Post New Article

The Mighty Gorsuch vs. the Administrative
State: Quotes from West Virginia vs. EPA

Original Article

Posted By: Judy W., 7/2/2022 9:00:56 AM

The power of the administrative state to destroy liberty and property – to blast through legislation, science, and judicial oversight – was never more on display than in the last two and a half years. One would hope that the deep bureaucracies would have learned their lessons on how not to respond to a new pathogen. There is no evidence they have. Regardless, the real problem is much deeper. It has to do with the status of the administrative state as the effective governing apparatus of the US. It’s not Congress and not the President. It’s the vast and permanent bureaucracy of 432 agencies and 2.9M bureaucrats who are unreachable

Comments:

This is wonderful! It's mostly excerpts from Gorsuch's concurrence with the ruling about the EPA. He extensively quotes the Founders and others and clearly explains that our government is not meant to be run by unaccountable "experts" but by the people through our elected officials. The quote from Woodrow Wilson is illuminating in recounting how we got to the point we are now, and shows up Wilson for the rotten elitist he was.

Post Reply

Reply 1 - Posted by: Mushroom 7/2/2022 9:18:31 AM (No. 1204109)
The administrative state is why, in my opinion, term limits will not work. The Congress is useless for it's elected purpose because they have given it all away to the second tier of unaccountable ,many times patronaged, professional bureaucrats serving only selective interests.
10 people like this.

Reply 2 - Posted by: FL_Absentee_Voter 7/2/2022 9:29:33 AM (No. 1204116)
Continuing the fight that his own mother patriotically began as the EPA Administrator under Reagan. Mom would be proud. (And just wait until the libs make THAT connection!)
10 people like this.

Reply 3 - Posted by: Ashley Brenton 7/2/2022 9:50:44 AM (No. 1204132)
I'd heard that Kagan's statement was that the court lacks the expertise to implement climate policy. This is what's known as being willfully obtuse. She knew the issue was not climate change, but laws created by unaccountable bureaucrats. And she pointedly did not want to make a statement on that.
20 people like this.

Reply 4 - Posted by: sanspeur 7/2/2022 10:20:26 AM (No. 1204180)
really astonishing read ! so much we ignore / just forget about the filthy swamp , to see it in print makes one realize again how far US has fallen under our dirty , snotty goobers-in-mint . a monkey , donkey and ugly pox upon them all
6 people like this.

Reply 5 - Posted by: Talk2 7/2/2022 10:21:33 AM (No. 1204184)
Let us get to the sad truth about civil servants. They are not called "feather merchants" for no reason for they have been feathering their own nests for generations. Once they got their unions and believed they could not be fired the administrative state began in earnest. I worked with hundreds of wage grade civil servants and found them mostly hard working and ethical. GS and SES employees are a totally different story. I've known many who would sell their own Mothers much less the country to build their own little empires. It works like this -- GS develops rules and regulations for others to follow. That requires someone to write, review, implement, and track compliance. Do you see how that means MORE employees in GS's office? More employees means more work for GS and that means GS must have a higher grade level. If GS moves up a grade or two many below him must also move up which means they now need more people to write, review, implement, and track the rules they dream up to keep busy and so it goes and goes and goes. Pretty soon GS moves up to SES and must have more feathers in his nest. It's a self perpetuating monster that grows and grows and grows. Call it administrative state or deep state, it's all the same, bad for this country and hard on taxpayers.
13 people like this.

Reply 6 - Posted by: 2assume 7/2/2022 10:30:39 AM (No. 1204197)
Stop letting W.H.O. decide what’s good for us. Stop letting the department of health make law. ((Fauci) Stop unions from controlling us. (teachers and others)). In fact I think we should not allow unions to be allowed to be in government service. Stop letting companies donate to political partys. It makes the person of the party beholden. Just when did we start allowing contributions from foreign entities. And for Gods sake we need tort reform to stop law fare.
9 people like this.

Reply 7 - Posted by: MickTurn 7/2/2022 10:33:36 AM (No. 1204204)
The Solution is to make all Bureaucrats personally responsible for their Decisions and bad effects of their mandates.
6 people like this.

