Post New Article

Is civil disobedience OK if it’s the
only way to prevent climate catastrophe?

Original Article

Posted By: NorthernDog, 4/13/2022 9:35:12 AM

This week, climate activists disrupted the UK’s oil supply, because they believe they face a desperate choice. Nonviolent resistance now, or the unthinkable violence of climate change later. “There is a need to break the law,” says Just Stop Oil’s Melissa Carrington, “so we are not guilty of greater crime.” But is she right? In so-called liberal democracies, we have a default obligation to obey the law. It’s a moral duty, as well as a legal one. It’s part of our implicit contract with the government we elected, which provides us, in return, with the protection of justice. But what

Comments:

They have the same mentality as the subway shooter. Society won't bend completely to their will, so violence is required.

Post Reply

Reply 1 - Posted by: downnout 4/13/2022 9:42:15 AM (No. 1127346)
They ask what could be more just than shutting down an industry that kills people? Really? I suspect the offices of the Guardian are heated by evil oil companies. Maybe we should let them freeze.
15 people like this.

Reply 2 - Posted by: Rich323 4/13/2022 9:43:51 AM (No. 1127350)
I can see it now, Burning Oil Matters protests in the US blocking traffic and fuel trucks. The problem is, their cause is based on media created lies, like “hands up don’t shoot” in Ferguson Mo was a lie, “Don’t say Gay” is a lie, and time after time the climate tales have been proven false. This may be their new campaign to compliment their plan to eliminate fossil fuel. Block all but electric vehicles.
19 people like this.

Reply 3 - Posted by: hershey 4/13/2022 9:46:01 AM (No. 1127354)
All liberals are unhinged mentally, the liberal eco-weenie, tree spiking, EV fanatics are even more so...if that were possible...according to Al Gorsky, we should all be swimming by now.....as he zips around in his planes and goes to his multiple houses...
14 people like this.

Reply 4 - Posted by: Maggie2u 4/13/2022 9:51:10 AM (No. 1127363)
FTA...'And what could be more unjust than supporting an industry that kills people?' Betcha $5 this person is pro-abort. An industry that just here in the U.S. has killed 60 million innocent helpless people in the past 50 years.
17 people like this.

Reply 5 - Posted by: columba 4/13/2022 9:54:20 AM (No. 1127368)
God said that mankind should be stewards of the earth. Climate change clowns believe that there is no God ... thus it is up to them to save the part of the planet that they like.
13 people like this.

Reply 6 - Posted by: Italiano 4/13/2022 9:56:29 AM (No. 1127372)
Is it OK to take out those who think it is?
19 people like this.

Reply 7 - Posted by: Mass Minority 4/13/2022 10:01:19 AM (No. 1127381)
This is not a simple question. Mainly because the clear answer is yes, even violent civil disobediance could be the moral and ethical response to a societal evil. The revolutionary war was certainly a violent act of civil disobedience and arguably both moral and just. Would a counter movement as violent as the NAZI brownshirts have been morally just if it could have prevented their ascension to power? In hindsight the answer is absolutely. The problem is that we do not have the benefit of hindsight about the future. Every "existential crisis" does not rise to the level that those two isolated examples did. The problem arises when individuals transform from advocate to zealot. Advocates can be effective Zealots are downright dangerous. Thoreau stated that civil disobedience was a citizens obligation in the face of injustice. He aso stated that as a citizen one must be willing to accept the consequences. Mandela spent years in prison and toppled the apartheid government. What rose was certainly better but still has problems, Lenin burned the nation to the ground and replaced it with terror. Both were expressing civil disobedience. Violence is always the last resort of a moral movement, it is far too often the first resort of an immoral movement. And without the benefit of hindsight the real problem is discerning which is which.
11 people like this.

Reply 8 - Posted by: bad-hair 4/13/2022 10:02:20 AM (No. 1127384)
Anybody seen Greta lately ? She must have lost her camera crew. Doesn't even TWIT anymore. Back to school moron. You've got some catching up to do.
14 people like this.

Reply 9 - Posted by: NamVet70 4/13/2022 10:04:23 AM (No. 1127388)
Anyone so arrogant to believe that the law is just for those other people needs to be sentenced to the maximum penalty possible.
10 people like this.

