Post New Article

Some thoughts on why Handel's Messiah
at Christmas is so compelling

Original Article

Posted By: Judy W., 12/26/2022 6:56:12 AM

At Christmas, instead of a lot of pop Christmas songs, I have been listening to passages from Handel's Messiah" oratorio, including the powerfully beautiful Christmas-oriented "For unto us a child is born" based on the writings of the Prophet Isaiah, and the soaringly magnificent Hallelujah Chorus. To hear these, compared to everything else makes me ask if this was the pinnacle of human musical achievement? Will there ever be anything greater? An argument can be made for it at least this far. This oratorio, after all, is touched by eternity.

Post Reply

Reply 1 - Posted by: MOBeef4u 12/26/2022 7:38:35 AM (No. 1364767)
To this day, many decades later, I can still remember singing this in my all-girl high school glee club. We even had the opportunity to join with an all boys high school to sing this in all the parts. We loved it so much that when Sr. Marcena, our director, gave us the choice of singing something to fill out the class time we invariably chose the "Hallelujah Chorus"; (except during Lent of course). Hearing this piece is one thing, singing it takes the joy to a whole different level. Nothing today rivals it.
36 people like this.

Reply 2 - Posted by: lakerman1 12/26/2022 7:44:36 AM (No. 1364769)
My days in High School ended in January 1956, when I dropped out and joined the U.., Air Force. (I took the GED exam while in basic training, and my father submitted the test results to the School Board, and over the objections of school admiistrators, graduated with my classmates. My test scors were too high to turn away. (The local newspaprer 'inadvertently' printed my name upside down, in thr list of graduates, which I thought was cool.) There were few inspirational teachers in my school, and some who added no value to the product, Donald Groomes, English, being one of them. The most inspirational teacher, viewed by most of us, was Mr. McDonald, who had just finished fighting WWII as a Marine. McDonald had the aura of genius about him, along with a violent hair trigger temper. (He once punched a school boad member's son, a tenor, off the top riser in Chorus.) McDonald chose to put on parts of the Messiah for our Christmas program. (We didn't hsve the strings to do justice to some of it.) It took great courage for a high school music teacher to move beyond Here Comes Santa Claus to Handel's Messiah.Singing in that production was one of the great experiences of my life. And I suspect Mr. McDonald knew that.
28 people like this.

Reply 3 - Posted by: foxglove 12/26/2022 9:04:11 AM (No. 1364807)
Thank you for posting this excellent article examining the different music we hear at Christmas. She asks if Handel’s music would be applauded by God. I say it was. The story is told that upon completing Messiah Handel was found in tears by his servant and said “I thought I saw the great God himself and angels singing”. Undoubtedly Handel was the capable conduit for this Heaven sent music.
25 people like this.

Reply 4 - Posted by: red1066 12/26/2022 9:22:13 AM (No. 1364814)
Handel's Messiah encapsulates the meaning of Christmas. There's no commercial meaning in it. It's all about the celebration and miracle of Christ's birth. I never get tired of listening to it. Even if I happen to hear it in the middle of summer. It's one of those musical pieces that makes me want to stand up and start to conduct. It never fails to bring a tear to my eye.
19 people like this.

Reply 5 - Posted by: udanja99 12/26/2022 9:54:10 AM (No. 1364836)
I can’t carry a tune in a bucket so have never sung one note of it, but every time I hear it, I get goosebumps.
17 people like this.

Reply 6 - Posted by: Highlander 12/26/2022 10:19:06 AM (No. 1364855)
I read, years ago, Handel wrote the piece in less than a month, driven by inspiration and love of God. We had great and wonderful geniuses in those times, never again.
14 people like this.

Reply 7 - Posted by: texaspast 12/26/2022 10:50:26 AM (No. 1364875)
Yes, he wrote the entire thing (the score, anyway) in 24 days. I've sung it many times. I have 'aged out' of the solo parts (thankfully) but the experience of singing it during the Christmas season is fantastic! Several years ago I heard a recording of The Messiah done by a Dublin choir using the orchestration and libretto from the first performance, which was done in Dublin. Hearing that choir, with the rather straight-toned sopranos and altos, brought a whole new experience of the piece. Those 'quavers' that Handel wrote into the solo parts made much more sense when the singer didn't have a very pronounced vibrato which all classically trained musicians have now.
12 people like this.

