Post New Article

Alito dissent blasts NYC gun law, as Supreme Court punts on highly charged case

Original Article

Posted By: crankyyankee, 4/29/2020 10:56:37 AM

The Supreme Court on Monday refused to decide on the constitutionality of a controversial New York City gun law that has since changed, ruling in an unsigned opinion that the case is now "moot" because of the changes in the law. he court's move to even hear the gun rights case despite a perceived procedural issue previously drew veiled threats from Democratic senators who filed a brief in the case, saying "[t]he Supreme Court is not well. And the people know it. Perhaps the Court can heal itself before the public demands it be 'restructured in order to reduce the influence of politics.'"

Post Reply

Reply 1 - Posted by: Bill O Rights 4/29/2020 11:04:38 AM (No. 395357)
Another John "the spineless" Roberts special. It appears that he is trying to neuter Heller and McDonald by letting the lower courts run amuck.
13 people like this.

Reply 2 - Posted by: Jethro bo 4/29/2020 11:25:33 AM (No. 395401)
I see this as different. It appears there are at least 4 justices not satisfied with this law or its replay law. I suspect NY will be defending the replay law soon in court and NY knows it faces serious opposition at the SCOTUS. It might be one case the liberals don't want in front of the court cause it will eviscerate liberals 'common sense' 2nd amendment restriction laws they so love.
8 people like this.

Reply 3 - Posted by: Chuzzles 4/29/2020 11:36:32 AM (No. 395417)
They have been making veiled threats regarding the SCOTUS for awhile now, pretty much since Trump got elected. If anyone could face prosecution for their sins, I wish it would be Roberts. For his willingness to abandon his professionalism in supervising the FISA court, he should pay for that with whatever legal action they can make stick. I would even settle for him resigning, just get him OFF the court bench.
20 people like this.

Reply 4 - Posted by: iraengneer 4/29/2020 11:39:53 AM (No. 395420)
Meanwhile, the loathsome and utterly unconstitutional Sullivan Act, an open abridgment of "shall NOT be infringed", has been on the books since around 1911. Thanks to the evil scuzzballs called " progressives". If their is a pit beneath a privy in Perdition, may they reside there forever. I'll believe that important improvements are happening when that goes into the dump.
13 people like this.

Reply 5 - Posted by: hershey 4/29/2020 12:07:16 PM (No. 395456)
Those butt wipe democrats are only saying the Court is 'not well' because it isn't top heavy with liberals anymore...more and more I think aliens have arrived and inhabited only democrat/liberal humans...
5 people like this.

Reply 6 - Posted by: RidgePole 4/29/2020 12:46:47 PM (No. 395500)
Someone is not well and I think the dhimmi-c rats are projecting again.
3 people like this.

Reply 7 - Posted by: Clinger 4/29/2020 12:51:23 PM (No. 395505)
If they took the teeth out of this law what's left? What lasting purpose does it serve? Sounds to me like intentional ambiguity potentially turning a wrong turn into a crime. Not a law at all but a license for arbitrary rule.
5 people like this.

Reply 8 - Posted by: BarryNo 4/29/2020 1:05:43 PM (No. 395522)
The surest sign that we're not out of the woods yet is the Democrats continued attempts to threaten the highest court when they don't get their way. I would say we are at least as much in danger of succession and revolution as we were in 1850. And its for the same damn reasons. Democrats are natural totalitarians. They HATE freedom. They like slavery, when they are the Masters. They often like to speak about talent skill and creating a Leadership of the Intelligentsia... But in reality, its a narrow field that includes the Leadership. It is comprised of those people who agree with their absolute desire to rule with an iron hand, every inch of every place inhabited by intelligent life. Anyone who doesn't fit the criteria, could be an Eistein, a Marcus Aurelius, a Lord Byron, a Bill Gates... If they don't hold to the enslavement of their fellows in their hearts, they don't count as Intelligentsia.
8 people like this.

Reply 9 - Posted by: wakeupcall 4/29/2020 1:18:47 PM (No. 395536)
"restructured in order to reduce the influence of politics." You mean like the Marxist Communist democrats have been doing for forever. Until now, and that there are supposed to be 5 Constitution following justices and only 4 Marxist Communist democrats trying to legally send America into the Marxist Communist democrat controlled cesspool of the Globalists One World Government.
7 people like this.

Reply 10 - Posted by: curious1 4/29/2020 2:33:14 PM (No. 395580)
Restructured? OK, so just remove the 4 leftards (shrink the court slots to 5) and replace Roberts with the proposed RBG replacement.
3 people like this.

