Post New Article

Letter sent months before deadly Florida
collapse warned damage to condo building
was accelerating

Original Article

Posted By: earlybird, 6/29/2021 2:19:54 PM

A correspondence from the board president of Champlain Towers South, part of which unexpectedly crashed to the ground last week in Surfside, Florida, describes the decay at the building since 2018 saying, "the observable damage such as in the garage has gotten significantly worse since the initial inspection." Board President Jean Wodnicki addressed the letter to neighbors April 9."The concrete deterioration is accelerating. The roof situation got much worse, so extensive roof repairs had to be incorporated," says the letter, (snip) "When you can visually see the concrete spalling (cracking), that means that the rebar holding it together is rusting and deteriorating beneath the surface."

Comments:

This article uses the term “neighbors”. The correct term would have been “owners”. This was an official board notice of the building’s problems. According to one 20 year owner, who survived, he didn’t totally understand it because he “doesn’t know about rebar and such”, but he did mention that each owner was to be assessed a substantial amount of money (I don’t recall the exact amount) which was to be paid at $800/month for a number of years. “Like another mortgage,” he said.

Post Reply

Reply 1 - Posted by: Zeek Wolfe 6/29/2021 2:35:15 PM (No. 830541)
I'm a little confused. Concrete decay? The concrete used in the Golden Gate bridge and the Hoover dam was formulated to last over 300 years. The Colosseum and Pantheon in Rome were built using concrete two thousand years ago. Both are considered structurally sound. Yet they built this condominium building in the 1980s made of concrete, rebar and modern specs only to see it collapse and kill over 100 people. Am I missing something here?
15 people like this.

Reply 2 - Posted by: earlybird 6/29/2021 2:38:57 PM (No. 830545)
Additional OP comment: The assessment amounts are in the post just published above this one. The $800/month figure in OP comment was for this particular owner, who said it would be paid over 15 years. The assessments and payment amounts varied based upon the size of the respective units.
1 person likes this.

Reply 3 - Posted by: earlybird 6/29/2021 2:54:43 PM (No. 830559)
For #1: https://www.cement.org/docs/default-source/fc_concrete_technology/durability/is536-types-and-causes-of-concrete-deterioration.pdf?sfvrsn=4
1 person likes this.

Reply 4 - Posted by: Halfvast Conspirator 6/29/2021 2:55:44 PM (No. 830561)
So the problem is on the condo owners themselves, who failed to act on the matter. Trial attorneys are going to have a tough time suing them all, but I bet they will try based on the dead people (who were also owners I suppose, unless some were renters and could have a claim against a condo owner). The aftermath will be interesting.
2 people like this.

Reply 5 - Posted by: DVC 6/29/2021 3:06:54 PM (No. 830576)
One of the photos shows, at the upper corner, a structural concrete beam which is severely spalled, with corroded rebar visible. This rebar would normally be an inch or two below the concrete surface, but the corrosion has cracked the concrete so severely that chunks have fallen off, exposing the bare steel bars to a more corrosive environment. The pool chemicals are extremely corrosive to steel. If I was designing that pool area, I'd want a double coat of epoxy paint over all the structural concrete to keep the pool chemicals from reaching the rebar. And that protective paint would need to be regularly renewed. This portion of the pool deck didn't come down, but it gives an idea of what the condition of the concrete structure was there, and MAY have been similar elsewhere. The article implies that spalling and cracking are the same thing. This is very much NOT the case. A crack is just that, a crack. Spalling is actual chunks of the surface popped off and gone, almost always due to subsurface cracking which has forced the missing piece away from the main part of the item. And it is important to understand that a lot of concrete structures have a cosmetic layer of stucco. Cracks in the stucco layer may be because of structural cracks in the concrete underneath, but stucco cracking and spalling (confined only in the stucco) can be entirely cosmetic if the concrete is OK underneath. This is why reports of "cracks" is very imprecise, and even "spalling" can be unclear, too. Cracks and spalling in a stucco layer are cosmetic. Cracks and spalling in main structural beams can be seriously compromising strength of beams. I can tell you that the concrete beam in the top of the left photo is in bad shape and that is serious, not cosmetic.
7 people like this.