Reply 8 - Posted by: Scribelus 7/2/2022 11:03:20 AM (No. 1204244)
Congress broke it, so only it can fix it. But a Congressman’s first job is to be re-elected. All else is incidental. So the problem that is the administrative state (AS) is incidental. So the AS is forever unless the Supreme Court finds that it is somehow unconstitutional. So the Congress fixes that by codifying the AS, a most convenient administrative solution. Ain’t America great?
5 people like this.

Reply 9 - Posted by: Starboard_side 7/2/2022 11:23:22 AM (No. 1204263)
Considering much of what they've done has not been based on Congress' direction and authority, shouldn't it all be undone now? .
9 people like this.

Reply 10 - Posted by: MDConservative 7/2/2022 12:44:51 PM (No. 1204339)
FTA: In Wilson’s eyes, the mass of the people were “selfish, ignorant, timid, stubborn, or foolish.” Does anyone want to argue this? Politicians hate opposition. Posters here regularly label certain politicians similarly- idiots, morons and worse. Conflict is the core of democracy. “Unity” is totalitarianism.
5 people like this.

Reply 11 - Posted by: DVC 7/2/2022 1:20:21 PM (No. 1204382)
This should be a Must Read. This ruling begins to disable and cripple the out of control administrative state, what has been called The Deep State. I mentioned a few days before this ruling came out that "I hope I am not reading too much into what this could be".....and now I can say, that I did not. This is EPIC and it will be the basis for crushing a LOT of adminstrative overreaching by our out of control, unelected, unaccountable bureaucracies. I sent an article on WVa v. EPA to a millenial friend, and he commented that "...the more educated wing of the limited-government crowd has for years been bitching that regulations are not voted on by anybody yet are enforced as law." Even some of the younger folks see that this is an important decision.
7 people like this.

Reply 12 - Posted by: gramma b 7/2/2022 2:17:00 PM (No. 1204423)
I practiced law in Utah while Gorsuch was on the Tenth Circuit. His opinions were often a joy to read. Hard hitting and sometimes very funny.
3 people like this.

Reply 13 - Posted by: WV.Hillbilly 7/2/2022 2:28:32 PM (No. 1204436)
"pen-and-phone regulations" A direct poke in the eye to Obama.
4 people like this.

Reply 14 - Posted by: czechlist 7/2/2022 3:17:46 PM (No. 1204483)
the first step is the REINS Act. encourage your repsto support it
0 people like this.

