Post New Article

SCOTUS Shoots Down Trump's Deployment
Of National Guardsmen To Chicago

Original Article

Posted By: J. Arthur Brown, 12/24/2025 7:24:54 PM

In a tough blow for the Trump administration, the U.S. Supreme Court shot down a bid by President Trump to deploy the National Guard to Chicago. (snip) In its order the majority claimed that, "At this preliminary stage, the Government has failed to identify a source of authority that would allow the military to execute the laws in Illinois." It further argued that Trump "has not invoked a statute that provides an exception to the Posse Comitatus Act," and that, "Instead he relies on inherent constitutional authority that (snip) allows him to use the military to protect federal personnel and property."

Comments:

Routine Federal immigration enforcement actions in Chicago were met with violent attacks on Federal property and enforcement personnel. In response, President Trump ordered the National Guard to Chicago for the limited purpose of protecting Federal personnel and property. The USSC majority's rationale for allowing a Resistance Judge's order staying this deployment raises several basic questions: (1) If the President lacks inherent authority to protect Federal personnel and property, what does s/he have inherent authority to do?; (2) Can the National Guard be used for limited protective purposes in the absence of an insurrection or general breakdown of law and order?; and (3) Do the three "Federalist judges" really prefer using regular military personnel (whose job is to kill foreign adversaries) to National Guard personnel (who are normal citizens trained and available to deal with civil disorders) for limited protective functions within the US?

Post Reply

Reminder: “WE ARE A SALON AND NOT A SALOON”

Your thoughts, comments, and ideas are always welcome here. But we ask you to please be mindful and respectful. Threatening or crude language doesn't persuade anybody and makes the conversation less enjoyable for fellow L.Dotters.


Reply 1 - Posted by: earlybird 12/24/2025 7:35:28 PM (No. 2045153)
Kavanauf and Barrett continue to disappoint. As for Roberts and the Three Blind Mice, they would only surprise if they showed Constitutional judgement.
26 people like this.

Reply 2 - Posted by: stablemoney 12/24/2025 7:44:49 PM (No. 2045155)
The SC issued a stay order, until arguments could be held. That is a lot different from "shoot down".
25 people like this.

Reply 3 - Posted by: Catfur27 12/24/2025 8:10:58 PM (No. 2045159)
..so Chicago thugs get to go on killing other Chicago thugs...no loss really
17 people like this.

Reply 4 - Posted by: jalo1951 12/24/2025 8:19:23 PM (No. 2045164)
You can't save everyone. Especially those that have decided to go down a different path. So let them. The citizens of Chicago own this one so let them live it. I think it was a poor decision on SCOTUS part but it's not totally over. In the meantime keep your head on a swivel and watch your back. Oh, and don't ride the L train. For some reason it draws the attention of those who like to stab people. No different than other blue cities.
17 people like this.

Reply 5 - Posted by: hershey 12/24/2025 9:18:28 PM (No. 2045176)
Heyjackass.com for the lastest stats from Chi-town...brutal and sad....
4 people like this.

Reply 6 - Posted by: singermom9 12/24/2025 10:47:29 PM (No. 2045185)
Sorry but I say let them destroy eachother. If you vote for this IT IS ON YOU. Why should we bother saving you from yourselves. This shows what happens when THE PEOPLE have NO MORALS. They are all ANIMALS and it is ALWAYS THEM'.
13 people like this.

Reply 7 - Posted by: Mike22 12/25/2025 12:33:55 AM (No. 2045198)
Given the plunge in crime, including murder, in locales where the Guard has been deployed, maybe the six just want more of Chicago's south side residents to die?
6 people like this.

Reply 8 - Posted by: TexasHillCountry 12/25/2025 1:01:22 AM (No. 2045201)
It would be one thing---still bad---if the thugs were only shooting each other. They have no regard for innocent by-standers who get caught in the crossfire or get hit by slugs that miss their intended targets and keep on going.
9 people like this.

