Post New Article

Oberlin alumni letter predicts
'lengthy and complex legal process'

Original Article

Posted By: Harlowe, 6/15/2019 1:41:37 PM

Less than 24 hours after a $44 million settlement against the college in favor of Gibson’s Bakery, Oberlin College President Carmen Twillie Ambar assured alumni in an email that the punitive damage award will change. In the letter sent to alumni that was obtained by the Chronicle-Telegram, Ambar writes: “This is not the final outcome. This is, in fact, just one step along the way of what may turn out to be a lengthy and complex legal process... It will not distract, deter or materially harm our education mission, for today’s students or for generations to come.”


There is a related story at the website reflecting the views of a Case Western Reserve University Law Professor predicting it unlikely the Gibson family will get $44 million from Oberlin College based on law and authority entrusted to judges to undo the jury’s verdict if the judge believes evidence did not support it; that judges have the obligation to look at the evidence after the trial. Also, the professor said “he finds it very unlikely” that Oberlin College intentionally tried to harm Gibson’s Bakery and the Gibson family “without a good-faith basis that what the bakery did was wrong.”

Post Reply

Reply 1 - Posted by: Harlowe 6/15/2019 1:42:06 PM (No. 98794)
Addendum to OP Comments: The law professor appears to not believe Oberlin College intentionally inflected emotion distress against David and Allyn W. Gibson, which the jury found the college liable for, and that it was a strange outcome akin to intentional infliction of emotional distress on the order of killing somebody’s dog while they watch. The professor doesn’t think that is going to survive the appellate process and that the verdict could have been the jury’s way of “thumbing their nose at a higher education institution ... seen as ‘elitist’ ... or uncaring about a small business in a town that has seen some town-versus-gown controversy in the past.” Yet, the professor concludes his view by saying he would “rather be the plaintiff than Oberlin College at this moment.”
5 people like this.

Reply 2 - Posted by: tsquare 6/15/2019 1:55:39 PM (No. 98807)
I am happy for Oberlin that they are setting new directions and that the award will not detract, deter, or materially harm its educationally mission or its students. Having pled poverty in the damage trial...there are those were celebrating the demise of Oberlin. Past and future jurors can now be relieved that the award size has no material affect on the school.
6 people like this.

Reply 3 - Posted by: earlybird 6/15/2019 1:56:35 PM (No. 98808)
The Gibsons will not get $44 million. That is discussed in this article as well as articles previously posted. There is a cap on punitive damages. They compensatory damages at $11million - punitive damages at twice that, $22million est. Total est. $33million. In no way could they have judged the venom that came out of Oberlin - especially that from Dr. Raimondo (who is also Oberlin’s legal counsel) to be anything less than intentionally inflicted. The radical Raimondo ran a real slash and burn operation against the Gibsons and their business. The Gibsons had to be labelled (libeled) as racists for Oberlin to support its students. That libelous label would stick. The law professor will be found to be wrong, IMO. The dog killing analogy is patently absurd and does not fit the circumstances.
9 people like this.

Reply 4 - Posted by: Nevadadad46 6/15/2019 1:57:27 PM (No. 98809)
If you thought Carmen Twilla Ambar sounded a little too affirmative actiony, you were right.
23 people like this.

Reply 5 - Posted by: jj1319 6/15/2019 1:57:28 PM (No. 98810)
The total time the jury spent deliberating, both compensatory and punitive, was less than 8 hours. They knew what they were going to do when they entered the jury room. This should be very troubling to Oberlin College. Cut your losses and pay the damages. Oh, and learn the lesson.
19 people like this.

Reply 6 - Posted by: john56 6/15/2019 2:01:42 PM (No. 98814)
I think if I were Oberlin, I'd call the Gibson's lawyers and say "Here's $15 million dollars. Let's make this go away. And settle for $20 million.
3 people like this.

Reply 7 - Posted by: Northcross 6/15/2019 2:03:08 PM (No. 98816)
I appreciate incisive sarcasm, and #2 is a master. Note well that Oberlin's general counsel announced they will not be making any further public comments. This after their office went public in calling the jury stupid before the punitive damage phase of the trial. At least they have learned something.
10 people like this.

