A Message From Lucianne

The Peculiar Blindness of Experts

Original Article

Posted By: DVC, 5/19/2019 10:45:37 AM

he bet was on, and it was over the fate of humanity. On one side was the Stanford biologist Paul R. Ehrlich. In his 1968 best seller, The Population Bomb, Ehrlich insisted that it was too late to prevent a doomsday apocalypse resulting from overpopulation. Resource shortages would cause hundreds of millions of starvation deaths within a decade. It was cold, hard math: The human population was growing exponentially; the food supply was not. Ehrlich was an accomplished butterfly specialist. He knew that nature did not regulate animal populations delicately. Populations exploded, blowing past the available resources, and then crashed. In his book, Ehrlich played out hypothetical scenarios


I normally am extremely suspect of The Atlantic, often a launching pad for ridiculous screeds. This is a good commentary, a lot of truth. Of course, any tiem Paul Ehrlich is show for the fool and incompetent that he is, it is a good thing. I have always had a wide bandwidth myself, and frequently been appalled at how ignorant some folks with a lot of knowledge in a narrow field are about the real world, and other things. I call it wide bandwidth, he calls them 'foxes'. But we agree.

Post Reply

Reply 1 - Posted by: snapper451 5/19/2019 11:03:05 AM (No. 67243)
I was young stupid and Democrat back in the 70's and after listening to and reading Ehrlich's book and predictions my wife and I decided to only have two children and then I had a vasectomy. No regrets, we are blessed with wonderful daughters and their families and our grandchildren. Perfect example of don't believe every crisis. I am now closer to 70 than 60 and watch things like Global Warming, Y2K, Save the Whales, etc. with great suspicion. What concerns me most about the Green movement is that it is all about controlling other peoples lives and power. Not a good thing.
8 people like this.

Reply 2 - Posted by: The Other Guy 5/19/2019 11:05:52 AM (No. 67244)
I read somewhere that an expert is defined as someone who knows more and more a bout less and less, who eventually knows everything about nothing.
9 people like this.

Reply 3 - Posted by: jacksin5 5/19/2019 11:20:46 AM (No. 67251)
What I find amazing is that no matter how much these so-called "Experts" pet theories are debunked, the MSM ignores their past faulty predictions, and seek out their opinions like they were the Oracles of Delphi.
13 people like this.

Reply 4 - Posted by: Nevadadad46 5/19/2019 11:26:24 AM (No. 67254)
I was an electronics expert, and Metallurgist in the early 70's. I looked at the idea of portable phones and declared loudly to anyone who would listen: "This is a stupid idea- it will never work! they would have to build transmission towers in every neighborhood!" I also predicted the home computer would be an absolute impossibility- they would be too large and way too expensive! My computer at work, which had the equivalent computing power of a modern wrist watch, had cost our company a half million bucks and took up two rooms and was operated by six highly paid technicians! I read an article in Popular mechanics about a global satellite navigation system: "What a crock of hooey!" I declared in public. Satellites are moving, the planet is moving! There is no way they could ever be made large enough to hold the computer needed to compensate for all that! Besides, you would need a satellite dish the size of a house to receive the signals! It will never work!" See? I was a scientist once...and what good did it do me? Alarmingly, I absolutely do not believe in Global Warming or CO-2 - "It's not science! It's bologna!"
9 people like this.

Reply 5 - Posted by: Chuzzles 5/19/2019 11:33:24 AM (No. 67257)
Ehrlich reminds me of people who refuse to acknowledge that there is a higher power at work. They can't wrap their heads around the fact that mankind cannot change a single thing in God's creation. But God can, and He will in the near future. He also refuses to acknowledge the role tyranny plays in the shortage of food. Take a look at South Africa, Zimbabwe, China, NK, Russia, Venezuela and all the countries who are ruled by dictators and Leftists. Some of those nations used to be the breadbasket of their continent, feeding millions. Now they can't even feed themselves and have to beg for scraps from the rest of us. If Ehrlich wants to be honest, it is his own political beliefs that are at the root of most of the current world problems. Not Christians and other commonsense thinkers.
7 people like this.