Reply 9 - Posted by: Strike3 12/25/2025 7:35:51 AM (No. 2045227)
Trump did his job, Porky Pritzker and Brandon Johnson would rather have Chicago citizens continue to suffer attacks on the street and watch little children get gunned down in gang wars. My sympathy meter seems to be frozen on zero today.
6 people like this.

Reply 10 - Posted by: Red Jeep 12/25/2025 8:29:19 AM (No. 2045234)
Send in ICE, then.
3 people like this.

Reply 11 - Posted by: Samsquanch 12/25/2025 9:40:40 AM (No. 2045255)
The Dims are at war with the American citizens and apparently Coney and Kav won't stand in their way.
5 people like this.

Reply 12 - Posted by: bighambone 12/25/2025 10:21:15 AM (No. 2045271)
About the same time that the Supreme Court butted in with their order, the leftist Democrat Mayor of Minneapolis commented that ICE and the other Federal Officers Who are there enforcing the Immigration Laws could be killed (murdered) by Minneapolis residents?
2 people like this.

Reply 13 - Posted by: DVC 12/25/2025 12:24:49 PM (No. 2045317)
Other presidents have deployed the National Guard for various riot and civil rights purposes, dozens of times. Only Trump gets judicial pushback.
1 person likes this.

Reply 14 - Posted by: MickTurn 12/25/2025 3:24:34 PM (No. 2045394)
All Trump needs to do is declare a National Emergency causing the Safety of all citizens in named cities, PERIOD. That bypasses SCOTUS's Totally Ignorant Ruling!
0 people like this.

Reply 15 - Posted by: preciosodrogas 12/25/2025 9:02:57 PM (No. 2045448)
My feelings on this are let them tear each other to pieces, but there are good people there, and they need our help. There are different elements of law enforcement, such as the US Marshals and ICE. I want to see President Trump pursue this case. He tends to think about situations like this before going forward. It would be a significant victory, cementing his power to take these actions. The result would have the other states, mostly blue ones, fall in line, with crime rates falling and deportations climbing.
0 people like this.

