Post New Article

Justice Thomas raised crucial question
about legitimacy of special counsel's
prosecution of Trump

Original Article

Posted By: Moritz55, 4/27/2024 6:51:58 PM

Supreme Court Justice Clarence Thomas raised a question Thursday that goes to the heart of Special Counsel Jack Smith's charges against former President Donald Trump. The high court was considering Trump's argument that he is immune from prosecution for actions he took while president, but another issue is whether Smith and the Office of Special Counsel have the authority to bring charges at all. "Did you, in this litigation, challenge the appointment of special counsel?" Thomas asked Trump attorney John Sauer on Thursday during a nearly three-hour session at the Supreme Court.

Post Reply

Reminder: “WE ARE A SALON AND NOT A SALOON”

Your thoughts, comments, and ideas are always welcome here. But we ask you to please be mindful and respectful. Threatening or crude language doesn't persuade anybody and makes the conversation less enjoyable for fellow L.Dotters.


Reply 1 - Posted by: jntsrgn 4/27/2024 8:15:23 PM (No. 1707373)
It’s interesting that Justice Thomas brought up this issue since it is not presently a question before the court.
37 people like this.

Reply 2 - Posted by: Krause 4/27/2024 8:44:19 PM (No. 1707386)
Did Garland not know Smith was not approved? Pretty sure Biden didn't know.
25 people like this.

Reply 3 - Posted by: your other brother 4/27/2024 9:16:43 PM (No. 1707396)
The question of presidential immunity is not ripe for decision so long as none of the federal prosecutions are legitimate because the prosecutor is not legitimate. The court should kick the immunity decision can down the road and simply kick Jack Smith to the curb and all his cases along with him. In due course the immunity question will come back up when the Republicans prosecute Biden at which point the Dems will do a 180 on "No man is above the law" BS when the law is tyrants whore.
41 people like this.

Reply 4 - Posted by: your other brother 4/27/2024 9:27:52 PM (No. 1707403)
My guess is the court will throw a roadblock into this case that will keep it from going to trial until after the election and then in the documents case throw yet another roadblock questioning Jack Smith's legitimacy. This is one of those cases that if you can avoid making a definitive decision you should. Tell the lower court Trump does have immunity for official acts but not necessarily for private acts. You figure out where that line is and then we will get back to you on how well you did and it will likely take until Trump and Biden are both dead if all the cases are not tossed because Jack Smith ain't an officer.
21 people like this.

Reply 5 - Posted by: MickTurn 4/27/2024 9:53:24 PM (No. 1707418)
IF SCOTUS agreed with Jack Smith and his Rabid interpretations, ALL Presidents that are still alive, Bill Clinton, Barak Obama, GW Bush, Trump could be prosecuted for things they did AS President. This is INSANE and it needs to be treated that way. Oh, by the way, Jack Smith was ILLEGALLY appointed so he's just a citizen with a Leftist Opinion.
32 people like this.

Reply 6 - Posted by: Kafka2 4/28/2024 6:15:14 AM (No. 1707537)
It is interesting to note that Garland should have known that Jack Smith was not qualified to prosecute Trump. It was good of Justice Thomas to point this out.
34 people like this.

Reply 7 - Posted by: Kafka2 4/28/2024 6:27:13 AM (No. 1707541)
Trying to draw a line between personal and official actions of the office is a fool’s errand. Many actions can have aspects that are both personal and official. Trying define all actions as exclusively personal or official is not possible.
15 people like this.

Reply 8 - Posted by: MakingSense 4/28/2024 6:43:39 AM (No. 1707544)
Mark Levin (who was deputy U.S. Attorney General under Ed Meese) has been addressing and supporting this Jack Smith illegitimacy issue on his Fox TV shows for the last couple of months. If the Supreme Court correctly agrees, its curtains for Smith.
23 people like this.

Reply 9 - Posted by: msjena 4/28/2024 8:19:11 AM (No. 1707582)
It is before the Court, isn't it? Not by the parties but by an amicus brief that was filed.
10 people like this.