Reply 6 - Posted by: Axeman 5/19/2019 11:48:00 AM (No. 67260)
I'm surprised this appeared in The Atlantic. Intuitives know that they don't always know what they don't know and are much more flexible and curious. People with hard beliefs who are sure they are right will make the information fit their beliefs. I think this is basic to personality types and not training. I just have to wonder why people who are always wrong are still trusted.
1 person likes this.

Reply 7 - Posted by: LadyChurchillUSA 5/19/2019 11:52:03 AM (No. 67262)
I found this article very interesting and passed it on. I really do think that the key is to be a fox. Sometimes you just have to share and learn and even change your mind when it is called for.
1 person likes this.

Reply 8 - Posted by: bad-hair 5/19/2019 12:07:17 PM (No. 67269)
The Chinese apparently believed him as is the one child per fsmily polcy. Didn't work out becasuse all the families wanted sons. Now we have Occasionally-Cognizant tell ud that having children is harmful to the environment. Ollie you idiot, whose environment?
2 people like this.

Reply 9 - Posted by: DVC 5/19/2019 12:10:39 PM (No. 67274)
I really enjoyed, and excelled at managing widely varying technology projects in the former soviet states because I have had friends and interests in a wide range of fields. I really enjoyed managing top scientists, being able to learn about their specialties, ask good questions, be taught to understand their answers, learning more, and guiding them to be more effective in their fields. And occasionally cross pollinating with concepts from another field. I learned a lot, and had an intellectually challenging time. But, Putin put an end to our collabotation, as did The Zero. The money for cooperative scientific research dried up, and that was that. Narrow field experts can be hopelessly blindered, I love folks with broad spectrum knowledge and try hard to be one, to learn from fields new to me.
3 people like this.

Reply 10 - Posted by: snakeoil 5/19/2019 12:29:35 PM (No. 67282)
Interesting read. Thanks OP. Two of my favorites are the Great Horse Manure Crisis of the late 19th Century. No internal combustion engines, population increasing, and everyone needed a horse. Where would they put all that stuff that horses produce. Second, the 1916 appearance of Halley's Comet. The Earth passes through the tail of the comet. Predictions that all life would cease as the comet tail would cause the atmosphere to catch on fire. Today's The Sky is Falling is of course Climate Change aka Global Warming. I'll worry about robots. They don't sleep or blink their eyes.
1 person likes this.

Reply 11 - Posted by: BGray2 5/19/2019 12:44:47 PM (No. 67284)
I trust the opinion of someone who is good at many things over someone who is great at just one thing. The first can see the big picture, the other has tunnel vision.
2 people like this.

Reply 12 - Posted by: tom7 5/19/2019 2:03:24 PM (No. 67304)
In any discussion of Erlich's "Population Bomb", it would be useful to point out that his population projections assumed that no one ever died - they just kept propagating forever.
1 person likes this.

Reply 13 - Posted by: jeffkinnh 5/19/2019 3:00:08 PM (No. 67319)
There is something of broad interest illustrated here. The idea of Utopia, something liberals are continually in pursuit of, is founded on "experts" running everything. The smartest people, tightly focused in areas of their expertise, will solve all the world's problems. Yet, according to THIS research, putting experts in charge of planning would be catastrophic, resulting in the worst outcomes possible. The "smart" people that the dems are always pushing on us are the least likely to be successful. When they face failure, their claim is that the idea isn't wrong but that the right person, supposedly the smarter one, hasn't come along yet. This dogged hunt for their brilliant savior is likely doomed to failure. They may find a genius but he is most likely to make a bigger mess of things rather than fixing things up. Perhaps this is the power to succeed behind the structure of the American union. All the foxes are scrambling around and looking for possibilities. They aren't smart enough to "know" that some things won't work so they try them anyway. And ... success. Millions of foxes, running around trying to figure things out beat the geniuses in power, hands down, every time. The successful leader might want to learn how to raise foxes rather than how to solve problems.
1 person likes this.

