Post New Article

Stanford professor who changed America
with just one study was also a liar

Original Article

Posted By: GO3, 11/11/2019 8:44:11 PM

Stanford psychology and law professor David Rosenhan could transfix an audience in a crowded lecture hall with just a few words. [snip] “What are we here for? Some things will be black … Others will be white. But be prepared for shades of gray.” Rosenhan would know. His own life, as I would later find out, was filled with shades of gray. His findings helped expedite the widespread closure of psychiatric institutions across the country, changing mental health care in the US forever. And, as I eventually uncovered, he was also not what he appeared to be.

Comments:

[Article updated to 11 Nov. 2019] The author tries to track down pseudo-patients who went undercover under the guidance of psychologist and Stanford professor David Rosenhan to document poor conditions and abuses in mental health institutions. Based on this one flawed study in 1973, we now live with the legacy of needlessly closing down mental institutions and cutting these people lose. According to the author we have about 100,000 mental patients who currently live on the streets.

Post Reply

Reply 1 - Posted by: Rumblehog 11/11/2019 9:46:37 PM (No. 232618)
Medicine wouldn't have shut down the mental institutions had they not wanted to do so. This one liar's work was insufficient to shutter all those facilities. The American Psychiatric Association must also have been inclined to shut them down, based no doubt on such faux-films as, "One Flew Over the Cuckoo's Nest" and others. One thing's for certain however, which is that many, many people have suffered needlessly, and even died, as the result of closing the very institutions there to help them. Truly a sad thing and hopefully, this lying piece of excrement received the punishment he deserved for his lies.
7 people like this.

Reply 2 - Posted by: heartlandconservative 11/11/2019 10:04:55 PM (No. 232631)
Phyco babble kills, we need comprehensive phyco babble control.
9 people like this.

Reply 3 - Posted by: earlybird 11/11/2019 10:25:00 PM (No. 232637)
I read an awful lot of opinion stated as fact. If she is going to write a treatise like this, she needs to have footnotes to her sources. Is it really an overlong teaser for her book?
1 person likes this.

Reply 4 - Posted by: bdog 11/11/2019 10:52:29 PM (No. 232649)
Ronald Regan, as Governor, closed a couple of mental institutions ans was immediately blamed for the mental health problems in CA. The ACLU sued to have 72 hour commitments ended in CA which was the real cause of the problem
7 people like this.

Reply 5 - Posted by: Vesicant 11/11/2019 10:53:38 PM (No. 232651)
I'd say psychiatry was on a level with witch doctors, but I don't see any reason to insult witch doctors. Everything about psychiatry is pseudo.
7 people like this.

Reply 6 - Posted by: ColonialAmerican1623 11/12/2019 1:44:48 AM (No. 232681)
Some institutions in the 1950's were barbaric and certainly archaic buildings. EST was par for the course and ruined many a woman's life because they didn't know how to treat postpartum depression. That being said, something has to be done to get mentally ill people off the streets.
4 people like this.

Reply 7 - Posted by: Timber Queen 11/12/2019 2:10:44 AM (No. 232688)
The Cloward-Priven strategy was introduced in 1966. This hot little number of a "study" was 1973. Since I first learned of the diabolic C-P philosophy (thank you Glenn Beck), public policies that made no rational sense have become understandable. They hate us. President Trump is just in the way. MAGA - Pray. Pray hard.
5 people like this.

Reply 8 - Posted by: Trigger2 11/12/2019 3:44:35 AM (No. 232696)
Rosenhan's study was a good reason for states to save money by closing psychiatric institutions so they could take that "savings" and waste it somewhere else.
7 people like this.

Reply 9 - Posted by: DCGIRL 11/12/2019 5:53:14 AM (No. 232721)
I'm with #8. Now that the mental institutions are closed, the mentally ill are living on sidewalks, underpasses, etc.
6 people like this.