Below, you will find ...
Most Recent Articles posted by "Judy W."
and
Most Active Articles (last 48 hours)
Most Recent Articles posted by Judy W."
The Mighty Gorsuch vs. the Administrative
State: Quotes from West Virginia vs. EPA
14 replies
Posted by Judy W. 7/2/2022 9:00:56 AM Post Reply
The power of the administrative state to destroy liberty and property – to blast through legislation, science, and judicial oversight – was never more on display than in the last two and a half years. One would hope that the deep bureaucracies would have learned their lessons on how not to respond to a new pathogen. There is no evidence they have. Regardless, the real problem is much deeper. It has to do with the status of the administrative state as the effective governing apparatus of the US. It’s not Congress and not the President. It’s the vast and permanent bureaucracy of 432 agencies and 2.9M bureaucrats who are unreachable
Dutch farmers protest climate regulations
on livestock amid looming global food crisis
9 replies
Posted by Judy W. 6/30/2022 9:48:14 AM Post Reply
Furious Dutch farmers brought cows to The Hague and threatened to slaughter the animals on Tuesday in protest of the Netherlands' $26 billion climate plan that could reduce the livestock population by 30%. The Netherlands, one of Europe's top greenhouse gas emitters, is planning on halving its nitrogen output by 2030, Bloomberg reported. The government plan would shutter some farms, as much of the nitrogen is blamed on manure and fertilizer from cattle. The output goal is in compliance with European Union rules to reduce pollution. The Netherlands is the world's second-largest agricultural exporter, per AFP, and some regions of the country will need to cut as much as 95%
The Invisible Power Controlling the US Government 10 replies
Posted by Judy W. 6/30/2022 6:47:06 AM Post Reply
I have written extensively on inverted totalitarianism, that being the once nascent, now entrenched form of government that truly controls the levers of federal power in the United States. This behemoth has turned the USA into a “managed democracy”; a bureaucracy which cannot be held accountable by the elected representatives of the people. (Snip) The Brownstone Institute’s Jeffery Tucker recently wrote an article about an executive order passed by Trump shortly before his departure, which would have enabled huge progress towards reigning in the power of the administrative state. The executive order would have allowed agencies to reclassify policy jobs under a new schedule,
Chuck Grassley slams Justice Department
for not prosecuting employees for lying
10 replies
Posted by Judy W. 6/28/2022 8:34:31 AM Post Reply
Ranking Senate Judiciary Committee member Chuck Grassley (R-Iowa) slammed the Department of Justice on Monday for "repeated failure to prosecute employees" who were caught lying during internal investigations. "An unsettling pattern has emerged from the Department of Justice (DOJ) whereby criminal referrals by the Department of Justice, Office of Inspector General (OIG), against DOJ employees for making materially false statements are rarely prosecuted," Grassley wrote in a letter to Attorney General Merrick Garland. Grassley said the "most shocking example of this pattern" occurred last month after the DOJ declined to bring charges against the former FBI agents who botched the investigation of Dr. Larry Nassar,
'Big rig man' Clarence Thomas gets away
from it all
18 replies
Posted by Judy W. 6/27/2022 8:37:32 PM Post Reply
The way Ginni Thomas recalled it, she and her husband, Supreme Court Justice Clarence Thomas, were driving through upstate New York, by Lake George, when the red check engine light flickered on the dash of their 40-foot 1992 Prevost Marathon conversion coach. (Snip) In the book of interviews, Thomas said he never traveled much as a poor child in Georgia. Then, over 20 years ago, a friend encouraged him to see the country by mobile home, and he’s never looked back. Now more than ever, a month on the road looks to be a good thing for the judge and his wife.
Guns and Roeses 11 replies
Posted by Judy W. 6/27/2022 10:29:04 AM Post Reply
It has long been a dictum of mine that, as far as the progressive Left is concerned, "they never stop, they never sleep, they never quit." After their twin defeats at the Supreme Court last week, regarding two of their most sensitive issues (both of which derive from their devotion to cultural suicide, which is their principal objective), don't expect them to give up easily. They subscribe to their version of Islamism or the Brezhnev Doctrine: once they've conquered moral or physical tparerritory, it can never go back to the way it was. They see themselves as the heroes of their own movies, good red-diaper babies constantly battling the forces
Navy threatens to penalize sailors who