Reply 14 - Posted by: chance_232 5/19/2019 3:09:10 PM (No. 67322)
What the experts always fail to take into account is the unquantifiable resourcefulness, ingenuity and tenacity of humans confronting a problem.
5 people like this.

Below, you will find ...
Most Recent Articles posted by "DVC"
Most Active Articles (last 48 hours)
Most Recent Articles posted by DVC"
F1 star Niki Lauda's family reveal he died surrounded by
close relatives at Swiss clinic days after he was
hospitalised for dialysis - as tributes pour in for one of the sport's 'greatest legends'
6 replies
Posted by DVC 5/21/2019 8:37:09 PM
Formula 1 legend Niki Lauda has died at the age of 70, his family has confirmed. Lauda, who won the F1 drivers' championship in 1975 and 1977 with Ferrari and again in 1984 with McLaren, passed away on Monday - eight months after undergoing a lung transplant. The Austrian died at University Hospital Zurich in Switzerland surrounded by his closest family, a spokesman said, after he was reported to have gone in for dialysis treatment earlier this month. Lauda had two kidney transplants in his life - the first in 1997 with an organ donated by his brother, and then again in 2005 donated by his future wife Birgit Wetzinger,
Eric Swalwell's shocking financial disclosure 13 replies
Posted by DVC 5/20/2019 10:25:35 PM
I believe that the technical psychiatric term for Rep. Eric Swalwell is "hot mess." Or at least it should be. After having been exposed as a liar about the "evidence" he claimed to have seen that President Trump is a traitor in league with Russia, Swalwell declared himself a candidate for president. Clearly, he has no chance, but at least one could justify it as a fundraising ploy appealing to the nutso faction of the Democrats, a significant constituency among the Donkeys.
Amash faces fresh GOP primary challenge
after Trump impeachment comments
15 replies
Posted by DVC 5/20/2019 11:00:06 AM
Less than 48 hours after GOP Rep. Justin Amash declared that President Trump "engaged in impeachable conduct," a fellow Republican has vowed to challenge him in the upcoming primary election. Michigan state Rep. Jim Lower made his intentions known Monday morning, announcing that instead of seeking a third term in the state legislature, he will run against Amash for their party's nomination for the 2020 election. Amash has served as the representative for Michigan's Third District since 2011 "Congressman Justin Amash tweets yesterday calling for President Trump’s impeachment show how out of touch he is with the truth
The Peculiar Blindness of Experts 14 replies
Posted by DVC 5/19/2019 10:45:37 AM
he bet was on, and it was over the fate of humanity. On one side was the Stanford biologist Paul R. Ehrlich. In his 1968 best seller, The Population Bomb, Ehrlich insisted that it was too late to prevent a doomsday apocalypse resulting from overpopulation. Resource shortages would cause hundreds of millions of starvation deaths within a decade. It was cold, hard math: The human population was growing exponentially; the food supply was not. Ehrlich was an accomplished butterfly specialist. He knew that nature did not regulate animal populations delicately. Populations exploded, blowing past the available resources, and then crashed. In his book, Ehrlich played out hypothetical scenarios
This is Truly a Trade War 3 replies
Posted by DVC 5/17/2019 4:34:18 PM
The trade negotiations between the Trump administration and the People's Republic of China (PRC) are not rooted in commercial disputes. Though media discussions are dominated by issues about opening markets for U.S. exports limited by Chinese policy, the real issue is national security and the need to keep the balance of power tilted in America's favor. Business is the means, not the end. Comparative national capabilities in industry and technology determine military potential, and financial strength supports economic development and diplomatic influence. China's rapid growth has moved the country from the seventh largest GDP in 1980 to the second largest today with the world's largest manufacturing capacity.
Democratic social media poll finds more users want Supreme Court justices like Kavanaugh than Ginsburg 7 replies
Posted by DVC 5/5/2019 3:50:01 PM