Reply 11 - Posted by: EQKimball 4/29/2020 3:00:17 PM (No. 395594)
SCOTUS at the least should have issued an order for amicus counsel to show cause why they should not be held in contempt for attempting to politically threaten the Court. The Court could have then levied a huge fine and disbarred them from practicing in the federal courts. .
3 people like this.

Reply 12 - Posted by: DVC 4/29/2020 3:09:23 PM (No. 395604)
Probably best not to try to hang important Supreme Court rulings on moot cases. It is good that the NY folks freaked out and KNEW that they couldn't get that law to pass muster, so quickly erased it before the court could act to create a real precedent. Basically, the NY folks ran scared. I have been working on 2nd Amendment issues (years sending out 7,000 newsletters a month that I wrote as communications director for a large KS gun rights organization, testifying regularly at legislative hearings, and helping to pass and write several gun rights laws, helping to defeat several bad gun laws, writing some of our the concealed carry regulations) since I first got a letter to the editor published against what became the 1968 Gun Control Act when I when I was 16, and had already bought several guns through the mail - legally, then. One thing I have learned is that rolling this hell storm back is a slow, difficult process. It is necessary to find "the right case" and bring it before "the right court" at "the right time". Unfortunately, if you have a weak case or the court is packed with leftists, or the public mood isn't amenable....it is (very sad to say) better to leave that one and wait for all things to be right. Heller and McDonald are HUGE big deals. And we need to carefully build upon those cases, and be very alert not to fail in that process due to a weak case. A moot case is weak, not a great foundation to build a lasting 2nd Amendment recovery upon. A "live to fight another day" sort of a thing, which is never very satisfying, for certain. We ARE winning. More and more people realize that gun control is NOT the answer. I was at two big gun stores today, looking for a specific handgun for a friend. Both stores were low on stock, selling rapidly, restocking and selling out again, and ammo sales have been frantic, shelves are nearly bare in one HUGE store. People are more and more realizing that they need their gun rights, and less willing to have them taken away or limited.
3 people like this.

Reply 13 - Posted by: lakerman1 4/29/2020 9:22:24 PM (No. 395843)
As an arbitrator, I never decided issues that were not before me.and while i appreciate Justice Alito's dissent, he is incorrect.
0 people like this.

Below, you will find ...
Most Recent Articles posted by "crankyyankee"
and
Most Active Articles (last 48 hours)
Most Recent Articles posted by crankyyankee"
A battle between farmers and ‘trust-fund hippies’: How a 170-foot Trump sign is dividing one Virginia county 20 replies
Posted by crankyyankee 9/28/2020 4:16:45 PM Post Reply
It was two weeks before anyone spoke of the hay bales. This was odd, said Rachel Rowland, of Flint Hill, Va. — because the locals had certainly seen them: The display is 170 feet wide. Wrapped in glinting white plastic, the bales are stacked atop a rolling mountain hillside along Route 211, relaying their message to any nearby resident who drives to the closest grocery store. “Farmers for Trump 2020,” the bales say, hand-painted with red and blue capital letters. “Keep America Great.”
State Dept. Cables Warned of China’s Wuhan Lab Two Years Ago: ‘Serious Shortage’ of Trained Staff 7 replies
Posted by crankyyankee 7/18/2020 7:05:12 PM Post Reply
Two State Department cables in 2018 warned that a new laboratory in Wuhan did not have enough trained personnel to operate it safely while it was studying SARS-like coronaviruses isolated from bats, according to the cables that were published on Friday after a Freedom of Information Act request. A cable sent from the U.S. Embassy in Beijing on January 19, 2018, notified Washington that China had opened the Wuhan Institute of Virology, its first Biosafety Level 4 (BSL-4) laboratory, and that the lab’s leadership considered it ready for research on class-four pathogens (P4) — the most virulent viruses that pose a high risk of person-to-person transmission.
Alito dissent blasts NYC gun law, as Supreme Court punts on highly charged case 13 replies
Posted by crankyyankee 4/29/2020 10:56:37 AM Post Reply
The Supreme Court on Monday refused to decide on the constitutionality of a controversial New York City gun law that has since changed, ruling in an unsigned opinion that the case is now "moot" because of the changes in the law. he court's move to even hear the gun rights case despite a perceived procedural issue previously drew veiled threats from Democratic senators who filed a brief in the case, saying "[t]he Supreme Court is not well. And the people know it. Perhaps the Court can heal itself before the public demands it be 'restructured in order to reduce the influence of politics.'"
Yes, Virginia's Governor Has Made It a Crime
for More Than 10 People to Attend
a Church Service
32 replies
Posted by crankyyankee 3/25/2020 2:05:01 PM Post Reply

Virginia Gov. Ralph Northam issued an executive order on Monday that is aimed at stopping the new coronavirus — and, in the process, makes it a criminal offense to hold a church service attended by more than 10 people. Yes, his order makes it a crime for more than 10 people to gather in a church. There are two passages in the text of the governor's order that are relevant to this.