Reply 10 - Posted by: Blue-Z-Anna 11/12/2019 6:57:02 AM (No. 232753)
The Left prefers imaginary problems and avoids real ones. Mental illness is sad and shocking and very real. The advent of new and improved drugs tempted government and doctors to close the nut farms.
4 people like this.

Below, you will find ...
Most Recent Articles posted by "GO3"
and
Most Active Articles (last 48 hours)
Most Recent Articles posted by GO3"
UIL pushes start of Texas
high school football season
back to end of September
3 replies
Posted by GO3 7/22/2020 3:51:56 PM Post Reply
AUSTIN, Texas — The University Interscholastic League has pushed the first games of the Texas high school football season for its biggest districts to the end of September due to the coronavirus. The modifications to the 2020-2021 UIL calendar and updated COVID-19 risk mitigation guidelines are set to take effect August 1st. UIL's updated plan provides a delay for schools in highly-populated metro areas, primarily conferences 5A-6A, given the challenges with COVID-19 those communities are facing. (snip) Meanwhile, smaller school districts that are 1A-4A have an opportunity to start seasons on schedule.
Abilene police release plan
for enforcing Gov. Abbott's
mandatory mask order
5 replies
Posted by GO3 7/4/2020 8:21:16 PM Post Reply
ABILENE, Texas — The Abilene Police Department released its plan for enforcing Governor Greg Abbott's mandatory mask order. "In an effort to be transparent and supportive of our citizens, the City Manager and I are releasing my enforcement protocols," said Chief Stan Standridge. "It is very important to note that the Governor’s Executive Order does not authorize detention for mask violations. This makes enforcement difficult at best, so we need our citizens to voluntarily comply." According to the order signed Thursday, masks are mandatory in any county with 20 or more active cases of COVID-19.
Hardin-Simmons University
investigating student's 'deeply
disappointing' social media post
14 replies
Posted by GO3 6/25/2020 10:16:03 AM Post Reply

ABILENE, Texas — Hardin-Simmons University is investigating a social media post by a student that it called "deeply disappointing and unacceptable." The post on Tik Tok shows a girl wearing a Hardin-Simmons shirt. HSU acknowledged she is a student. In the video, she reveals how she thinks people react when a black person kills another black person or a black person kills a white person versus when a white person kills a black person. University officials tweeted a a statement Tuesday evening that said “the message shared by this student is not reflective of the Christian values of our institution.”    Correction*

