Post New Article

FBI Spied on Catholic Priest for Refusing
to Divulge Details of Conversations with Parishioner

Original Article

Posted By: Dreadnought, 7/23/2025 10:32:33 AM

The FBI began surveilling a Catholic priest in 2023 after the clergyman refused to divulge details about a recently arrested parishioner who was converting to Catholicism and seeking spiritual guidance. The FBI’s Richmond Field Office, the same branch responsible for producing an anti-Catholic memo that was quickly retracted, tracked the priest’s movements and coordinated with several other FBI offices and a foreign law enforcement agency to gather intelligence on the clergyman and his priestly organization, according to a new House Judiciary Committee report obtained by National Review.

Post Reply

Reminder: “WE ARE A SALON AND NOT A SALOON”

Your thoughts, comments, and ideas are always welcome here. But we ask you to please be mindful and respectful. Threatening or crude language doesn't persuade anybody and makes the conversation less enjoyable for fellow L.Dotters.


Reply 1 - Posted by: Timber Queen 7/23/2025 11:38:39 AM (No. 1981522)
This issue was explored in Alfred Hitchcock's1953 movie, "I Confess", starring Montgomery Clift as a priest who hears a confession about murder and his hounded by the authorities to reveal the information he knows. All aspects of this situation are explored in this intense film. It climaxes with a criminal charge being brought against the priest and his trial. Well worth viewing to understand all the competing moral aspects of this situation. This controversy is not new. It is an aspect of the Catholic faith that seculars just don't understand. The Church has insisted on this aspect of confession since its earliest days. The only time it receives push-back on this sacrament is when Fascists, Communists and tin-pot dictators take over a government. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=NiajVY-f99s
15 people like this.

Reply 2 - Posted by: itsonlyme 7/23/2025 11:40:37 AM (No. 1981524)
Former Attorney General Merrick "Gestapo" Garland and his mob of armed thugs with badges
8 people like this.

Reply 3 - Posted by: earlybird 7/23/2025 11:56:43 AM (No. 1981532)
This is not a matter for the flaky National Review. Every other line a seemingly important detail is said to be "unclear".
3 people like this.

Reply 4 - Posted by: earlybird 7/23/2025 12:04:08 PM (No. 1981536)
Hit submit too soon. The FBI was wrong. There had to be other evidence that did not involve invading the confessional. As a non-Catholic I do wonder what a priest would do if someone confessed a plan to do harm.
3 people like this.

Reply 5 - Posted by: WWIIDaughter 7/23/2025 1:08:29 PM (No. 1981556)
As cradle Catholic, let me tell non-Catholics how the Official Catechism of the Church defines the Sacrament of Confession (now termed Reconciliation to fully describe what the Sacrament is and does). The Priest is there to affirm the person confessing's true goals: *To speak the sin(s) he has willfully committed, *to admit that he knew what he was doing was against God's laws, *to request penance to show that he is willing to suffer earthly penalty to establish that he accepts his guilt, *to accept and carry out the penalty the priest provides to prove to himself to God that he truly is sorry and that *he swears to God to never commit the sin(s) again. (God--of course--knows if the person is lying and *the act of penance that he must perform is meant to reinforce the sinner's true honesty as well as to provide an earthly punishment to atone before coming before God at the Last Judgment.) The idea that all the sinner must do is tell a priest a lie and he gets forgiveness from God is absolutely false. It's a multiple stage process as described above, and all parts must be fulfilled in order for the Seal to apply. If priest is told by a killer that he has murdered someone, the priest may give the following penance: That the killer must turn himself in to police immediately in order to prevent an innocent person from being punished for the crime the killer committed. If the sinner dies on his way to the police station, the Act of Confession/Reconciliation has not been completed. The Seal of the Confessional does not apply. The priest should complete the act of Penance for the sinner and inform the police. If the priest fails in this duty to prevent miscarriage of justice, God in Heaven is not bound by the Seal. He always is the One who is actually forgiving sins (or not). So why this elaborate sacramental ceremony? Because it's a great gift to the truly sorrowful sinner to be able to cleanse his soul and be acknowledged by God's minister as being reconciled with his Lord God. It's both spiritually and psychologically powerful and one reason the Catholic Church is 2,000 years old.
8 people like this.

