Post New Article

Attorney, Self-Defense Expert: Alex Pretti
Shooting Was Legally Justified

Original Article

Posted By: J. Arthur Brown, 1/28/2026 10:04:51 AM

With many videos and angles emerging, many are wondering if the shooting of Alex Pretti by federal officers was legally justified. Andrew Branca -- an attorney, author, and internationally recognized expert on self-defense -- joined Liz Collin on her podcast and explained some of the details that he included in his own viral video analysis of the incident. Branca explained that "fundamentally all the videos are pretty consistent consistent with each other and really nothing's inconsistent with this being a lawful use of force."

Comments:

"And the one's that spurred us on sit in judgment of our wrongs." This line must be going through the minds of ICE agents who have watched certain "influencers" on Fox News in the last 74 hours. There is nothing more contemptible than to send someone out to do a thankless job and then fail to stand behind them when they encounter fully foreseeable difficulties. The job must be continue to be done until every last illegal alien is deported. Bovino and Homan Si, Squishes No!

Post Reply

Reminder: “WE ARE A SALON AND NOT A SALOON”

Your thoughts, comments, and ideas are always welcome here. But we ask you to please be mindful and respectful. Threatening or crude language doesn't persuade anybody and makes the conversation less enjoyable for fellow L.Dotters.


Reply 1 - Posted by: JHHolliday 1/28/2026 10:09:17 AM (No. 2061308)
Ashley Babbitt was murdered in cold blood by a Capitol cop. I don't remember any outrage from the left or their mouthpieces on the left. Remember her name.
51 people like this.

Reply 2 - Posted by: earlybird 1/28/2026 11:55:01 AM (No. 2061359)
An excellent article and video. Should be a Must Read.
19 people like this.

Reply 3 - Posted by: JimBob 1/28/2026 11:55:40 AM (No. 2061360)
As usual, a LIE Goes Around the World while the Truth is Putting On it's Shoes. The Truth on the Minneapolis shootings can be allowed to start seeping out (not to be mentioned by the Lamestreams, but through alternative outlets that do not have nearly the reach to the Great Unwashed) now, as the Left and the Lamestreams have milked this dry over several news cycles. Time to 'Move On' to a new Lie to further stir up the Useful Idiots. Just like all the other 'news' lies that the Left uses to further The Cause... When the Truth finally comes out, it is Radio Silence, and On to the Next Outrage (also a Lie.) It is a never-ending treadmill. It is Standard Operating Procedure for the Leftist Lamestream Liars.
19 people like this.

Reply 4 - Posted by: chance_232 1/28/2026 1:39:06 PM (No. 2061416)
I think Ill wait for the facts to come out before drawing and conclusions in this case. I have questions.
4 people like this.

Reply 5 - Posted by: DVC 1/28/2026 2:27:55 PM (No. 2061446)
Excellent analysis by a lawyer who is particularly schooled in self defense law. He makes the excellent point that most lawyers don't know anything much about self defense law, since " it is not covered in any significant dept in law school.", to quote Branca. This matches what many commenters here have said. Pretti came armed, with the intent to attack ICE agents. THAT attack is a federal felony, so they tried to arrest him. He violently resisted arrest, and in the melee that Pretti caused, it was discovered that he had a gun, which ups the ante massively in any fight with LEOs, and then 'a shot was fired'....and the ICE agents responded by shooting him. It isn't absolutely clear how the "shot was fired". Some report that an ICE agent caused an accidental discharge of Pretti's gun while removing it in the melee. The gun model is well known for having a light, short trigger pull and NO THUMB SAFETY, so accidental discharges are distressingly common with this particular model. Multiple police agencies have selected the P320 SIG pistol, and then switched after excessive numbers of accidental discharge by officers. The US Army uses this model.....BUT, the Army version has a thumb safety. Very few civilian versions have the manual "thumb" safety.
14 people like this.

Reply 6 - Posted by: J. Arthur Brown 1/28/2026 4:03:55 PM (No. 2061496)
Be sure to click the link for the second video containing a solo presentation by Mr. Branco. The regime media are silent re the cost of Pretti's gun-gunsight combo ($2,000) and the 20-bullet capacity of its magazine. Several law enforcement officers could have been lost in this incident.
10 people like this.