Revealed: How rogue Iran
airline spread coronavirus
through Middle East
6 replies
Posted by GO3 5/6/2020 7:09:32 AM Post Reply
LONDON: An Iranian airline under US sanctions flew passengers infected with the coronavirus to Iraq and Lebanon and between Iran and China, fueling the spread of the virus across the Middle East. Mahan Air, a private company linked to the Islamic Revolutionary Guard Corps (IRGC), continued flying to China and elsewhere for weeks after Tehran officially barred flights to and from the country on Jan. 31. The airline lied about these flights taking place, according to an investigation by the BBC. (snip) Planes that went to Tehran from China also made onward travel within 24 hours to Barcelona, Dubai, Kuala Lumpur and Istanbul.
Iran Guards commander
promotes fake anti-bomb
device as virus detector
5 replies
Posted by GO3 4/17/2020 7:31:21 PM Post Reply
IRAN: The commander of Iran’s Islamic Revolutionary Guard Corps (IRGC) has been promoting what appears to be a notorious fake bomb-detecting device as a coronavirus detector. Maj. Gen. Hossein Salami, who replaced Qassem Soleimani as head of Iran’s asymmetric warfare unit after his assassination by a US drone in Iraq in January, presented the device on state TV on Wednesday, claiming that it could detect COVID-19 “within seconds.” The model shown is almost identical in appearance to the famously useless plastic and metal fake bomb-detecting device that was first sold by convicted British fraudster James McCormick to Iraqi security forces.
City of Abilene to enforce
shelter-in-place more aggressively
this week
13 replies
Posted by GO3 4/7/2020 1:24:21 PM Post Reply
ABILENE, Texas — The City of Abilene will begin enforcing the limited shelter-in-place more aggressively this week. City Manager Robert Hanna said if non-essential businesses don't shut down, the City may have to pull their certificate of occupancy, which means they'd lose their power meter. "Please do what we're asking you to do," Hanna said. "We're not doing this because we want to hurt y'all. We're not doing this because we want to hurt the economy. We're doing this because it's a public emergency, and we need people to take it seriously." The City is also expecting revenue issues going forward.
School closures of 8 weeks
or more may better
mitigate coronavirus
spread, CDC says
9 replies
Posted by GO3 3/14/2020 3:47:43 PM Post Reply
Closing schools for eight weeks or more may have a greater impact on mitigating the spread of the novel coronavirus than two- to four-week closures, the US Centers for Disease Control and Prevention has said. Shorter-term closures will likely make little difference in the spread of the disease, new CDC guidance states, even as K-12 school districts across the country began announcing school closures within the shorter time frame. Further, short-term closures may actually have detrimental effects, negatively impacting older caregivers at home, the CDC said.
5 rockets hit near US embassy in
capital Baghdad: Report
9 replies
Posted by GO3 1/26/2020 1:25:41 PM Post Reply
Baghdad: A volley of rockets landed near the US embassy in the Iraqi capital Baghdad Sunday night, two security sources told AFP, in the latest unclaimed attack on American installations in the country. Five rockets hit near US embassy in Baghdad. AFP reporters heard loud thuds emanating from the western bank of the Tigris, where most foreign embassies are located. One security source said three Katyusha rockets hit near the high-security compound while another said as many as five struck the area. There was no immediate word on casualties.
You can’t touch this:
Pope Francis says sorry
for slapping devotee
43 replies
Posted by GO3 1/1/2020 11:44:46 AM Post Reply
VATICAN CITY: Pope Francis apologized Wednesday for his widely-viewed slap of a woman who had grabbed his hand as he greeted Catholic faithful on New Year’s Eve. The image of Francis slapping his way free from the clutches of the admirer was an instant hit on social media. A personal apology followed. “We lose patience many times,” Francis confessed. “It happens to me too. I apologize for the bad example given yesterday,” the head of the Catholic church said before celebrating Mass at the Vatican.
Stanford professor who changed America
with just one study was also a liar
10 replies
Posted by GO3 11/11/2019 8:44:11 PM Post Reply
Stanford psychology and law professor David Rosenhan could transfix an audience in a crowded lecture hall with just a few words. [snip] “What are we here for? Some things will be black … Others will be white. But be prepared for shades of gray.” Rosenhan would know. His own life, as I would later find out, was filled with shades of gray. His findings helped expedite the widespread closure of psychiatric institutions across the country, changing mental health care in the US forever. And, as I eventually uncovered, he was also not what he appeared to be.