Reply 6 - Posted by: FormerDem 7/23/2025 1:18:11 PM (No. 1981557)
Thank you to #1 and #5 for going to the heart of the matter. just to add, there is not one issue other than abortion where Democrat administrations have maintained a steady consistent outlook. when it comes to punshing, investigating and locking up pro-lifers, they have had a steady consistent focus since second half of Carter administration. Can't say the same for the stance on unions, war, free speech, tolerance, the meaning of racism, the dignity of the working class, the Holocaust, the value of maintaing contact with Russia while disagreeing with it. All that is over the side.
2 people like this.

Reply 7 - Posted by: Catherine 7/23/2025 1:22:35 PM (No. 1981558)
I was raised Catholic. Went to Catholic school, etc. I did learn that whatever is said in the confessional can never be told by the priest. I lost my belief in the church decades ago for a specific reason. I still adhere to most of their teachings and the ten commandments. Now, it's been said that if someone confesses he's going to kill another person, I cannot imagine a priest not speaking up. Same if they find out someone is sexually abusing children. I'll leave the decision on this to the church and law enforcement but as a mother, grandmother and great grandmother, I'd vote for the priest to be able to speak up.
3 people like this.

Reply 8 - Posted by: rochow 7/23/2025 2:31:19 PM (No. 1981583)
What did the bidet trash 'confess' when in church?
1 person likes this.

Reply 9 - Posted by: Miss T 7/23/2025 5:32:16 PM (No. 1981685)
"The FBI agent asserted that priest-penitent privilege did not apply because the subject of the FBI’s investigation had yet to be baptized and had not finished the conversion process." That is offensive. Nobody at the FBI has standing to interpret canon law. The priest is correct to respect the confidentiality of conversations of Catechumens and even of inquirers. Imagine the havoc to be wrought if priests in Moslem countries repeated the private thoughts and questions of Moslems who are in the process of converting.
4 people like this.