Reply 6 - Posted by: DVC 6/29/2021 3:11:11 PM (No. 830580)
Re: the comment on Roman concrete.....KEY point, they used unreinforced concrete, which can last virtually forever. The Pantheon is a perfect example. We use REINFORCED concrete which can do things that unreinforced concrete can never do. This requires reinforcing bars inside. Unless these are a corrosion proof material, the structure will last until the bars corrode and pop apart the concrete. Some engineers are studying at fiberglass reinforcing bars in concrete to resist corrosion. If you REALLY want a durable structure, use titanium reinforcing bars. Titanium is usually used in aerospace for lightness, which is hopeless in heavy concrete structures, but titanium is also nearly corrosion proof. It would be VERY expensive, but VERY durable, too.
4 people like this.

Reply 7 - Posted by: mc squared 6/29/2021 4:07:34 PM (No. 830636)
Is 'unexpectedly' the proper term? Maybe anticipated. That of, course changes things legally.
2 people like this.

Reply 8 - Posted by: john56 6/29/2021 5:05:34 PM (No. 830670)
Remember, we're also dealing with the forces of nature -- sandy, shifting, water from the barrier island where the building was constructed. Yeah, in hindsight, they should have dealt with this at the time. But then again, how many high-rise towers, even in beach front communities, fall down (excluding, of course, damage ala 9-11, terrorism, war, or natural disasters)?
5 people like this.

