Post New Article

The Truth About World
War II

Original Article

Posted By: Mercedes44, 9/5/2024 6:31:22 AM

In a recent and now widely seen Tucker Carlson interview, a guest historian named Darryl Cooper casually presented a surprising number of flawed theories about World War II. He focused his misstatements on the respective roles of Winston Churchill’s Britain and Adolf Hitler’s Germany—especially in matters of the treatment and fate of Russian prisoners, the Holocaust, the systematic slaughtering of Jews, strategic bombing, and the nature of Winston Churchill. Because of the size of the audience Carlson introduced him to, and because of the gravity of Cooper’s falsehoods, his assertions deserve a response.

Post Reply

Reminder: “WE ARE A SALON AND NOT A SALOON”

Your thoughts, comments, and ideas are always welcome here. But we ask you to please be mindful and respectful. Threatening or crude language doesn't persuade anybody and makes the conversation less enjoyable for fellow L.Dotters.


Reply 1 - Posted by: petrichor 9/5/2024 7:43:19 AM (No. 1790678)
Well done by VDH. It is foolish to try and rewrite your own history when in earshot of Victor David Hansen.
54 people like this.

Reply 2 - Posted by: downnout 9/5/2024 7:54:54 AM (No. 1790688)
VDH is a world treasure.
49 people like this.

Reply 3 - Posted by: cThree 9/5/2024 7:56:10 AM (No. 1790690)
Reading VDH is never a waste of time. This concise review of the stupefying magnitude and savagery of World War II is a vital antidote to the natural inclination to rewrite and paper over events and policies that overwhelm reason and morality.
47 people like this.

Reply 4 - Posted by: philsner 9/5/2024 7:56:20 AM (No. 1790691)
I didn't see the interview. Did Carlson buy into Cooper's version?
9 people like this.

Reply 5 - Posted by: BarryNo 9/5/2024 8:06:57 AM (No. 1790699)
Completely agree with Victor on this matter. Historical Revisionism is usually the first step of a new wave of such atrocity. Check who funds Darryl Cooper's lectures. Russia is equally guilty. Hitler may have plotted to backstab his ally, but for Russia, especially under the Communists, this was SOP. Nazism was birthed from Communism, and both were reinforced by the writings of American and European Elites who were enamored of Eugenics and a world "rid of the superstitions of religion". Marx was an open Satanist, who may have believed he WAS Satan. If the West was responsible for WWII or even WWI, for that matter, it was because of Liberal Elites poisoning the minds of Elite wannabes through their abhorrent philosophies.
33 people like this.

Reply 6 - Posted by: Calvinesq 9/5/2024 8:25:09 AM (No. 1790707)
I have not seen the Cooper interview by Tucker, just some snippets of aghast reactions on other sites. But, if Cooper was espousing falsehoods without push back from Tucker, then Tucker needs to get VDH on his platform to allow VDH to state his measured and intelligent reaction to Cooper's blathering. I have read VDH's writings and book on WWII, and each is brilliant. Thanks VDH.
37 people like this.

Reply 7 - Posted by: Wetenschapper 9/5/2024 8:38:47 AM (No. 1790710)
I absolutely agree with reply #6. If Carlson wants to retain so much as a soupcon of credibility after his disastrous and sycophantic Cooper interview, he absolutely needs to host a 'counterpoint' interview with Hanson, or he risks being written off as a crank.
39 people like this.

Reply 8 - Posted by: VAPMAN 9/5/2024 8:50:15 AM (No. 1790720)
I am deeply into VDH’s book ‘The Second World Wars’. I suggest Cooper and Carlson read it before further comment on WW2.
23 people like this.

Reply 9 - Posted by: Corndoggies 9/5/2024 8:57:14 AM (No. 1790725)
Does Darryl’s middle name start with a B?
8 people like this.

Reply 10 - Posted by: VirtuDawg 9/5/2024 9:05:46 AM (No. 1790735)
It appears that Tucker, unfortunately, has jumped the shark . . . getting more into weird conspiracy theories these days.
16 people like this.