Below, you will find ...
Most Recent Articles posted by "Dreadnought"
and
Most Active Articles (last 48 hours)
Most Recent Articles posted by Dreadnought"
'Crisis' at Media Matters, As It Cuts
Staff, Struggles to Pay Legal Bills
11 replies
Posted by Dreadnought 7/25/2025 7:43:07 PM Post Reply
You can almost hear the death rattle emanating from Media Matters for America (MMFA), the unofficial (wink-wink) media arm of the Democrat Party, which unironically calls itself the "progressive research and information center dedicated to comprehensively monitoring, analyzing, and correcting conservative misinformation in the U.S. media." From the New York Times: The organization, which is funded by some of the Democratic Party’s biggest donors, has racked up about $15 million in legal fees over the past 20 months to defend itself against lawsuits by Elon Musk, in addition to investigations by Mr. Trump’s Federal Trade Commission and Republican state attorneys general.
Poll: Public Swings Massively in Trump’s
Favor on Economy Since April
1 reply
Posted by Dreadnought 7/25/2025 4:10:23 PM Post Reply
A bipartisan poll shows a dramatic shift in public opinion on the state of the U.S. economy, with a net 23-point swing toward optimism since April, an uptick that parallels renewed economic momentum under President Donald Trump’s policies, according to officials and market data. The Wall Street Journal survey, conducted by Republican pollster Tony Fabrizio and Democrat partner firm Impact Research, found that 47 percent of Americans now rate the economy as “excellent” or “good,” up from just 36 percent in April. Meanwhile, those saying the economy is “not so good” or “poor” dropped from 63 percent to 51 percent. The swing in public opinion
Can Private Donors Keep NPR and PBS Afloat? 21 replies
Posted by Dreadnought 7/25/2025 3:53:23 PM Post Reply
It's striking how similar NPR's situation is to that of Planned Parenthood. Both organizations have an affiliate model and both just had a lot of federal money cut from their budgets. That means both are now hoping to find new sources of funding to keep the doors open. The NY Times reports there has been an increase in donations to PBS and NPR but so far the amount isn't nearly enough to offset the cuts. Over the last three months, as the prospect of the cuts intensified, roughly 120,000 new donors have contributed an estimated $20 million in annual value,
Klain: Biden Wasn't 'Politically Viable'
In Final Year
9 replies
Posted by Dreadnought 7/25/2025 3:45:06 PM Post Reply
Should we be surprised that alleged Joe Biden Regency 'politburo' member Ron Klain decided to cooperate with the House Oversight Committee? Fellow senior advisers such as Annie Tomasini and Anthony Bernal took the Fifth when asked to testify about Biden's cognitive incapacity while President and who really ran the White House. Even Biden's doctor, Kevin O'Connor, took Five rather than rely on HIPAA. Biden's former chief of staff, however, decided to cooperate, getting praise for his willingness to testify from committee members of both parties. And while Klain doesn't flat-out declare Biden incompetent during his tenure as president, Klain told the committee that his decline
Trump: Obama Has Immunity for His Role
in Steele Dossier Hoax
16 replies
Posted by Dreadnought 7/25/2025 3:15:58 PM Post Reply
I suspected that this was the case, and even said so in a recent radio interview. But I have been very reluctant to write about it because I am not a lawyer, so I can only use my common sense and layman's understanding of the law in what must be a very, very complex question. But Trump, who certainly has access to excellent legal advice, has just said that Obama has immunity from prosecution for any crimes he may have committed in conspiring to use falsified intelligence to undermine Trump's presidency, set up a phony impeachment, and perhaps put Trump in jail.
New Polling Shows Great News for GOP,
Bad News for Dems That Will Bring a Lot
of Liberal Tears
4 replies
Posted by Dreadnought 7/25/2025 2:59:14 PM Post Reply
I wrote earlier about how Democrats tripped all over themselves with a marvelous mistake that is a perfect example of how they don't understand the economy. They posted a graph about a rise in prices, captioning it "Trump's America." The problem? The graph showed that the rise in prices came under Joe Biden, and that it had previously been flat during President Donald Trump's first term (and has flattened again in his second). What a self-own that was. If they can't even read a graph intelligently, how can they deal with the economy? Of course, that's just one problem with the Democrats, and it's one of those bread-and-butter issues
Oregon Mom Wins Huge Victory Against Woke
System Preventing Her From Adopting Foster Kids
2 replies
Posted by Dreadnought 7/25/2025 2:06:01 AM Post Reply
Widowed Oregon mom of five Jessica Bates won a huge victory from the 9th Circuit Court when it ruled Oregon's policy, which prevented Bates from adopting foster kids because she wouldn't buy into the state's insanity on gender ideology, violated her First Amendment rights. In a post on Thursday on X, President and CEO of ADF Legal Kristen Waggoner celebrated their client Jessica's victory after she was barred from "adopting a foster child-regardless of the child's age or beliefs—because she wouldn't promise to affirm gender ideology."
‘He’s Talking’: Did Biden’s Former
Chief of Staff Squeal to Congress?
7 replies
Posted by Dreadnought 7/25/2025 2:00:21 AM Post Reply
The walls may finally be closing in on Joe Biden’s inner circle. This week, former Chief of Staff Ron Klain, who effectively ran the White House during Biden’s first two critical years, showed up for a closed-door interview with staff from the House Oversight Committee. Did the ultimate Biden insider finally confirm what millions of Americans have suspected for years: that Biden’s mental decline was no secret inside the West Wing? The House Oversight Committee, under the leadership of Chairman James Comer, is investigating whether Biden’s inner circle deliberately hid signs of his decline, whether his top aides shielded him from public scrutiny, propped him up behind the scenes, o
