Post New Article

Expert turns tables on Dem critics after
Musk accuses Social Security of being
'Ponzi scheme'

Original Article

Posted By: Harlowe, 3/23/2025 7:05:22 PM

Democrats have pushed back after Elon Musk claimed that social security operates like a "Ponzi scheme" as he continues to argue for cuts to the federal bureaucracy, but one expert tells Fox News Digital that Musk is on track with his criticism of the agency. "Musk’s statement about Social Security being the world's biggest Ponzi scheme does have validity," James Agresti, president of the nonprofit research institute Just Facts,... [Snip] "What it does is, it transfers money when we are young and working and paying into Social Security taxes,"... "That money, the vast bulk of it, goes immediately out the door to people who are currently receiving benefits.

Comments:

After 90 years of operation, the trust fund “currently has enough money to fund two years of program operations.” The fund’s interest payments have been higher than the rate of inflation. “...the Obama administration sent out (stimulus) checks via Social Security numbers to 80,000 people who were dead, and about 70,000 of them, the Social Security Administration knew they were dead.” Democrats claiming Mr. Musk is attempting to “strip away benefits” is not true; severing employment/salaries of SSA administrative overhead workers “actually strengthens the program financially.” ~ “In other words, Social Security is every bit as insecure as the stock market.” (Tony Snow)

Post Reply

Reminder: “WE ARE A SALON AND NOT A SALOON”

Your thoughts, comments, and ideas are always welcome here. But we ask you to please be mindful and respectful. Threatening or crude language doesn't persuade anybody and makes the conversation less enjoyable for fellow L.Dotters.


Reply 1 - Posted by: AntiStatist 3/23/2025 8:37:33 PM (No. 1920160)
The main problem with SS is that Congress added numerous benefits there that had no withholding taxes to fund them, such as disability benefits, benefits for children with difficulties (easily exploited by welfarians- “crazy checks” for their kids). Those should have been left to the states. And they are bleeding SS dry.
48 people like this.

Reply 2 - Posted by: caljeepgirl 3/23/2025 8:56:12 PM (No. 1920169)
Exactly, #1! While it's always been a Ponzi setup from its inception, veering away from its original intent to only support retirement benefits was the real death sentence!
30 people like this.

Reply 3 - Posted by: DVC 3/23/2025 9:28:48 PM (No. 1920175)
Musk is right, and I've said it myself many times.
31 people like this.

Reply 4 - Posted by: rememberwhen 3/23/2025 10:49:01 PM (No. 1920188)
SS was designed to fail. It could only work with ever-increasing classes of people being added to the mix. Once everyone was in, it had to implode. Typical Dim program--not thought through. I have advocated replacing it with an actuarially sound retirement system since the 1970's.
20 people like this.

Reply 5 - Posted by: crashnburn 3/23/2025 11:13:56 PM (No. 1920193)
I'll have to live past 90 to break even on my SS, and it doesn't come close to covering my bills. When I first joined the workforce, I didn't expect SS to be around when I didn't have to work anymore, so I invested in stocks, bonds, and sectors. My total investments completely dwarf what I put into them, thanks to compounding. I know DemonRats always demonize whoever mentions investing SS into the stock market, but it's the best long-term investment available. Currently, a worker fresh out of high school has up to 52 years to contribute to SS, and you don't even keep pace with inflation! Long-term conservative investments beat inflation by 7 or 8%. And you don't have to have a fund manager. Just have passive investments that hold the entire stock and bond markets. Government employees already have something very similar.
21 people like this.

Reply 6 - Posted by: davew 3/23/2025 11:16:31 PM (No. 1920195)
The primary difference between a Ponzi scheme and Social Security is that a Ponzi scheme does not own a bank that can generate all the money it needs to pay benefits. These benefits are established by law as an entitlement to all workers who meet the program qualifications. This is a solemn promise made by a government that can only be broken by an act of Congress that changes the law. This forces them to prioritize fiscal spending in a way that reflects the best interests of citizens. Providing a source of income for people no longer in the workforce is both a social and moral good. Prioritization requires discipline to avoid pumping more money into the economy than can be put to productive use, thus causing inflation.
10 people like this.