purposely misuse gender pronouns
35 replies
Posted by Judy W. 6/27/2022 9:49:19 AM Post Reply
The Navy is threatening to penalize sailors who purposely misuse pronouns to describe transgender service members, viewing it as a violation of the service's harassment policy. Sailors who run afoul of the policy could face administrative or judicial action under the Uniform Code of Military Justice, Navy Capt. Dave Hecht, a public affairs officer, told American Military News. "Intentional misuse of transgender service member pronouns is inappropriate and inconsistent with the Navy zero tolerance policy on harassment," Hecht told the news site. "The UCMJ prohibits provoking speeches or gestures, conduct that is of a nature to bring discredit upon the Armed Forces or is prejudicial to good order and discipline,
Modern Medical Ethics and How They Relate
to Roe vs. Wade
0 replies
Posted by Judy W. 6/27/2022 8:25:23 AM Post Reply
One of the most frustrating arguments the medical field has refined is the unacceptability of challenging any medical dogma because doing so “harms” patients. For example, I and many of my colleagues believe that the number one cause of infant mortality within the United States is the childhood vaccine schedule (which is also what is most clearly linked to Sudden Infant Death Syndrome), and that vaccines often fail to prevent infectious disease and that most of the diseases we vaccinate against are extremely rare or relatively harmless. However, the typical response by the mainstream medical community has been to label anyone who opposes any childhood vaccination as a “baby killer,“
This Is What Real Revolution Looks Like 11 replies
Posted by Judy W. 6/26/2022 5:26:35 AM Post Reply
If you listen to the mainstream media you will know that from time to time spontaneous peaceful protests break out in the nation focused on various social issues. You will also know that Antifa is largely a fiction of the ‘delusional right’ and that the real threat to the nation comes from a vast right-wing conspiracy driven by white supremacists. In short, you will know nothing. (Snip) What we saw in the infamous “summer of love” was the work of a nationwide network of highly organized anarchist and Marxist groups with the express purpose of destroying the nation as we know it. Their actions are meticulously planned and well supported.
Doctors question kids' vax as U.K. research
shows minuscule COVID risk
5 replies
Posted by Judy W. 6/25/2022 9:34:55 AM Post Reply
The quality of evidence for the FDA's emergency use authorization (EUA) of COVID-19 vaccines for children as young as 6 months is drawing scrutiny from high-profile doctors and academics, some of whom are asking the White House not to pressure parents to vaccinate. With CDC seroprevalence data from February finding 75% of minors had natural immunity, more attention is going to the risk/benefit calculation of vaccines for the age group at lowest risk from COVID. Parents on the fence may find their hesitancy reaffirmed by new studies, not yet peer-reviewed, on the COVID infection fatality rate (IFR) by age and underlying health conditions and "serious adverse events of interest" following
ABIM [American Board of Internal Medicine]:
"There shall be no public accountability
on our decision to de-certify Dr. McCullough"
15 replies
Posted by Judy W. 6/23/2022 6:54:39 AM Post Reply
ABIM contacted Dr. Peter McCullough in a letter dated May 26, 2022 notifying him he is accused of spreading misinformation and started an investigation to remove his board certification. Senator Ron Johnson heard about the letter and sent a letter dated June 15 to Dr. Richard Baron, President & CEO of the ABIM where he politely offered to host an expert panel of doctors in Washington DC to resolve what the science actually says, similar to the widely popular “A second opinion” panel he hosted, but this time with scientists on both sides. Note that Johnson’s original panel invited scientists on all sides but nobody was willing to support
Clarence Thomas Recalls Grandfather as
‘Strongest Person I’ve Ever Known’
8 replies
Posted by Judy W. 6/22/2022 10:24:43 AM Post Reply
Editor’s note: In these exclusive excerpts from the book “Created Equal: Clarence Thomas in His Own Words,” out Tuesday, author Michael Pack asks the Supreme Court justice about the influence of his maternal grandfather. (Snip) Pack: What happened on the other end, when you showed up to your grandparents’ house? Thomas: My grandfather was this myth. We saw him maybe once or twice when we lived on the West Side. He was very stern. And he sat us there at the kitchen table and he said, “Boys, the damn vacation is over.” He said from then on it was going to be “rules and regulations and manners and behavior.”
Most Active Articles (last 48 hours)
Liz Cheney says Justice Department ‘doesn’t