Reply 8 - Posted by: 3XALADY 12/26/2022 11:09:07 AM (No. 1364890)
I participated in The Messiah when I was in high school at the School of the Ozarks in probably 1960 or 1961. I sing the alto part and to this day can still sing every note. It is so beautiful and has such a message.
14 people like this.

Reply 9 - Posted by: RockiesFan 12/26/2022 11:16:00 AM (No. 1364896)
From the first chords of the overture, The Messiah is so beautiful and wonderful it inspires comfort, peace, appreciation and the Glory of God all at once. Singing the Hallelujah chorus in high school choir was a thrill. The orchestration of He Shall Feed is Flock is so moving it endures goosebumps, and the chorus Glory to God imagines angels dancing around singing. Take a break from modern life and listen to The Messiah in its entirety. It will rejuvenate you and bring hope. He shall reign forever and ever, indeed.
13 people like this.

Reply 10 - Posted by: smokincol 12/26/2022 11:59:18 AM (No. 1364924)
"compelling" is an apt descriptor to explain Messiah but one must attend a performance, by an organized and well orchestrated company to really "get" it.
6 people like this.

Reply 11 - Posted by: Robert Jones 12/26/2022 7:32:52 PM (No. 1365101)
Christmas is torally out of style with our intelligensia. Our neighbor is an accomplished opera singer. When at the University of Pittsburg their daughter sang for the Christmas program . Forget Jingle Bells, no Ave Maria, and no Handel’’s Messiah! I am no opera buff, and I couldn’t recognize one song. I liked Handel the first time I heard him.
3 people like this.

Reply 12 - Posted by: ladydawgfan 12/27/2022 1:09:57 AM (No. 1365209)
I am a soprano and I have sung the Messiah many times, sometimes with the church choir, occasionally with local "Sing-it-Yourself" productions, and sometimes as an audience member listening to other exquisite voices give Glory to the King through music. My soul is happier when I can hear the Messiah at Christmas!!
2 people like this.

Reply 13 - Posted by: mamabear 12/27/2022 2:51:02 AM (No. 1365218)
Handels Messiah is beautiful and effective because it is word for word taken from Scripture. It is the story of the life of Jesus Christ and the redemptive mission He completed on our behalf. God was in Christ reconciling the world back to Himself. I think the most beautiful and eloquent section of the libretto is PART 2: 22. Chorus – “Behold the Lamb of God, that taketh away the sin of the world.” (John 1, v.29) 23. Air (mezzo-soprano) – “He was despised and rejected of men; a man of sorrows, and acquainted with grief. (Isaiah 53, v.3); “He gave his back to the smiters, and his cheeks to them that plucked off the hair: he hid not his face from shame and spitting.” (Isaiah 50, v.6) 24. Chorus – “Surely he hath borne our griefs, and carried our sorrows: he was wounded for our transgressions, he was bruised for our iniquities: the chastisement of our peace was upon him;” (Isaiah 53, vv.4–5) 25. Chorus – “And with his stripes we are healed.” (Isaiah 53, v.5) 26. Chorus – “All we like sheep have gone astray; we have turned every one to his own way; and the Lord hath laid on him the iniquity of us all.” (Isaiah 53, v.6) Another gorgeous work by George Frideric Handel's is "The Arrival of the Queen of Sheba" from the oratorio Solomon. Perfect replacement for Lohengrins Wedding March. Happy New Year all! :-)
2 people like this.

Reply 14 - Posted by: ussjimmycarter 12/27/2022 3:22:53 AM (No. 1365226)
Handle wrote this over 12 days! Both music and vocals! Pure inspired genius!
2 people like this.

Reply 15 - Posted by: msjena 12/27/2022 8:32:48 AM (No. 1365329)
Would a public school try to put this on today? Or would they find it "offensive."
2 people like this.

