy, nationally and in some states, it is seeping into what once were private matters of choice (e.g., light bulbs, kitchen cooktops). Many scientists, primarily physicists, consider the belief pure supposition, however, and colossally off track. John Stuart Mill observed in chapter six of his System of Logic, on ratiocination or logical thinking, that a doctrine may endure because inferences from it lead to ostensibly sound conclusions -- while belief in the doctrine’s truth may exist only by excluding evidence it is false.
Hyping a Hurricane Nothingburger 13 replies
Posted by DVC 8/21/2023 8:18:12 PM Post Reply
The Media Says The Deadly Hurricane Hilary Is Reeking Havoc All Across San Diego County, Souther California, The LA River Is Out Of Control…. Meanwhile California Residents Continue To Post Their Own Videos… The Media Says The Deadly Hurricane Hilary Is Reeking Havoc All Across San Diego County, Souther California, The LA River Is Out Of Control…. Meanwhile California Residents Continue To Post Their Own Videos…
VIDEO: A good, quick analysis about China’s
serious internal problems
10 replies
Posted by DVC 8/16/2023 10:52:09 PM Post Reply
China is a problem. It’s an immediate problem for Taiwan, but it’s also a long-term problem for America, given that it’s our greatest geopolitical enemy (no matter what Democrats say about Russia! Russia! Russia!). However, Ben Shapiro has put together an excellent short video detailing the structural problems that bedevil China and that put it both at risk of implosion and explosion. Over the years, I’ve written often about China, both the threat it poses and the weaknesses it has. I’ve covered its demographic problems, the way it’s overreached itself with its belt-and-road policies, its shaky internal economy, and its showy but surprisingly weak military.
The COVID mask holdouts 19 replies
Posted by DVC 8/15/2023 8:15:04 PM Post Reply
My son came back from shopping today a little stunned, as though he had seen a ghost. He was shocked to see a person in the grocery store still wearing a COVID mask. He immediately leapt to an analogy that has kept me laughing all day. Long after World War II ended, Japanese soldiers remained hidden in the jungles and caves of the Pacific islands, either unaware or unwilling to accept that Japan had surrendered.[snip] The last known of these holdouts, Teruo Nakamura, surrendered in 1975, [snip] it is safe to assume many more never came out and died unknown in hiding...or who knows?
Most Active Articles (last 48 hours)
Exclusive: Married South Dakota governor
Kristi Noem and Trump advisor Corey Lewandowski
have been having a years-long clandestine affair
35 replies
Posted by Imright 9/15/2023 9:59:59 AM Post Reply
A rising Republican star tipped by many to be Donald Trump's running mate should he win the presidential nomination has been involved in a clandestine affair for years, multiple sources tell DailyMail.com. Married South Dakota governor Kristi Noem, 51 – who stresses her belief in 'family values' – and Trump advisor Corey Lewandowski, who is also married, began carrying on in 2019, if not before. Now news of the relationship threatens to wreck Noem's chances of joining Trump's ticket in a potential rematch with President Joe Biden.
Ford CEO: We Won’t Give Workers Pay
Increases that Keep Us ‘from Investing
in This Transition to EVs’
34 replies
Posted by Hazymac 9/15/2023 7:00:53 AM Post Reply
On Thursday’s broadcast of CNN’s “The Lead,” Ford President and CEO Jim Farley stated that he’s not opposed to giving workers pay increases, “But if it prevents us from investing in this transition to EVs and in future products like the ones we have now like a new F-150,” they won’t do that because they’ll go bankrupt. While discussing the pay raises demanded by the UAW in negotiations and pay raises for CEOs, Farley said that they have offered pay raises and are open to big pay increases, but the 40% that the UAW is asking for is too much and would put the company out of
Chicago Mayor Brandon Johnson Wants to
Open City-Owned Grocery Stores
29 replies
Posted by mc squared 9/15/2023 2:01:25 PM Post Reply
Chicago Mayor Brandon Johnson (D) is looking into opening taxpayer-funded, city-owned grocery stores in areas in which businesses have pulled out due to rampant crime. Johnson announced a partnership with the Economic Security Project to look into the possibility of opening city-owned grocery stores. The first step in the partnership will be to perform a feasibility study, but the city did not provide a timeline, the Chicago Tribune reported. Johnson claimed his administration is “committed to advancing innovative, whole-of-government approaches to address these inequities.”
Biden Drops New Origin Story, Tells Rabbis
on High Holy Days Call About Being 'Raised'
in Synagogues
21 replies
Posted by Dreadnought 9/15/2023 10:07:27 AM Post Reply
At this point, the people in power behind the scenes at the White House have to be pulling their hair out over this question: How do you solve a problem like Joe Biden? As I wrote on Thursday, among the bad things he said were weird comments about Gov. Wes Moore's biceps and a racist comment about "African Americans, Hispanic workers, and veterans" as "you know, the workers without high school diplomas." He also just can't stop making things up and telling bizarre falsehoods. People trying to be charitable sometimes refer to these fantasies as trying to relate to their audience. But when you are falsely stealing an aspect
Mike Pence says he would consider a female
VP - but won't say if he would dine with
her after promising his wife he would
never be alone with another woman
20 replies
Posted by Imright 9/15/2023 9:28:29 PM Post Reply
Former Vice President Mike Pence said he'd be open to having a female vice president- but wouldn't say if he'd dine with her alone. Pence appeared at a town hall with Leland Vittert on NewsNation Wednesday and was asked about his much-talked-about deal the Republican struck with his wife Karen to never dine alone with another woman. Vittert then asked if that same rule would apply with a woman vice president - as presidents and vice presidents often have official lunches as part of their schedule.