Reply 10 - Posted by: janjan 4/28/2024 8:47:33 AM (No. 1707609)
The article states that the issue has been raised in a Florida Federal Court. Won’t that court have to rule before it is sent to the Supremes? I’m not an attorney. Just asking.
7 people like this.

Reply 11 - Posted by: Rumblehog 4/28/2024 10:08:52 AM (No. 1707664)
This issue of legitimacy has been out in the open and commented on for a long, long time. The ever-evil, partisan-hack, Garland wanted an expedient Persecutor be appointed, "Damn the torpedoes!" Simple logis says that a "right thing," must be done in a "right way," otherwise it's "wrong." This should be thrown OUT of court immediately, and Garland must go back to square one and PROPERLY request that a Special Prosecutor be assigned.
9 people like this.

Reply 12 - Posted by: Zigrid 4/28/2024 10:13:19 AM (No. 1707668)
The new MAGA republicans will not let this continue forever....WE the people are seeing...first hand how corrupt the washington swamp is...and there's nothing the swamp can do to stop US.....
4 people like this.

Reply 13 - Posted by: edgar 4/28/2024 12:00:29 PM (No. 1707727)
#2 - The law does not apply to democrats. The Mueller Special Counsel was put in place the same sketchy way.
4 people like this.

Reply 14 - Posted by: Geoman 4/28/2024 1:02:07 PM (No. 1707764)
FTA: "He resigned from the private sector after then-President Trump nominated a different prosecutor as U.S. attorney for the middle district of Tennessee." How does one "resign from the private sector?" Do you write a "Dear Private Sector" letter? The latter half of the sentence supplies the motivation for Smith going after Trump for exercising his Constitutional prerogative as the Chief Executive to nominate U.S. attorneys. It also shows the small mindedness, mendacity, and corruption of Garland, Obama's USSC Marxist nominee and current AG. McConnel's final act as a statesman-like Republican, by letting Garland's nomination 'die on the vine.' Garland knew that Biden's hard left political worldview, filthy fingers, and authoritarian drive would back his decision, even if unconstitutional, like his "student" loan bailout.
4 people like this.

Reply 15 - Posted by: SouthernYankee 4/28/2024 3:06:12 PM (No. 1707801)
Minor point is the legal issues. The main point is the left is prosecuting Trump solely to influence the 2024 election. It is obvious by NY State law that Marchand is required to recuse himself as his daughter is financially benefitting from this case. NY State law prohibits any relative/associate withing six degrees of a case from benefitting. Daughter is 1 degree. Keeping Trump from campaigning is lawfare and blatantly illegal. Gag orders are designed to protect the defendant not the prosecution. Trump should hire an impersonator and write notes in court then every day when they adjourn stand next to the impersonator laughing and smiling as he reads Trumps notes. Trump is gagged Marchand is humiliated as he is helpless.
2 people like this.

Reply 16 - Posted by: danu 4/29/2024 10:09:47 AM (No. 1708235)
the wolves are eating the foxes, roosters, hens, and the henhouse , and the farmer. these justices are MIA for most of the fray
0 people like this.