Below, you will find ...
Most Recent Articles posted by "earlybird"
and
Most Active Articles (last 48 hours)
Most Recent Articles posted by earlybird"
Ashli Babbit’s Killer is a Dangerous Incompetent 19 replies
Posted by earlybird 7/1/2021 5:20:27 PM Post Reply
(Photos)A picture is worth a thousand words. So these two pictures tell you two thousand words worth of Ashley Babbit’s. He is demonstrably incompetent.There are four critical rules for handling any firearm, especially a pistol: (snip)The lack of training discipline this man exhibits is alarming. And the results of this incompetence was the murder of Ashli Babbit. If a cop on the street in any city in America handled a pistol like this he or she would have their gun taken away and be sent back to training. Making matters worse–he took an innocent life.
Kamala Harris Is The Case Against
Affirmative Action
15 replies
Posted by earlybird 7/1/2021 5:09:36 PM Post Reply
If there was ever a case against affirmative action, it would be the sitting vice president. All of the things opponents of race quotas say — that they inspire mediocrity, lead to lower standards, and set unqualified people up for failure — are precisely what we’re seeing in the shockingly poor job performance of Kamala Harris. President Biden has admitted he chose her as his running mate, first and foremost, because she is a woman. “I’ll pick a woman to be vice president,”(snip). And black Democrat leaders, during last year’s threatening race riots, demanded his choice also be black. Qualifications for the actual White House weren’t really part of the equation.
Cosby ruling an example where prosecutors
can undermine their own case, court was
‘clearly correct'
10 replies
Posted by earlybird 7/1/2021 4:46:07 PM Post Reply
George Washington University law professor and Fox News contributor Jonathan Turley joined criminal defense attorney Donna Rotunno on "The Story" Tuesday to react to the Pennsylvania Supreme Court overturning the sex assault conviction of Bill Cosby.(snip)JONATHAN TURLEY: I think the court was clearly correct. This was a trial that became entirely untethered from basic principles of due process. This is part of the corrosive effect of high-profile trials. The prosecutors, the judge, discarded basic guarantees of a defendant. Here, an earlier prosecutor determined that he did not have evidence to try [Bill] Cosby on these charges. So he agreed he would not do so if Cosby agreed to participate in
ICE Agents, Sheriffs Sue Biden Over
‘Unlawful’ Deportation Policy
4 replies
Posted by earlybird 7/1/2021 4:19:45 PM Post Reply
GALVESTON, Texas—A group of sheriffs and active Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE) officers sued the Biden administration on July 1 for its “unlawful and unconstitutional” requirements regarding the arrest and deportation of illegal aliens. The plaintiffs are seeking an injunction to a Feb. 18 memorandum that they say “commands ICE officers to violate the specific terms of federal immigration law.” “The relief we are seeking is that the court order ICE and the Department of Homeland Security to simply follow the law,” lead attorney Kris Kobach said in Galveston after filing the suit(Snip)“To follow the specific laws … that require them to detain and deport certain illegal aliens.”
New York’s Mayoral Primary Vote Count
Voided After 135,000 Ballot Discrepancy
17 replies
Posted by earlybird 7/1/2021 1:34:51 PM Post Reply
The New York City Board of Elections said on June 29 that 135,000 test ballots were accidentally included in a preliminary tally of votes cast in the city’s mayoral primary election, leading to the count being voided and drawing the ire of candidates. New York’s first attempt at ranked-choice voting (RCV) descended into confusion after the elections board abruptly removed updated vote totals from its website hours after posting them, citing a “discrepancy” in the numbers.“We are aware there is a discrepancy in the unofficial RCV round by round elimination report,”
Arizona Ballot-Harvesting Ban Is Legal,
Supreme Court Rules in High-Stakes
Electoral Integrity Case
11 replies
Posted by earlybird 7/1/2021 11:51:06 AM Post Reply
Arizona’s ban on ballot-harvesting and out-of-precinct voting does not violate the federal Voting Rights Act, the Supreme Court ruled 6-3 this morning in a closely watched case with implications for future elections. The court opinion split neatly along ideological and partisan lines with the 6 conservative justices nominated by Republican presidents voting to uphold the state law and the 3 liberal justices voting to strike it down. The decision reverses a judgment issued by the 9th Circuit Court of Appeals and comes the week after the Biden administration filed a lawsuit against Georgia over the state’s new electoral integrity-promoting law claiming it amounts to so-called voter suppression.
Pennsylvania Democrats to Propose Bullet
Tax and Encoded Rounds to Track Ammo
Owners
20 replies
Posted by earlybird 6/30/2021 7:25:43 PM Post Reply
A 5 cent per bullet tax will be proposed in Pennsylvania as part of legislation to be brought forth by two state House Democrats, Rep. Manny Guzman and Rep. Stephen Kinsey. The tax would fund a state police database of ammunition sold in Pennsylvania. The planned legislation would require ammunition manufacturers to encode ammunition provided for retail sale in Pennsylvania, and to provide ammunition serial numbers to the Pennsylvania State Police for the ammunition database. The plan was revealed in a joint memo to the state legislature by Guzman and Kinsey.
Pennsylvania Gov. Vetoes GOP-Backed
Election Integrity Bill
11 replies
Posted by earlybird 6/30/2021 7:22:58 PM Post Reply
Pennsylvania Gov. Tom Wolf vetoed a Republican-backed election overhaul bill that would expand voter identification requirements, move up the voter registration deadline, limit the use of drop-boxes, and allow county officials to conduct early pre-canvassing for mail-in ballots, among other measures. In explaining why he vetoed the bill, the Democrat governor wrote that he “made it clear I wouldn’t sign a bill that creates barriers to voting,” adding “that’s exactly what this bill does by: Limiting mail ballots, (Snip) On Wednesday, Wolf also used his line-item veto authority to remove a budget legislation proposal that would earmark millions of dollars to create an election-auditing agency.