Below, you will find ...
Most Recent Articles posted by "Judy W."
and
Most Active Articles (last 48 hours)
Most Recent Articles posted by Judy W."
‘Extremely Irresponsible’: Expert
Warns China’s Border Reopening Amid
COVID Surge May Trigger Global Pandemic Resurgence
19 replies
Posted by Judy W. 12/29/2022 7:55:06 AM Post Reply
A health expert has sharply criticized the Chinese regime’s lifting of international travel restrictions in the midst of a massive COVID wave sweeping through the country, saying the move is “extremely irresponsible” and could cause a global resurgence of the pandemic. The National Health Commission announced on Dec. 26 that the country would end all quarantine requirements for inbound travelers from Jan. 8, 2023. Travelers will need to obtain a negative PCR test within 48 hours of departure, it said. Currently, travelers entering China need to undergo five days of mandatory quarantine in an approved facility, followed by three days at home.
Ten major revelations exposing extent
of government pressure on Big Tech to
censor Americans
6 replies
Posted by Judy W. 12/28/2022 5:20:56 AM Post Reply
Two hundred and thirty-one years ago this month, America's founders enshrined free speech as the first protection in the ratified Bill of Rights with a declaration that the government could not infringe expression. A series of blockbuster revelations at the end of 2022 show just how imperiled those protections have become in the era of Big Tech. From Elon Musk’s "Twitter files" to an FBI agent's candid testimony, Americans have gotten a glimpse into a once-hidden enterprise where federal agencies pressured social media platforms – directly and through proxies – to censor content under their terms of service. The goal, it appears, was to preserve the ruling elite's favored narratives
Some thoughts on why Handel's Messiah
at Christmas is so compelling
15 replies
Posted by Judy W. 12/26/2022 6:56:12 AM Post Reply
At Christmas, instead of a lot of pop Christmas songs, I have been listening to passages from Handel's Messiah" oratorio, including the powerfully beautiful Christmas-oriented "For unto us a child is born" based on the writings of the Prophet Isaiah, and the soaringly magnificent Hallelujah Chorus. To hear these, compared to everything else makes me ask if this was the pinnacle of human musical achievement? Will there ever be anything greater? An argument can be made for it at least this far. This oratorio, after all, is touched by eternity.
Deep State Suspicions 6 replies
Posted by Judy W. 12/18/2022 7:35:49 AM Post Reply
I wonder if it’s because so many of us lost faith in the federal government after its absurd overreactions, bad public health policies, and demonstrable lies respecting COVID, or is it just the passage of time and changes at the top making it harder to keep secrets, but this week both the FBI and CIA are in the line of fire. The CIA Sixty years after the assassination of President John F. Kennedy, the National Archives and Records Administration has finally released over 13,000 records in its possession relevant to that tragic event. Some 3% of the records are still being hidden from us. Why?
Hospice in Crisis 10 replies
Posted by Judy W. 12/16/2022 6:33:43 AM Post Reply
Both my parents left this earth under the beneficent care of hospice professionals who kept them comfortable and at peace. (Snip) In recent years I have been hearing disturbing stories of hospice failings — things such as too much pain control to speed up the dying or inadequate services. Now, one of the nation’s top palliative-care doctors is sounding the alarm. From “Hospice care needs saving,” by Ira Byock: As a palliative care physician who has contributed to hospice care and kept my finger on its pulse for more than four decades, I have been dismayed to witness the increasing frequency and severity in lapses in this type of care.
A tradition unlike any other 5 replies
Posted by Judy W. 12/15/2022 8:14:08 AM Post Reply
Americans love to cleave to cultural traditions that have stood the test of time — especially ones that tell stories of the people who formed their communities, stories that reflect the craftsmanship, sacrifice and hard work of those who came before us. When inventor and master tinkerer Joshua Lionel Cowen designed an electric fan operated by dry cells—and then, using the same motor that drove the fan, built a miniature railroad car—he began a business and a movement that has enthralled millions of people young and old. Hobbyists not only bought trains and track, but also often created elaborate homemade displays enjoyed by family and friends over the Christmas holidays.