Below, you will find ...
Most Recent Articles posted by "J. Arthur Brown"
and
Most Active Articles (last 48 hours)
Most Recent Articles posted by J. Arthur Brown"
Trump's Second Term Brings A Triple Dose
of Doubling Down On Policy Issues
2 replies
Posted by J. Arthur Brown 12/26/2025 9:43:10 AM Post Reply
Despite constant criticism from his detractors, Trump appears emboldened in his second term to persevere on issues he campaigned on (snip.) As President Trump prepares to ramp up his immigration crackdown next year, his second term has proven to be a case study in doubling down on hallmark agenda items like immigration, tariffs and eradicating DEI (Diversity, Equity, and Inclusion) initiatives from government. On the three issues on which he's received some of the most ardent and aggressive pushback, Trump has doubled down in ways that go beyond even his first term.
San Francisco Reparations: Will Mayor
Lurie Veto This Unconstitutional And Illegitimate Scheme?
8 replies
Posted by J. Arthur Brown 12/26/2025 9:09:49 AM Post Reply
After last week's near unanimous approval by San Francisco's Board of Supervisors (our 11-member city council) to establish a "fund" to accept and distribute so-called Reparations to qualified city residents, will Mayor Lurie veto it? (snip) Make no mistake, this figure goes far beyond a 7-figure payout. The 100-point Reparations proposal includes the highly-publicized $5 million lump-sum payments to eligible black adults, and adds annual income supplements to match the area median income for 250 years. It also features comprehensive black debt forgiveness, prioritizes housing assistance, and provides targeted programs in black education and black health. (snip)
Another Left-Wing Judge Just Decided He's
Got More Authority Than President Trump
9 replies
Posted by J. Arthur Brown 12/25/2025 1:17:09 PM Post Reply
On March 23, President Trump revoked the security clearances of several Biden administration officials and others, including Joe Biden, Kamala Harris, and Hillary Clinton.(snip) One of the people whose security clearance was revoked is attorney Mark Zaid.(snip) In May,  Zaid sued the Trump administration, with ABC describing Zaid as a "whistleblower attorney" who claimed his security clearance was revoked for "improper political retribution." In response to that suit, White House spokesman Harrison Fields said, "The decision to grant any individual access to the nation's secrets is a sensitive judgment call entrusted to the President (snip) and reviewing the President's clearance decisions falls well beyond the judiciary's authority." Now, a radical Leftist judge has ruled that President Trump cannot revoke Zaid's security clearance.
Somali Fraud Scheme Exposes Billions Siphoned
From US, One State Set To Crack Down
8 replies
Posted by J. Arthur Brown 12/25/2025 11:48:48 AM Post Reply
Somali fraud scheme not limited to Minnesota: Missouri State Treasurer Vivek Malek is imposing new requirements that remittance payment businesses ensure that customers are lawfully in the U.S. before they can send money to foreign countries. He hopes other states will follow suit. (snip) Malek said his research showed that more than $200 billion leaves the United States annually through remittances, with Mexico alone receiving $52 billion. Some sizable portion of that involves illegal immigrants, most of whom crossed the border during the Biden years.
Federal Judge Blocks Trump Admin's New
FEMA Grant Requirements
16 replies
Posted by J. Arthur Brown 12/25/2025 11:01:00 AM Post Reply
U.S. Magistrate Judge Amy Potter said the government failed to sufficiently justify the change in FEMA's Emergency Management Performance Grant program, which supports disaster readiness efforts, including training and staffing. (snip) The administration said in October that states need to recount their population figures and remove individuals who have been deported as a condition of funding, but a group of Democrat-led states sued over the new requirement last month.
USDA Intervenes In PG&E''s Planned Decommissioning
Of The Potter Valley Hydroelectric Project
11 replies
Posted by J. Arthur Brown 12/25/2025 9:46:41 AM Post Reply
The U.S. Department of Agriculture has intervened in the Potter Valley Hydroelectric Project proceedings currently being considered by the Federal Energy Regulatory Commission (FERC). (snip) If the plan goes through as proposed it will devastate hundreds of family farms and wipe out more than a century of agricultural tradition in in Potter Valley," said USDA Secretary Brooke Rollins. (snip) If those dams are removed (snip) more than 600,000 northern California residents, including hundreds of family farms, will lose a century-old water supply. State policymakers support these efforts. The Governor has openly boasted about removing dams across California to please environmental activists.