What Rush Means To Us, And To Me 18 replies
Posted by crankyyankee 2/5/2020 12:43:16 PM Post Reply
It’s a tribute to the great Rush Limbaugh that the reaction to his cancer diagnosis by the tens of millions of people he inspired was not to be devastated but to focus and to resolutely offer their thoughts and prayers in his fight. And he will fight – he’ll fight this like he has fought everything and everyone else that tried to take him out over the last third of a century. He is the archetypal conservative brawler, a no-apologies, no-excuses conservative who never submitted, never allowed himself to be domesticated and neutered by the elite.
Most Active Articles (last 48 hours)
Biden's Incoherence Just Hit Critical Mass,
This Is Scary Awful
48 replies
Posted by Dreadnought 3/8/2021 11:45:49 PM Post Reply
As we reported two days ago, Joe Biden completely made no sense when he was trying to explain the Wuhan coronavirus relief bill. It was really bad and it explains why they’re afraid to have him deliver an address to Congress or do any kind of a real solo press conference, because at this point they have to be afraid this is all going to fall apart if he does anything live and this all becomes too obvious to the American people. But there’s only so long that they can hold this off. And it’s getting worse, as video today revealed. Biden was holding an event to announce the nomination
‘Huge Development’: Democrat Sen. Joe
Manchin Starts To Crack On Filibuster,
Signals Openness To Change
41 replies
Posted by Imright 3/8/2021 12:32:41 AM Post Reply
Democrat Senator Joe Manchin (WV) appears to have started to shift his views on the filibuster with remarks that he made on two news shows on Sunday morning.The shift from Manchin comes after he has repeatedly stated that he would not vote to end the filibuster, despite pressure from the far-Left. During the interviews on Sunday, Manchin repeatedly claimed that he was not open to ending the filibuster because he did not want to strip the minority party of their power in the Senate, but signaled that he was open to changing it.Fox News host Chris Wallace asked Manchin if he would consider “reforming the filibuster” if “Republicans
Evangelicals For Biden ‘Feel Used And Betrayed’
By Biden Fulfilling His Radical Abortion Promises
37 replies
Posted by Calvinesq 3/8/2021 10:37:51 AM Post Reply
In an open letter released Sunday, Pro-Life Evangelicals for Biden urged him to “honor his commitment” and include the Hyde Amendment in Democrats’ $1.9 trillion COVID-19 spending package, writing “we feel used and betrayed.” The letter states: We are very disappointed about the COVID-19 relief package’s exclusion of the Hyde Amendment, a longstanding bipartisan policy that prevents taxpayer funding for abortion. [snip] As pro-life leaders in the evangelical community, we publicly supported President Biden’s candidacy with the understanding that there would be engagement [with] us on the issue of abortion and particularly the Hyde Amendment
Meghan Markle reveals her true
self in Oprah interview
32 replies
Posted by Imright 3/8/2021 9:11:10 AM Post Reply
If you had any doubts that Meghan Markle is a manipulative piece of work, her bombshell Oprah interview Sunday night dumping on the British monarchy would set you straight. Prince Harry’s American wife accused his family of hateful racism against her baby, claimed they refused to protect her and drove her to the point of suicide.She made the incendiary and implausible charge that when she was pregnant with Archie, the royal family decreed that her unborn son would be denied the title of “prince” because her mixed race meant he might have dark skin.
Biden’s German Shepherds Shipped Back
to Delaware After ‘Biting Incident’
Involving White House Security
31 replies
Posted by Imright 3/8/2021 11:38:50 PM Post Reply
Joe and Jill Biden’s German Shepherds were shipped back to Delaware after a “biting incident” involving White House security, CNN reported.Major was adopted by Joe Biden and his handler wife Jill in 2018 from an animal shelter.Major and Champ moved into the White House in January and they’re already gone. The condition of the victim was not disclosed but it was serious enough to remove both dogs from the White House.CNN reported: The two German Shepherds belonging to President Joe Biden and first lady Jill Biden were returned to the Biden family home in Delaware last week
Pelosi’s HR1 bill a blatant power grab for Democrats 30 replies
Posted by FlyRight 3/8/2021 5:28:52 AM Post Reply
Nancy Pelosi’s top priority is to turn America into a one-party nation ruled by Democrats. Her bill HR 1 trashes the U.S. Constitution in an attempt to rig the system and make it virtually impossible to elect a Republican president or Congress again. It’s a power grab. The bill eviscerates state voting laws and forces all the states to conform to a set of rules that includes automatic voter registration. Anyone who goes to a DMV or applies for food stamps, Medicaid or other social services, or attends a public college will be automatically enrolled to vote. Noncitizens are obligated to identify themselves and opt out,