Black Guns Matter 9 replies
Posted by Judy W. 12/15/2022 6:27:13 AM Post Reply
We know about Black Lives Matter. My new video is about a group called Black Guns Matter. Maj Toure, a Philadelphia high school dropout-turned-activist, tells me he started it after he got tired of hearing people endless chanting, “Black lives matter,” but saying nothing “when it’s time for black people to defend their lives.” Toure carries a gun wherever he goes. “This is my human right,” he says. “If anybody wants to come chase me down about that, let’s go to court.” (Snip) “The only thing that’s going to stop evil are good, solid people strong enough to stop them.” He sells a T-shirt withthe slogan “Make criminals afraid again”
Psychotherapist: I Warned About Sam Brinton,
the Nonbinary Biden Official Now Arrested
for Theft, but No One Listened
19 replies
Posted by Judy W. 12/13/2022 7:34:45 AM Post Reply
A licensed psychtherapist who testified against laws banning so-called conversion therapy says he warned Americans about Sam Brinton, the non-binary Biden administration nuclear official who is facing charges for allegedly stealing two pieces of luggage at two separate airports. “My colleagues and I warned lawmakers in California and Massachusetts, and the LGBT activist groups which were sponsoring him, about Sam Brinton’s ever-changing story about abuse he allegedly underwent in therapy because of his LGBT attractions,” Dr. Joseph Nicolosi, Jr., the therapist and founder of the Reintegrative Therapy Association, said. “But nobody cared, so Brinton’s testimony about his alleged experience played a key role in banning legitimate practices across the nation.”
Rasmussen poll shows the COVID vaccines
are not safe
9 replies
Posted by Judy W. 12/11/2022 4:23:55 AM Post Reply
Rasmussen polled the American people with a simple four question survey and found that my polls were accurate and so was the V-safe data and so was the Israeli Ministry of Health safety report that nobody wants to see. The Rasmussen poll of 1,000 Americans found that: 32% were not vaccinated 7% of those surveyed had a major side effect. A 7% major side effect rate is unprecedented. We know from the V-safe data that this effectively means that the side effect was so bad, they had to seek medical attention. If any drug had that kind of safety profile, it would be immediately pulled from the market.
The Guardian: Arctic Was 11-19C Warmer
2 Million Years Ago
29 replies
Posted by Judy W. 12/10/2022 4:46:47 AM Post Reply
The Guardian just reported the results of a study of 2 million-year-old DNA found in northern Greenland. Two-million-year-old DNA from northern Greenland has revealed that the region was once home to mastodons, lemmings and geese, offering unprecedented insights into how climate change can shape ecosystems. The breakthrough in ancient DNA analysis pushes back the DNA record by 1m years to a time when the Arctic region was 11-19C warmer than the present day. The analysis reveals that the northern peninsula of Greenland, now a polar desert, once featured boreal forests of poplar and birch trees teeming with wildlife. The work offers clues to how species might adapt,
Detransitioner, experts issue warning
over American Girl pushing gender transitions:
'Protect your daughters'
16 replies
Posted by Judy W. 12/8/2022 8:03:59 AM Post Reply
The American Girl doll brand is facing backlash over a book targeted at prepubescent girls that promotes gender transition seemingly without parental consent. The book, titled "A Smart Girl's Guide: Body Image," which is marketed to girls ages 3 to 12, encourages children to talk with a doctor if they are questioning their gender identity. "At first, you and the doctor might talk about wearing the clothes and using the pronouns (like he, she, or they) that make you feel most like the true you," the book reads. "If you haven't gone through puberty yet, the doctor might offer medicine to delay your body's changes,
Oversight Project Investigation Uncovers
Shocking Facts About Who’s Facilitating
Biden Border Crisis
6 replies
Posted by Judy W. 12/6/2022 7:00:07 AM Post Reply
WASHINGTON—The Heritage Foundation’s Oversight Project, and Border Security and Immigration Center, today released new information documenting the scope not just of the Biden border crisis, but the role of non-governmental organizations in facilitating and continuing it. In a new memo titled, “Tracking Movement of Illegal Aliens from NGOs to Interior of USA”, the Oversight Project unveiled new data showing the massive numbers of illegal aliens who have made their way to NGO facilities physically located along the border and in border states, and subsequently traveled throughout the United States.