Reply 7 - Posted by: Lawsy0 3/24/2025 12:18:04 AM (No. 1920203)
Musk isn't the first to call it that. Dearly Departed Rush did, too.
31 people like this.

Reply 8 - Posted by: jinx 3/24/2025 6:03:48 AM (No. 1920227)
I thought that Johnson put the SS it collected into the general coffers. There is no lock box.
9 people like this.

Reply 9 - Posted by: Sorosisbehindit 3/24/2025 6:27:21 AM (No. 1920232)
Even worse - Ponzi never paid money to people who invested nothing.
21 people like this.

Reply 10 - Posted by: bpl40 3/24/2025 7:04:09 AM (No. 1920241)
Since the crash of '29 the US stock market has returned 7.7% on an average. Social Security funds on the other hand have earned 1.2%. Right there is the main answer to all problems about Social Security. We need the 'Chicago Solution' implemented by Chile. The average Social Security check will more than double.
6 people like this.

Reply 11 - Posted by: Dodge Boy 3/24/2025 8:29:05 AM (No. 1920277)
Recall that W floated the idea of converting the social security program into an individual payer 401k-like system some 20 plus years ago. Congress laughed him out of the room for proposing such a ridiculous idea. Wonder who gets the last laugh now.
10 people like this.

Reply 12 - Posted by: janjan 3/24/2025 8:52:10 AM (No. 1920301)
Most seniors are deluded into thinking that they are just getting their own money back in social security payments. They truth is that within a few years they have gotten back everything they paid in. After that it becomes a liability. The Government has lied to us for years about this and unfortunately most retirees have to rely on those payments to live. That’s why telling the truth about it now causes an earthquake and makes the messenger an evil enemy.
7 people like this.

Reply 13 - Posted by: Zigrid 3/24/2025 9:52:55 AM (No. 1920339)
Just in time...Social Security has been opened by Doge so WE can see just how corrupt the government has been...Social Security was robbed by the government....and the trust fund set up for old folks was depleted...WE are lucky Elon Musk and his musketeers are checking out every number and no longer will 120 year old recipents get the money for their family who have scammed the fund....they will not be sent to jail....but...let's take them off the list to receive funds forever.....
7 people like this.

Reply 14 - Posted by: MickTurn 3/24/2025 11:38:36 AM (No. 1920391)
The real crime is when people die before getting Social Security ALL their contributions along with their employers contributions go into the BIG POT, NOT to the Estate of the person that OWNED THE MONEY!
11 people like this.

Reply 15 - Posted by: Aklon70 3/24/2025 2:52:04 PM (No. 1920521)
The only way to save social security is to strip Congress of their own cushy retirement system and heath care plan, making them reliant on social security, Medicare, and a 401k just like the rest of us. With their own skin in the game, it'll be less than two weeks before everything's fixed.
6 people like this.