Reply 10 - Posted by: joew9 4/13/2022 10:05:12 AM (No. 1127390)
There is no climate catastrophe coming. The civil disobedience and the oppressive laws will be the catastrophe.
23 people like this.

Reply 11 - Posted by: marbles 4/13/2022 10:05:16 AM (No. 1127391)
There is no " climate catastrophe "....................so everything they're advocating for is based on a lie.
22 people like this.

Reply 12 - Posted by: EJKrausJr 4/13/2022 10:32:45 AM (No. 1127428)
Smith, Wesson and Colt may have a say in their default obligation to break the law. As Dirty Harry once said - go ahead ......
11 people like this.

Reply 13 - Posted by: Strike3 4/13/2022 10:33:41 AM (No. 1127433)
Where does Queen Gretta stand in all of this? Did she grow up and leave her followers to fend for themselves?
8 people like this.

Reply 14 - Posted by: WhamDBambam 4/13/2022 10:35:04 AM (No. 1127435)
I dunno. Is extreme physical violence OK if it's the only way to stop climate terrorists?
18 people like this.

Reply 15 - Posted by: FLCracker 4/13/2022 10:35:53 AM (No. 1127436)
So what if I believe "there is a need to break the law" to keep her and people of her ilk from destroying our economy and culture?
10 people like this.

Reply 16 - Posted by: cor-vet 4/13/2022 10:45:30 AM (No. 1127460)
I may not use lethal force to protect my car from a violent environmental extremist, but the application of a baseball bat is not out of the question!
9 people like this.

Reply 17 - Posted by: BarryNo 4/13/2022 10:49:52 AM (No. 1127471)
Is Civil Disobedience okay if it's the only way to prevent tyranny using unscientfic memes to scare people into non-existent problems? These would be Man Made Climate Change, Covid, Wag-the-Dog Wars, and manufactured economic downturns. How about open, armed rebellion?
8 people like this.

Reply 18 - Posted by: mc squared 4/13/2022 11:24:48 AM (No. 1127512)
How many times has the earth been on the brink of climate catastrophe? Let me count the years: !971 1975 All the Reagan years 1990 1998 2000 2012 All the Trump years 2020 Now.
16 people like this.

Reply 19 - Posted by: JunkYardDog 4/13/2022 11:37:43 AM (No. 1127521)
Environmental terrorists who love to virtue signal. Never mind the the tens of thousands who freeze and starve to satisfy their narcissistic moral code. If they want to live in the Stone Age, let the UK set aside a nice island with no utilities and leave them there to fend for themselves.
8 people like this.

Reply 20 - Posted by: formerNYer 4/13/2022 11:53:28 AM (No. 1127546)
I hope they like the "climate" in jail.
11 people like this.

Reply 21 - Posted by: TJ54 4/13/2022 12:31:39 PM (No. 1127595)
We should shoot climate change activists on site
5 people like this.

Reply 22 - Posted by: DVC 4/13/2022 1:37:02 PM (No. 1127662)
There is NO "climate catastrophe". They have been pumping this "emergency" baloney for over 50 years. NOTHING changed yet.
7 people like this.

Reply 23 - Posted by: SALady 4/13/2022 1:44:03 PM (No. 1127670)
OK then, based on this lie-beral "logic", it sounds like it's time to burn down all the Planned Parenthood abortion slaughterhouses, and bomb the factories that make the abortion pills. All for the "greater good" as they say!!!
4 people like this.

Reply 24 - Posted by: ROLFNader 4/13/2022 8:49:41 PM (No. 1127955)
Well- that settles it. I need more and bigger guns.....
1 person likes this.