Most Active Articles (last 48 hours)
I bought a Tesla to help the environment.
Now, I'm embarrassed to drive it
45 replies
Posted by bad-hair 12/28/2022 10:28:14 AM Post Reply
Afew years ago, I bought a used Tesla, not because I’m a car nut but because I had been a hypocrite. For years, I had been outspoken about the dangers of carbon emissions. Yet at the same time, I was driving an old gas-powered heap that got about 25 miles per gallon, and that sounded like a rocket launch every time I turned on the ignition.
'I could not stand him for 10 years':
Michelle Obama says raising 'terrorists'
Malia and Sasha while Barack was launching
his political career at the expense of
her practicing law put a strain on their marriage
43 replies
Posted by Imright 12/28/2022 7:18:21 PM Post Reply
Michelle Obama has revealed that she 'couldn't stand' husband Barack while their children were young. The former First Lady, 58, also dubbed her two daughters, Sasha and Malia, as 'terrorists' when they were small. She claims the couple struggled as they were both trying to 'advance their careers' – with her husband going on to become the president. Michelle made the claims about her relationship with Barack, 61, while promoting her new book The Light We Carry.
Buffalo blizzard fuels racial and class
divides in polarized city
33 replies
Posted by NorthernDog 12/29/2022 9:31:34 AM Post Reply
As Buffalo begins to dig itself out from its deadliest disaster in a decade, the plights of people stuck for days in frigid homes without much food, their streets still unplowed, have reignited deep economic and racial fault lines that have long polarized the city. (Snip) As the toll on the city has become clearer, a dozen residents and community leaders said in interviews that structural issues such as poverty, food deserts, poor housing and a lack of investment by government have made the impacts on working-class, Black and Brown neighborhoods much worse. They expressed concerns that surrounding wealthier and
Oxford residents will soon be prisoners
of their own neighborhoods
31 replies
Posted by DVC 12/28/2022 5:51:45 PM Post Reply
This is one of those stories that you’re certain is from the Babylon Bee, and that is stunning in its implications when it turns out to be the truth. In this case, the truth is that, in accordance with UN and WEF climate recommendations, the city of Oxford (home to the famed university) approved plans mandating that citizens may not drive more than 15 minutes distance from their homes without permission. It’s called the “15 Minute City” and is intended to reduce auto emissions. Mostly, though, it will reduce liberty, which is what climate change madness has always been about.
LGBTQ+++™ Pinocchios Now Claim Male-to-Female
Transgenders Can Get Periods: 'I'm a Real Girl!'
30 replies
Posted by Hazymac 12/28/2022 7:04:04 AM Post Reply
Biological assimilation into femininity has long been the final frontier for transgender activists — a Rubicon they had not yet been able to fully cross. Aspirational transgenders can get various sordid surgeries to appear more feminine; they can adopt feminine social roles, but they could never really become fully biologically female. This nags at the LGBTQ+++™ community something fierce, as biological reality always belies the religious conviction that “transgender women are women,” full-stop. They wish they could menstruate because, like transgender Pinocchios, they want desperately to be real girls, despite the deep-seated and dysphoric knowledge that their goal is impossible. For instance, transgender TikTok star Dylan Mulvaney explains
Photos: 2 Million Views On A Twitter Thread
That Asks For A Picture Of Michelle Obama
Pregnant & Still No Picture – We Finally
Solved That Conspiracy
29 replies
Posted by Black Conservative Voice 12/28/2022 10:09:19 AM Post Reply
Have you ever wondered why no pictures of Michelle Obama pregnant are available online? The right-wing conspiracies are that there are no pictures of Michelle Obama pregnant at all. But the left wing thinks that they aren’t pictures out there because Michelle Obama wasn’t famous at the time she was pregnant because Obama wasn’t a big deal and paparazzi weren’t hunting them. One recent Twitter, thread sparked a huge controversy!
Book: Joe Biden Doesn’t Trust His Secret
Service, Fears ‘MAGA Sympathizers’
in Ranks
28 replies
Posted by Imright 12/28/2022 9:00:38 PM Post Reply