A Democratic Senatorial Campaign Committee Twitter poll asking what type of Supreme Court justices social media users would like to have on the bench apparently backfired when 71 percent of respondents selected “justices like Brett Kavanaugh” compared to just 29 percent who chose “justices like Ruth Bader Ginsburg.” The poll, which is not scientific and open to anyone with a Twitter account, was posted on May 3 and stated it had two more days before it closes. There is likely no pairing currently on the Supreme Court more dissimilar than Ginsburg and Kavanaugh.
The Solar Energy Racket 25 replies
Posted by DVC 5/5/2019 2:04:44 PM
If solar energy were not propped up by various government policies and subsidies, no utility would buy it. Not only does solar not work at night, but it does not work if it is cloudy or if a cloud passes in front of the sun. Utility-scale solar requires a large solar farm consisting of photovoltaic panels. For $100 million, one can buy a solar farm capable of generating about 80 megawatts of electric power when the sun is squarely shining on the panels. Depending on the geographical location and the climate, the average power generated will be about 18 megawatts,
Injuries reported after burning Aeroflot plane lands at Moscow´s Sheremetyevo Airport 8 replies
Posted by DVC 5/5/2019 1:37:05 PM
At least 10 people were injured after a fire was reported on a Russian airliner that landed in flames at Moscow´s Sheremetyevo Airport on Sunday, according to local media. Russian national carrier Aeroflot flight SU1492, a Sukhoi SSJ-100 regional jet, had taken off from the airport headed to Murmansk before it was forced to turn around and make a landing at the airport. Flight tracking website FlightRadar24 said the flight had reported an emergency after takeoff and returned to Sheremetyevo Airport.
AG Barr gets attacked because his probe endangers powerful people 38 replies
Posted by DVC 5/3/2019 2:42:20 AM
The only thing uglier than an angry Washington is a fearful Washington. And fear is what’s driving this week’s blitzkrieg of Attorney General William Barr. Mr. Barr tolerantly sat through hours of Democratic insults at a Senate Judiciary Committee hearing Wednesday. His reward for his patience was to be labeled, in the space of a news cycle, a lawbreaking, dishonest, obstructing hack. Speaker Nancy Pelosi publicly accused Mr. Barr of lying to Congress, which, she added, is “considered a crime.” House Judiciary Committee Chairman Jerrold Nadler said he will move to hold Mr. Barr in contempt unless the attorney general
Barr stuns Sen. Blumenthal during Judiciary Committee hearing 18 replies
Posted by DVC 5/2/2019 4:36:05 PM
Attorney General William Barr is unflappable, a quality that enabled him to deftly handle the “pack of Iagos” that Democrats on the Senate Judiciary formed into yesterday. In addition to highlighting the key question for which there is no good answer, he stunned Senator Richard Blumenthal, the villain who falsely posed as a Vietnam Veteran yet somehow maintains the trust of Nutmeg State voters. Blumenthal was on a fishing expedition, looking for quibbles to raise in the wake of the collapse of the Russia Hoax. Assuming the role of a Grand Inquisitor – the favorite pose of Democrats in the
Pope sends aid to migrants stranded at the US border 35 replies
Posted by DVC 4/27/2019 3:39:49 PM
Pope Francis has donated 500,000 dollars to assist migrants in Mexico. The funds, from the Peter’s Pence collections, will be distributed among 27 projects promoted by sixteen Mexican dioceses and religious congregations, which requested assistance in continuing to provide food, lodging, and basic necessities to the migrants. According to a statement from Peter’s Pence, “In recent months, thousands of migrants have arrived in Mexico, having travelled more than 4,000 kilometres on foot and with makeshift vehicles from Honduras, El Salvador and Guatemala. Men and women, often with young children, flee poverty and violence, hoping for a better future in the United
Massachusetts judge who helped illegal immigrant escape ICE arrest indicted, federal authorities say 18 replies
Posted by DVC 4/25/2019 1:43:04 PM
A Massachusetts judge and a court officer accused of helping an illegal immigrant flee an Immigration and Customs Enforcement agent waiting to take him into custody were indicted Thursday by a federal grand jury for obstruction of justice and three other counts, officials said. U.S. Attorney for the District of Massachusetts Andrew Lelling and Peter Fitzhugh, special agent in charge of the Homeland Security Investigations in Boston, announced the charges in a news conference Thursday afternoon. Newton District Court Judge Shelley M. Richmond Joseph and the court officer, identified in court documents as Wesley MacGregor, face several charges stemming from an April
