Post New Article

Gun rights showdown – Supreme Court
case a potential big win for Second Amendment

Original Article

Posted By: DVC, 11/2/2021 3:07:30 PM

On Wednesday, the Supreme Court will take up arguably the oldest and most controversial right in our history. New York State Rifle Association v. Bruen is the first major gun rights case in over 10 years to come before the Supreme Court and it has the makings of a major gun rights victory. The case concerns concealed-carry restrictions that require a showing of "proper cause." Lower courts have upheld the New York law, but there are ample constitutional concerns over its vague standard, such as showing that you are "of good moral character." New York wants to exercise discretion in deciding who needs to carry guns in public

Comments:

I am optimistic that this case may become the basis for mandating that all states use objective criteria for CCW permits , called "shall issue", as opposed to subjective "may issue" laws.

Post Reply

Reply 1 - Posted by: govlawyer 11/2/2021 3:19:17 PM (No. 964910)
I live in NY and have a concealed carry pistol permit; every pistol permit in NYS (or City for that matter) is a concealed carry permit because it is against the law to openly carry a pistol unless you're in law enforcement or an armored car crew member on duty; business owners can carry concealed in some limited situations as well. What the Court is deciding is basically whether or not we have a right to carry our handguns for purposes other than going to a firing range--namely for self defense. And in NY, only the truly elite are allowed to carry for that purpose (and they're the ones with bodyguards to boot). I don't have much hope for this one and predict that Roberts will be the deciding vote 5-4, simply because he's such a wuss, but I won't be surprised if Kavanaugh bails on us as well (call it a gut feeling). I can hear Kagan's questioning the petitioner's attorney now: "Why does he need a gun? Does he think he's Davey Crockett?"
9 people like this.

Reply 2 - Posted by: DVC 11/2/2021 3:41:40 PM (No. 964938)
Roberts voted for the Heller Case and for the MacDonald case, both major wins for Second Amendment rights where he could have pushed the ruling the other way, and did not. I think that there is a reasonable chance for a 6-3 vote on this one in favor of the Second Amendment, at worst 5-4, still in favor of gun rights.
7 people like this.

Reply 3 - Posted by: govlawyer 11/2/2021 4:16:56 PM (No. 964983)
#2- I hope I'm wrong, but the Roberts who voted for Heller is not the Roberts sitting up there today--we're witnessing his "evolution" (just like Barky obongo evolved on things).
5 people like this.

Reply 4 - Posted by: Stencil 11/2/2021 4:17:52 PM (No. 964985)
Nothing in court is a sure thing. Kind of like the saying Bear Bryant used about the pass - there are three things that can happen and two of them aren't good.
4 people like this.

Reply 5 - Posted by: chumley 11/2/2021 4:31:46 PM (No. 964999)
I have hope, but the SC has not shown me much lately. I dont know what is their inspiration but it isn't The Constitution.
7 people like this.

Reply 6 - Posted by: bpl40 11/2/2021 5:09:51 PM (No. 965035)
The Second Amendment to the Constitution, does not grant or create any rights. It merely admonishes State governments that their legitimacy and authority is contingent upon respecting a natural God given right of self defense that all Americans possess as freemen. Whether the Republic exists or not, its Constitution is upheld or not, this right will always exist. It doesn't need any 'victories'.
2 people like this.

Reply 7 - Posted by: DVC 11/2/2021 5:17:42 PM (No. 965042)
I see you philosophical point, and agree with the philosophy. But folks in NY, Hawaii, NJ, etc still go to jail for years if they try to act like they have this right....when their police, prosecutors and jailers do not see it that way. We need to work on getting the various states to recognize those pre-existing rights and stop arresting and imprisoning people for trying to exercise them.
5 people like this.