SCOTUS Shoots Down Trump's Deployment
Of National Guardsmen To Chicago
15 replies
Posted by J. Arthur Brown 12/24/2025 7:24:54 PM Post Reply
In a tough blow for the Trump administration, the U.S. Supreme Court shot down a bid by President Trump to deploy the National Guard to Chicago. (snip) In its order the majority claimed that, "At this preliminary stage, the Government has failed to identify a source of authority that would allow the military to execute the laws in Illinois." It further argued that Trump "has not invoked a statute that provides an exception to the Posse Comitatus Act," and that, "Instead he relies on inherent constitutional authority that (snip) allows him to use the military to protect federal personnel and property."
Georgia Judge Grants Investigating Board
Access To Fulton County 2020 Election Ballots
8 replies
Posted by J. Arthur Brown 12/24/2025 6:05:55 PM Post Reply
Fulton County Superior Court Judge Robert McBurney ruled that the Republican-led Georgia Election Board will have access to 2020 presidential ballots and documents, but it will have to cover the $400,000 cost of producing the materials. (snip) Fulton County Chairman Robb Pitts told Fox5 that the elections were open and transparent, and he insisted all votes were counted. He also asserted that Fulton County taxpayers will not be on the hook for the $400,000 that the production of the documents are estimated to cost.
After Raffensperger Downplays 2020 Election
Errors, Republicans Call For Federal Investigation
14 replies
Posted by J. Arthur Brown 12/24/2025 10:07:54 AM Post Reply
The tabulation tapes in question included 315,000 votes -- exponentially more than the 11,780 votes mentioned by President Trump in his fateful phone call to Raffensperger in January, 2021. Georgia Secretary of State Brad Raffensperger's downplaying of a 2020 election blunder as a mere "clerical error" has done little to quiet a growing backlash within his own party. Far from accepting Raffensperger's explanation that Fulton County's failure to properly sign tabulation tapes "does not erase valid, legal votes," 2020 election skeptics are calling for a federal investigation into what they view as a massive coverup. One state senator called for arrests and charges of treason.
Democrats Push For Epstein Files Boomeranged
With Clinton Featured Prominently Throughout
13 replies
Posted by J. Arthur Brown 12/24/2025 9:31:37 AM Post Reply
Democrat's push for the release of documents surrounding convicted sex offender and disgraced financier Jeffrey Epstein through a house vote appears to have backfired, as the disclosures intended to scrutinize Team Trump have instead spotlighted their own party's connections, including former President Bill Clinton's prominent mentions and salacious photos with the disgraced financier and/or young women. Clinton had long been married to Hillary Clinton at the time the photos were taken.
It Is Undeniable US Allowed Child Trafficking
During Afghan Withdrawal
11 replies
Posted by J. Arthur Brown 12/23/2025 6:52:08 PM Post Reply
It is an uncomfortable fact that the United States government was complicit in child trafficking during Operation Allies Refuge, the evacuation mission that began in July of 2021 when the United States withdrew from Afghanistan. What is most distressing is that the government quickly swept claims of forced marriage and sexual assaults under the rug. (snip) "[I]ntake staff at Fort McCoy reported multiple cases of minor females who presented as "married" to adult Afghan men as well as polygamous families. (snip) Rather than vigorously investigate these claims, the State Department waved them away, saying they "are anecdotal."
5 Years Too Late, Fulton County Proves
Trump's Call To Raffensperger Right
5 replies
Posted by J. Arthur Brown 12/23/2025 12:02:57 PM Post Reply
If nothing comes of Fulton County's admission, the implication will be that election laws can be treated as optional rather than binding. Fulton County made an admission that should have commanded national attention. During a hearing before the Georgia State Election Board, county officials acknowledged that approximately 315,000 early ballots cast in the 2020 presidential election were unlawfully certified yet were nevertheless included in Georgia's final, official results, in a race Joe Biden was officially declared to have won by just 11,779 votes.
Most Active Articles (last 48 hours)
Biden shares perplexing family Christmas
photo with himself hidden in back: ‘Where’s Joe?’
30 replies
Posted by ConservativeYankee 12/25/2025 1:54:55 PM Post Reply