Most Active Articles (last 48 hours)
Ocasio-Cortez says growing cauliflower
in community gardens is 'colonial'
51 replies
Posted by NorthernDog 5/21/2019 11:36:22 AM
Rep. Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez said Sunday that growing cauliflower in community gardens is part of the “colonial” attitudes that her Green New Deal will stamp out. The New York Democrat, who introduced the proposal to tackle climate change by radically transforming the economy, posted a series of Instagram videos filmed in her home state talking about community gardens as a “core component” of her proposal. “What I love too is growing plants that are culturally familiar to the community. It’s so important,” she said as she filmed a community garden in the Bronx. “So that’s really how you do it right.
Nevada passes National Popular Vote
bill in bid to upend Electoral College
27 replies
Posted by Harlowe 5/22/2019 12:39:48 AM
The Nevada Senate approved Tuesday a National Popular Vote bill on a party-line vote, sending the legislation aimed at upending the Electoral College to the governor. Assembly Bill 186, which passed the Senate on a 12-8 vote, would bring Nevada into the National Popular Vote Interstate Compact, an agreement between participating states to cast their electoral votes for the winner of the popular vote. If signed as expected by Democratic Gov. Steve Sisolak, Nevada would become the 16th jurisdiction to join the compact, along with 14 states and the District of Columbia.
Four in 10 Americans Embrace
Some Form of Socialism
27 replies
Posted by M2 5/21/2019 5:38:25 AM
Americans today are more closely divided than they were earlier in the last century when asked whether some form of socialism would be a good or bad thing for the country. While 51% of U.S. adults say socialism would be a bad thing for the country, 43% believe it would be a good thing. Those results contrast with a 1942 Roper/Fortune survey that found 40% describing socialism as a bad thing, 25% a good thing and 34% not having an opinion. The Roper/Fortune survey is one of the oldest trend questions measuring attitudes on socialism in the U.S. Gallup's update of the question in an April 17-30 survey finds
AOC, Warren disappointed by
'Game of Thrones' finale:
'Ugh, this was written by men'
25 replies
Posted by NorthernDog 5/21/2019 10:25:30 PM
Sen. Elizabeth Warren, D-Mass., and Rep. Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez, D-N.Y., joined the legion of “Game of Thrones” fans disappointed by the show’s finale. “I’m sad,” said Ocasio-Cortez in a video of the two legislators posted to Warren’s Twitter account Tuesday. “Disappointed about it.” “I was just really… meh,” said Warren. The pair bemoaned the arcs of the female characters who seemed prime to rule at the end of the series. Instead, one “went crazy” and the other settled for ruling only part of the continent. The lawmakers were not alone in their distaste for the series’ treatment of its female characters
A federal judge’s ‘tell’ in his order
forcing Trump to turn over financial records
to House committee
23 replies
Posted by Magnante 5/21/2019 7:23:40 AM
The political zealotry of the federal judge who ordered ten years’ worth of Donald Trump’s financial records be turned over to the House Oversight and Reform Committee chaired by Elijah Cummings has been revealed with a highly unusual provision of his order. (snip) The remedy for potential political bias in a federal judge’s ruling consists of the appeals process, with the US Court of Appeals for the District of Columbia and ultimately the Supreme Court able to reverse such a decision. But Judge Mehta’s order forbids this
What's Mitt Romney's problem? 22 replies
Posted by ladydawgfan 5/21/2019 2:43:23 PM
After taking President Trump's endorsement to get himself elected senator, Mitt Romney has made quite a show of turning on Trump. The last two incidents have been notable: He declared GOP "maverick" congressman Justin Amash "courageous" for joining the Democrats and calling for the impeachment of President Trump in the House. He also made this ad hominem attack on Trump over the weekend, playing Puritan for us: On Sunday, Romney was back at it, attacking the president's character. "I think he could substantially improve his game when it comes to helping shape the character of the country," Romney said on CNN.