Reply 8 - Posted by: Come And Take It 11/2/2021 5:25:37 PM (No. 965048)
This case should be about as close to a legal slam dunk as you can get. It is very well reasoned BUT, I wouldn't even hazard a guess about this court past about three votes. After watching SCOTUS slap away every single legal challenge to the 2020 election, I don't think reason or legality factors into most of their decisions these days. Five years ago? I would have bet the farm. Now with Roberts and a bunch of McConnell appointees, no way.
0 people like this.

Reply 9 - Posted by: MickTurn 11/2/2021 6:12:51 PM (No. 965106)
I will relish the day the SCOTUS (Conservative Majority) takes this Law and shoves it in New Jerks Wazoo!
2 people like this.

Reply 10 - Posted by: Captain Howdy 11/2/2021 6:22:33 PM (No. 965117)
I hope that they establish strict scrutiny for 2nd amendment issues and that the opinion is authored by Clarence Thomas.
5 people like this.

Reply 11 - Posted by: bighambone 11/2/2021 6:45:37 PM (No. 965150)
No matter how the court rules the only only impact will be on law abiding firearms owners, as criminals and terrorists who possess and use illegal firearms to commit crimes are not about to obey any firearms control laws.
2 people like this.

Reply 12 - Posted by: udanja99 11/2/2021 7:25:59 PM (No. 965189)
All fifty states should have Constitutional Carry laws.
5 people like this.

Reply 13 - Posted by: SkeezerMcGee 11/2/2021 7:53:51 PM (No. 965222)
Thomas, Alito, Barrett, Kavanaugh, and Gorsuch will be in the majority to find parts of the New York Statute to be unconstitutional. Kagan and Sotomayor will have no problem with the New York law. Breyer could go either way. Robers will probably vote with the minority.
0 people like this.

Reply 14 - Posted by: DVC 11/2/2021 8:25:57 PM (No. 965253)
I think you are close, #14, but zero chance Breyer votes for ANY Second Amendment friendly ruling. Hell will freeze over long before that.
0 people like this.