Reply 8 - Posted by: earlybird 6/15/2019 2:15:22 PM (No. 98823)
It seems that the Gibsons made an effort to settle before this went to trial. Oberlin (surely its legal counsel Dr. Raimondo) and its insurance company did not respond to the Gibsons settlement overture and decided to take it to court.
11 people like this.

Reply 9 - Posted by: earlybird 6/15/2019 2:19:59 PM (No. 98826)
(hit submit too soon) As for the amount of time the jury spent deliberating the punitive damage phase, it turned on whether Oberlin acted with malice (intentionally) or not. The judge reportedly spent a fair amount of time schooling the jury on that aspect. They had already decided that the actions took place (in the compensatory phase). This was just the matter of whether the actions were intentional or not. It does not take a genius to review the actions of Dr. Raimondo and the Oberlin officials that they were out to intentionally damage the Gibsons and their business in the community.
13 people like this.

Reply 10 - Posted by: earlybird 6/15/2019 2:27:29 PM (No. 98830)
Correcting bad editing in #9: It does not take a genius to review the actions of Dr. Raimondo and the Oberlin officials and conclude that they were out to intentionally damage the Gibsons and their business in the community.
6 people like this.

Reply 11 - Posted by: bad-hair 6/15/2019 2:34:44 PM (No. 98836)
When all else fails (miserably), pay more lawyers.
4 people like this.

Reply 12 - Posted by: lakerman1 6/15/2019 2:36:51 PM (No. 98838)
If the leaders of Oberlin College had a lick of sense, they would apologize to Gibson's Bakery owners. As to the final cost to Oberlin, they have now told everyone that they are going to string this out forever. In the end, they will pay the full amount plus compound interest. Appeals courts are hesitant to re-try the facts of the case, unless the outcome was outrageous. This was not an outrageous outcome, in my opinion.(arbitrator's awards can be appealed, but hardly ever will an award be reversed. And in 3 decades as an arbitrator, just two cases were appealed - one to county court, and my award was upheld, and one to federal court, finally appealed to the federal court of appeals, and my award was upheld. I realize that a jury decision is easier to reverse than an arbitration award, but still, Oberlin has a tough row to hoe. They seemed not to have learned anything in this situation. That is bad leadership. Oberlin is stinking up Higher Ed.
15 people like this.

Reply 13 - Posted by: PostAway 6/15/2019 2:37:07 PM (No. 98839)
A once highly respected school can’t compete with the myriad other small private liberal arts colleges in more desirable locations throughout the country. Instead of insistence on ethical and moral behavior from students, Oberlin not only began accepting less scholastically gifted students but also thuggish ones. Now, even the townspeople are hostile. Way to go, Oberlin.
17 people like this.

Reply 14 - Posted by: Vesicant 6/15/2019 2:38:29 PM (No. 98840)
"Lengthy" as defined by the time it takes to find a leftist appeal judge appointed by scumbama.
7 people like this.

Reply 15 - Posted by: M2 6/15/2019 2:43:15 PM (No. 98844)
Twillie Ambar is a black woman who cried racism. We won’t forget.
17 people like this.

Reply 16 - Posted by: msjena 6/15/2019 3:46:54 PM (No. 98868)
There will likely be a settlement, soon. This is a PR nightmare for the college.
3 people like this.

Reply 17 - Posted by: gramma b 6/15/2019 4:02:12 PM (No. 98875)
The person who wrote this article is a moron. It wasn’t a “settlement” and it wasn’t $44 million.
4 people like this.

Reply 18 - Posted by: earlybird 6/15/2019 4:41:20 PM (No. 98892)
The original award was for $11+million in compensatory damages. The punitive damage award came in at $33million. Total: $44million. We were also advised that the punitive damages in this case cannot exceed $22million, double the compensatory damages. Even if modified after the fact, the jury awards did total $44million.
6 people like this.

Reply 19 - Posted by: Jethro bo 6/15/2019 4:43:19 PM (No. 98893)
Hey colleges and univeristies that coddle spoiled snowflakes, your next. The adults that make up juries are tired of the crazies running the institutions of lower learning.
5 people like this.