Where's the pope?
Stuck in Vatican elevator until rescue
13 replies
Posted by GO3 9/1/2019 10:25:17 AM Post Reply
Where's the pope? He's stuck in a Vatican elevator. Thousands of people who were gathered in St. Peter's Square for the traditional Sunday on-the-dot-of-noon appearance by Pope Francis were watching for the window of the Apostolic Palace to be thrown open so they could listen to the pope's remarks and receive his blessing. But after seven minutes, people were looking at each other quizzically: no pope? Then Francis popped out and answered their question: "First of all I must excuse myself for being late. I was blocked in an elevator for 25 minutes."
How Qatar is molding
Americans’ opinion
in favor of extremism
2 replies
Posted by GO3 7/15/2019 10:02:33 AM Post Reply
CHICAGO: Qatar is investing billions of dollars in American universities, cash-hungry lobbyists in Washington, DC, journalists, mainstream activist groups and policy think tanks in an apparent drive to soften criticism of its activities that researchers focused on terrorism say fuels violent extremism. The researchers argue that these concerns should have led the discussion that President Donald Trump held with Qatar’s Emir Tamim bin Hamad Al-Thani on July 9 at the White House. Though in the past Trump has criticized Qatar over its support for terrorism, this meeting focused only on economic issues.
Most Active Articles (last 48 hours)
Biden's Incoherence Just Hit Critical Mass,
This Is Scary Awful
48 replies
Posted by Dreadnought 3/8/2021 11:45:49 PM Post Reply
As we reported two days ago, Joe Biden completely made no sense when he was trying to explain the Wuhan coronavirus relief bill. It was really bad and it explains why they’re afraid to have him deliver an address to Congress or do any kind of a real solo press conference, because at this point they have to be afraid this is all going to fall apart if he does anything live and this all becomes too obvious to the American people. But there’s only so long that they can hold this off. And it’s getting worse, as video today revealed. Biden was holding an event to announce the nomination
‘Huge Development’: Democrat Sen. Joe
Manchin Starts To Crack On Filibuster,
Signals Openness To Change
41 replies
Posted by Imright 3/8/2021 12:32:41 AM Post Reply
Democrat Senator Joe Manchin (WV) appears to have started to shift his views on the filibuster with remarks that he made on two news shows on Sunday morning.The shift from Manchin comes after he has repeatedly stated that he would not vote to end the filibuster, despite pressure from the far-Left. During the interviews on Sunday, Manchin repeatedly claimed that he was not open to ending the filibuster because he did not want to strip the minority party of their power in the Senate, but signaled that he was open to changing it.Fox News host Chris Wallace asked Manchin if he would consider “reforming the filibuster” if “Republicans
Evangelicals For Biden ‘Feel Used And Betrayed’
By Biden Fulfilling His Radical Abortion Promises
37 replies
Posted by Calvinesq 3/8/2021 10:37:51 AM Post Reply
In an open letter released Sunday, Pro-Life Evangelicals for Biden urged him to “honor his commitment” and include the Hyde Amendment in Democrats’ $1.9 trillion COVID-19 spending package, writing “we feel used and betrayed.” The letter states: We are very disappointed about the COVID-19 relief package’s exclusion of the Hyde Amendment, a longstanding bipartisan policy that prevents taxpayer funding for abortion. [snip] As pro-life leaders in the evangelical community, we publicly supported President Biden’s candidacy with the understanding that there would be engagement [with] us on the issue of abortion and particularly the Hyde Amendment
Meghan Markle reveals her true
self in Oprah interview
32 replies
Posted by Imright 3/8/2021 9:11:10 AM Post Reply
If you had any doubts that Meghan Markle is a manipulative piece of work, her bombshell Oprah interview Sunday night dumping on the British monarchy would set you straight. Prince Harry’s American wife accused his family of hateful racism against her baby, claimed they refused to protect her and drove her to the point of suicide.She made the incendiary and implausible charge that when she was pregnant with Archie, the royal family decreed that her unborn son would be denied the title of “prince” because her mixed race meant he might have dark skin.
Biden’s German Shepherds Shipped Back
to Delaware After ‘Biting Incident’
Involving White House Security
31 replies
Posted by Imright 3/8/2021 11:38:50 PM Post Reply