Below, you will find ...
Most Recent Articles posted by "DVC"
and
Most Active Articles (last 48 hours)
Most Recent Articles posted by DVC"
Supreme Court Conservatives Maul New York's
Restrictive Concealed Carry Law in First
Major Second Amendment Case in a Decade
14 replies
Posted by DVC 11/4/2021 4:30:14 PM Post Reply
This morning, while most of us were reclining on one elbow and enjoying a cigarette and perhaps a warm, damp washcloth in the post-election afterglow of the Glenn Younkin, Winsome Sears, and Jason Miyares sweep of Virginia’s elections, the Supreme Court heard arguments in the first major Second Amendment case to make its docket since McDonald vs. Chicago in 2010. This is not because the Second Amendment hasn’t been under siege but because Chief Justice John Roberts has shown scant interest in treating the Second Amendment as anything other than a curious artifact of our history.
A cartoon (not The Simpsons for once)
predicts liberal meltdown over 'Lets go, Brandon'
5 replies
Posted by DVC 11/4/2021 4:02:43 PM Post Reply
Even as a full-grown adult with adult children, I still like cartoons. As I was raising my two sons, I made it a point to usually keep only one TV in the house. If video games were being played, or cartoons being watched, it was always a family affair — and intentionally designed as such. The idea was to compel negotiation, compromise, and good behavior all around. Any fighting over what to watch or play immediately resulted in no one watching or playing anything. Kids like to play and watch, so they naturally figured out how mostly not to fight about these things.
Texas builds makeshift border wall with
surprising material
8 replies
Posted by DVC 11/4/2021 2:00:09 PM Post Reply
Texas Gov. Greg Abbott has begun taking matters into his own hands, installing makeshift border walls created from repurposed shipping containers in strategic locations where migrants are likely to cross. Rep. Troy Nehls, R-Texas, who previously served as a sheriff in the Rio Grande Valley for eight years, called the new border structures "a great idea" Thursday on "Fox & Friends." "It’s a tool that the governor is using to try to help slow down, curb this invasion, this invasion that we’re seeing at our southern border," said Nehls. Nehls described the border wall construction as a "defensive position" to "channel" migrants into areas with larger law enforcement and Border Patrol presences.
Gun rights showdown – Supreme Court
case a potential big win for Second Amendment
14 replies
Posted by DVC 11/2/2021 3:07:30 PM Post Reply
On Wednesday, the Supreme Court will take up arguably the oldest and most controversial right in our history. New York State Rifle Association v. Bruen is the first major gun rights case in over 10 years to come before the Supreme Court and it has the makings of a major gun rights victory. The case concerns concealed-carry restrictions that require a showing of "proper cause." Lower courts have upheld the New York law, but there are ample constitutional concerns over its vague standard, such as showing that you are "of good moral character." New York wants to exercise discretion in deciding who needs to carry guns in public
Lindsey Graham breaks with most Republican
colleagues by supporting Biden judicial nominees
31 replies
Posted by DVC 10/30/2021 4:11:41 PM Post Reply
With Democrats controlling the Senate, it comes as no surprise that President Biden has successfully nominated dozens of federal judges, but nearly all of those picks enjoyed the support of a high-profile Republican: Sen. Lindsey Graham, R-S.C. Graham, who until January was the chairman of the Senate Judiciary Committee, voted in favor of all but three of Biden’s picks who have gone before the full Senate for votes. In two of those cases he did not vote at all, and he voted no in just one. In a political environment that has become highly polarized – particularly when it comes to presidential nominations – Graham’s approach to judicial nominations
Arizona Marine vet who disarmed robbery
suspect accepts heroism award in 'let's
go Brandon' T-shirt
6 replies
Posted by DVC 10/27/2021 12:21:11 PM Post Reply
The U.S. Marine Corps veteran seen on video stopping an attempted robbery at an Arizona convenience store has accepted an award from the Yuma County Sheriff’s Office for this "extraordinary heroism and exceptional courage" wearing a "let's go Brandon" T-shirt. James Kilcer was presented with the Citizen’s Valor Award on Tuesday following the incident that happened on Oct. 20. Sheriff Leon Wilmot gave Kilcer the award – which his office describes as the "highest award for citizens whose actions warrant recognition" – for Kilcer’s "extraordinary heroism and exceptional courage while voluntarily coming to the aid of another citizen during an incident involving criminal activity at extreme, life threatening, personal risk