Below, you will find ...
Most Recent Articles posted by "NorthernDog"
and
Most Active Articles (last 48 hours)
Most Recent Articles posted by NorthernDog"
Biden approval rating tumbles to lowest
point of his presidency: poll
13 replies
Posted by NorthernDog 4/13/2022 6:13:19 PM Post Reply
President Biden's approval rating has reached the lowest level of his presidency, with a new poll showing only a third of Americans approve of his job performance. Just 33% of Americans approve of Biden's job performance compared to 54% who disapprove, according to the results of a Quinnipiac University poll released Wednesday. That mark ties the lowest approval Biden has received in the poll during his precedency, matching the number set in January when the president faced a 33-53 approval deficit. Biden's approval numbers are slightly among registered voters, with 35% saying they approve of the president's job performance compared
Gender equity, family planning missing
from US city climate plans: report
17 replies
Posted by NorthernDog 4/13/2022 4:43:04 PM Post Reply
American women and gender-diverse individuals are disproportionately affected by climate change, but municipal climate plans fail to address family planning or gender equity solutions, a new report has found. The report, released on Tuesday by the Center for Biological Diversity, scrutinized 21 climate plans in cities nationwide, whose total populations represent about 10 percent of the U.S. population. The authors found that none of the plans included family planning, contraception or reproductive health solutions and that only one city — Boston — referred to gender equity as a climate change mitigation strategy. “Societies are more resilient when governments invest in
Is civil disobedience OK if it’s the
only way to prevent climate catastrophe?
24 replies
Posted by NorthernDog 4/13/2022 9:35:12 AM Post Reply
This week, climate activists disrupted the UK’s oil supply, because they believe they face a desperate choice. Nonviolent resistance now, or the unthinkable violence of climate change later. “There is a need to break the law,” says Just Stop Oil’s Melissa Carrington, “so we are not guilty of greater crime.” But is she right? In so-called liberal democracies, we have a default obligation to obey the law. It’s a moral duty, as well as a legal one. It’s part of our implicit contract with the government we elected, which provides us, in return, with the protection of justice. But what
Seattle's transit system struggles as
riders refuse to pay
27 replies
Posted by NorthernDog 4/12/2022 9:17:29 AM Post Reply
SEATTLE – Seattle’s Link Light Rail is a freeloader’s paradise. There are no turnstiles, so passengers are supposed to either buy a ticket or tap their pre-paid card. But so few riders are paying, fares are currently covering just 5% of the system’s operating costs, a fraction of the 40% mark Sound Transit set as a requirement. At a recent Sound Transit Board meeting, the outgoing CEO summed up the situation. "Our fare collection system relies overwhelmingly on an honor system," Peter Rogoff said, "and our increasingly acute problem is that our riders aren’t honoring the system." By one measurement
Saudi state-funded TV aired a sketch mocking
Biden as a forgetful, sleepy old man as
US-Saudi relations hit new low
11 replies
Posted by NorthernDog 4/12/2022 8:55:09 AM Post Reply
A major Saudi government-owned broadcaster aired a sketch mocking President Joe Biden as US-Saudi relations plunge to a new low. In the comedy sketch on MBC's "Studio 22" show, which aired Monday, Biden's character appeared sleepy and forgetful, wandering offstage before being tugged back by a likeness of Vice President Kamala Harris. Biden is then seen confusing Spain and Africa, forgetting Russian President Vladimir Putin's name, and mistakenly calling Harris his "first lady." The sketch then ends with the Harris character dragging the sleeping Biden character off stage. (Snip) The Saudi government owns a majority stake in MBC and it
Portland sees first measurable April snow
in known history; High Desert also sees
late snow
12 replies
Posted by NorthernDog 4/11/2022 8:42:26 PM Post Reply
PORTLAND, Ore. — Portland received its first measurable April snowfall in recorded history on Monday as a spring storm brought rare late-season snow elsewhere and large amounts in the Cascades. One inch of snow fell at Portland International Airport, setting a record with the only measurable amount of snow there since official record-keeping for snowfall began there in 1940, the National Weather Service said. Schools across the region were closed and some areas about an hour west of Portland received up to several inches of snow. Portland General Electric reported more than 55,000 customers were without power in a six-county region