Biden seems to forget defense
secretary’s name, calls him
'the guy who runs that outfit'
29 replies
Posted by Ribicon 3/8/2021 8:37:17 PM Post Reply
President Biden on Monday seemed to forget Defense Secretary Lloyd Austin’s name at a White House event—calling the Pentagon chief “the guy who runs that outfit over there.” Biden was announcing the nomination of two female generals to lead US military combatant commands. “And I want to thank the sec—the, the, ah former general. I keep calling him general, but my, my—the guy who runs that outfit over there,” Biden said.(Snip) Earlier at the event, Biden mentioned the Defense Department leader by his name, “Secretary Austin,” while appearing to read from a teleprompter.
Oprah interview bombshells: Meghan claims
she was suicidal when she was five months
pregnant, Kate made HER cry and Royals
refused to make Archie a prince because
they were worried how 'dark' he would be
27 replies
Posted by Imright 3/8/2021 8:21:02 AM Post Reply
The Royal Family was left reeling this morning after Meghan Markle tearfully revealed that the stress of royal life made her suicidal when she was five months pregnant, claimed Archie was denied the title of prince because he is mixed-race and said Kate Middleton made her cry before she married Harry in a bombshell interview with Oprah Winfrey.The couple also chose to reveal that they are having a baby girl to the tens of millions of people watching the CBS show broadcast in the US before accusing the Royal Family of racism and revealing the deep rift 'Megxit' has caused with Prince Charles and Prince William.
Meghan Markle openly
accuses the Royals
of racism
26 replies
Posted by Magnante 3/8/2021 5:26:07 AM Post Reply
I’m probably second to none in my dislike for Meghan Markle. There’s something unattractive about a mature woman marrying into the British Royal family with one of the world’s most expensive weddings, hanging out with the Queen, living in insane luxury…and then whining non-stop about the horror of her life. There’s something even less appealing when that woman accuses the Royal family of race hatred. And the problem is that, when it comes to that left-wing diva, Meghan Markle, it’s hard to believe most of what she says. After weeks of hype, CBS finally televised Meghan Markle and Prince Harry’s interview with Oprah.
Watch: John Solomon Gives Stunning Update
in Durham’s ‘Russiagate’ Investigation
24 replies
Posted by Imright 3/8/2021 4:56:55 PM Post Reply
Without question, the vast majority of Americans who support former President Donald Trump were angry and frustrated throughout 2020 passed with barely a mention of then-U.S. Attorney John Durham’s criminal investigation into the FBI’s fraudulent “Russiagate” counterterrorism operation directed at his 2016 campaign.In the weeks before the November election, word got out that then-Attorney General William Barr wasn’t going to announce any indictments or even a report on Durham’s investigation because he did not want to influence the outcome.So far, in fact, the only indictment to come out of the Durham probe is that of former FBI lawyer Kevin Clinesmith, who essentially got a slap on the wrist
Democrats renew calls to remove
J. Edgar Hoover's name from FBI building
24 replies
Posted by Ribicon 3/8/2021 2:56:29 PM Post Reply
Rep. Steve Cohen vowed to renew the push to remove former FBI Director J. Edgar Hoover’s name from the bureau’s downtown Washington headquarters, according to an interview released Monday. Appearing on Yahoo! News’ Skullduggery podcast, the Tennessee Democrat said the effort is getting a fresh look after the release of a new movie highlighting the FBI’s secret program to discredit civil rights activists. The Washington Times in 2019 first reported Democrats’ bid to strip the longtime FBI director’s name from the bureau’s headquarters. Mr. Cohen said the impetus to revive the bid is the new movie, “Judas and the Black Messiah.” The movie details
Jill Biden, the Meghan Markle
in the WH, is egregiously
guilty of elder abuse
23 replies
Posted by Magnante 3/9/2021 4:40:38 AM Post Reply
“There must have been a moment, at the beginning, when we could have said –-no. But somehow we missed it.” Tom Stoppard The millions of Americans who were paying attention throughout the 2020 election campaign all became painfully aware of the fact that Joe Biden’s cognitive abilities were slipping and slipping fast. His wife, as the person closest to him, should have been the one to call the campaign quits in order to reduce stress on the man. Instead, apparently so anxious to become the First Lady by any means necessary, Mrs. Biden continued to push her failing husband’s campaign forward as if he were mentally qualified.
Post New Article