Below, you will find ...
Most Recent Articles posted by "Harlowe"
and
Most Active Articles (last 48 hours)
Most Recent Articles posted by Harlowe"
Biden prosecutor Jessica Aber's tragic
health battle before she was found dead
in her home after resigning on Trump's
first day
0 replies
Posted by Harlowe 3/27/2025 12:13:12 AM Post Reply
A Biden-appointed US attorney who resigned on President Donald Trump's first day in office had suffered from epilepsy before she died in her sleep, her family revealed. Jessica Aber, 43, once the top prosecutor in the Eastern District of Virginia, was found unresponsive in her Washington DC home on Saturday. [Snip] ...Aber's family has told ABC News she suffered from epilepsy and epileptic seizures for many years. Such a condition could cause fatal asphyxiation or heart problems, according to the Centers for Disease Control. Fatal epileptic seizures, known as Sudden Unexpected Death in Epilepsy, are rare, but are considered a major risk for people who suffer from the disorder.
Greenland takes savage step to freeze
out Usha Vance ahead of controversial
trip over 'underlying agenda'
1 reply
Posted by Harlowe 3/26/2025 11:55:38 PM Post Reply
A Greenlandic tourism business which was due to host Usha Vance has canceled the trip amid the Trump administration's 'underlying agenda' for the visit. [Snip] It was initially billed as a family-friendly holiday with Usha and one of her children... Then it emerged that she would be joined by embattled National Security advisor Mike Waltz, sparking fury among the nation's leaders--including the prime minister. But the final straw came when Usha's husband, Vice President JD Vance revealed he, too, would join her on the trip... [Snip] 'After closer consideration, however, we have now informed the consulate that we do not want her visit,' the store said.
Atlantic editor's coy response to killer
question about cabinet 'war plans' group
text on Signal
15 replies
Posted by Harlowe 3/26/2025 12:42:30 AM Post Reply
The Atlantic's editor-in-chief Jeffrey Goldberg refused to reveal the status of the phone he was using when the Trump Administration added him to a top secret war plans group text. [Snip] He also told Darcy he was not concerned about retaliation from federal authorities for publishing some of the messages. [Snip] ...he is considering releasing more of the group chat messages. 'My colleagues and I and the people who are giving us advice on this have some interesting conversations to have about this,' Goldberg told Tim Miller on the Bulwark Podcast. 'But just because they're irresponsible with material, doesn't mean that I'm going to be irresponsible.'
Trump signs executive order requiring
proof of citizenship in federal elections:
'An honor to sign this one'
25 replies
Posted by Harlowe 3/25/2025 11:26:00 PM Post Reply
President Donald Trump on Tuesday signed an executive order requiring people to provide proof of American citizenship when they register to vote and demanding that all ballots be reviewed by Election Day. The order requires government-issued proof of U.S. citizenship on its voter registration forms, directs the attorney general to enter into information-sharing agreements with state election officials to identify cases of election fraud or other election law violations and conditions federal election-related funds on states complying with federal election integrity measures. [Snip] Documentary proof of citizenship includes a U.S. passport, a REAL ID or military, state or federally-issued identification indicating American citizenship.
Maxine Waters floats deporting Melania
Trump in anti-DOGE diatribe
27 replies
Posted by Harlowe 3/25/2025 4:57:19 PM Post Reply
Democratic California Rep. Maxine Waters suggested President Donald Trump should investigate and potentially deport first lady Melania Trump during an anti-DOGE protest in Los Angeles over the weekend. "When he [Trump] talks about birthright, and he's going to undo the fact that the Constitution allows those who are born here, even if the parents are undocumented, they have a right to stay in America. If he wants to start looking so closely to find those who were born here and their parents were undocumented, maybe he ought to first look at Melania,"
Trump Isn’t Defying The Courts, He’s
Defending The Constitution
6 replies
Posted by Harlowe 3/25/2025 1:44:16 PM Post Reply
On March 7, I argued in The Federalist that President Donald Trump should ignore a Supreme Court that would allow lower courts to refuse to uphold the Constitution and instead encroach on executive authority. [Snip] They do not check executive power--they seize it, substituting judicial preference for the president’s constitutional role. Article II gives Trump, not judges, authority over federal agencies and the military. [Snip] If Congress will not curb this overreach through impeachment--and with a divided Senate it likely cannot--the president must step in. [Snip] The American people expect Trump to do the job he promised. In an unprecedented fashion, he is doing just that.