Reply 7 - Posted by: ARKfamily 1/29/2026 6:05:59 AM (No. 2061714)
As far as I am concerned, Alex Pretti was not going to a protest. He was going to a federal legal proceeding and trying to intervene. I am tired of seeing statements that he was going to a protest. He absolutely does not have a right to bring a firearm to a federal legal proceeding.
8 people like this.

Reply 8 - Posted by: Dodge Boy 1/29/2026 7:17:08 AM (No. 2061743)
Of course, it was legally justified. Interfering with a LEO and aiming a gun at him is generally a very bad idea. I'll bet Pretti won't do that again.
8 people like this.

Reply 9 - Posted by: athina 1/29/2026 8:08:48 AM (No. 2061761)
He had the right to carry a weapon. He had the right to carry an extra magazine. He can’t be condemned for that alone. You can’t presume violent intent, because it’s his right. And the officers did not presume it either, until he appeared to reach for it while resisting arrest. As one whose 2A rights are unconstitutionally restricted here in NY, I hate to see the Trump administration making statements that imply he did not have that right. Their language is fuzzy:’carry a gun to a protest and expect to be killed’. No, that should not be the point made here. He interfered and he resisted, and THEN he appeared to be a threat with a weapon. That’s the point.
9 people like this.

Reply 10 - Posted by: danu 1/29/2026 3:20:04 PM (No. 2062003)
we're glad ICE were able to get an expert in self-defence; it could well be the saving of them going forward --in such a hostile over-heated stretch of the minnisnowta mayhem. may they all fall down, on their airses. i'm stuck on --the intent--before the 'so-calledprotestor' left home w/ such an unsafe gun as this. yes, the irrelevant gossip was- this man was kinky, and as mad as a bag of bees. some goofballs re-did his photo to glam him up--the face, hair, added biceps--h'wood style-- but there's more to this. the sorazz psycho-commies want to paint feds as knuckle-dragging imbeciles w/ guns. nevertheless, it is the shooter who demonstrated the real, willingly dangerous, extremism: the patent lack of due care, the sound reason, and proper training it takes to go out in public -- loaded for bear-- to public riots /protests/ general lunacy on a maoist scale/ hunting for ... federal targets, knowingly it would seem, carrying a spikey sort of gun without a safety catch. if blame belongs anywhere, it is on the uber-rich psychopaths who pay the criminally unstable dirtbags they import --to set loose on america for kink and kicks, and 80B in fraud thus far, in mn. the blame is on the evil politicians taking bribes to protect these 'mad emperors' from prison, and the death penalty. lock them up. all up. in a death penalty state. nuremberg isn't good enough for these shoitez. bring us the faucinstein crime gang; we'll talk. oi, gaslighting gop goebbelist gasbags in the uniparty of crime: we want you too, for starters: in angola, rikers, sing sing, alcatraz, II , alligator hilton, gitmo, the dc gulag, el salvador, fulton county-listening to big fanny and raffensberger complaining, and kemp after he returns the ill-gotten gains ...commies to devils island, the bastille. you'll be charmed w/ all the ...local colour... au revoir gophairs.
1 person likes this.