NYC man who tried to strangle 11-year
old girl in park arraigned, out on bail
13 replies
Posted by DVC 10/24/2021 4:28:41 PM Post Reply
A 29-year-old man accused of trying to strangle an 11-year-old girl in a Manhattan park was arraigned and released on $7,500 bail on Saturday night. Nathaniel Direnzo, of Saint Marks Place, was arrested on Saturday morning for a bizarre, broad-daylight attack on the young girl and another minor on Wednesday afternoon. [SNIP] He was charged with second-degree strangulation, two counts of acting in a manner injurious to a child, second-degree harassment and two counts of assault. According to police, just around noon on Oct. 20, Direnzo approached the girl and her classmates at Stuyvesant Square and began to yell at them ,before spraying water on the group and trying to attack
Vaccine mandates create conflict with
defiant workers
8 replies
Posted by DVC 10/24/2021 1:23:56 PM Post Reply
Josh "Chevy" Chevalier is a third-generation shipbuilder who hasn't missed a day of work during the pandemic in his job as a welder constructing Navy warships on the Maine coast. But he's ready to walk away from his job because of an impending mandate from President Joe Biden that federal contractors and all U.S. businesses with 100 or more workers be fully vaccinated against COVID-19. "People are fighting for their constitutional rights — the way they think their life should be," said Chevalier, one of hundreds of employees at Bath Iron Works threatening to leave.
Maryland U.S. Rep. Andy Harris, a doctor,
prescribes ivermectin to patient to treat COVID-19
13 replies
Posted by DVC 10/20/2021 1:37:50 PM Post Reply
A Republican congressman from Maryland who is also a licensed physician said he prescribed the drug Ivermectin to patients for the treatment of the early stages of COVID-19. "I have prescribed ivermectin as treatment for early COVID," U.S. Rep. Andy Harris, who represents Maryland’s first congressional district, said in a statement to Fox 5 DC. "Data from India and elsewhere supports that off-label use. Off-label prescribing is commonly done for many medical illnesses." Harris, who was a physician at the Johns Hopkins Hospital, a medical officer in the Naval Reserve, and a state senator before coming to Congress, still practices part-time at Memorial Hospital in Easton, Maryland.
NBC fact-checks Fauci's fear that college
football games would be COVID super-spreaders:
'Never happened'
12 replies
Posted by DVC 10/18/2021 12:46:51 AM Post Reply
A report on NBC's "Today" Saturday fact-checked Dr. Anthony Fauci’s fear – made on its cable arm MSNBC – of a dramatic COVID-19 surge from crowded football stadiums, saying it "never happened." NBC reporter Shaquille Brewster reported packed stadiums for sporting events have not become "super-spreader events" for the coronavirus. "For weeks, crowds in the tens of thousands, mostly unmasked, have sat side-by-side now cheering on their teams at the halfway point of the season," Brewster reported. "All while doctors warned of games becoming potential super-spreader events. A frightening prospect at the time with hospitals already on the brink." Brewster cited Fauci’s theory that packed college games would lead to rising COVID cases
School Shootings and Students of Color 5 replies
Posted by DVC 10/17/2021 5:40:43 PM Post Reply
To paraphrase Jeff Foxworthy, if you feel a shiver of excitement when “school shooting” trends on Twitter, you just might be woke. Last Wednesday, Erica -- a nurse and “humanist” -- proved her wokeness in spades. “They’re already making excuses for the shooter ‘he got in a fight with someone,’” she tweeted. “Okay, but who chooses to shoot people? White males are a problem #TexasShooter #EnoughIsEnough.” Although reluctant to admit as much, many on the Left welcome a school shooting. Perhaps more than any other event, a shooting reinforces their empty mishmash of a worldview. It allows them to flaunt their hatred both of guns and of their lily-white selves.
How California seriously messed up its
drought problem
5 replies
Posted by DVC 10/17/2021 4:54:47 PM Post Reply
Who else but Mark Twain could have said, "Whiskey is for drinkin'. Water is for fightin'"? A few years after the Civil War, a one-armed veteran of the conflict did exhaustive explorations of the arid West. John Wesley Powel is credited with nailing down the difference between the eastern U.S. and the drought-prone west. This leads us to a tale of two cities: Los Angeles and San Francisco. At the beginning of the 20th century, both relied on well water to sustain their populations. And both had ambitious plans to build aqueducts to import snow melt from the fairly distant Sierra Nevada mountains.
Most Active Articles (last 48 hours)