WASHINGTON — For Christmas, former President Joe Biden gave everyone scrolling through X something to talk about by sharing a strange family photo — with himself hardly visible. Biden, 83, shared the image of himself and seven members of his family around 9 p.m. on Christmas Eve, writing: “Wishing you a peaceful and joyful Christmas Eve filled with love.” Surprisingly, the gaffe-prone 46th president wasn’t front and center, as is common for family patriarchs. Instead, former first son Hunter Biden, who once used the Secret Service code name “Chieftain,” and his adult daughter Maisy occupy the prime location. The ex-president’s own face is partially visible in a corner behind
Politico Frames European Christmas Celebrations
as ‘Far-Right Spectacle’
17 replies
Posted by Dreadnought 12/25/2025 12:10:47 PM Post Reply
Politico is framing the celebration of Christmas as a “far-right” front in Europe, arguing that Italian Prime Minister Giorgia Meloni and her party have made it a “spectacle.” Conservative social media users blasted the left-wing outlet’s Wednesday article, “How the far right stole Christmas,” authored by Rome correspondent Hannah Roberts. “Not a ‘far right’ concept.. politico is such a joke,” wrote podcast host Mel K: “Wow, imagine marking Christmas as being Christian. Revolutionary thinking in Europa,” wrote former Breitbart News journalist Chris Tomlinson: In the Christmas Eve piece, Roberts wrote that the holiday “is becoming a new front line in Europe’s culture wars,”
Federal Judge Blocks Trump Admin's New
FEMA Grant Requirements
16 replies
Posted by J. Arthur Brown 12/25/2025 11:01:00 AM Post Reply
U.S. Magistrate Judge Amy Potter said the government failed to sufficiently justify the change in FEMA's Emergency Management Performance Grant program, which supports disaster readiness efforts, including training and staffing. (snip) The administration said in October that states need to recount their population figures and remove individuals who have been deported as a condition of funding, but a group of Democrat-led states sued over the new requirement last month.
Islam And The West: Time For A Divorce 16 replies
Posted by Hazymac 12/25/2025 7:10:08 AM Post Reply
Islam is simply incompatible with Western civilization, and that couldn’t be more evident considering the 2025 Christmas and Hanukkah season. We get it rubbed in our faces, time and time again, with one massacre after another. These aren’t just lone gunmen who go nuts. These are organized terrorism cells. Bondi Beach, a massacre allegedly committed by two Muslims (father and son), is only the latest example. San Bernardino, California was the scene of a similar massacre by two Muslims (husband and wife). Nineteen Muslims, backed up by the wealth of other Muslims, gave us 9/11. Only Islam commands its followers to “kill the infidels.”
Newsmax host says there’s actually 44
million illegals and reveals Trump’s
ONLY option…
14 replies
Posted by earlybird 12/25/2025 1:09:52 PM Post Reply
For as long as anyone can remember, Americans have been told the same number over and over again. Eleven million illegal immigrants have taken up “space” in the USA. That’s the figure we’ve heard for what seems like decades now, like it’s carved in stone or something. But it’s just not adding up. It seems like that number didn’t budge much through waves of border surges. It feels like we’ve been told eleven million for a really long time, and quite frankly, a lot of people don’t buy it anymore.
Obama Foundation chief breaks silence
on controversial design of Obama's 'eyesore'
presidential library
13 replies
Posted by ConservativeYankee 12/26/2025 7:49:02 AM Post Reply
The CEO of the Obama Foundation offered an inside look at the former president's controversial presidential library, addressing lingering concerns over its design. The monumental project in Chicago is all compiled on a 20-acre campus filled with parks, playgrounds, and the 225-foot 'eye-sore' museum tower. The CEO of the Obama Foundation, Valerie Jarrett, told CBS News Chicago that they are excited to open their doors next June. Despite her enthusiasm, locals have raised concerns about its appearance. However, the CEO explained how this investment and project will demonstrate how diversity can 'better represent the community in which we're located and be a national model for how you can be inclusive and have a world-class
Migrant truckers sue California DMV over
canceled commercial drivers’ licenses
12 replies
Posted by ConservativeYankee 12/26/2025 7:22:58 AM Post Reply