Russia has 8-mile military convoy, 'colossal'
amount of equipment ready for new blitz:
Live Ukraine updates
15 replies
Posted by NorthernDog 4/11/2022 12:41:53 PM Post Reply
Russia is resupplying and reinforcing its invasion force in eastern Ukraine with a long convoy of vehicles heading to the region, indicating a new phase of the war is likely to occur there, according to a senior Pentagon officials. The convoy, exposed in commercial satellite imagery, stretches an estimated eight miles. It appears to contain vehicles to command and supply infantry units and possibly helicopters, said the official who provided intelligence assessments on condition of anonymity. Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelenskyy warned of an impending Russian offensive in his country's east and has urged civilians to flee the region. "The occupiers
Ukraine War: Russia warns Sweden and Finland
against Nato membership
8 replies
Posted by NorthernDog 4/11/2022 9:12:54 AM Post Reply
Russia has warned Finland and Sweden against joining Nato, arguing the move would not bring stability to Europe. Kremlin spokesman Dmitry Peskov told reporters that "the alliance remains a tool geared towards confrontation". It comes as US defence officials said Moscow's invasion of Ukraine has been a "massive strategic blunder" which is likely to bring Nato enlargement. US officials expect the Nordic neighbours to bid for membership of the alliance, potentially as early as June. Washington is believed to support the move which would see the Western alliance grow to 32 members. US State Department officials said last week that
Environmental group calls for deflating
tires of SUVs to combat climate change:
target ‘wealthy areas’
54 replies
Posted by NorthernDog 4/10/2022 8:52:24 PM Post Reply
A radical environmental group raised a few eyebrows on Twitter after encouraging people to let the tires out of SUVs in an apparent bid to combat climate change. The group, Adbusters, tweeted step-by-step instructions for the provocation on Wednesday, calling it a "gentle escalation" or ramping up the urgency about climate change. (Tweet) "Wedge gravel in the tire valves, leaflet the SUV to let them know the tires are flat and why it was done, and walk away. It’s that simple," the group tweeted. "If we organize, we can hit enough SUVs in particular neighborhoods to spark reporting and spread
'Family, family, family:' Valerie Biden
Owens defends brother 'Joey' and nephew Hunter
17 replies
Posted by NorthernDog 4/10/2022 9:41:15 AM Post Reply
NEWARK, Delaware – With the Bidens, it's all in the family .For better or worse. There's the "safehaven" President Joe Biden's sister Valerie provides in their regular late-night phone conversations, chitchat about nothing after a day that might have been dominated for him by Russian aggression and record inflation. But there's also the escalating furor around his son Hunter, the subject of a federal investigation and the likely target of Capitol Hill hearings if Republicans win control of Congress in November. (Snip) She was her brother's first campaign manager and decades later remains a voice he trusts. Dubbed "the Biden whisperer,"
CDC warns of meningococcal disease outbreak
in Florida primarily affecting gay, bi men
42 replies
Posted by NorthernDog 4/9/2022 9:52:01 PM Post Reply
The Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC) issued a health warning about an outbreak of meningococcal disease in Florida, which the agency said is mainly affecting gay and bisexual men, including those living with HIV. The CDC urged gay and bisexual men and other men who have sex with men to get the MenACWY vaccine if they live in Florida. It also recommended that those planning to visit Florida talk with their healthcare provider about getting the vaccine. The agency added in the advisory that multiple meningococcal disease cases in college students have been reported in the state over
Nevada Personifies Democrats' Electoral
Problems Nationwide
9 replies
Posted by NorthernDog 4/8/2022 8:02:31 PM Post Reply
Ruy Teixeira is a liberal political scientist who has been sounding the alarm for the past decade about Democrats’ problems with Hispanic voters as well as working-class whites. And the state that most personifies the Democrats’ opportunities and challenges with these voters is Nevada. (Snip) But despite the state’s continued, rapid diversification, the margins for Democratic victories have been narrowing. But hidden in these facts are some troubling signs. Despite rapid diversification, the Democratic margin in Presidential elections from 2008 to 2016 declined sharply from 12.5 to 2.4 points. And in 2020, as the Democrats gained ground in the country
Most Active Articles (last 48 hours)