Reply 11 - Posted by: Kate318 9/5/2024 9:18:43 AM (No. 1790744)
Careful, #10. If experience has shown us anything—especially these last three years—today’s “conspiracy theory” is tomorrow’s “I told you so.”
17 people like this.

Reply 12 - Posted by: Quigley 9/5/2024 9:22:43 AM (No. 1790747)
I wonder how many people born after 1980 have any sense of the monumental history that is WW2. I remember when Dole - a WW2 veteran - was still on the political scene and Clinton, born after WW2, was a newcomer, how Clinton thought that "World War 2 stuff" was so anachronistic for the times. I wonder what currents - both of human natural and societal-geographic - predating WW2 are still at play, and what role whoever runs the US sees the US as having. Big Bidet was born in 1942, Trump in 1946. I can't believe that whoever runs this country believes in the wokeisms other than as a screen behind which to accomplish something nefarious, ie, a war type psyops.
14 people like this.

Reply 13 - Posted by: franq 9/5/2024 9:36:59 AM (No. 1790756)
A well-written rebuttal. The old saying, "In a war, truth is the first casualty" applies. Don't know Carlson's heart. Sometimes, the bizarre sells. FOX is about ratings, just like all other networks.
4 people like this.

Reply 14 - Posted by: Italiano 9/5/2024 9:48:23 AM (No. 1790765)
VDH vs. whoever Darryl Cooper is? Mercy killing. I like Tucker, but he may be going off the rails.
14 people like this.

Reply 15 - Posted by: LadyHen 9/5/2024 11:04:23 AM (No. 1790808)
In a free society, it is never wrong to have the free exchange of ideas and theories and the orthodoxy can be very wrong as we have seen time and time again in countless wars. That said, when VDH literally waits less than 24 hours to rebut your entire premise and relay the documented facts, maybe you should reconsider your career choices.
13 people like this.

Reply 16 - Posted by: DVC 9/5/2024 11:14:49 AM (No. 1790816)
Tucker was stupid to give a lunatic revisionist history jerk such a large audience. Such nutballs exist, but we shouldn't pay attention to their falsehoods. Thanks to VDH for correcting the record.
23 people like this.

Reply 17 - Posted by: RubiconDan 9/5/2024 11:53:17 AM (No. 1790832)
Tucker jumped the shark a long time ago. Now he is not interested in truth, just clickbait and money. I think he is an idiot.
10 people like this.

Reply 18 - Posted by: Luke21 9/5/2024 12:15:28 PM (No. 1790842)
God bless VDH. This answers the call devoid of emotion. The smearing of the great Churchill made my blood boil. What a revisionist scum*bag this dude was. Shame on Tucker Carlson.
6 people like this.

Reply 19 - Posted by: kono 9/5/2024 12:40:04 PM (No. 1790854)
VDH is usually insightful and clear. That's why I tend to consider him a worthwhile read. In this post, though, we have Cooper analyzing conventional history of WWII, Carlson analyzing Cooper's work, and VDH analyzing the whole thing (with focus on analyzing Carlson's work). With several layers of analysis, it's so necessary to be clear about who made what claim and what claim is true or false. Or the potential for double / triple negatives leave my head a little dizzy. I feel like I won't understand what VDH has said here, until I study more WWII history, then study Cooper's critique of that, and then watch Carlson's evaluation of that. Case in point from the start: "It is simply not true, as Cooper alleges, that Hitler’s Wehrmacht was completely surprised" Did Cooper allege the Wehrmacht was surprised? Or that the surprise claim is simply not true? I'll have to come back to this when I have more time.
4 people like this.

Reply 20 - Posted by: homefry 9/6/2024 7:43:32 AM (No. 1791160)
I have always believed that fdr goaded japan into attacking us, so he could get us into the war and end the depression that he had not been able to with his leftwing lunatic policies.
0 people like this.