Reply 20 - Posted by: Philipsonh 6/15/2019 6:15:57 PM (No. 98939)
It was a legal matter which had NOTHING to do with the college. They got involved because they wanted to destory the bakery's business. If a college student robs a bank, does the college get involved. How about a student committing murder ? The college's involvement was based on racism.
6 people like this.

Reply 21 - Posted by: udanja99 6/15/2019 7:27:22 PM (No. 98962)
Let the idiots turn it into a lengthy process. By the time they are done and are forced to pay the $44 million, they will have spent more than that in legal fees.
4 people like this.

Below, you will find ...
Most Recent Articles posted by "Harlowe"
Most Active Articles (last 48 hours)
Most Recent Articles posted by Harlowe"
Eric Trump: Trump Organization taking legal
action over MSNBC host Lawrence O'Donnell's
'reckless attempt to slander family'
7 replies
Posted by Harlowe 8/28/2019 9:58:13 PM Post Reply
Eric Trump vowed that the Trump Organization will take legal action against MSNBC and Lawrence O'Donnell after the left-leaning host aired a singled-sourced, unverified report that President Trump had loans co-signed by Russian oligarchs. "This was a reckless attempt to slander our family and smear a great company. Apologies are not enough when the true intent was solely to damage and cause harm. As a company, we will be taking legal action. This unethical behavior has to stop. @Lawrence @MSNBC," Eric Trump tweeted Wednesday night.
Alabama GOP adopts resolution pushing for
Rep. Ilhan Omar's expulsion from Congress
19 replies
Posted by Harlowe 8/27/2019 8:02:20 PM Post Reply
Alabama Republicans are urging lawmakers to remove Rep. Ilhan Omar, D-Minn. from Congress after a series of controversial statements, including remarks about Israel and her support of economic boycotts against that country. The state GOP passed a resolution last weekend at the party's summer meeting in Auburn calling on its congressional delegation to “proceed with the expulsion process” against the first-term congresswoman. “Representative Omar has engaged in rhetoric that explicitly runs counter to American values and patriotism by falsely accusing U.S. armed forces of committing war crimes while on mission to liberate her home country of Somalia,” the resolution said.
US eyes ransomware threat to voter
databases prior to 2020 election
8 replies
Posted by Harlowe 8/27/2019 12:31:53 PM Post Reply
The U.S. government is ramping up its efforts to protect voter registration databases from ransomware attacks in the run-up to the 2020 presidential election. The plan was first reported by Reuters, which notes that the Cybersecurity Infrastructure Agency (CISA), part of the Department of Homeland Security, is contacting state election officials to bolster protections against ransomware. “Recent history has shown that state and county governments and those who support them are targets for ransomware attacks,” said CISA Director Chris Krebs, in a statement provided to Fox News. “Voter registration databases could be an attractive target for these attacks.”
Oberlin College Seeks New
Trial in Gibson’s Bakery Case
6 replies
Posted by Harlowe 8/23/2019 11:26:23 AM Post Reply
Everyone is waiting for the appeal in the Gibson’s Bakery v. Oberlin College case that has captured the attention of the nation. The judgment is for almost $32 million in damages and defendants were required to post a $36 million bond to secure the judgment pending appeal. The appeal phase, as I’ve previously indicated, is the most perilous for the Gibsons. Their case was so strong on the facts, and the trial defense so tone deaf, that a jury verdict in their favor was likely. But on appeal, there are legal landmines the defense will try to raise that could
'We're looking at it': Trump adviser
says of potential Greenland purchase
6 replies
Posted by Harlowe 8/18/2019 1:19:58 PM Post Reply
WASHINGTON – Yes, President Donald Trump is really considering purchasing Greenland. "We're looking at it," top White House economic adviser Larry Kudlow said on "Fox News Sunday." That's despite the fact that Greenland's government told President Donald Trump on Friday that the island was "not for sale." (Snip) Kudlow said Sunday the issue is "developing." "I don’t want to predict an outcome," Kudlow said. "I’m just saying: the president, who knows a thing or two about buying real estate, wants to take a look at a Greenland purchase."
Israel bars Omar and Tlaib
entry after Trump tweet
18 replies
Posted by Harlowe 8/15/2019 11:04:13 AM Post Reply