Bezos Buyout: Another Washington Post
Columnist is Gone
6 replies
Posted by Dreadnought 7/25/2025 1:53:18 AM Post Reply
Philip Bump wasn't the worst columnist at the Washington Post. That title will probably remain in the hands of former columnist Taylor Lorenz who wound up being ushered out after repeatedly lying to her own editors. And we can't forget the insufferable Jennifer Rubin who left the paper in January. But even in a crowded field of partisans, Bump was certainly one of my least favorites at the Post. Over the years I've written a few takedowns of his columns.
Fox News Poll: Trump facing headwinds
at six-month mark
18 replies
Posted by Dreadnought 7/24/2025 10:42:28 PM Post Reply
Six months into Donald Trump’s second presidency, the political tea leaves are muddled. Voters disapprove of the job he is doing, dislike his new budget law, and doubt his dealings with Iran are making the U.S. safer. At the same time, ratings of the economy show signs of improvement, feelings on the direction of the country are inching upward, and the president’s job approval ratings are holding steady, according to a new Fox News national survey. Thirty-two percent of voters rate economic conditions positively. That’s the highest number, by one percentage point, in about a year. On a personal level, 44% rate their financial situation positively, up from
Thailand launches airstrikes on Cambodia
as border clashes leave at least 14 dead
7 replies
Posted by Dreadnought 7/24/2025 7:03:03 PM Post Reply
SURIN, Thailand — Thai and Cambodian soldiers clashed along the border between their countries on Thursday in a major escalation that left at least 14 people dead, mostly civilians. The two sides fired small arms, artillery and rockets, and Thailand also launched airstrikes. Fighting took place in at least six areas, Thai Defense Ministry spokesperson Surasant Kongsiri said, a day after a land mine explosion along the border wounded five Thai soldiers and led Bangkok to withdraw its ambassador from Cambodia and expel Cambodia’s envoy to Thailand. It was a rare instance of military conflict
Chuck Mangione, Jazz Musician Whose ‘Feels
So Good’ Stormed the Pop Top 10 in the
Late ’70s, Dies at 84
7 replies
Posted by Dreadnought 7/24/2025 6:44:51 PM Post Reply
Jazz musician Chuck Mangione, who had one of the biggest pop-jazz instrumental crossover hits of all time with “Feels So Good” in the 1970s, died Tuesday at age 84. The death was reported by multiple news outlets out of his native Rochester, NY. The city’s WROC-TV reported that the Bartolomeo & Perreto Funeral Home said the musician died in his sleep at home on Tuesday. The flugelhorn and trumpet player won two Grammys, out of 14 nominations, in a career that spanned 30 albums. Beyond his musical success, the musician was also familiar to millions for his recurring role playing himself on the animated series “King of the Hill.”
Most Active Articles (last 48 hours)
Trump signs executive order forcing homeless
off America’s streets
31 replies
Posted by JoElla Bee 7/24/2025 5:56:03 PM Post Reply
WASHINGTON — President Trump signed an executive order Thursday calling on states and cities to end “endemic vagrancy” — and rehouse homeless people including drug addicts and those suffering from mental problems in “treatment centers.” The order redirects federal funding to prioritize “shifting homeless individuals into long-term institutional settings for humane treatment through the appropriate use of civil commitment.” On average, more than 274,000 people were sleeping on the streets each night last year under then-President Joe Biden, the order says.
UN court rules rich nations could be required
to pay climate reparations to poorer countries
29 replies
Posted by JoElla Bee 7/25/2025 12:00:26 AM Post Reply
Wealthy nations that fail to limit their fossil fuel use and reduce pollution could be held financially liable by countries most affected by climate change, says the United Nations' top court in a new opinion issued Wednesday. The 15-judge International Court of Justice (ICJ), based in The Hague, Netherlands, concluded that international treaties require developed countries to curb global warming and oversee the climate impact of companies operating under their jurisdiction.[snip] The court’s finding extends legal responsibility beyond governments to include private corporations operating within national borders.
Ghislaine Maxwell preparing ‘new evidence’
ahead of highly anticipated meeting with
feds, her brother explains
24 replies
Posted by Mercedes44 7/24/2025 5:25:30 AM Post Reply
Ghislaine Maxwell is assembling “new evidence” to present to the feds when she meets with them this week, her brother told The Post. Jeffrey Epstein’s madame never gave her version of events to federal prosecutors before her 2021 trial, which resulted in a 20-year sentence for recruiting women and underage girls for Epstein to sexually abuse. She also never testified in her own defense. “She will be putting before that court material new evidence that was not available to the defense at her 2021 trial, which would have had a significant impact on its outcome,” Ian Maxwell told The Post in an email Wednesday.
Democratic Party tries to pin ‘record
high’ 2025 grocery prices on Trump –
but it completely backfires
22 replies
Posted by Mercedes44 7/25/2025 6:12:11 AM Post Reply
The Democratic National Committee (DNC) drew widespread mockery Thursday over a since-deleted social media post that showed how the cost of groceries skyrocketed under former President Joe Biden. The X post included a graph of soaring cheese, alcohol, dairy, grocery, produce and meat prices dating back to October 2019, with the major inflection point being near the start of the Biden administration in 2021. “Trump’s America,” read the tweet shared by @TheDemocrats. “Prices are higher today than they were on July 2024 all in major categories listed below,” read the caption on the graphic, which did not note the source of the data.