Below, you will find ...
Most Recent Articles posted by "Moritz55"
and
Most Active Articles (last 48 hours)
Most Recent Articles posted by Moritz55"
Is the Worst Yet to Come? 6 replies
Posted by Moritz55 4/28/2024 8:27:14 PM Post Reply
This and that. Random thoughts and observations about current events. Trigger alert! What follows might “harm” the psyche of the woke. Perhaps those sensitive souls should retreat to a safe space, which I suspect will be Judenfrei. Peaceful protest is a hallowed right and tradition in America. These days, however, that right, which achieved so much good in the civil rights era, is being hijacked to disrupt everyday life in big cities and on university campuses. The protests are said to be about the suffering of Palestinians in Israel’s war against Hamas. But they’re not. They’re the ravings of antisemitic bigots and far left wing fanatics celebrating the terrorist savagery
Columbia students once rallied against
Nazis — now they cheer for them
5 replies
Posted by Moritz55 4/28/2024 2:30:47 PM Post Reply
Nearly a century ago, Columbia students staged mass protests against the university’s friendly relations with Nazi Germany. Today, Columbia students are protesting in support of Hamas terrorists who mimic the Nazis. How did this strange role reversal come about? In December 1933, Columbia president Nicholas Murray Butler invited the Nazi German ambassador to the United States, Hans Luther, to speak on campus. Students staged a huge protest rally against Luther. Some years ago, I interviewed one of those protesters.
Shock and Awe on the Campaign Trail 2 replies
Posted by Moritz55 4/28/2024 2:25:31 PM Post Reply
I would wager that a million or more words have been written about the trials and tribulations—but especially the trials—of Donald Trump. I have written quite a few myself, here at American Greatness and elsewhere. Some stories from the left are of the gleefully salivating variety. “Goodie! The Bad Orange Man is Getting His and Might Even go to Jail. Hallelujah!” But it is my impression that more and more commentary has a worried, if not an out-and-out tone of alarm. Former Attorney General William Barr is no fan of Donald Trump. But he recently announced that he was endorsing Trump because the likely alternative—Joe Biden—was so much worse.
On Alvin Bragg and the art of not taking
the law too seriously
5 replies
Posted by Moritz55 4/28/2024 11:14:22 AM Post Reply
Rube Goldberg, the inventor of bizarre machines that performed simple tasks through dozens of mechanical steps, was once asked about the essence of creating such fantastic, illogical machines. He replied “An inventor is simply a fellow who doesn’t take his education too seriously.” After the first week of testimony, the trial of Donald Trump is increasingly looking like a mad prosecution machine by lawyers who don’t take law too seriously. I have long been a critic of the Bragg indictment as legally incomprehensible. However, I must confess that after a week of testimony, some of us have developed a weird fascination with the utter madness of the scene unfolding in Manhattan.
Growth slowing, inflation rebounding:
Fresh, bitter Bidenomics pills
7 replies
Posted by Moritz55 4/27/2024 6:55:50 PM Post Reply
Literally the day after President Biden bragged, “We’re following my blue collar blueprint to rebuild America, and guess what? It’s working!” Bidenomics struck with a vengeance Thursday: The economy grew at just a 1.6% annualized rate in the first quarter, a third less than the consensus forecast. And while growth is slowing (from 4.9% in last year’s third quarter, to 3.4% in the fourth, and now 1.6%), inflation is heating back up. A key gauge of price hikes, the personal consumption expenditures (PCE) price index, excluding food and energy, surged at a 3.7% rate in the first quarter.
Justice Thomas raised crucial question
about legitimacy of special counsel's
prosecution of Trump
16 replies
Posted by Moritz55 4/27/2024 6:51:58 PM Post Reply
Supreme Court Justice Clarence Thomas raised a question Thursday that goes to the heart of Special Counsel Jack Smith's charges against former President Donald Trump. The high court was considering Trump's argument that he is immune from prosecution for actions he took while president, but another issue is whether Smith and the Office of Special Counsel have the authority to bring charges at all. "Did you, in this litigation, challenge the appointment of special counsel?" Thomas asked Trump attorney John Sauer on Thursday during a nearly three-hour session at the Supreme Court.
Alvin Bragg's Show Trial of Donald Trump
Is an Attack on the Rule of Law
8 replies
Posted by Moritz55 4/26/2024 8:47:00 PM Post Reply