Israel on Thursday announced that it would deny Reps. Ilhan Omar (D-Minn.) and Rashida Tlaib (D-Mich.) entry to the territory during an upcoming overseas trip, according to multiple reports. The decision was announced moments after President Trump tweeted that it would show "great weakness" for Israel to allow the two congresswomen into the country. The president has been an outspoken critic of both Omar and Tlaib, who last year became the first two Muslim women elected to Congress.
Oberlin College Professor after Gibson’s Bakery
verdict: “how idiotic can the college be always?”
4 replies
Posted by Harlowe 8/15/2019 12:12:12 AM Post Reply
Despite over 100 posts at Legal Insurrection on the Gibson’s Bakery v. Oberlin College conflict and lawsuit, I just read a fresh perspective on what happened. The perspective is that of Abraham Socher, currently Editor of the Jewish Review of Books. Pertinent to this discussion, Socher is a former Oberlin College Associate Professor of Religion and Director of Jewish Studies, where he taught for 18 years. In March 2016, when still at the college, Socher wrote in the student-run Oberlin Review about Joy Karega, whose anti-Semitic conspiracy rants on Facebook were another in an long line of Oberlin College scandals, Karega-Mason’s Facebook Posts Anti-Semitic.
Drive-By Media Hell-Bent on
Talking Us Into a Recession
11 replies
Posted by Harlowe 8/14/2019 5:28:38 PM Post Reply
RUSH: The Drive-Bys, they’re incorrigible. Now they are literally trying to once again talk the people of this country into a recession. Now they’re doing it with the inverted yield curve. And the whole problem here is the Federal Reserve. The Federal Reserve is anti-Trump, is making a mess of the interest rate circumstance. So many people in that town want rid of Trump that they’re going to stop at nothing. It doesn’t matter what damage they do to the economy or the country. And it’s not unprecedented, folks. This has been done before.
Exclusive–Watch: Leftists Threaten
Contractor in Fla; Day Before ICE
Facility Shot at in Texas
5 replies
Posted by Harlowe 8/13/2019 10:17:13 PM Post Reply
A group of open borders activists threatened employees of a government contractor in Florida that provides facility space for the Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE) agency to detain border crossers and illegal aliens the day before a shooting at the contractor’s offices in Texas. In exclusive footage captured by Matt Perdie of Breitbart News, protesters with Never Again Action, Miramar Circle of Protection Friends of Miami-Dade Detainees, Food Not Bombs Fort Lauderdale, Students Working for Equal Rights, and the Black Lives Matter Alliance of Broward County shouted threats at workers and former employees of the GEO Group, a private contractor used by ICE for facility and detention space.
First day of school photo
of siblings praying goes viral:
'We pray for everyone'
4 replies
Posted by Harlowe 8/10/2019 1:15:13 AM Post Reply
First day of school photos are precious but one Louisiana mother's photo is going viral for what her kids are doing in the face of tough times. Jamisha Harris, of Baton Rouge, shared a prayer and photo of her three children--Eugene, 10, Jorden, 8, and Emily, 7--praying before their first day of school Monday. (Snip) What you can't see in the photo is that the Harris family lost their apartment the day before, and Jamisha and her husband recently lost their jobs.
NY bill to make water attacks
on cops a felony faces
Democratic opposition
10 replies
Posted by Harlowe 8/8/2019 5:03:39 PM Post Reply
A Republican bill that would increase penalties for throwing water on cops, after a series of incidents in which members of New York’s Finest were doused by bucket-wielding mobs, is facing some initial Democratic opposition months before the bill could even be taken up. (Snip) Assembly Speaker Carl Heastie, who will decide whether the bill gets brought up for a vote, indicated his opposition to the measure this week.
Gibson's Bakery owner announces cancer
diagnosis, says Oberlin College is trying to
wait him out (UPDATED/VIDEO)
14 replies
Posted by Harlowe 8/7/2019 11:43:09 AM Post Reply
Gibson’s Bakery co-owner David Gibson is fighting pancreatic cancer, he announced in a video posted Tuesday to the bakery’s Facebook page. He also said he believes Oberlin College is trying to wait until he and his 91-year-old father are dead as the two sides continue to battle in court in a case that resulted in the largest monetary award for libel in Ohio history. Doing so wouldn’t absolve the college of having to pay if it loses or exhausts all its appeals, according to an experienced First Amendment attorney who has been following the case.