Canadian school library removes all books
published prior to 2008
20 replies
Posted by ladydawgfan 9/15/2023 9:02:27 PM Post Reply
Every book published prior to 2008 has been removed from a public high school library in Canada to ensure that kids are not exposed to non-inclusivity. Yes, you read that correctly. Imagine the surprise of students at Erindale Secondary School in Mississauga, Ontario, when they entered the school's library last spring to discover...empty shelves. Staff told them, "If the shelves look emptier right now it's because we have to remove all books [published] prior to 2008." Why? Because "The Peel District School Board works to ensure that the books available in our school libraries are culturally responsive, relevant, inclusive,
Is Joe preparing to run his wife for 2024? 20 replies
Posted by FlyRight 9/15/2023 5:50:23 AM Post Reply
Wednesday's Cabinet meeting was most interesting. After a minute of introduction, President Biden turned the meeting over to his wife Jill, who continued to run it. This allows us a glimpse into the Democrat presidential strategy for 2024: run Jill Biden. In order for Jill to win the Democrat nomination for president, she needs to do several important things: 1. Box out Kamala Harris, Michelle Obama, and Gavin Newsom. 2. Maintain DNC support for Joe. 3. Keep Democrat contributors in line. 4. Do more and more of the president's job now.
UAW launches strike against Big 3 automakers 20 replies
Posted by Dreadnought 9/15/2023 12:46:25 AM Post Reply
A union representing nearly 150,000 autoworkers launched a strike early Friday morning against the Big 3 U.S. automakers -- General Motors, Ford and Stellantis. The United Auto Workers, or UAW, and the car manufacturers failed to reach a contract agreement before a deadline set by the union for Thursday at 11:59 p.m. ET. Less than two hours before the deadline, UAW president Shawn Fain announced the plants where union members would strike if a tentative agreement wasn't reached in time. By midnight Friday, that amounted to approximately 12,700 union workers, including ones at GM in Wentzville, Missouri; Stellantis in Toledo, Ohio; and Ford’s Wayne, Michigan plant.
Five Quick Things: Thanks for Everything,
Mitt — And Buh-Bye
19 replies
Posted by Mercedes44 9/15/2023 6:27:59 AM Post Reply
1. Another Bush Republican Bites the Dust The continuing purge of the dead wood that is the post-Reagan establishment “conservative” political class continues apace, though at a ferociously slow rate that threatens the future of the nation. Mitt Romney has finally gotten the message: U.S. Senator Mitt Romney will not seek reelection in 2024, capping a roller-coaster ride through Republican politics from the height of his party’s 2012 presidential nomination to the depths of tribal warfare in the age of Donald Trump. Casting aside the hopes and appeals of colleagues, including Senate Republican Leader Mitch McConnell, the 76-year-old
Dove faces growing boycott over partnership
with morbidly obese BLM activist and hate hoaxer
18 replies
Posted by Imright 9/15/2023 8:38:30 PM Post Reply
Beauty products giant Dove is facing calls for a boycott after it partnered with a morbidly obese Black Lives Matter activist and hate hoaxer who wrecked a white University of Virginia student’s life over a “racist” comment that she later acknowledged was “misheard” in the latest example of a major corporate brand that has been burned by wokeness. Apparently, the geniuses in Dove’s marketing department were unaware of the backlash that cost Bud Light and Target billions of dollars in market value earlier this year when they rolled out Zyahna Bryant for a “fat liberation” campaign despite her history of making false racial accusations.
Dove Faces Boycott for Partnering with
‘Fat Liberation’ Activist who Targeted
UVA Student for ‘Misheard’ Remark
17 replies
Posted by Beardo 9/15/2023 1:01:59 PM Post Reply
Personal care brand Dove is facing a boycott after partnering with Black Lives Matter and “fat liberation” activist Zyahna Bryant, who ruined a white UVA student’s life in 2020 over a “misheard” remark. Now, #BoycottDove is trending on X/Twitter. Dove recently partnered with Bryant — who spread a false rumor about a fellow University of Virginia (student) in 2020 — in a new and bizarre campaign to promote “fat liberation,” a move that resulted in the hashtag “#BoycottDove” to trend on X, formerly known as Twitter.
Striking Hollywood Actors and Writers
Escalate War with Studios: They’re ‘Behaving
Like Petty Tyrants’
17 replies
Posted by Dreadnought 9/15/2023 10:03:05 AM Post Reply
Striking Hollywood actors and writers escalated their war with the studios this week, participating in a joint march in Los Angeles that clogged the streets of the Hollywood neighborhood as protestors marched Tuesday from Netflix offices to the historic Paramount lot. Meanwhile, the actors union fired off an acrimonious salvo, accusing the studios and streamers of refusing to return to the bargaining table, with SAG-AFTRA leadership calling executives “petty tyrants.” The escalation is the latest sign that the historic strikes that have brought most of the industry to a standstill won’t be resolved any time soon. With little leverage to work with, and even less public goodwill,
Post New Article