The "criminal" trial of former president Donald J. Trump is underway, and there is much speculation about the merits of the case. We can dispense with that up front: the merits are practically nonexistent. Partisan prosecutor Alvin Bragg, more showman than lawman, alleges that a 2016 transaction from the Trump Organization was deceptively categorized in its accounting. Even if that dubious claim were true, it is only a misdemeanor offense whose statute of limitations ran out long ago. So how is it that a felony trial is underway for an act that isn't a felony, and is well outside the statute of limitations?
Iran’s Nightmares 10 replies
Posted by Moritz55 4/26/2024 8:06:17 AM Post Reply
Details of the recent limited Israeli retaliatory strike against Iranian anti-aircraft missile batteries at Isfahan are still sketchy. But nonetheless, we can draw some conclusions. Israel's small volley of missiles hit their intended targets, to the point of zeroing in on the very launchers designed to stop such incoming ordnance. The target was near the Natanz enrichment facility. That proximity was by design. Israel showed Iran it could take out the very anti-missile battery designed to thwart an attack on its nearby nuclear facility. The larger message sent to the world was that Israel could send a retaliatory barrage at Iranian nuclear sites with reasonable assurances that the incoming attacks could not
Biden's capital gains tax proposal could
crush the economy, experts say
16 replies
Posted by Moritz55 4/26/2024 8:01:34 AM Post Reply
President Biden's latest proposal to hike the top capital gains tax rate to its highest level in more than a century is facing heavy criticism from experts who warn such an action could significantly harm the U.S. economy. According to a report issued by the Treasury Department, led by Secretary Janet Yellen, the president's proposed fiscal year 2025 budget would increase the top marginal rate on long-term capital gains and qualified dividends to a staggering 44.6%. A capital gains tax hike of that magnitude would take the rate to its highest level since it was first introduced in the early 1920s.
Will Israel Be A Game-Changer In The 2024
Election? I&I/TIPP Poll
6 replies
Posted by Moritz55 4/24/2024 11:03:58 PM Post Reply
In recent weeks, the Biden administration has distanced itself and U.S. policy from Israel’s response to attacks from Hamas and Iran, two of Israel’s bitterest enemies. Americans show sharp political divisions in their support of Joe Biden’s policy shift toward the U.S.’ long-time Mideast ally. Hardly a day goes by without more news from the Mideast, much of it related to Israel’s retaliation following Hamas’ shocking Oct. 7 invasion, resulting in at least 1,200 dead and 240 kidnapped and held as hostages in Gaza and elsewhere.
In 2024, Americans Will Be Voting Like
It’s 1892
2 replies
Posted by Moritz55 4/24/2024 3:57:15 PM Post Reply
As the world’s oldest continually functioning constitutional republic, few things are unprecedented in American politics. Even the pending rematch between Donald Trump and Joe Biden, while a first within recent memory, has happened several times in our country’s long history. There have been six presidential election rematches in American history, going all the way back to John Adams and Thomas Jefferson’s showdown in 1800. In four of those rematches, the loser of the first tilt won. But one election in particular stands out as a model for Trump vs. Biden round two: the 1892 election between Grover Cleveland and Benjamin Harrison. To this day, it is the only rematch election
I Thought the Bragg Case Against Trump
Was a Legal Embarrassment. Now I Think
It’s a Historic Mistake.
10 replies
Posted by Moritz55 4/24/2024 2:29:13 PM Post Reply
About a year ago, when Alvin Bragg, the Manhattan district attorney, indicted former President Donald Trump, I was critical of the case and called it an embarrassment. I thought an array of legal problems would and should lead to long delays in federal courts. After listening to Monday’s opening statement by prosecutors, I still think the Manhattan D.A. has made a historic mistake. Their vague allegation about “a criminal scheme to corrupt the 2016 presidential election” has me more concerned than ever about their unprecedented use of state law and their persistent avoidance of specifying an election crime or a valid theory of fraud. To recap: Mr. Trump is accused
Most Active Articles (last 48 hours)
California Gov. Gavin Newsom Proclaims
April as Arab American Heritage Month
30 replies
Posted by Imright 4/28/2024 9:23:14 PM Post Reply