Below, you will find ...
Most Recent Articles posted by "Mercedes44"
and
Most Active Articles (last 48 hours)
Most Recent Articles posted by Mercedes44"
Biden to present Hillary Clinton, George
Soros and 17 others the Presidential Medal
of Freedom
75 replies
Posted by Mercedes44 1/4/2025 6:14:28 AM Post Reply
President Biden will award the Presidential Medal of Freedom, the nation’s highest civilian honor, to former presidential candidate Hillary Clinton, billionaire Democratic megadonor George Soros and several others at a White House ceremony on Saturday. The White House said Clinton, Soros and the 17 other recipients of the prestigious award are “individuals who have made exemplary contributions to the prosperity, values, or security of the United States, world peace, or other significant societal, public or private endeavors.” “President Biden believes great leaders keep the faith, give everyone a fair shot, and put decency above all else,” the White House said in a statement.
Law Professor Nails Why Judge Mer 19 replies
Posted by Mercedes44 1/4/2025 6:12:33 AM Post Reply
President-elect Donald J. Trump will be sentenced on January 10, but there will be no jail time, not that was ever a concern. The laws and statutes got so contorted that even CNN’s Elie Honig, the network's chief legal analyst and former assistant US attorney, couldn’t defend it, aptly calling it a total disaster of a case. In essence, Trump only got convicted because Manhattan District Attorney Alvin Bragg and his team perverted the rule of law. Law professor Jonathan Turley nailed why Judge Juan Merchan wants to get this wrapped on January 10. It’s to give the liberal media the talking point they’ve salivated over for months:
Once-in-a-Lifetime Opportunity: Defeat
Iran's Oppressive Regime
8 replies
Posted by Mercedes44 1/4/2025 6:10:19 AM Post Reply
Iran's mullahs would surely love nothing more than to cut a deal with the incoming Trump administration that would enable them to stay in power, build their nuclear weapons and unleash them at a later date. Bribing adversaries to stop only provides funding, which finances their military so they can attack us later with bigger weapons. That is how North Korea and Iran built their nuclear weapons programs. China's was built by direct investment: a gift to kill us from Uncle Sam.
Venezuela Places $100,000 Bounty on Real
Winner of Maduro’s Sham Election
3 replies
Posted by Mercedes44 1/3/2025 7:00:46 PM Post Reply
Venezuela’s socialist regime on Thursday announced a $100,000 bounty for information leading to the capture of exiled opposition presidential candidate Edmundo González. The bounty on González, who currently lives in exile in Spain, comes days before January 10, 2025, the start date of a new six-year presidential term in Venezuela as per the nation’s constitution. Both socialist dictator Nicolás Maduro and González, a 75-year-old former diplomat, are planning presidential inaugurations in Caracas on that day. Both claim to have won the 2024 presidential election, which a large number of international observers have dismissed as rigged.
Stunning New Information From Vegas Authorities
on Cybertruck Explosio
4 replies
Posted by Mercedes44 1/3/2025 6:45:51 PM Post Reply
As they have throughout the hours and days following the shocking Cybertruck explosion outside of the Trump International Hotel in Las Vegas, Nevada, on New Year's Day, law enforcement officials conducted another press conference in which they disclosed multiple stunning new details regarding the incident. Below are some of the key details disclosed in Friday afternoon's presser: Authorities recovered the phone of Matthew Livelsberger, the 37-year-old man believed to be the driver of the Cybertruck. The phone was damaged in the explosion, but they were able to extract the data.
Ingratiating Politics 0 replies
Posted by Mercedes44 1/3/2025 6:43:48 PM Post Reply
Folks, I know this is not a popular opinion, but I have always promised to call them exactly as the data aligns and as I see them unfolding. Taking a position in support of Tommy Robinson, taking a strong position against Muslim rape gangs in the U.K., and taking a position in favor of Nigel Farage are not controversial positions in the world of MAGA. In fact, they are popular positions widely held by all of us. However, those positions have little bearing on OUR set of challenges in the USA.
DANG! Bernie Sanders Threw Some Serious
Shade at Kamala Harris
4 replies