Report: Chris Wallace ‘Having Daily
Breakdowns’ over CNN+ Failure
49 replies
Posted by Imright 4/13/2022 8:57:46 AM Post Reply
Former Fox News anchor Chris Wallace has reportedly been breaking down in front of his crew over the “miserable failure” of the new streaming platform CNN+.The launch of CNN+ has been anything but stellar, according to the latest statistics, with the platform drawing in close to 10,000 daily viewers and even fewer subscribers. Per CNBC: Fewer than 10,000 people are using CNN+ on a daily basis two weeks into its existence, according to people familiar with the matter. The people spoke with CNBC on the condition of anonymity in order to discuss nonpublic data.
Democratic colleagues are concerned that
Senator Dianne Feinstein, 88, is 'mentally
unfit to serve', say her memory is 'rapidly
deteriorating' and have had to 'reintroduce
themselves multiple times'
38 replies
Posted by zephyrgirl 4/14/2022 2:03:37 PM Post Reply
Multiple Democrats on Capitol Hill are worried about the ability of one of their longest-serving senators, Dianne Feinstein, to continue serving in Congress, a new report suggests on Thursday. Feinstein, 88, had long been renowned in Washington for an issue-focused passion and quick wit -- but one California Democratic lawmakers told the San Francisco Chronicle there was 'no trace of that' in recent months.
Biden administration unveils plan to root
out ‘racial inequality’ in government agencies
37 replies
Posted by Ribicon 4/14/2022 10:06:39 AM Post Reply
The Biden administration on Thursday unveiled hundreds of strategies across several federal agencies aimed at addressing what it says is racial and gender inequity in the federal government. A senior administration official said the initiative is the first major assessment of how government policies have allowed “inequality to fester,” including ways they said the government has blocked underserved communities from government services. “This is about getting under the hood in every agency,” the official said. The plan outlines more than 300 different strategies and commitments by more than 90 federal agencies, including the Justice, Defense, Energy and Labor departments. For example, the Justice Department will offer more language-accessible programs
Elon Musk’s vision for the internet
is dangerous nonsense
34 replies
Posted by Dreadnought 4/14/2022 1:39:25 PM Post Reply
The Russian people know little about Putin’s war on Ukraine because Putin has blocked their access to the truth, substituting propaganda and lies. Years ago, pundits assumed the internet would open a new era of democracy, giving everyone access to the truth. But dictators like Putin and demagogues like Trump have demonstrated how naive that assumption was. At least the US responded to Trump’s lies. Trump had 88 million Twitter followers before Twitter took him off its platform – just two days after the attack on the Capitol, which he provoked, in part, with his tweets. (Trump’s social media accounts were also suspended on Facebook, YouTube, Instagram, Snapchat, Twitch and TikTok
‘Now I’m ******’: Secret Service
agents outraged by White House spin over
First Dog bites
33 replies
Posted by Ribicon 4/13/2022 7:31:54 PM Post Reply
Secret Service agents were outraged last year by the White House’s attempt to downplay bite injuries caused by then-first dog Major—even trying to get President Biden to personally pay for a coat destroyed by then-first dog Major Biden, newly released documents show. Secret Service leaders also sought to keep attack details out of official paperwork—at one point rejecting an agent’s “excessively detailed” account to avoid upsetting the first family—after Major bit agents on eight consecutive days.(Snip)The March 8 bite actually was the final attack in an eight-day streak and the wounded agent—whose injuries were categorized as “severe” by a colleague—fumed
Two inmates at all-women's New Jersey
prison are PREGNANT after both had sex
with the same transgender inmate after
local ACLU chapter won battle to house
trans inmates in women's prisons
32 replies
Posted by Ribicon 4/13/2022 7:44:56 PM Post Reply
Two women at New Jersey's only all-women's prison have both fallen pregnant after having sex with a transgender inmate. The pregnant women, who were not identified, are housed at the embattled Edna Mahan Correctional Facility, in Clinton, which New Jersey Governor announced plans to close last year.(Snip)It is unclear if the women had sex with the same transgender inmate, or if it was two different inmates. Edna Mahan houses 27 transgender prisoners, and over 800 women altogether. It is also unclear how far along the two inmates are, and whether they plan to continue with their respective pregnancies. An investigation has been launched.