The California DMV is facing a lawsuit brought on behalf of nearly 20,000 immigrant truckers over the state’s plans to revoke their commercial drivers’ licenses (CDLs). The Asian Law Caucus and the Sikh Coalition, along with the law firm Weil, Gotshal & Manges LLP, filed the lawsuit on Tuesday in an effort to stop the California DMV from canceling the CDLs, which the complaint says would “result in mass work stoppages” starting Jan 5, 2026. “This class-action lawsuit is brought on behalf of the Jakara Movement and five commercial drivers who have been deprived of their rights and livelihoods,” a joint statement from the Asian Law Caucus and Sikh Coalition said.
Trump launches Christmas night airstrikes
on ISIS 'Terrorist Scum' in Nigeria after
killings of Christians
12 replies
Posted by Dreadnought 12/25/2025 7:01:27 PM Post Reply
President Donald Trump said the U.S. launched airstrikes in northwest Nigeria on Christmas night targeting ISIS militants he accused of killing Christians, calling the operation decisive and warning further attacks would follow if the violence continues. "Tonight, at my direction as Commander in Chief, the United States launched a powerful and deadly strike against ISIS Terrorist Scum in Northwest Nigeria, who have been targeting and viciously killing, primarily, innocent Christians, at levels not seen for many years, and even Centuries!" Trump said Thursday on Truth Social. "I have previously warned these Terrorists that if they did not stop the slaughtering of Christians, there would be hell to pay
Gabbard suggests prominent Muslim group
wants Shariah law, New Jersey city fires back
12 replies
Posted by mc squared 12/25/2025 12:06:21 PM Post Reply
irector of National Intelligence Tulsi Gabbard claimed at a recent Turning Point USA AmericaFest event that the Council on American-Islamic Relations (CAIR) called for Sharia Law in the U.S. "Earlier this year, there was a conference that was held representing organizations like the Council on American Islamic Relations, also known as CAIR, which issued a call to action to use American legal and political systems to implement Sharia law," she declared. [snip] Gabbard specifically criticized the city of Paterson, New Jersey, which calls itself the first Muslim City. Gabbard said the town is working to implement Islamic principles in the local government.
Jimmy Kimmel's Christmas message to British
public sparks outrage: 'He should've stayed fired'
12 replies
Posted by Hazymac 12/25/2025 9:23:21 AM Post Reply
Jimmy Kimmel has been slammed as 'out of touch' and a 'joke' after it was revealed that he would be delivering an alternative Christmas Message about fascism to British audiences. The comedian is set to lecture Britons on the rise of authoritarianism on Channel 4's version of the traditional speech, which will run counter to the annual address given by King Charles on Christmas Day. Kimmel reportedly decided to use the speech to poke fun at 2025 as a 'great year' from a 'fascism perspective', in reference to his show being taken off the air for comments he made about the assassination of Charlie Kirk.
USDA Intervenes In PG&E''s Planned Decommissioning
Of The Potter Valley Hydroelectric Project
11 replies
Posted by J. Arthur Brown 12/25/2025 9:46:41 AM Post Reply
The U.S. Department of Agriculture has intervened in the Potter Valley Hydroelectric Project proceedings currently being considered by the Federal Energy Regulatory Commission (FERC). (snip) If the plan goes through as proposed it will devastate hundreds of family farms and wipe out more than a century of agricultural tradition in in Potter Valley," said USDA Secretary Brooke Rollins. (snip) If those dams are removed (snip) more than 600,000 northern California residents, including hundreds of family farms, will lose a century-old water supply. State policymakers support these efforts. The Governor has openly boasted about removing dams across California to please environmental activists.
Another Left-Wing Judge Just Decided He's
Got More Authority Than President Trump
9 replies
Posted by J. Arthur Brown 12/25/2025 1:17:09 PM Post Reply
On March 23, President Trump revoked the security clearances of several Biden administration officials and others, including Joe Biden, Kamala Harris, and Hillary Clinton.(snip) One of the people whose security clearance was revoked is attorney Mark Zaid.(snip) In May,  Zaid sued the Trump administration, with ABC describing Zaid as a "whistleblower attorney" who claimed his security clearance was revoked for "improper political retribution." In response to that suit, White House spokesman Harrison Fields said, "The decision to grant any individual access to the nation's secrets is a sensitive judgment call entrusted to the President (snip) and reviewing the President's clearance decisions falls well beyond the judiciary's authority." Now, a radical Leftist judge has ruled that President Trump cannot revoke Zaid's security clearance.
Post New Article