President Joe Biden reportedly does not trust the Secret Service to protect him, even though the agency has appeared to slow-walk disclosing documents related to Hunter Biden’s alleged gun violations. According to Chris Whipple’s new book, “The Fight of His Life: Inside Joe Biden’s White House,” Biden does not trust the Secret Service because some of them allegedly do not support him politically. “A bigger problem was Biden’s discomfort with his Secret Service detail; some of them were MAGA sympathizers. He didn’t trust them,” Whipple wrote. “The Secret Service is full of white ex-cops from the South who tend to be deeply conservative.” Whipple makes Biden appear paranoid
Action movie director James Cameron doesn't
want to "fetishize" gun violence
25 replies
Posted by Dreadnought 12/28/2022 11:36:44 PM Post Reply
James Cameron has made some of the best action movies ever. Terminator, Terminator 2, Aliens. Even True Lies was pretty good. I thought Titanic sucked, and Avatar was a snooze, but Cameron has a few greats to be proud of. But he isn’t proud of them. In fact, without naming these movies he implies he wished he never made them. They “fetishize” gun violence, and he is done with that. Guns make him sick to his stomach now. He is so done with gun violence, in fact, that he has made a war movie (Avatar 2 is indeed a kind of war movie, in which the human beings
Woke and broke U.S. Army now accepting
recruits with ADHD, other "behavioral challenges"
24 replies
Posted by Dreadnought 12/28/2022 6:45:00 PM Post Reply
Being all uber-woke you can be has just about brought the Army to its knees. In this day and age, they’ve fallen so far down the rabbit hole anymore that they can’t get anyone who’s their normal target recruit to sign up to save their lives. Or anyone else’s, for that matter. Their recruiting numbers are dismal. …The service fell 15,000 recruits short of its fiscal 2022 goal and it cut its goal for total number of soldiers in fiscal year 2023 by an additional 15,000, suggesting that it sees a longer-term problem. Only 23% of young Americans meet the fitness, health and other standards required to join the military,
What Christmas crisis? Bidens enjoy Caribbean
paradise after 'blizzard of the century'
killed dozens and Southwest's latest meltdown
stranded tens of thousands across the nation
23 replies
Posted by Imright 12/28/2022 11:42:16 AM Post Reply
President Joe Biden is enjoying his tropical vacation in St Croix while thousands of Americans continue to suffer from travel chaos and the deadly blizzard that killed at least 68 people. He will be sunning himself in the 84-degree Caribbean heat at a private home with beach access in the Virgin Islands. He's staying as a rent-free guest at the home of Bill and Connie Neville, who are bigtime Democratic donors. He is joined by first lady Jill, grandkids Natalie and Hunter Jr., and daughter Ashley and her husband Howard for a family vacation. Ashley and Howard even brought their dog for the week-long getaway.
Chinese Travelers Land in Italy, Half
Test Positive for Coronavirus
21 replies
Posted by Dreadnought 12/28/2022 10:52:41 PM Post Reply
Italy’s decision to take extra precautions with Chinese travelers paid off on Wednesday as two flights from China landed in Milan and half of the passengers tested positive for Covid-19. Italy was one of four countries that announced they would impose coronavirus restrictions on Chinese travelers because a massive wave of coronavirus infections is ripping across China, racking up millions of cases in a single day — but the tyrannical Chinese government decided to abandon almost all of its disease control protocols with almost no preparation for the consequences, loosen up travel restrictions, and begin handing out passports just in time for the Lunar New Year holiday.
‘Extremely Irresponsible’: Expert
Warns China’s Border Reopening Amid
COVID Surge May Trigger Global Pandemic Resurgence
19 replies
Posted by Judy W. 12/29/2022 7:55:06 AM Post Reply
A health expert has sharply criticized the Chinese regime’s lifting of international travel restrictions in the midst of a massive COVID wave sweeping through the country, saying the move is “extremely irresponsible” and could cause a global resurgence of the pandemic. The National Health Commission announced on Dec. 26 that the country would end all quarantine requirements for inbound travelers from Jan. 8, 2023. Travelers will need to obtain a negative PCR test within 48 hours of departure, it said. Currently, travelers entering China need to undergo five days of mandatory quarantine in an approved facility, followed by three days at home.
Post New Article