Gov. Gavin Newsom (D-CA) issued a proclamation on Saturday declaring April as Arab American Heritage Month. Newsom’s statement comes as anti-Israel protests and encampments have sprouted up on university and college campuses across the United States, calling for a ceasefire in the ongoing war between Israel and Hamas, for the U.S. government to stop arming Israel, and for colleges to divest from Israeli companies.WATCH — Pro-Israel and Pro-Palestinian Protesters Clash at UCLA: (Video)
McConnell: Military Aid ‘Is Not Charity
to Ukraine,’ U.S. Jobs Are Being Created
30 replies
Posted by mc squared 4/28/2024 7:03:59 PM Post Reply
Senate Minority Leader Mitch McConnell (R-KY) said Sunday on NBC’s “Meet the Press” that military aid to Ukraine was not charity, adding that it created jobs in the United States. Host Kristen Welker said, “I want to ask you about your legacy. You said just this week that you often feel like the only Reagan Republican left. As you prepare to step down from your leadership position this year, what are your greatest concerns about the future of the Republican Party?” McConnell said, “I tell you, I feel better about it after we had our vote. I don’t know what I said then, it may have been before the vote.
Ford Loses $1.3 Billion on Electric Vehicles
in First Quarter of 2024, Delays Plans
to Make More
28 replies
Posted by OhioNick 4/28/2024 4:48:54 PM Post Reply
Ford Motor Company reported a whopping $132,000 loss on each electric vehicle (EV) sold during the first three months of 2024, amassing a $1.3 billion loss. The auto manufacturer’s electric vehicle unit revealed Thursday that they experienced a 20 percent decrease in sales volume and were forced to slash prices due to low consumer demand, CNN reported. The revenue for Ford’s EV car, the Model e, plunged by 84 percent to about $100 million, which the company blamed on EV price cuts across the auto industry. “That resulted in the $1.3 billion loss before interest and taxes (EBIT), and the massive per-vehicle loss in the Model e unit,” the publication noted.​
Exclusive: Unhinged 63-Year-Old New York
Leftist with TDS Gets Rude Awakening –
Is Arrested for Keying Pickup Truck with
‘Let’s Go Brandon’ Sticker in Florida
22 replies
Posted by DW626 4/28/2024 10:41:19 PM Post Reply
Eff around and find out. A 63-year-old leftist from Syracuse, New York, has been arrested in Florida after being accused of keying a pickup truck with a “Let’s Go Brandon” sticker that provoked his ire. Richard Philip Brothers was arrested on March 26, 2024, after he was caught on camera keying a green Toyota Tundra in the parking lot of a Winn-Dixie supermarket in Monroe County, Florida. The incident occurred two days prior, on March 24. According to the police report obtained by The Gateway Pundit, “Richard Brothers knowingly and intentionally used a key to scrape the paint on the victim’s vehicle.
Snow White’s Evil Queen Being Played
by Transgender Biological Male at Disney
World Resort in Florida (Video)
20 replies
Posted by Imright 4/29/2024 12:56:09 AM Post Reply
A transgender biological male is playing Snow White’s Evil Queen at Walt Disney World Resort’s Wilderness Lodge in Florida. One family who went and filmed the character said they had paid $300 for a meet-and-greet photo opportunity after their themed dinner at Story Book Dining at Artist Point — only to be greeted by what the father referred to as a drag queen. (X Video) The father spoke to the Disney news site That Park Place, which broke the news that a man is playing a female character. The upset parent explained, “While we were waiting for the desserts to come out we received our invitation to meet the Evil Queen
Four teenagers including high school football
star aged 14 to 16 are killed in horror
crash after cop cruiser used PIT maneuver
to stop them speeding at 111mph - as horrifying
photos show their mangled wreckage
19 replies
Posted by zephyrgirl 4/29/2024 8:29:39 AM Post Reply
Four Florida teenagers have been killed after they were involved in a police chase in which officers used a maneuver designed to get a car to stop, but caused them to spin out of control. The four, who were between the ages of 14 and 16, attended Newberry High School in Bradford County, northeast of Gainesville. Two of the teens in the car died at the Waldo area scene, while the other two passed away from their injuries days later at UF Health Shands Hospital in Gainesville.
Radical Islamists Rally in Hamburg Calling
for Caliphate in Germany
18 replies
Posted by OhioNick 4/28/2024 4:47:17 PM Post Reply