Posted by Mercedes44 1/3/2025 6:40:28 PM Post Reply
It has not been a good day for Kamala Harris. We’ll be rid of her soon enough, but her last big job before leaving will be certifying the results of the election that she just spent a billion dollars to lose. That will be fun to watch. On Friday, however, Kamala came out of hiding for one of her remaining ceremonial duties: swearing in the new senators. Predictably, even that didn’t go smoothly. She kicked off the day by leading the Senate chamber in the Pledge of Allegiance, only to fumble her way through it.
What We Got Right — And Wrong — In 2024 3 replies
Posted by Mercedes44 12/31/2024 10:31:02 AM Post Reply
As editorial writers for a combined 90 or so years, we’ve found ourselves often trying to divine the future in addition to insightfully commenting on the present. So we thought with only a few hours left in the year, we’d look back and see if our foresight was sharp, or maybe just a bit blurry, and if our assessment of current events was on the mark. What We Got Right We suggested in February that Joe Biden wasn’t going to be the Democrats’ nominee in 2024. “In short,” we said, “given that the establishment left is now insisting that Biden will be the nominee makes it more likely that he won’t be.”
Canada Promises Crackdown on Student Visa
Abuse After India Human Smuggling Charges
5 replies
Posted by Mercedes44 12/31/2024 10:07:57 AM Post Reply
The Canadian government pledged to crack down on student visa abuse after Indian officials complained about a “well-planned conspiracy” that used Canadian student visas to smuggle Indian nationals into the United States. According to India’s Directorate of Enforcement, an umbrella agency that coordinates interdepartmental investigations of money laundering, a sophisticated criminal operation in India has been systematically abusing student visas to smuggle Indians into Canada. The criminals allegedly targeted a hundred Canadian colleges and universiti
2024’s Biggest Loser Was Barack Obama 26 replies
Posted by Mercedes44 12/31/2024 10:05:11 AM Post Reply
As desperate, phony, and even dangerous of a campaign Democrats ran this year, and as embarrassing as the outcome was for all of them, nobody came out looking more pathetic than Barack Obama. From 2024’s vantage point, is there any way to look at his legacy but as a tragic blight on American history? In the final months of the campaign, Obama seemed to know the outcome of the election would say just as much about him as it would about Joe Biden, Kamala Harris, or Donald Trump. And, like all realistic Democrats, he knew that the nominee he supported was on track to lose.
Obama and Biden Just Achieved the Impossible 4 replies
Posted by Mercedes44 12/31/2024 9:57:28 AM Post Reply
For the first time since FDR and the Great Depression, voters who identify as Republicans outnumber Democrats by a significant margin, according to data released this week by Gallup. Not just Gallup, either. Political analyst Patrick Ruffini noted Monday, "After the exit polls were reweighted to reflect the final popular vote result, Republicans outnumbered Democrats by 5 points in the AP VoteCast survey and by 4 points in the network exit polls."Tonight we're gonna party like it's 1928. So what changed? In the last 16 years, we've had 12 years of hard-left Democrat presidents who got everything they wanted, legislatively,
Hochul’s senseless $75B climate cash
grab will only speed New York’s decline
13 replies
Posted by Mercedes44 12/31/2024 4:05:27 AM Post Reply
Gov. Hochul last week signed a new climate bill forcing fossil-fuel companies to pay $75 billion in “recovery” assessments over the next 25 years for their alleged role in causing “extreme weather.” “It’s time for large polluters to pay their fair share,” she declared. But the claim is an unscientific joke — and the law, passed by some of the nation’s most obtuse and know-nothing legislators, means the political class in Albany just hit the gas pedal on the Empire State’s economic demise. Under this law, New York will “impose cost recovery demands” for extreme weather events “on responsible parties,” or fossil fuel companies,
Most Active Articles (last 48 hours)
Biden to present Hillary Clinton, George
Soros and 17 others the Presidential Medal
of Freedom
75 replies
Posted by Mercedes44 1/4/2025 6:14:28 AM Post Reply