Most Active Articles (last 48 hours)
Illinois Passes New Law Requiring
LGBTQ Classes in Middle School
34 replies
Posted by Imright 8/29/2019 5:04:20 AM Post Reply
Illinois Gov. J.B. Pritzker has signed a new bill into law requiring the state’s schools to teach “LGBTQ history” to students by the eighth grade.The law will require schools to add the history of prominent lesbian, gay, bisexual, and transgender Americans, according to the New York Post. The law states that textbooks “must include the roles and contributions of all people protected under the Illinois Human Rights Act and must be non-discriminatory as to any of the characteristics under the Act.” “One of the best ways to overcome intolerance is through education
Comey Taunts Critics Following Release of
IG Report, Takes Swipe at President Trump
30 replies
Posted by Imright 8/29/2019 11:45:16 AM Post Reply
Fired FBI Director James Comey taunted critics and took a swipe at President Trump immediately following the release of the Inspector General’s report regarding Comey’s handling of the Russia probe and leak of memos. The Justice Department declined to prosecute Comey, however the IG found multiple ethics and department guideline violations by Comey. (Photo) “DOJ IG “found no evidence that Comey or his attorneys released any of the classified information contained in any of the memos to members of the media.” I don’t need a public apology from those who defamed me, but a quick message
Doomsday AOC: Brave millennials are first
‘informed’ generation to defy government
26 replies
Posted by Imright 8/29/2019 5:15:56 AM Post Reply
Rep. Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez, D-N.Y., claimed in her latest blabbering Instagram Live video that millennials are more “informed” than past generations and also the first generation “willing to go to the streets” to protest the government.“I think young people are more informed and dynamic than their predecessors,” the controversial congresswoman said. She added, “They actually take time to read and understand our [world] history.” AOC on Instagram live: “Young people are more informed and dynamic than their predecessors… they actually take time to read and understand our [world] history.”
Sasha Obama starts classes next week
at University of Michigan: report
25 replies
Posted by Imright 8/29/2019 6:53:54 PM Post Reply
Sasha Obama, the younger daughter of former President Barack Obama and Michelle Obama, will be attending the University of Michigan starting this fall.The first daughter was spotted by students of the school while attending freshman orientation, and was seen again on campus this week with men believed to be Secret Service agents, the Detroit News reports.Sasha is the first person in her immediate family to attend a public Big Ten university instead of an Ivy League school. Her classes begin Tuesday.
There Is No ‘Gay Gene,’
Comprehensive Scientific Study Finds
24 replies
Posted by Hazymac 8/30/2019 8:22:59 AM Post Reply
Recent polls have shown that most Americans believe that homosexuals are “born that way” rather than become gay as the result of environmental factors. In fact, perpetuating the belief that sexual orientation is innate has been crucial to the gay rights movement. According to the most recent Gallup Poll on the subject, 88 percent of people who believe homosexuals are “born that way” support the legality of same-sex marriage, while only 39 percent of those who believe homosexuality is the result of environmental factors support the legality of same-sex marriage. So, what happens when science proves that homosexuals aren’t “born that way”?
Trump says farmers will be 'so happy'
with new plan to boost ethanol
24 replies
Posted by Ribicon 8/29/2019 10:50:18 AM Post Reply
President Trump said Thursday he’s preparing to announce a “giant package” to boost demand for ethanol, responding to rising concerns in rural America about the administration’s exemptions for refineries from blending biofuels. “The Farmers are going to be so happy when they see what we are doing for Ethanol, not even including the E-15, year around, which is already done,” the president tweeted. “It will be a giant package, get ready! At the same time I was able to save the small refineries from certain closing. Great for all!”(Snip) Mr. Perdue said one proposal would strengthen infrastructure to allow greater use of E15,
Lesbian couple share their dilemma after