The German city of Hamburg saw over a thousand Muslims rally on Saturday against the freedom of the press and other liberal values of the country while calling for the imposition of an Islamic caliphate. Around 1,100 gathered in the central Hamburg district of St. Georg — a progressive area of Germany’s second-largest city often identified as a gay neighbourhood — to demonstrate against what they perceived as an attempt by the media to portray all Muslims in Germany as radical Islamists. However, the rhetoric reported from the event indicated the radical positions of the group itself, with chants of Allahu Akbar (God is great or Our God is greater than yours).
D.C. Police Reject George Washington University’s
Request to Clear out Anti-Israel Encampment
18 replies
Posted by Dreadnought 4/28/2024 11:30:31 AM Post Reply
Police in Washington, D.C., rejected requests from campus officials at George Washington University to clear anti-Israel protesters from their campus encampment this week, fearing that doing so could be bad publicity. Although police were poised to disband the encampment at around 3 a.m. on Friday morning, city officials in the police chief’s and mayor’s office told police to stand down and said that it would look bad publicly for police to disrupt a “small number of peaceful protesters,” the Washington Post reported on Friday. The same city officials know of no immediate plans to clear out the school’s University Yard, which is blocks from the White House, and where the encampment
Chattanooga Volkswagen Workers Embrace
Union in Historic Vote as UAW Sets Its
Sights on the South
18 replies
Posted by Skinnydip 4/28/2024 10:52:10 AM Post Reply
Chattanooga, Tennessee, is known as “Gig City,” not for its many live music venues, but for its role as the first city in the Western Hemisphere to offer 1 gigabit-per-second fiber internet service to residents and businesses, an honor that it claimed in 2010. In 2024, Chattanooga has come to be representative of a different movement—the labor movement in the South. An overwhelming vote by the city’s Volkswagen employees on April 19 to join the United Auto Workers (UAW) union was the first crack in a decades-long barrier holding back the labor movement south of the Mason-Dixon Line. Until now, the Chattanooga facility has been the only non-union Volkswagen plant worldwide.
Campus anti-war protesters dig in from
New York to California as universities
and police take action
18 replies
Posted by 4250Luis 4/28/2024 6:52:38 AM Post Reply
From New York to California, students protesting the Israel-Hamas war slept in tents at college campuses, as some universities moved to shut down encampments and arrested dozens of demonstrators after reports of antisemitic activity. With the death toll mounting in the war in Gaza, protesters nationwide are demanding schools cut financial ties to Israel and divest from companies they say enable the conflict. Some Jewish students say the protests have veered into antisemitism and made them afraid to set foot on campus. At Columbia University in New York City, where early protests sparked pro-Palestinian demonstrations across the country, students and administrators have engaged in negotiations,
Biden tries to downplay age with jokes,
mocks Trump at White House Correspondents Dinner
16 replies
Posted by Mercedes44 4/28/2024 7:42:05 AM Post Reply
President Biden took the stage at the annual White House Correspondents Dinner on Saturday and cracked jokes about his old age. Biden spoke before a crowd of nearly 3,000 journalists, celebrities and Washington insiders at the Washington Hilton in Washington, D.C., as hundreds of anti-Israel protesters rallied outside. The black-tie annual event gives Biden a major platform to speak to voters — and flex his sense of humor — while his approval rating sits at a historic low ahead of the November election. Biden, 81, made jokes to make light of voters’ concerns about electing him into office for another four years in his advanced age. The 2024 election is in full swing.
Breaking: Rioting Pro-Hamas Students Tear
Down Barricades at George Washington University
Just Blocks From White House; Palestinian
Flag and Keffiyeh Draped on Statue of
Nation’s First President
15 replies
Posted by Imright 4/29/2024 5:10:17 AM Post Reply
Several hundred pro-Hamas students, angered by an attempted arrest of a protester by police, rioted at George Washington University overnight, located a few blocks west of the White House in Washington, D.C. The students tore down barricades that had blocked off an earlier attempted ‘occupy’ protest on campus grounds at University Yard (U-Yard). The students retook U-Yard, erecting tents and planting Palestinian flags on the pile of barricades. A Palestinian flag and keffiyeh draped on a statue of our nation’s first President George Washington at the start of the protest several days ago were still desecrating America’s founding father.
Post New Article