Below, you will find ...
Most Recent Articles posted by "J. Arthur Brown"
and
Most Active Articles (last 48 hours)
Most Recent Articles posted by J. Arthur Brown"
Josh Shapiro Accuses JD Vance Of Antisemitism
Over Not Mentioning Jews In Holocaust
Remembrance Statement -- He Didn't Mention
Them Either
1 reply
Posted by J. Arthur Brown 1/30/2026 12:35:02 AM Post Reply
Pennsylvania Governor Josh Shapiro has accused JD Vance of being antisemitic for not mentioning that it was the Jewish people who were killed in the Holocaust in his post marking Holocaust Remembrance Day. Shapiro, however, did not explicitly state that it were Jews killed in the Holocaust either. (snip) "It is not surprising to me, however, given the way in which he has openly supported the AfD Party, given the way he openly embraces neo-Nazis and neo-Nazi political parties, given the way in which he has offered comfort, really, to the antisemites on the right who are infecting the Republican Party," Shapiro continued.
Breaking: Jury Finds Seattle Negligent
In 2020 Chaz Killing Of 16-Year Old Antonio
Mays, Jr, Awards Family $30 Million
5 replies
Posted by J. Arthur Brown 1/29/2026 9:41:46 PM Post Reply
A King County jury found the City of Seattle negligent and liable for the 2020 death of 16-year old Antonio Mays Jr., who was fatally shot in the Capitol Hill Autonomous Zone (CHAZ), also known as the Capitol Hill Organized Protest (CHOP). The verdict, delivered three-plus weeks after a month-long trial at the King County Courthouse presided over by Judge O'Donnell, stems from a wrongful death lawsuit filed by the Mays Estate accusing the city of negligence in the handling of the zone, which protesters occupied for three weeks amid nationwide unrest following George Floyd's death.
David Marcus: Minneapolis Protesters Think
They Are In "One Battle After Another,"
But This Isn't A Movie
1 reply
Posted by J. Arthur Brown 1/29/2026 8:43:29 PM Post Reply
Fox News digital columnist David Marcus analyzed the anti-ICE demonstrators in Minneapolis in an interview with network host Will Cain. (snip) [David Marcus:] Let's be perfectly clear: Alex Pretty [sic.] was not at a protest. There was no protest. He was in a direct action, the purpose of which was to impede federal officers from making an arrest. It succeeded. The suspect got away. These people are running around in these organized militia groups as if they're in "One Battle After Another" with Leonardo DiCaprio (snip.) But this isn't a movie. People are dying. And we need it to stop. And I'd like to hear the President send that message.
Democrats Using Shutdown Threat To Rewrite
Immigration Enforcement
10 replies
Posted by J. Arthur Brown 1/29/2026 7:56:06 PM Post Reply
Another government shutdown looks increasingly likely by the end of the week. Democrats are demanding that major changes to Department of Homeland Security enforcement policy be written directly into the budget agreement. Those changes would largely shut down President Trump's deportation efforts. (snip) They want to require judicial warrants for immigration arrests, force ICE agents to be readily identifiable and grant states the authority to conduct their own investigations of federal ICE agents. Democrats have also demanded body cameras for ICE agents, even though the current budget proposal already funds them. (snip) Democrats have one goal in mind: Stop Trump from deporting illegal aliens.
The Key Reason Democrats Stop At Nothing
To Block Deportations
4 replies
Posted by J. Arthur Brown 1/29/2026 5:25:30 PM Post Reply
In a recent interview with Fox News, former ICE Acting Director Jonathan Fahey said that "Democrats fight each deportation as if it's a Democratic vote." Rarely have truer words been uttered. (snip) The American Redistricting Project (snip) published its 2030 Apportionment Forecast (snip) (b)ased on the Census Bureau's July 1, 2025 population estimate (snip) shows California losing four seats. Illinois, Minnesota, New York, Oregon, Pennsylvania, Rhode Island, and Wisconsin each lose one seat tor a total of 11 seats lost among blue states [with] (snip) red and purple states gaining those same eleven seats.
Slouching Toward Fort Sumter? 8 replies
Posted by J. Arthur Brown 1/29/2026 4:19:17 PM Post Reply
In the months before the April 12, 1861, firing on Fort Sumter, there were sharp divisions in the North about the proper reaction to the first seven states that had already left the Union. (snip) Something similar is emerging over Minnesota (snip.) Governor Walz, Mayor Frey, and Attorney General Ellison are actively encouraging Minnesotans to obstruct federal officers (snip.) They view as a political asset millions of arriving poor in dire need of massive federal (snip) subsidies and entitlements (snip.) They still cherish the months of riots (snip) in the George Floyd "summer of love" in 2020 as critical in defeating Donald Trump.