Pam Bondi threatens prosecution amid DOGE's
findings about fraud: 'We're coming after you'
18 replies
Posted by Harlowe 3/24/2025 11:00:25 PM Post Reply
U.S. Attorney General Pam Bondi issued a stern warning to those engaged in government fraud at the most recent Cabinet meeting on Monday. ...Bondi thanked Tesla CEO Elon Musk for uncovering "fraud, waste and abuse" through the Department of Government Efficiency (DOGE) initiative. [Snip] "We will prosecute you," the attorney general warned. "We have an internal task force now working with every agency sitting here at this table. And if you've committed fraud, we're coming after you. Thank you, Elon." Bondi also mentioned that, under Trump's directive, the Department of Justice (DOJ) will begin seeking the death penalty for those convicted of violent crimes.
Ohio Could Be The Next State To Protect
Kids Online, Unless The Porn Industry
Gets Its Way
2 replies
Posted by Harlowe 3/24/2025 5:29:48 PM Post Reply
Ohio could become the next state to protect children from obscene content online if legislation introduced last month becomes law. “We’re just trying to protect kids who are in the state of Ohio from adult content and the prevalence of obscene material in our society,”... House Bill 84, or the Innocence Act, would compel platforms to verify users are age 18 or older... [Snip] But the bill has found a powerful enemy. The so-called Free Speech Coalition, the “trade association for the adult industry” whose board is composed of porn executives, has targeted this measure. The FSC Action Center features a page tracking the bill among others it opposes.
SCOOP: House to hold hearings next week
on 'activist judges' blocking Trump agenda
9 replies
Posted by Harlowe 3/24/2025 2:37:50 PM Post Reply
FIRST ON FOX: The House Judiciary Committee is expected to hold a hearing early next week looking into the issue of "activist judges," three people familiar with discussions told Fox News Digital. [Snip] House Judiciary Chairman Jim Jordan, R-Ohio, also confirmed on Fox News' "America's Newsroom" that he intended to hold hearings on "activist judges" opposing the administration. He said he expects a House-wide vote next week on a bill...to block district judges from issuing nationwide injunctions. [Snip] ...House leaders were wary of the impeachment route given the intense political maneuvering such a measure would take--only for it to likely die in the Senate.
Disobedience to Judges is Obedience to
the Constitution
9 replies
Posted by Harlowe 3/23/2025 11:05:46 PM Post Reply
Judge James Boasberg issued an oral order demanding that planes carrying Venezuelan gang members, who were not even a party to the lawsuit before him and over which he did not have jurisdiction, be turned around in international airspace. Boasberg is now infuriated that his mere utterance, not even set down in writing, was not immediately obeyed. Democrats and their media have taken to crying that any disobedience of Boasberg, who was appointed by Barack Obama to apparently rule not only the entire country, but the planet and all its airspace, is a “threat to democracy” and a violation of checks and balances.
Expert turns tables on Dem critics after
Musk accuses Social Security of being
'Ponzi scheme'
15 replies
Posted by Harlowe 3/23/2025 7:05:22 PM Post Reply
Democrats have pushed back after Elon Musk claimed that social security operates like a "Ponzi scheme" as he continues to argue for cuts to the federal bureaucracy, but one expert tells Fox News Digital that Musk is on track with his criticism of the agency. "Musk’s statement about Social Security being the world's biggest Ponzi scheme does have validity," James Agresti, president of the nonprofit research institute Just Facts,... [Snip] "What it does is, it transfers money when we are young and working and paying into Social Security taxes,"... "That money, the vast bulk of it, goes immediately out the door to people who are currently receiving benefits.
Rogue Judges Are Turning Judicial Review
Into Judicial Rule
4 replies
Posted by Harlowe 3/22/2025 3:31:39 PM Post Reply
President Donald Trump made headlines this week by continuing deportation flights of illegal immigrants, including members of the violent Tren de Aragua gang, despite a federal judge’s ruling that attempted to halt the practice. [Snip] For too long, judges have operated under the assumption that their authority is limitless, that elected officials must bow to their rulings no matter how far they stray from the Constitution. [Snip] Even the Supreme Court has recognized the dangers of this judicial overreach. In Trump v. Hawaii (2018), Chief Justice John Roberts warned lower courts that they do not have the authority to micromanage national security decisions made by the executive.