President Biden will award the Presidential Medal of Freedom, the nation’s highest civilian honor, to former presidential candidate Hillary Clinton, billionaire Democratic megadonor George Soros and several others at a White House ceremony on Saturday. The White House said Clinton, Soros and the 17 other recipients of the prestigious award are “individuals who have made exemplary contributions to the prosperity, values, or security of the United States, world peace, or other significant societal, public or private endeavors.” “President Biden believes great leaders keep the faith, give everyone a fair shot, and put decency above all else,” the White House said in a statement.
Honduras President Threatens to Shut Down
U.S. Military Base Over Trump’s Plan
to Deport Illegal Honduran Immigrants
30 replies
Posted by Imright 1/4/2025 11:43:35 AM Post Reply
Honduran President Xiomara Castro has threatened to terminate military cooperation with the United States if President-elect Donald Trump proceeds with his plan for mass deportations of illegal immigrants, including those from Honduras. This ultimatum underscores the glaring hypocrisy of a leader who has failed to address the root causes driving her own citizens to flee her country in the first place. A primary objective of Trump’s mass deportation plan is to remove individuals with criminal records who are residing in the country illegally.
Crazed Kathy Griffin Begs Fans to Buy
Tickets to Her Tour Before Trump Sends
Her to an ‘Internment Camp’
30 replies
Posted by Imright 1/3/2025 3:13:01 PM Post Reply
The disgraced comedian Kathy Griffin thinks it is only a matter of time before she is sent to an internment camp. In an interview with Chicago’s WGN radio station this week, Griffin urged her fans to buy tickets to her latest tour, My Life On the PTSD List, before she is taken away by authorities. “Come see me before I’m in one of those internment camp,” she said. “I’m on the enemies list. That’s very obvious.” “He was very, very scared when I did a parody photo of him and a Halloween mask and a lot of ketchup.
Schumer Appoints Adam Schiff to Powerful
Senate Judiciary Committee
28 replies
Posted by Imright 1/3/2025 9:43:03 AM Post Reply
Incoming Senate Minority Leader Sen. Chuck Schumer (D-NY) has named newly-installed Sen. Adam Schiff (D-CA) to the powerful Senate Judiciary Committee, which reviews judicial appointments, including to the Supreme Court. Mynewsla.com reported: According to Schiff’s office, he will serve on the Senate committees on the Judiciary; Agriculture, Nutrition and Forestry; Environment and Public Works; and Small Business and Entrepreneurship. “I am grateful for the opportunity to serve on four committees of keen interest to all Californians,” Schiff said in a statement. “These assignments will allow me to work directly on the high cost of housing and other inflation issues,
Disgusting: MSNBC Host Lawrence O’Donnell
Says American Veterans Are Greater Terror
Threat Than Illegals Crossing the Border (Video)
25 replies
Posted by Imright 1/4/2025 2:15:00 AM Post Reply
MSNBC has an ongoing ratings problem and host Lawrence O’Donnell is clearly doing everything he can to make sure it stays that way. During a recent rant on his little-watched program, O’Donnell singled out U.S. veterans, specifically from the Army, as a greater terror threat than the people illegally crossing the southern border. A former CIA officer recently said that more than a thousand al-Qaeda operatives have likely crossed the open border and are now in the United States just waiting to strike but apparently, O’Donnell hasn’t heard that report. MSNBC should be ashamed for airing this.
Trump Names One-Time Liberal Activist
Turned MAGA Supporter As State Dept. Spokesperson
25 replies
Posted by Dreadnought 1/3/2025 10:15:13 PM Post Reply
Tammy Bruce was a liberal activist in the 1990s—until she saw the light and became a powerful (self-described) Independent Conservative voice on Fox News, talk radio, books, and as a columnist at The Washington Times. On Friday night, President-elect Donald Trump named her as spokesperson for the U.S. Department of State in his upcoming administration. The Trump-Vance Transition Team released a statement: It is my great honor to announce that Tammy Bruce will be joining our incredible Nominee for United States Secretary of State, Marco Rubio, as Spokesperson for the U.S. Department of State.
Watch: Election Denier, Two-Time Failed
Presidential Candidate Hillary Clinton
Receives Presidential Medal of Freedom
24 replies
Posted by Imright 1/4/2025 5:08:30 PM Post Reply