Rep. Lauren Boebert Can Block People
on Personal Twitter Account, Judge Rules
4 replies
Posted by earlybird 6/30/2021 6:49:19 PM Post Reply
A federal judge has sided with Rep. Lauren Boebert (R-Colo.) in a First Amendment lawsuit, allowing the first-time Congresswoman to continue blocking a critic on her personal Twitter account. Boebert, a vocal supporter of former President Donald Trump, blocked former state Rep. Brianna Buentello, a Democrat, after Buentello criticized Boebert’s remarks in the days leading up to the Jan. 6 breach of the U.S. Capitol, calling her a “seditionist” and demanding that she resign. Buentello sued on the basis of First Amendment rights, arguing that Boebert’s Twitter block was not an act of a private individual, but an act on behalf of the state, because Boebert uses her personal Twitter account
Wisconsin Supreme Court Rejects Lawsuit
to Ban Absentee Ballot Drop Boxes
8 replies
Posted by earlybird 6/30/2021 4:06:18 PM Post Reply
The Wisconsin Supreme Court recently rejected a lawsuit that sought to ban the state’s usage of absentee ballot drop-boxes, although another legal challenge on their use is still being considered in a lower court. Conservative businessman and GOP donor Jere Fabick in March petitioned (pdf) the state Supreme Court in March to consider a ban of the drop-boxes, arguing that they violate state election laws. He also sought to ban election officials from filling in missing addresses of witnesses on ballot envelopes, and his suit attempted to limit who can return absentee ballots to election clerks.
Donald Rumsfeld, former defense secretary
at helm of 2 wars, dead at 88
22 replies
Posted by earlybird 6/30/2021 3:41:23 PM Post Reply
Donald Rumsfeld, who charted an impressive Washington career serving under four presidents but whose legacy largely was defined by his controversial tenure as defense secretary during the Iraq war, has died, his family announced Wednesday. He was 88. Rumsfeld, a confident adviser to power with a trenchant style that made him admirers as well as enemies, had a long and winding career in public life that spanned five decades. He had been a congressman and a White House chief of staff, and had a successful corporate career, too. But it was his second term as secretary of Defense from 2001 to 2006 – during the most tumultuous period of the
Tucker Carlson Outlines the Biden
Administration Logistic Program to Facilitate
the Southern Border Invasion
4 replies
Posted by earlybird 6/30/2021 3:31:21 PM Post Reply
Beyond the insanity of the U.S. southern border being unsecured, many people wonder how this entire logistical process is funded. The answer is quite simple; within every federal spending and appropriation bill there are carve-outs for various segments of the process. The Department of Homeland Security and Department of Health and Human Services receive hundreds of billions in supplemental appropriation funding from within each federal spending package. Each of the COVID relief bills contained money to facilitate various elements of this process. Federal housing grants, food assistance programs, education funding, employment and income assistance, all of it, every single spending package, contains funding mechanisms to support the
Most Active Articles (last 48 hours)
Rosanna Arquette: I Will Kneel in Protest
of National Anthem, U.S. Flag ‘For the
Rest of My Life’
64 replies
Posted by OhioNick 7/1/2021 12:38:44 AM Post Reply
Left-wing Hollywood star Rosanna Arquette has declared she will take a knee in protest of the national anthem and U.S. flag “for the rest of my life.” Her comment comes just days after athlete Gwen Berry turned her back as “The Star-Spangled Banner” played during the U.S. Olympic track and field trials. Arquette is the latest celebrity figure to denigrate the American flag after pop star Macy Gray called for the flag to be replaced because it represents “divisiveness and hate.”
Roman Catholic church frequented by
Biden will let anyone receive Communion
amid abortion controversy
60 replies
Posted by OhioNick 7/1/2021 12:35:35 AM Post Reply
A Washington, D.C., church frequented by President Biden says it won't get involved in what it describes as "a political issue" over Communion. The Holy Trinity Catholic Church in the city's Georgetown neighborhood, which Biden has attended several times since taking office, said Wednesday it will not deny the Eucharist to the president over his abortion stance or "anyone else who presents themselves." "The great gift of the Holy Eucharist is too sacred to be made a political issue," the church’s parish council said.
Jill Biden Tells Vogue People Can
‘Breathe Again’ with Trump Out of
Office: Joe ‘Healed This Nation’
53 replies
Posted by OhioNick 7/1/2021 2:24:28 PM Post Reply
First Lady Jill Biden — who is featured on the August cover of Vogue after the fashion magazine broke a decades-long tradition by snubbing former First Lady Melania Trump during her four years in the White House — says people can “breathe again,” now that former President Donald Trump is out of office. Mrs. Biden said President Joe Biden came in and “heal[ed] this nation.” “During the campaign, I felt so much anxiety from people — they were scared,” Jill Biden told Vogue. “When I travel around the country now, I feel as though people can breathe again.” “I think that’s part of the reason Joe was elected,” the first lady added.
Joe Biden Suggests Global Warming and
Rising Sea Levels May Have Contributed
to Florida Condo Collapse (Video)
45 replies
Posted by Imright 7/1/2021 6:46:18 PM Post Reply