'This is the Duchess of Sussex': Meghan
Markle is now cold calling Republican
Senators on their private numbers and
using her royal title to lobby for paid
paternity leave: Wants to be part of a
'working group' to formulate policy
53 replies
Posted by Imright 11/4/2021 5:52:06 AM Post Reply
Meghan Markle has called two Republican senators on their private numbers and using her royal title to urge them to vote in favor of paid parental leave, it emerged on Wednesday - shocking the politicians with her latest foray into political activism.The move is just the beginning for the Los Angeles-born mother of two, as she is now hoping to be part of 'a working group to work on paid leave long term,' according to Senator Kirsten Gillibrand. She called Republican Sens. Susan Collins from Maine Shelley Moore Capito from West Virginia, both of whom said they were shocked that Markle called out of the blue and
Rep. Adam Kinzinger Won’t Rule Out 2024
White House Run
52 replies
Posted by Imright 11/4/2021 7:13:45 PM Post Reply
Rep. Adam Kinzinger (R-IL), a staunch critic of former President Donald Trump who recently announced he would not seek reelection to Congress, has not ruled out launching a long-shot campaign for the White House in 2024.In a Thursday interview with CNN, Kinzinger said he is considering potential bids for the U.S. Senate in Illinois or the governor’s mansion. The anti-MAGA lawmaker added that he “definitely” isn’t ruling out a 2024 campaign for the highest office in the land.“The key is, how do we restore the honor of the party in the country?” he asked.
Joe Biden Administration Warns of ‘Planned
Inspections’ and $136,532 Fines to Enforce
Coronavirus Vaccine Mandate
40 replies
Posted by Imright 11/4/2021 11:08:32 AM Post Reply
President Joe Biden’s administration warned Thursday there would be “planned inspections” and heavy fines to ensure businesses comply with a new coronavirus vaccine mandate set for a Jan. 4th deadline.A senior Biden official spoke to reporters about their planned enforcement measures prior to leveling an Occupational Safety and Public Health requirement for businesses with over 100 employees to get them vaccinated for the coronavirus or test unvaccinated employees weekly and require them to wear masks.“We also will be having some programmed or planned inspections where we do go to workplaces to check to make certain that the workplace is in compliance
Mother of Loudoun County Bathroom Rapist
Blames Victim: 'You're 15. You Can Reasonably
Defend Yourself'
40 replies
Posted by ladydawgfan 11/4/2021 3:50:14 AM Post Reply
The mother of the skirt-wearing boy, who was convicted of raping a ninth-grade girl in a Loudoun County school restroom, said Monday that the victim was to blame for being assaulted because she did not make stronger attempts to defend herself. The boy's mother said in an interview that her son, who last week was found guilty on two counts of rape, was not transgender despite reports alleging that he was. She said he just likes to wear skirts sometimes. But she also defended her son's actions pertaining to the sexual assault, falsely alleging that, at the time of the May 28 assault, he "wanted to have sex in the bathroom,
Joe Biden: ‘Our Tables and Our Hearts
Are Gonna Be Full’ This Thanksgiving
35 replies
Posted by Imright 11/4/2021 5:28:59 AM Post Reply
President Joe Biden said Wednesday that Americans should be grateful that this Thanksgiving would be dramatically better than last year’s Thanksgiving.“A year ago, we were headed into a Thanksgiving where public health experts were advising against traveling or gathering with family and friends,” he said.The president recalled spending Thanksgiving dinner in 2020 with just his wife Jill and his daughter and son-in-law.“Later this month, our tables and our hearts are gonna be full, thanks to the vaccines,” he said, speaking to Americans from the White House on the importance of vaccinating children age 5-11 with the coronavirus vaccine.
White House: Actually, Joe Biden ‘Perfectly
Comfortable’ with Payouts for Illegal Immigrants
28 replies
Posted by Dreadnought 11/4/2021 8:54:54 PM Post Reply
The White House on Thursday reversed a comment made by President Joe Biden that his administration would not issue payouts to illegal immigrants suing the federal government. White House deputy press secretary Karine Jean-Pierre said Biden was actually “perfectly comfortable” with the idea, despite his comment Wednesday insisting it was “not going to happen.” She said: If it saves taxpayer dollars and puts the disastrous history of the previous administration’s use of zero tolerance and family separation behind us, the president is perfectly comfortable with the Justice settling with the individuals and families currently in litigation with the federal government.