INCREDIBLE EXCLUSIVE VIDEO: Capitol Police
ALLOW Protesters to Enter Side Door –
WILL BE USED IN COURT – “Dream Team”
of Lawyers Including Alan Dershowitz Set
to Defend January 6’ers
32 replies
Posted by ladydawgfan 4/13/2022 12:47:12 AM Post Reply
New professionally edited video has emerged of police officers allowing protesters into the Upper West Terrace Doors of the United States Capitol on January 6th, 2021. A trusted source exclusively released the video below to The Gateway Pundit. Tightly edited with markers and commentary narration, it is meant to be presented in court to defend Brady Knowlton and Patrick Montgomery. Both men are facing felony charges for “Obstruction of an Official Proceeding” on January 6th. This new video will indisputably exonerate Brady Knowlton, Patrick Montgomery and all the rally-goers seen entering these doors by any reasonable jury or fair judge. See video of Capitol Police Officers letting Trump Supporters in The Capitol:
Woman arrested after umpire is punched
at 12-year-old softball game in Laurel
31 replies
Posted by Ribicon 4/13/2022 1:40:48 PM Post Reply
Laurel, Miss.—An umpire is recovering Monday after she was punched in the face following a softball game. Moments after that confrontation, a Laurel mother was arrested and charged with simple assault. Saturday night. Kristie Moore says she was filling in, calling a 12-year-old softball game after one of her umpires got sick. She’s been calling games for 10 years. One of the moms was allegedly cursing so badly during the game that she was asked her to leave. Eventually the coach made the mom leave, but instead of going home, Kiara Thomas allegedly waited for Moore after the game.(Snip) Moore says parents are out of control
Unapologetic Tony Dungy Smokes Out Obama’s
Betrayal of Black America
30 replies
Posted by Magnante 4/14/2022 3:48:02 AM Post Reply
Tony Dungy, the first black coach ever to win a Super Bowl, might have escaped notice this week had he merely supported Florida Governor Ron DeSantis’s “Responsible Fatherhood Initiative.” His real sin was to explain why. Dungy, a Christian father or eleven, recounted a conversation he had years back with the Rev. Abe Brown about Brown’s prison ministry. At Brown’s request, Dungy accompanied him to prison. Expecting to find hardened criminals, Dungy found instead “19- and 20- and 21-year-old kids who looked like my boys.” When Dungy asked what accounted for the young men’s incarceration, Brown told him, “(snip) Ninety-five percent of these boys did not grow up with their dad.”
Zuckerbucks: Mark Zuckerberg says he won't
be so naked about it anymore
29 replies
Posted by PageTurner 4/13/2022 9:11:22 AM Post Reply
Mark Zuckerberg, whose $419 million "Zuckerbucks" vote-rigging operation played a significant part in swinging the election to Joe Biden in 2020, now says he's a changed man. A representative for Mark Zuckerberg confirmed the Facebook CEO will not make another multi-million dollar donation to aid this year’s elections, which comes after fierce pushback that Zuckerberg’s 2020 contributions tilted the outcome of the presidential race toward President Biden. "As Mark and Priscilla made clear previously, their election infrastructure donation to help ensure that Americans could vote during the height of the pandemic was a one-time donation given the unprecedented nature of the crisis," Ben LaBolt,
Awesome: Faith-Based Hollywood Star Breaks
From Leftist Ranks, Touts God And Family
27 replies
Posted by AmericaFirstAlways 4/13/2022 10:43:38 PM Post Reply
Actor Mark Wahlberg, who has a new film, “Father Stu,” set to come out very soon, has been thinking long and hard about what the future might hold for him. The actor, who has been busy promoting his new movie, stated that his new career goal is to take his faith and marry it with his films. “I feel like this is starting a new chapter for me in that, doing things like this – real substance – can help people,” the 50-year-old went on to say during an interview on Entertainment Tonight. “I definitely want to focus on making more,” he continued.
White House explanation for mystery substance
that landed on Biden raises A LOT of eyebrows
26 replies
Posted by Imright 4/13/2022 10:49:25 PM Post Reply
President Joe Biden’s latest speech, it appears, was one for the birds. At least it seemed that way, as the somewhat hapless commander-in-chief gave what was meant to be a rousing speech and pep rally in Iowa on Tuesday. It was difficult to miss what appeared to be the projectile of avian fecal matter that scored a direct hit on the president’s left lapel. Although, after much mockery, the White House has given clarification on the supposed flying mystery substance that many aren’t buying.
Post New Article