Can Private Donors Keep NPR and PBS Afloat? 21 replies
Posted by Dreadnought 7/25/2025 3:53:23 PM Post Reply
It's striking how similar NPR's situation is to that of Planned Parenthood. Both organizations have an affiliate model and both just had a lot of federal money cut from their budgets. That means both are now hoping to find new sources of funding to keep the doors open. The NY Times reports there has been an increase in donations to PBS and NPR but so far the amount isn't nearly enough to offset the cuts. Over the last three months, as the prospect of the cuts intensified, roughly 120,000 new donors have contributed an estimated $20 million in annual value,
The country deserves better than the Dems
‘cracked out clown show,’ ‘elite’
media ignoring Gabbard’s bombshell
20 replies
Posted by Mercedes44 7/24/2025 5:23:22 AM Post Reply
America deserves better than the degenerate propaganda machine that passes for “elite” journalism. We deserve better than the evil “cracked out clown show” the Democratic Party has become. The New York Times and The Washington Post all but ignored DNI Tulsi Gabbard’s bombshell press conference Wednesday, at which she announced that she had sent criminal referrals to the DOJ and FBI implicating former President Barack Obama and his national security team in the “seditious conspiracy” of the Russia collusion hoax.
France Stabs America in the Back With
Announcement, Hamas Immediately Takes Advantage
19 replies
Posted by ladydawgfan 7/25/2025 11:24:45 AM Post Reply
What's the only gear a French car has? Reverse. That's an old joke that I remember an uncle telling many years ago, and it's evergreen. Amid the rise of Islamist influence across the world, specifically in Western countries, France has decided to do what it does best: Preemptively surrender. French President Emmanuel Macron announced on Thursday that he and his nation will formally recognize a "Palestinian State," rewarding the murderous terrorists who still control Gaza and the West Bank. That will officially take place at the UN General Assembly, set to happen in September. Hamas was quick to take advantage, thanking Macron
Fox News Poll: Trump facing headwinds
at six-month mark
18 replies
Posted by Dreadnought 7/24/2025 10:42:28 PM Post Reply
Six months into Donald Trump’s second presidency, the political tea leaves are muddled. Voters disapprove of the job he is doing, dislike his new budget law, and doubt his dealings with Iran are making the U.S. safer. At the same time, ratings of the economy show signs of improvement, feelings on the direction of the country are inching upward, and the president’s job approval ratings are holding steady, according to a new Fox News national survey. Thirty-two percent of voters rate economic conditions positively. That’s the highest number, by one percentage point, in about a year. On a personal level, 44% rate their financial situation positively, up from
Biden Gets a Memoir Deal, and It's an
Embarrassing Disaster
18 replies
Posted by ladydawgfan 7/24/2025 2:54:29 PM Post Reply
Former President Joe Biden has reportedly sold his presidential memoirs. According to the Wall Street Journal, Biden sold the book to Hachette Book Group, with Little, Brown and Company set to publish it. Biden is reportedly getting $10 million for the book. While a $10 million advance might sound impressive at first glance, it’s actually a paltry payday compared to what other presidents have commanded for their memoirs. In 2017, Penguin Random House shelled out a jaw-dropping $60 million for the combined book rights of Barack and Michelle Obama. Bill Clinton landed $15 million for his 2004 memoir “My Life,”
Trump: Obama Has Immunity for His Role
in Steele Dossier Hoax
16 replies
Posted by Dreadnought 7/25/2025 3:15:58 PM Post Reply
I suspected that this was the case, and even said so in a recent radio interview. But I have been very reluctant to write about it because I am not a lawyer, so I can only use my common sense and layman's understanding of the law in what must be a very, very complex question. But Trump, who certainly has access to excellent legal advice, has just said that Obama has immunity from prosecution for any crimes he may have committed in conspiring to use falsified intelligence to undermine Trump's presidency, set up a phony impeachment, and perhaps put Trump in jail.
Teen Girl Shoots Attackers to Save Brother—Now
Prosecutors Want Her Locked Up for Life
14 replies
Posted by ladydawgfan 7/25/2025 2:14:01 PM Post Reply
Two siblings in Eastpointe, Michigan, are facing multiple charges related to a shooting near a Foot Locker store that occurred on May 3. The altercation left two people dead and one seriously injured. At around 2:50 p.m., Lakylia Taylor (19) and her brother Dejuan Taylor (21) arrived at the Foot Locker parking lot with some friends. After exiting the vehicle they began walking toward the store when they came across a Jeep Compass parked nearby. This vehicle contained another group of young men. Tyjaune Pierre Morrs-Turner emerged from the Jeep with three others carrying a handgun and got into an argument with Dejuan. The verbal dispute soon turned physical,
Colbert Wants to Get Fired 14 replies
Posted by Hazymac 7/25/2025 8:29:49 AM Post Reply
Colbert and his allies in the Pravda Media/entertainment complex--along with Democrats--are insisting that the former funnyman was fired at the behest of President Trump. The accusation is absurd. You can't lose tens of millions of dollars a year and expect to keep your $15 million a year job. The math doesn't work. But, as we know, propaganda works with people who want to believe it. All you need is an authoritative voice to say the most absurd things, and people inclined to believe it, will. Even many who do not start out believing it come to do so, based on the "when there is smoke, there's fire principle.
Post New Article