have to wait’ for the January 6 committee
to refer Trump for criminal charges and
warns the Republican Party 'can't survive'
if ex-president is the GOP 2024 nominee
62 replies
Posted by Imright 7/3/2022 11:41:54 AM Post Reply
Rep. Liz Cheney publicly nudged the Justice Department on Sunday to move against Donald Trump, warning that not holding the former president accountable for January 6 is a 'graver Constitutional threat' to American democracy than letting him off the hook. Cheney - one of two Republicans on the Democrat-led Capitol riot committee - also shared a warning for her own party, which has largely ostracized her for her role on the panel. 'I think that that he can't be the party nominee' in the 2024 presidential race, the Wyoming lawmaker told ABC News of Trump. 'I don't think the party would survive that.'
Breaking: Internal Memo Reveals Capitol
Police Were Warned BLM from Baltimore
Was Bussing in Rioters Disguised as Trump
Supporters on Jan. 6
39 replies
Posted by ladydawgfan 7/3/2022 3:29:30 AM Post Reply
It was all a setup. Trump supporters were framed by FBI and government operatives and BLM and Antifa terrorists. A leaked internal memo revealed that the US Capitol Police intel unit warned that BLM from Baltimore was bussing in rioters for January 6th protests. According to the memo the rioters were going to blend in. Via investigative reporter Paul Sperry: “BLM/Antif will wear MAGA hats, wear camo,and attempt to blend in with MAGA crowd” so violence blamed on Trump supporters attending Trump rally. [Tweet] Antifa was actively involved in the January 6th protests and riots. This has been widely discussed by officials and in reports on this website.
GOP Rep. Adam Kinzinger defends his tweet
calling Liz Cheney's challengers 'armpit
farters,' saying they are 'spreading conspiracy'
35 replies
Posted by NorthernDog 7/3/2022 3:52:06 PM Post Reply
GOP Rep. Adam Kinzinger, who is a member of the January 6 House committee, defended his tweet calling Rep. Liz Cheney's primary challengers "armpit farters" during a recent Wyoming Republican primary debate. Kinzinger told CNN's Dana Bash on Sunday's State of the Union that Cheney's GOP primary opponents are "spreading conspiracy." During a primary debate on Friday, Kinzinger called Cheney's challengers "a bunch of arm-pit farters" on Twitter. Cheney's challengers made a point to spread conspiracy theories during the debate, including claims of stolen elections, and anti-vaccination theory. "I hope this serves as a lesson to every American. Let's fix
Biden blames gas stations for high prices
at the pump and even the Chicoms are laughing
35 replies
Posted by PageTurner 7/3/2022 9:24:11 AM Post Reply
Old Joe is still trying to figure out where inflation comes from. It's gotten so bad even the Chicoms are laughing at him. This time the intellectually blindfolded president has pinned the donkey tail on gas station owners. According to Fox Business: President Biden is telling companies that are "running gas stations" to "bring down" their prices because "this is a time of war and global peril." "My message to the companies running gas stations and setting prices at the pump is simple: this is a time of war and global peril," Biden tweeted on Saturday. "Bring down the price you are charging at the pump
Nervous Democrats pray for anyone but
Kamala Harris as 2024 nominee
29 replies
Posted by Imright 7/3/2022 8:20:33 AM Post Reply
Democrats are despairing about the possibility of Kamala Harris becoming the 2024 nominee if President Biden doesn’t seek a second term in office, insiders told The Post. Three polls just this month show more than 50% of Americans hold an unfavorable view of Harris, and those headwinds will likely only increase should Republicans retake the House next year. “Her main problem is not being a woman or mixed race, her problem is she has low ratings just like President Biden,” said Larry Sabato, a professor of Politics at the University of Virginia.
Moment 100 Patriot Front white supremacist
group members march along Boston's Freedom
Trail on July Fourth Weekend to ‘reclaim
America’: Accused of assaulting black
man during demonstration
28 replies
Posted by Ribicon 7/3/2022 2:07:37 PM Post Reply
A large group of white supremacists marched along Boston's Freedom Trail ahead of the Fourth of July in protest that allegedly turned violent. Patriot Front led nearly 100 members carrying white nationalist flags and shields through the Massachusetts capital on Saturday as part of their efforts to 'reclaim America.' Video shows the group walking step with a snare drum, with flags and banners in hand, as they made their way to the Old State House and City Hall Plaza. Boston police have launched an investigation into the protest after a black man reported that he had been assaulted by the demonstrators. He claimed a group of Patriot Front members donning shields