New Gallup Poll finds Americans liking
the idea of socialism more
21 replies
Posted by SurferLad 5/21/2019 5:20:30 PM
Here’s a revealing — and disturbing — new poll that bears on the current gang fight among leftists for the soul of the Democratic Party and its 2020 presidential nomination. See Also: ESPN chief: You’ll never guess what our viewers want to hear nothing about Almost half of Americans in a new Gallup Poll believe that socialism would be a good thing for the United States to have. Almost half (43 percent). A good thing. Democrats like Bernie Sanders driving that party to the left may be on to something for a winning theme in next year’s vote. Today, a bare majority (51 percent) says socialism would
“Something Strange Going On” At Fox News,
And Not For the Good of America
21 replies
Posted by Cavallodifiero 5/21/2019 1:59:04 PM
There’s no longer any way to avoid it: “Something strange is going on at Fox News.” “Something strange is going on at Fox News. Something very strange,” President Donald Trump told a throng of thousands at his Pennsylvania rally last night. “The audience showed their agreement by booing Fox News.” (The Blaze, May 21, 2019) According to the Blaze "President Donald Trump
Jerry Nadler’s cynical, cowardly show 19 replies
Posted by MissMolly 5/22/2019 3:57:46 AM
Jerry Nadler was at it again Tuesday, waxing indignant about former White House counsel Don McGahn’s refusal to testify before the House Judiciary Committee. It’s all a show, meant to keep old news in the headlines, and to appease the large “Impeach Now!” wing of the Democratic Party without actually doing anything. Everyone on Judiciary knows perfectly well that Congress can’t compel testimony from top presidential advisers except in the most extraordinary circumstances: The chief executive’s right to frank, confidential discussions with his staff is well-established. So Nadler’s bluster about how he’ll “go to court to secure” McGahn’s appearance is just noise for the cameras. Then again, that’s all
House Judiciary Chairman Nadler: Trump
is making it 'more difficult' not to consider
19 replies
Posted by Hazymac 5/21/2019 11:38:19 AM
House Judiciary Committee Chairman Jerrold Nadler, D-NY, accused the White House of "intimidating" former White House Counselor Don McGahn from testifying on Capitol Hill and said it was becoming "more and more difficult" to not consider President Trump's impeachment on Monday night. Nadler told CNN anchor Chris Cuomo that his committee will hold McGahn "in contempt" for not complying with the subpoena and will take the battle to court. "You are dealing with a lawless president who is willing to go to any lengths to prevent testimony that might implicate him, that does implicate him," Nadler said. Nadler expressed that Trump's "lawless behavior"
Self-driving trucks begin mail
delivery test for U.S. Postal Service
19 replies
Posted by NorthernDog 5/21/2019 10:30:55 AM
The U.S. Postal Service on Tuesday started a two-week test transporting mail across three Southwestern states using self-driving trucks, a step forward in the effort to commercialize autonomous vehicle technology for hauling freight. San Diego-based startup TuSimple said its self-driving trucks will begin hauling mail between USPS facilities in Phoenix and Dallas to see how the nascent technology might improve delivery times and costs. A safety driver will sit behind the wheel to intervene if necessary and an engineer will ride in the passenger seat. If successful, it would mark an achievement for the autonomous driving industry and a possible
Democrats Embrace Socialism:Are We
Headed Towards 'Atlas Shrugged'?
18 replies
Posted by Hazymac 5/21/2019 8:45:28 AM
There's a recurring theme in American science fiction where the country loses its way, endures some horrible but cleansing disaster, and then rediscovers the blessings of liberty. You'll find it in Robert Heinlein's "Future History" stories, where the Crazy Years -- a period of rapid technological advances, decaying social norms, and mass psychosis -- leads to the backlash of a religious dictatorship. The Prophets regime is eventually toppled by a liberty-loving group dedicated to individual rights. The theme is even more pronounced in Ayn Rand's Atlas Shrugged, where a socialist regime puts the country into another Great Depression, only worse. The country's capitalists
Post New Article