one transitions to a man, leaving people
assuming they are a straight couple when
they are proudly gay
24 replies
Posted by Ribicon 8/29/2019 12:56:38 AM Post Reply
A couple who met as two women have shared their dilemma after one transitioned to become male, leaving the other struggling to cope after years of being in a same-sex relationship. Andy Arnold and Kate Murray have been together for several years. In 2017, Andy revealed that he identified as a man and would be transitioning. While Kate was supportive of his decision, it has since left her struggling to cope since she is inherently homosexual and attracted to women. The pair, who are still together and are now engaged, say they are working to 'navigate' the issue as a team,
The Coming Climate Change
Propaganda Tsunami
22 replies
Posted by Pluperfect 8/30/2019 5:01:38 AM Post Reply
Batten down the hatches! Yet another tsunami of global warming and “clean energy” propaganda is approaching! On September 23, United Nations Secretary-General António Guterres will host the 2019 Climate Action Summit at UN headquarters. Guterres is calling on all leaders to come to New York City with “concrete, realistic plans” to increase their greenhouse gas (GHG) emission reduction pledges “in line with reducing GHG emissions by 45 per cent over the next decade, and to net zero emissions by 2050.” The goal is to “hold the increase in the global average temperature to well below 2°C”, lessen sea level rise, reduce extreme weather, and other impossible objectives. The UN warns:
Former Canadian PM says she's 'rooting for
a direct hit' of Hurricane Dorian on Mar-a-Lago
22 replies
Posted by Pluperfect 8/30/2019 4:29:30 AM Post Reply
Former Canadian Prime Minister Kim Campbell said Thursday that she wished for Hurricane Dorian to make a "direct hit" on President Trump's Mar-a-Lago club in Florida. The strengthening storm churned over the warm, open waters of the Atlantic on Thursday, upgrading to Category 2 strength late in the day, with maximum sustained winds of 105 mph, the National Hurricane Center reported. Forecasts showed Dorian tracking toward Florida's east coast — prompting Trump to warn Dorian "will be BIG!" Forecasters believe the storm will strengthen into a Category 3 hurricane by Friday, and stay well east of the southern and central Bahamas before making a turn toward Florida by Sunday afternoon.
Department of Justice declines
to prosecute Comey over leaked memos
21 replies
Posted by M2 8/29/2019 10:37:58 AM Post Reply
The Department of Justice will not prosecute former FBI director James Comey after an internal probe of Comey’s handling of memos he kept of his interactions with President Donald Trump. In a report released Thursday, the Office of the Inspector General said its probe found that Comey violated department policy. "Upon completing its investigation, the OIG provided its factual findings to the Justice Department for a prosecutorial decision regarding Comey’s conduct, as required by the Inspector General Act. After reviewing the matter, the DOJ declined prosecution," the office said in a statement.
Talking Head Neil Cavuto Convinced
That The President Wants Him To
“Fawn” Over Him
20 replies
Posted by Cavallodifiero 8/30/2019 11:26:12 AM Post Reply
Arrogant, dying-to-be-noticed-out-there-in left-field Neil Cavuto has somehow convinced himself that President Donald Trump wants the Fox News host to “fawn” over him: “First of all, Mr. President, we don’t work for you,” Cavuto postulated at the end of his last night show. (The Blaze, Aug. 29, 2019) Addressing a tweet that the president lobbed at the cable news channel, Cavuto went all-out TDS: “I don’t work for you. My job is to cover you, not fawn over you or rip you, just cover you. Call balls and strikes. Our job is to keep score, not settle scores,” he explained.
How do you solve a problem
like James Comey?
20 replies
Posted by Magnante 8/30/2019 5:47:32 AM Post Reply
To begin solving the problem of former FBI director James Comey, who's been blasted by the Department of Justice in its Inspector General report, start by never again hiring people who value themselves so loftily over the people they are charged with representing. In other words, never hire someone like him, who absolutely believed that he was smarter than, better than, and more important than, the people whose laws his agency was tasked with enforcing. Enforcing the law was never on Comey's agenda, not at all. He was all about the power he had amassed as director of the FBI. What was in his head?
Post New Article