NJ senate president now claims ballots
have suddenly APPEARED in race with trucker
who spent $153 on campaign: Dem refuses
to concede defeat in humiliating loss
to Raymour and Flanagan driver who 'doesn't
know' what he'll do in office
28 replies
Posted by Ribicon 11/4/2021 4:07:48 PM Post Reply
A Republican truck driver who spent just $153 on his campaign and ran for office after he was denied a gun permit secured a stunning victory against the longest-serving legislative leader in New Jersey history in the state's elections—but the loser is disputing the results and claims more ballots were 'found' on Thursday. The election was held on Tuesday but Associated Press only called the race today after 100 percent of precincts had reported. Underdog GOP candidate Ed Durr delivered a humiliating defeat to Democratic Senate President Steve Sweeney in South New Jersey's 3rd Legislative District by a razor thin margin of 52 percent of the vote to 48.
Angry Democrats Slam Joe Biden After Catastrophic
Election, ‘Nobody Elected Him to Be FDR’
26 replies
Posted by Come And Take It 11/4/2021 4:01:25 PM Post Reply
Imperiled and “mad” Democrats slammed President Joe Biden on Wednesday after the catastrophic election that left the Democrat Party disoriented over the defeats in Virginia, New York State, New Jersey, and Texas. “Nobody elected him to be F.D.R., they elected him to be normal and stop the chaos,” said vulnerable Rep. Abigail Spanberger (D-VA), suggesting Biden’s radical agenda will have a “bruising” impact on the 2022 midterms, the New York Times reported.
White House accuses Republicans of 'getting
in the way of saving lives' by fighting
back against Biden's new $14,000 vaccine
fines and they 'clearly have authority'
to impose rules facing flurry of lawsuits
25 replies
Posted by Imright 11/4/2021 6:17:32 PM Post Reply
The White House is confident that it can beat any Republican challenges to its new workplace vaccine mandate and claimed Thursday the GOP is trying to block the Biden administration from saving lives.'The question that we always have is and that we ask to the Republicans is why are they getting in the way?' Deputy Press Secretary Karine Jean-Pierre said during Thursday's White House press briefing.'Why are they getting in the way of trying to protect and save lives? That's all we're trying to do,' she added.
Arrest illustrates how the Steele dossier
was a political dirty trick orchestrated
by Hillary Clinton
24 replies
Posted by Imright 11/5/2021 12:00:22 AM Post Reply
Special counsel John Durham’s indictment of Igor Danchenko, the principal source for the bogus Steele dossier used by the FBI as a basis for the Trump-Russia investigation, further illustrates that Durham has his sights set on the Clinton campaign.Danchenko has been charged with five counts of lying to the FBI in interviews during 2017, as the bureau struggled in futility to verify outlandish allegations that Donald Trump and his campaign were clandestine agents of the Kremlin. Those allegations were compiled in the so-called Steele dossier, which the FBI relied on in obtaining surveillance warrants from a secret federal court.The dossier was generated by the Clinton campaign.
Judge Orders Release Of January 6 Defendant
After Inspection Shows ‘Mistreatment
Of Detainees’
24 replies
Posted by Come And Take It 11/4/2021 5:50:39 PM Post Reply
Following an impromptu inspection of the D.C. jail, a federal judge has ordered the release of January 6 defendant, Christopher Worrell, over the mistreatment of detainees. The surprise inspection of the jail by U.S. Marshals took place last month, but the report from the inspection was not made public until Wednesday. Due to the findings, U.S. District Judge Royce Lamberth said he has “‘zero confidence that the D.C. jail’ will provide the treatment correctly and not retaliate against Worrell,” who has cancer, CNN reported Wednesday.
US Navy FIRES USS Connecticut Captain,
XO and Chief of the Boat after $3.1bn
nuclear-powered attack submarine collided
with 'uncharted seamount' in South China Sea
23 replies
Posted by Ribicon 11/4/2021 7:22:02 PM Post Reply
The US Navy has fired a nuclear submarine's Commanding Officer, Executive Officer and Chief of the Boat for 'loss of confidence' after their vessel collided with an 'uncharted seamount' in the South China Sea. The $3.1 billion USS Connecticut's CO Cmdr Cameron Aljilani, XO Lt Cmdr Patrick Cashin and COB Cory Rodgers were relieved of their positions on Wednesday. A seamount is a mountain which rises from the ocean floor. A statement from the Navy said that the October 2 crash, which injured 11 crew members, could have been prevented with 'sound judgement, prudent decision-making and adherence to required procedures in navigation planning'.(Snip)Beijing today accused Washington
Post New Article