Minnesota Cops Beg Walz, Pols To Let Them
Work With ICE, Say They Could Have Prevented Shooting
10 replies
Posted by J. Arthur Brown 1/29/2026 3:06:48 PM Post Reply
The head of a major Twin Cities police union slammed local officials for blocking cooperation between local cops and ICE and Border Patrol agents -- saying if they were involved, "there would be no loss of life." (snip) Since the Republican National Convention was held in St. Paul in 2008, Minnesota law enforcement has undergone extensive training in mobile field force configurations and crowd management for major events. And because of that, I think we're in the best position to deal with that," Ross said. "Unfortunately, our local politicians would not allow us to do that," he added.
Legal Analyst Says New Video Shows Alex
Pretti's "State Of Mind" Before Fatal
Border Patrol Shooting
6 replies
Posted by J. Arthur Brown 1/29/2026 12:08:45 PM Post Reply
Newly released video that appears to show Alex Pretti spitting at federal agents and damaging a government SUV days before he was fatally shot by U.S. Customs and Border Protection/Border Patrol agents in Minneapolis "shows his state of mind" leading up to his death, Fox News legal analyst Greg Jarrett said Wednesday."He was an angry person who is expressing his rage with assault. Spitting at an officer is assault, obviously attacking a federal vehicle and destroying the property, and then he seems to resist, to some extent, the arrest. It tells you a lot about his mindset" (snip.)
How China Supercharged "Birth Tourism"
And Scammed American Citizenship For Up
To 1.5 Million Babies
9 replies
Posted by J. Arthur Brown 1/29/2026 11:02:56 AM Post Reply
As we sang "Auld Lang Sein" in the early morning of Jan. 1, 2025, the first American newborn of the year arrived to much fanfare and celebration. But this time, the baby was the progeny of Chinese citizens (snip.) Birth tourism from China exploded under President Barack Obama's tenure because his administration (snip) instructed US consular officers "not to deny visa applicants solely because they planned to travel to the United States to obtain citizenship for their child."(snip) Beijing encourages US birth tourism (snip.) A group of influential, indoctrinated, legal citizens is being indoctrinated to act in China's interests, not America's.
More Cities Rebel Against ICE After Trump's
Compromise In Minnesota Showed Riots Work
22 replies
Posted by J. Arthur Brown 1/28/2026 7:29:06 PM Post Reply
The Trump Administration's response to the weekslong insurrection in Minneapolis showed left-wing leaders across the country one thing: Riots work. (snip) Democrats in other cities are emboldened to block Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE) officers from doing their jobs. (snip) Sean Ryan, Democrat mayor of Buffalo, New York, decided on Monday to prohibit "the use of City of Buffalo personnel or resources for federal immigration enforcement." (snip) On Monday, the city council of (snip) Helena also passed a resolution instructing the city police department not to enter into agreements with or assist ICE. (snip) Democrats across the country are taking the Minneapolis blueprint and running with it (snip.)
Will Trump Once Again Let The Media Dictate
The Rest Of His Agenda?
10 replies
Posted by J. Arthur Brown 1/28/2026 6:44:40 PM Post Reply
Democrat Minnesota Gov. Tim Walz had some uncharacteristically useful comments on CNN this week. (snip) Walz said, "There was a tone shift. (snip) I think it's probably the press." (snip) It's one thing for Trump to engage in a tone shift (snip ) telling Minnesota Democrats (snip) that the deportation operation in the state "all goes away" if they simply hand over "criminals." But if he's going to cave in any way (snip) he might as well rename Kamala Harris the president's border czar, with CNN's wombat Brian Stelter second in command of immigration policy.
If Illegal Aliens Don't Vote In Virginia
Elections, Then Why Are Democrats Trying
To Ban ICE From Polling Places?
9 replies
Posted by J. Arthur Brown 1/28/2026 12:36:50 PM Post Reply
With Democrats pushing a number of progressive policies now that they are in control of Virginia, a Virginia state Democrat is working to ban immigration agents from operating at polling places. (snip) The move has left Republicans wondering why a Democrat would move to prevent immigration law enforcers near polling places if Democrats believe illegal aliens are not voting in Virginia elections.
Most Active Articles (last 48 hours)
Tim Walz says he'll never seek elected
office again
46 replies
Posted by NorthernDog 1/29/2026 9:54:58 AM Post Reply