Joe Biden traveled to Surfside, Florida on Thursday to deliver remarks on the collapsed condo.Last Thursday morning a portion of the Champlain Towers South condo building in Surfside, Florida collapsed. The death toll rose to 18 on Thursday with 145 people unaccounted for. A reporter asked Biden what he learned about the collapsed condo in his meeting with Governor DeSantis and investigators.Biden immediately suggested global warming, storms and rising sea levels may have contributed to the collapse.Shameless.
San Jose plans to be first U.S. city
requiring firearms owners to pay back
taxpayers for gun violence
38 replies
Posted by konocti95 7/1/2021 12:28:27 PM Post Reply
A month after a gunman killed nine workers at a rail yard in San Jose, the city is taking steps to become the first in the nation to require firearms owners to buy insurance and pay fees to relieve taxpayers of the costs of responding to gun violence. The San Jose City Council voted unanimously Tuesday night to draft an ordinance that would order gun owners in the city to obtain insurance and pay an annual fee to subsidize police responses, ambulances, medical treatment and other municipal expenses related to shootings, injuries and deaths. The amount of the fee hasn’t been determined, but Mayor Sam Liccardo said
Biden mentions ‘good’ side of Florida
condo collapse during site visit
32 replies
Posted by Imright 7/1/2021 1:39:35 PM Post Reply
President Biden struck an odd tone near the site of the Florida building collapse Thursday as he talked about finding a “good” side to the disaster that left at least 18 dead and nearly 150 missing.“You know what’s good about this?” Biden said at a briefing with local leaders. “It lets the nation know we can cooperate and when it’s really important.” Biden added, “I just got back from 12 days in Europe. You wonder whether we can do this. And you’re doing it. I mean, just the simple act of everybody doing whatever needs to be done.”
Report: Kamala Harris is an awful boss 32 replies
Posted by Magnante 7/1/2021 5:19:56 AM Post Reply
Vice President Mike Pence may be in the doghouse with conservatives but no one can say there were stories that he was a bad boss or that his office was chaotic, mismanaged, or incompetent. Things are different with Kamala Harris. According to an article in Politico, Harris’s office sounds like the real-life version of Veep, the HBO political satire that focused on the stupid, self-centered, and vicious Selina Meyer, a Vice President whose office was filled with slavish gatekeepers and self-centered staff, all of whom were incompetent. The story rings true. What's more interesting is contemplating why Democrats are going after Harris.
Are We Nazi Germany? 31 replies
Posted by Magnante 7/1/2021 3:47:49 AM Post Reply
I've noticed that whenever the subject of Nazi Germany is raised, someone always says something like this: "It's unbelievable that Adolf Hitler was able to manipulate and control the entire German population. It just seems impossible." (snip) Like a lot of Americans, I always assumed that America was safe from the kind of tyranny the German people experienced under the heavy hand of the Third Reich. (snip) Yet, for the past eighteen months, that's exactly what has happened in America. A nation that always prided itself on its independence and individuality was suddenly locked down.
Nancy Pelosi says Liz Cheney will be the
lone Republican on January 6 committee
30 replies
Posted by Imright 7/1/2021 1:49:55 PM Post Reply
House Speaker Nancy Pelosi on Thursday said Rep. Liz Cheney of Wyoming will be the sole Republican on the House's select committee to investigate the fatal January 6 insurrection on the US Capitol. "We're very honored and proud that she has agreed to serve on the committee," Pelosi said of Cheney.Cheney has in many ways been ostracized by her own party for refusing to echo former President Donald Trump's lies about the 2020 election. In May, Republicans ousted Cheney from her leadership post as conference chair. The Wyoming lawmaker stands among the small group Republicans willing to openly criticize Trump.
Kamala Harris’s ‘abusive’ office: VP rocked
by claims staffers are 'treated like sh**' and
that chief of staff Tina Flournoy has created
a 'blame culture' - despite Biden's threat to
FIRE anyone treating colleagues poorly
30 replies
Posted by Imright 7/1/2021 4:47:24 AM Post Reply
The office of Vice President Kamala Harris has been rocked by claims that staffers are 'treated like sh**' and that Chief of Staff Tina Flournoy has created 'blame culture.' Tensions started to boil over after Harris finally decided to visit the border last week, blindsiding staffers, according to a Politico report based on interviews with 22 current and former vice presidential aides, officials and associates. Sources described a tense atmosphere with low morale and trust, as well as bad communication, according to the outlet.Flournoy has allegedly created an environment
Target store closings show limits
of pledge to Black communities
29 replies
Posted by Ribicon 7/1/2021 12:14:05 PM Post Reply
Baltimore—When Target announced that it was opening a store in Mondawmin, a predominantly Black neighborhood in Baltimore, a city struggling with crime and poverty, it seemed like a ticket to a turnaround. And from the start, it was a practical success and a point of community pride. The store, which opened in 2008, carried groceries, operated a pharmacy and had a Starbucks cafe—the only one in this part of Baltimore's west side.(Snip) But in February 2018, with almost no warning or explanation, Target closed the store. Residents, especially those without cars, lost a convenient place to shop for quality goods.
Seven Reasons to Be Extremely Optimistic
About the Economy Right Now
27 replies
Posted by rememberwhen 7/1/2021 3:13:13 PM Post Reply
The U.S. economy is in the middle of an awkward transition. Like a groggy bear roused from hibernation, the country is no longer dormant due to the pandemic but isn’t quite back in full form either. Millions remain unemployed, businesses are having trouble hiring, workers are still avoiding the office, and shortages of everything from lumber to computer chips have helped push up consumer prices.  CORRECTION*
Post New Article