President Joe Biden awarded election denier and two-time failed presidential candidate Hillary Clinton the Presidential Medal of Freedom on Saturday. The medal is the highest civilian award in the United States.Biden, 82, hung the medal around Clinton’s neck as she smiled. He then kissed her on the cheek before she walked away to sit down. (X Video) Clinton, who failed to defeat now President-elect Donald Trump in 2016 and Barack Obama in 2008, is a longtime election denier: 2016: Claimed the Supreme Court “took away a presidency” in Bush v. Gore. 2017: Said she would not “rule out” questioning the legitimacy of the 2016 election.
FBI declines to say whether it will fire,
discipline agent who said attack was 'not
a terrorist event'
24 replies
Posted by NorthernDog 1/3/2025 2:24:46 PM Post Reply
The FBI has remained silent on whether it will fire or discipline the agent who initially told the media and public that the shocking New Year's Day attack in New Orleans was "not a terrorist event," before the agency quickly backtracked and reported the attack was in fact under investigation as a terror incident. Fox News Digital reached out to the FBI's press office and press secretary on Thursday and Friday, inquiring whether New Orleans field office FBI Assistant Special Agent in Charge Alethea Duncan would face termination or disciplinary action over her initial claim the attack was not connected
Shamsud-Din Jabbar’s New Orleans attack
was terrorism — why did the FBI lie
about it?
23 replies
Posted by 4250Luis 1/3/2025 4:54:47 AM Post Reply
After Shamsud-din Jabbar’s New Orleans attack turned a New Year’s celebration into violent tragedy, the Federal Bureau of Investigation continues to show why it has forfeited the trust of the American people. Jabbar affixed an ISIS flag to the pickup he drove at high speed into a crowd of revelers, killing at least 14 people. Yet the FBI at first refused to call the attack what it plainly was: terrorism. That’s even though it arrested a shocking 10 ISIS would-bes in 2024 alone, thankfully before they were able to carry out any attacks — including a 17-year-old in Arizona. “This is not a terrorist event,”
Buttigieg ridiculed for comparing Joe’s
accomplishments to the Hoover Dam
22 replies
Posted by ladydawgfan 1/3/2025 11:12:13 PM Post Reply
Outgoing Transportation Secretary Pete Buttigieg was mocked as a fool after his effort to burnish the legacy of his soon-to-be ex-boss, suggesting that President Joe Biden’s accomplishments should be viewed in a historic context. On New Year’s Eve, Buttigieg, who only got his important job because he’s openly gay, posted a video to his X account hailing Biden and fellow DEI hire Kamala Harris for their “Big Deal” for infrastructure and ludicrously claiming that their work will one day be viewed as a titanic achievement, much like the Hoover Dam. [Tweet, video] I’m confident that a century from now,
Customs officers interrupt Lauren Sánchez
sunbathing on Jeff Bezos’ $500M yacht
to conduct surprise raid
21 replies
Posted by 4250Luis 1/3/2025 4:57:11 AM Post Reply
Lauren Sánchez’s sunbathing aboard her fiancé Jeff Bezos’ $500 million yacht, Koru, was interrupted by customs officers for a search that lasted three hours on New Year’s Eve, Page Six has learned. We obtained photos of the former TV reporter, 55, smiling and posing on the top deck of the luxury ship, wearing a Versace bikini, black sarong and large hat, while officers scoped another area. The uniform-clad officials, who stepped onto the boat with all of their equipment and black life jackets, were seen speaking to a stewardess, as she appeared to instruct them on where to go.
Mayorkas on Terror Risk at Border: Border
Numbers Are Lower Now, We Prioritize Safety
Threats for Detention, Removal
20 replies
Posted by Imright 1/3/2025 1:50:39 AM Post Reply
On Thursday’s broadcast of the Fox News Channel’s “Your World,” DHS Secretary Alejandro Mayorkas responded to questions on how we can ensure ISIS won’t exploit the border by stating that “individuals who pose a threat to public safety or our national security are prioritized for immigration detention and removal from the United States.” And that policy changes have been made to reduce traffic at the southern border. After listing figures about potential terrorists at the border, host Sandra Smith asked, [relevant exchange begins around 2:30] “How can we be sure that ISIS won’t find a safe harbor here?”Mayorkas answered, “It is our highest responsibility to ensure the safety and security
Post New Article