Minnesota Gov. Tim Walz said Wednesday that his time as an elected official will permanently end when he finishes his term as governor. “I will never run for an elected office again. Never again,” Walz, the 2024 Democratic vice presidential nominee, said in an interview with MS NOW. Walz had said this month that he would not seek re-election as governor — sending shock waves through state and national politics — but he did not go so far as to say he would not consider another elected position down the line. In explaining his decision Wednesday, Walz talked about the
Mamdani Casts Blame on Eric Adams for
NYC $12B Deficit Budget: NYC Facing ‘Serious
Fiscal Crisis’
20 replies
Posted by 4250Luis 1/29/2026 5:48:06 AM Post Reply
New York City (NYC) Mayor Zohran Mamdani cast blame on former NYC Mayor Eric Adams for the city’s $12 billion deficit budget, stating that the city is facing a “serious fiscal crisis.” During a press conference on Wednesday, Mamdani accused Adams of underbudgeting important services that NYC residents “rely on every single day,” while “quietly leaving behind enormous gaps for the future.” Mamdani also accused former New York Gov. Andrew Cuomo (D) of extracting NYC’s “resources” and using the city’s revenues to “address state level holes, while withholding from the city what it was owed.”
Hunter Biden says it doesn’t matter
that he ‘ghosted’ daughter, 7, with
ex-stripper because he never agreed to
be part of her life
19 replies
Posted by JoElla Bee 1/29/2026 5:08:48 PM Post Reply
Hunter Biden says it doesn’t matter that he has “ghosted” his 7-year-old daughter with ex-stripper Lunden Roberts because he never agreed to be a part of her life, according to a stone-hearted new legal filing. The 55-year-old former first son argued Tuesday in new court papers that the contentious Arkansas child support case for daughter Navy Joan Roberts shouldn’t be reopened after he and his baby mama settled in 2023. But Roberts, 34, earlier this month said Hunter should be jailed for failing to uphold his end of the bargain, claiming he’s refusing to talk to Navy and not giving her pieces of his artwork before it dramatically plunged in value
Hillary Clinton Fundraises for Minneapolis Rioters 17 replies
Posted by ConservativeYankee 1/29/2026 3:48:23 PM Post Reply
Hillary Clinton took to social media to express support for the rioters in Minneapolis even as the disgraced former candidate and her husband were dodging a congressional subpoena looking into their relationship with family friend and Clinton Foundation co-founder Jeffrey Epstein. After condemning the Trump administration’s push to deport illegal alien criminals from Minneapolis, despite the obstruction of violent leftist rioters who had tried to murder federal law enforcement agents and bit off an agent’s finger, Clinton urged directing funding to the rioters. “In Minnesota, scores of ordinary people are bravely looking out for their neighbors, defending their communities, and protesting lawless violence,” she tweeted. “Here’s how to stand with them.”
Ex-NFL star who swapped football for FBI
quits with brutal swipe at Donald Trump
over ICE raids
16 replies
Posted by ConservativeYankee 1/29/2026 5:11:27 PM Post Reply
Former NFL star Charles Tillman swapped footballs for rifles and pistols after hanging up his cleats, swapping a career on the field for one in it. That was until one day in January 2025 when ICE descended on Chicago. After 13 seasons in the NFL, the former cornerback joined the FBI, enrolling in the bureau's 20-week training program in Quantico, Virginia in 2018, two years after retiring from football. And the Chicago Bears icon embraced the role, previously citing a desire to 'do my part and give back' as his reasons for joining up in an exclusive interview with The Daily Mail last year. However, Tillman, 44, has now revealed
GOP Senators Consider Breaking Off DHS
Funding as Shutdown Clock Ticks — Risking
Chaos at the Border and Weakening National Security
15 replies
Posted by ConservativeYankee 1/29/2026 9:52:34 AM Post Reply
With the clock ticking down to a potential government shutdown this Friday, Senate Republicans are reportedly considering a move that could leave the southern border wide open to invasion. A group of Republican senators is now openly discussing whether to split the Homeland Security appropriations bill away from a six-bill funding package in order to avert a partial government shutdown that would impact the Pentagon and several other major federal departments, according to The Hill. The six-bill package includes funding for the Departments of Defense, Health and Human Services, Labor, Education, Transportation, State, and financial services-related agencies.
America needs to hear ‘You’re fired!’