‘The View’ reportedly to announce
new permanent conservative co-host; Ann
Coulter speaks up
22 replies
Posted by Imright 7/3/2022 7:58:22 PM Post Reply
Anticipation is building that “The View” will soon announce its permanent conservative replacement for departed co-host Meghan McCain who left the show last year, giving way to a rotating slate of fill-ins who were served up to be torn to shreds by vicious harpies Joy Behar, Whoopi Goldberg and Sunny Hostin. The popular ABC daytime gabfest which just celebrated its 25th anniversary with a special set of shows from a swanky resort in the Bahamas where the wealthy regulars lived it up in a $14K per night villa, will reportedly be making the big announcement before the season wraps up in early August.
'I feel cheated': California seniors disappointed
they're left out of state's inflation
relief package
22 replies
Posted by NorthernDog 7/3/2022 10:46:37 AM Post Reply
MANTECA, Calif. — Karen Boyles lives back in her childhood home in Manteca, California. She lives a simple life. "I'm 78 years young," she said, smiling. (Snip) Boyles is one of the thousands of California seniors depending solely on social security. "Although we do pay into taxes every year, we buy houses, we buy cars, washing machines, groceries," she said. "We are paying taxes and we have paid our taxes in the past." She is in the group excluded from the state's new inflation relief program. "I feel very cheated and let down," she said. Boyle said it's no relief for
NY Times: American Flag Has Been Hijacked
By Red Staters
21 replies
Posted by Dreadnought 7/3/2022 11:37:09 PM Post Reply
New York Times columnist Margaret Renkl may be based in Nashville, but she’s as contemptuous of Trumpers and Red Staters as any of the paper’s Manhattan-based writers, as shown in her latest self-important trashing of an American holiday: “The American Flag Belongs to Me, Too, and This Year I’m Taking It Back.” She reminisced how in her younger days, “We were all proud to be Americans, even if we didn’t agree about which aspects of our sprawling, messy democracy merited pride.” Not anymore though, with Old Glory now hijacked by the Red Staters, in all their irredeemable tackiness. Take a drive through any red state, and you will see American flags
Singapore craft beer uses recycled sewage
to highlight water scarcity
21 replies
Posted by Ribicon 7/3/2022 5:56:10 PM Post Reply
It is a beer made with only the finest ingredients: premium German barley malts, aromatic Citra and Calypso hops, farmhouse yeast from Norway–and reclaimed sewage. NewBrew, a collaboration between Singapore’s national water agency and the local craft brewery Brewerkz, has already proved popular and has sold out on tap at the brewery’s restaurants, according to reports. Brewerkz describes the beer as “highly quaffable” and suitable for Singapore’s tropical climate, with a smooth, toasted honey-like aftertaste.(Snip)Brew uses NEWater, wastewater that Singapore’s Public Utilities Board has treated with microfiltration and reverse osmosis as well as ultraviolet light to remove contaminants, bacteria and viruses.
Amazon warehouse employee, 19, is arrested
'for plotting mass-shooting at the Texas
depot where he worked': Teen 'idolized'
Uvalde gunman that killed 19 children
and had recently bought an AR-15
21 replies
Posted by Ribicon 7/3/2022 2:28:31 PM Post Reply
A 19-year-old Amazon employee has been arrested on suspicion he plotted a mass shooting at the depot where he worked, with an AR-15 rifle, authorities said. Rodolfo Valdivia Aceves was arrested on a charge of terroristic threats on June 27, according to San Antonio Police. Police responded to reports of threats at the Amazon warehouse on 8210 Sous Vide Way. Staff at the delivery station said they heard Aceves planning a mass shooting.(Snip)Aceves' father also said that his son suffered from an unspecified mental health illness and had received in-patient treatment at a facility when he was 16, according to News4.
Not Funny? Unhinged Alec Baldwin’s Anger
Issues On Display, Goes After Critic For
Harmless Jab
20 replies
Posted by AmericaFirstAlways 7/3/2022 8:43:14 AM Post Reply
There was a time, long ago, when actor Alec Baldwin was actually entertaining. His performance as a main character in the classic 1988 comedy Beetlejuice was solid, though Michael Keaton stole the show in that film. And Baldwin was adequate in the movies Hunt for Red October in 1990 and Glengarry Glen Ross in 1992. He was even decent in the terrific drama The Departed in 2006. Indeed, Baldwin had been blessed with good looks and enough talent to make himself a wealthy man with a robust career. But as we’ve seen with so many actors – consider Robert DeNiro, Susan Sarandon, and Sean Penn as examples – Baldwin’s onscreen success
Post New Article