Most Active Articles (last 48 hours)
West-Coast Judges Say Trump Admin Must
Take In Refugees and Pay for Their Housing
20 replies
Posted by Mercedes44 3/26/2025 10:56:29 AM Post Reply
“We welcome this continued relief for tens of thousands of refugees who will now have the opportunity to restart their lives in the United States,” said Melissa Keaney, the progressive lawyer for the elite-funded, anti-borders International Refugee Assistance Project. In a second courtroom in Seattle, another federal judge ordered the Trump administration to keep paying the quasi-government agencies that settle the refugees in Americans’ crowded housing, schools, and workplaces, such as in Springfield, Ohio.
Atlantic editor's coy response to killer
question about cabinet 'war plans' group
text on Signal
15 replies
Posted by Harlowe 3/26/2025 12:42:30 AM Post Reply
The Atlantic's editor-in-chief Jeffrey Goldberg refused to reveal the status of the phone he was using when the Trump Administration added him to a top secret war plans group text. [Snip] He also told Darcy he was not concerned about retaliation from federal authorities for publishing some of the messages. [Snip] ...he is considering releasing more of the group chat messages. 'My colleagues and I and the people who are giving us advice on this have some interesting conversations to have about this,' Goldberg told Tim Miller on the Bulwark Podcast. 'But just because they're irresponsible with material, doesn't mean that I'm going to be irresponsible.'
EXCLUSIVE: One Gov’t Agency Still Spending
$1,000,000,000 On DEI Despite Trump’s
Order To Cut It Out
14 replies
Posted by sunset 3/26/2025 10:59:42 AM Post Reply
The National Institutes of Health (NIH) continues to fund more than a billion dollars in diversity, equity and inclusion programs, even after President Donald Trump ordered federal agencies to eliminate them. While other agencies have moved to eliminate the “illegal and immoral programs” targeted in Trump’s day-one executive order, NIH is still funding over $1.3 billion in active grants that include DEI components — from race-based hiring schemes to “anti-racist” training initiatives and diversity-first faculty pipelines. At least $441 million of those grants explicitly cite DEI in their project descriptions, according to NIH data compiled by watchdog group Do No Harm.
REPORT: Passwords of Top U.S. Security
Officials Found Online – Hegseth, Gabbard,
Waltz Among Those Affected
13 replies
Posted by JoElla Bee 3/26/2025 7:22:25 PM Post Reply
Passwords and private information belonging to top national security officials in the Trump administration have been found online, according to the German publicationDer Spiegel. In a stunning report published on Wednesday, the paper said its journalists “used commercial people search engines along with hacked customer data that has been published on the web.” Those whose information was compromised include Secretary of Defense Pete Hegseth, Director of National Intelligence Tulsi Gabbard, and National Security Advisor Mike Waltz.
Warner: Gabbard, Ratcliffe ‘Lied’
Under Oath to Congress
13 replies
Posted by JoElla Bee 3/26/2025 12:35:06 PM Post Reply
Senator Mark Warner (D-VA) said Wednesday on MSNBC’s “Morning Joe” that Director of National Intelligence Tulsi Gabbard and CIA director John Ratcliffe “lied” under oath to the Senate Intelligence Committee when denying classified information was included in a Signal group chat on military strikes against the Houthis.[Snip] the reason why I say it’s a pattern, in the first two weeks of the administration, they inadvertently released the names of 200 new CIA agents.[Snip] There’s not a day that goes by that you guys don’t report another one of the DOGE boys in one of classified agencies giving up personal information.
Greg Abbott hits back at Jasmine Crockett
for mocking his wheelchair use: ‘Nothing
to sell but hate’
13 replies
Posted by mc squared 3/26/2025 11:53:55 AM Post Reply
Texas Gov. Greg Abbott has hit back at left-wing Rep. Jasmine Crockett (D-Texas) after she mocked his use of a wheelchair, claiming the Democrats have “nothing to sell but hate.” The firebrand Texas lawmaker was slammed after she branded Abbott “Governor Hot Wheels” on Saturday during a Human Rights Campaign dinner in Los Angeles.[snip] She responded to the criticism by bizarrely claiming her remarks had nothing to do with Abbott’s disability. “I wasn’t thinking about the governor’s condition — I was thinking about the planes, trains, and automobiles he used to transfer migrants into communities led by Black mayors,
Dem-Appointed Judge Who Blocked Gang Deportations
To Hear Lawsuit Over Trump Admin Signal Chat
12 replies
Posted by ConservativeYankee 3/26/2025 3:48:55 PM Post Reply