again, President Trump
13 replies
Posted by Mercedes44 1/29/2026 8:38:12 AM Post Reply
If the second Trump term turns out to be like “The Apprentice” without “You’re fired!” its ratings are going to resemble Joe Biden’s. That means needlessly big losses in the coming midterms, and an end to — or even reversal of — President Donald Trump’s agenda. President Biden never accepted blame for the Afghanistan debacle, for economic malaise and record inflation or any of his other disasters, such as the endless waves of illegal migrants waved into the country. But he also never even implicitly admitted his team had failed by axing an obvious author of those debacles —
Brandon Johnson Says He’s Coordinating
With Other Democrat Mayors To Thwart ICE
13 replies
Posted by ConservativeYankee 1/29/2026 8:28:54 AM Post Reply
Democratic Chicago Mayor Brandon Johnson admitted Wednesday he was “in regular communication” with other mayors leading so-called “sanctuary cities” in efforts to impede enforcement of federal immigration laws. President Donald Trump called for an end to “sanctuary cities” in a post on Truth Social Monday, following a series of shootings, two of them fatal, that took place in Minneapolis involving Department of Homeland Security personnel engaged in immigration enforcement operations. Johnson said during a press conference at the National Press Club he’d been talking with Democratic Mayors Jacob Frey of Minneapolis and Michelle Wu of Boston about how to combat
Homan Says Minnesota Dems Ready to Cooperate
with ICE, Allowing Agency to Begin Pulling
Officers Out
12 replies
Posted by Dreadnought 1/29/2026 1:08:17 PM Post Reply
Following weeks of unrest in Minnesota over immigration enforcement in the state, White House border czar Tom Homan announced Thursday that he will begin reducing the number of federal agents in the state once state officials follow through on their pledge to begin cooperating with Immigration and Customs Enforcement. Homan, who was dispatched to Minnesota after the fatal shooting of Alex Pretti over the weekend, acknowledged that ICE and Customs and Border Patrol operations in the state had not been conducted “perfectly” and that changes needed to be made — but he also reserved significant criticism for Minnesota Democrats who have prevented federal agents from collecting the targets of enforcement operations
How to Stop the Female March Leftwards 12 replies
Posted by Mercedes44 1/29/2026 5:43:30 AM Post Reply
What have Little Red Riding Hood, Jane Austen’s Emma and prison reformer Elizabeth Fry got in common? They are all female-coded ‘compassionate’ girls and women who can help us understand why young women are veering to the radical Left. The New Statesman has reported on this trend and the predilection of young women to support various perceived victim groups – trans rights and Palestinians, for example – even when these groups clash with their own interests. Explained as “suicidal empathy” by Gad Saad and the “hijacking” of instinctive female care for victims by Eric Kaufmann, the lurch to extreme Left-wing ideology by young women today deserves our full attention.
Mamdani's 'Great Recession' Fearmongering:
Only Answer Is to Tax the Pants Off the Rich
12 replies
Posted by Mercedes44 1/29/2026 5:39:39 AM Post Reply
New York’s new mayor, Zohran Mamdani, is already discovering that governing can be a whole lot harder than campaigning — you actually have to manage a budget, deliver on services, and do so without alienating your key supporters and allies. The grinning socialist is realizing that he and the Big Apple are facing some serious fiscal issues, but he has three answers: 1) It’s all former Mayor Eric Adams' fault (with some help from disgraced former Empire State Governor Andrew Cuomo, and 2) Scare the heck out of everyone by saying we’re risking the next “Great Recession,”
Deqa Dhalac won't seek reelection to Maine
House, citing hostility and racism
11 replies
Posted by ConservativeYankee 1/29/2026 7:20:22 PM Post Reply
Augusta, Maine - Democratic state Rep. Deqa Dhalac will not seek reelection to represent House District 120, and says the decision comes after "serious reflection and conversations" about the political climate for Black elected officials. Dhalac says during her time serving in the Maine Legislature, the climate has become "increasingly hostile and unsafe." "Throughout my tenure, I have experienced persistent racism, harassment and threats that reflect a broader national pattern targeting Black and brown elected officials," Dhalac said. "These dangers are real and carry heavy emotional and physical consequences not only for those serving but for their families as well." Dhalac is one of the first Somali Americans to serve
Post New Article