The judge who blocked the Trump administration from deporting foreign gang members will hear a lawsuit challenging officials’ use of a Signal chat to discuss attack plans. American Oversight alleged in its lawsuit Tuesday that the app Signal, where officials hosted a chat about plans to bomb the Houthis in Yemen that included The Atlantic editor-in-chief Jeffrey Goldberg, does not comply with federal record laws. “Upon information and belief, under current State recordkeeping rules and practices, officials do not forward Signal messages, including messages from the Signal chat, to their official email accounts, thereby barring American Oversight and other FOIA [Freedom of Information Act] requesters from
Arrest made after TPUSA chapter president
violently assaulted by leftist wielding
bike lock on Texas campus
12 replies
Posted by Hazymac 3/26/2025 1:07:52 PM Post Reply
The University of Texas at Dallas Campus Police have arrested the suspect involved in the attack on TPUSA chapter president Paige Neumann and vice president Grace. TPUSA CEO Charlie Kirk confirmed the arrest on social media, stating that the individual has been placed in jail. According to information on the Collin County, Texas police department's website, the suspect, listed as Liam Thanh Tam Nguyen, is a biological male. (Snip) Original story below. A Turning Point USA (TPUSA) chapter president was assaulted on campus at the University of Texas at Dallas while hosting an informational table on Tuesday. Paige Neumann and her chapter vice president, Grace, were tabling when an individual
Democrats’ disdain for young men backfired
in 2024 — as Trump capitalized on new
media and turned Gen Z red
11 replies
Posted by Mercedes44 3/26/2025 5:02:03 AM Post Reply
For years, the Democratic political figures, liberal activists, and the resistance movement writ large have drawn morbid comfort from the fact that Donald Trump’s supporters were, frankly, quite old. The Trump phenomenon, they believed, had an expiration date sometime in the near future: Young voters would replace their parents and grandparents as demographics shifted, and all would be right — or rather, left — with the world. The 2024 election has shattered these hopes. Trump’s gains with young people are so massive that Gen Z might as well be called Gen Trump. Data guru David Shor laid bare this stark reality in an interview with The New York Times’ Ezra Klein last week;
More illegal migrants are fleeing into
Canada over the northern border than are
coming into US after Trump’s crackdown
10 replies
Posted by Mercedes44 3/26/2025 4:59:54 AM Post Reply
More migrants are fleeing into Canada across the border than are coming south into the US after President Trump’s crackdown on illegal immigration, sources told The Post. Homeland Security sources said that there are “lots of northbounders” now running scared and “self-deporting” from the US with Trump back in office. In a remote stretch of Washington state, border agents report seeing an average of five migrants crossing illegally north into Canada each day. The numbers were starting to pick up even before the Trump administration began in full force.
Democrat Rep. Dan Goldman Calls FBI Task
Force on Tesla Terrorism ‘Political
Weaponization’ of DOJ
9 replies
Posted by ladydawgfan 3/26/2025 5:04:40 PM Post Reply
Rep. Daniel Goldman (D-NY) bizarrely referred to the FBI task force on Tesla terrorism as “lawfare” and the “political weaponization” of the DOJ. Goldman’s statement is especially curious given Democrat’s campaign of lawfare and weaponization against Donald Trump. “This is the political weaponization of the DOJ. Trump uses his official authority to defend his benefactor Elon Musk,” Rep. Goldman oddly claimed of the Trump administration investigating an actual series of crimes in a Tuesday X post. [Tweet] “The FBI then creates a task force to use our law enforcement to ‘crack down’ on adversaries of Musk’s. Where are the Republicans so opposed to ‘lawfare’?” the Congressman added.
How Are The Media Treating Trump In His
Second Term? (Hint: It’s Not Better):
I&I/TIPP Poll
9 replies
Posted by RockyTCB 3/26/2025 9:25:25 AM Post Reply
President Donald Trump had a rough ride with the media during his first term. Big media and smaller social media alike often treated Trump with open scorn, and peppered him with insulting epithets, calling him “fascist” or even “Hitler.” Is it better this time? Not much: A majority in the latest I&I/TIPP Poll say he’s still being treated the same or worse as back then. There’s little doubt, even among those on the left, that Trump is deeply reviled by the mostly left-leaning media. His braggadocio, his aggressive leadership style, his creatively unorthodox policies, his personal fearlessness and his overall popularity have kept Trump a media target.
Post New Article