Joe and Jill Biden’s German Shepherds were shipped back to Delaware after a “biting incident” involving White House security, CNN reported.Major was adopted by Joe Biden and his handler wife Jill in 2018 from an animal shelter.Major and Champ moved into the White House in January and they’re already gone. The condition of the victim was not disclosed but it was serious enough to remove both dogs from the White House.CNN reported: The two German Shepherds belonging to President Joe Biden and first lady Jill Biden were returned to the Biden family home in Delaware last week
Pelosi’s HR1 bill a blatant power grab for Democrats 30 replies
Posted by FlyRight 3/8/2021 5:28:52 AM Post Reply
Nancy Pelosi’s top priority is to turn America into a one-party nation ruled by Democrats. Her bill HR 1 trashes the U.S. Constitution in an attempt to rig the system and make it virtually impossible to elect a Republican president or Congress again. It’s a power grab. The bill eviscerates state voting laws and forces all the states to conform to a set of rules that includes automatic voter registration. Anyone who goes to a DMV or applies for food stamps, Medicaid or other social services, or attends a public college will be automatically enrolled to vote. Noncitizens are obligated to identify themselves and opt out,
Biden seems to forget defense
secretary’s name, calls him
'the guy who runs that outfit'
29 replies
Posted by Ribicon 3/8/2021 8:37:17 PM Post Reply
President Biden on Monday seemed to forget Defense Secretary Lloyd Austin’s name at a White House event—calling the Pentagon chief “the guy who runs that outfit over there.” Biden was announcing the nomination of two female generals to lead US military combatant commands. “And I want to thank the sec—the, the, ah former general. I keep calling him general, but my, my—the guy who runs that outfit over there,” Biden said.(Snip) Earlier at the event, Biden mentioned the Defense Department leader by his name, “Secretary Austin,” while appearing to read from a teleprompter.
Oprah interview bombshells: Meghan claims
she was suicidal when she was five months
pregnant, Kate made HER cry and Royals
refused to make Archie a prince because
they were worried how 'dark' he would be
27 replies
Posted by Imright 3/8/2021 8:21:02 AM Post Reply
The Royal Family was left reeling this morning after Meghan Markle tearfully revealed that the stress of royal life made her suicidal when she was five months pregnant, claimed Archie was denied the title of prince because he is mixed-race and said Kate Middleton made her cry before she married Harry in a bombshell interview with Oprah Winfrey.The couple also chose to reveal that they are having a baby girl to the tens of millions of people watching the CBS show broadcast in the US before accusing the Royal Family of racism and revealing the deep rift 'Megxit' has caused with Prince Charles and Prince William.
Meghan Markle openly
accuses the Royals
of racism
26 replies
Posted by Magnante 3/8/2021 5:26:07 AM Post Reply
I’m probably second to none in my dislike for Meghan Markle. There’s something unattractive about a mature woman marrying into the British Royal family with one of the world’s most expensive weddings, hanging out with the Queen, living in insane luxury…and then whining non-stop about the horror of her life. There’s something even less appealing when that woman accuses the Royal family of race hatred. And the problem is that, when it comes to that left-wing diva, Meghan Markle, it’s hard to believe most of what she says. After weeks of hype, CBS finally televised Meghan Markle and Prince Harry’s interview with Oprah.
Watch: John Solomon Gives Stunning Update
in Durham’s ‘Russiagate’ Investigation
24 replies
Posted by Imright 3/8/2021 4:56:55 PM Post Reply
Without question, the vast majority of Americans who support former President Donald Trump were angry and frustrated throughout 2020 passed with barely a mention of then-U.S. Attorney John Durham’s criminal investigation into the FBI’s fraudulent “Russiagate” counterterrorism operation directed at his 2016 campaign.In the weeks before the November election, word got out that then-Attorney General William Barr wasn’t going to announce any indictments or even a report on Durham’s investigation because he did not want to influence the outcome.So far, in fact, the only indictment to come out of the Durham probe is that of former FBI lawyer Kevin Clinesmith, who essentially got a slap on the wrist
Democrats renew calls to remove
J. Edgar Hoover's name from FBI building
24 replies
Posted by Ribicon 3/8/2021 2:56:29 PM Post Reply
Rep. Steve Cohen vowed to renew the push to remove former FBI Director J. Edgar Hoover’s name from the bureau’s downtown Washington headquarters, according to an interview released Monday. Appearing on Yahoo! News’ Skullduggery podcast, the Tennessee Democrat said the effort is getting a fresh look after the release of a new movie highlighting the FBI’s secret program to discredit civil rights activists. The Washington Times in 2019 first reported Democrats’ bid to strip the longtime FBI director’s name from the bureau’s headquarters. Mr. Cohen said the impetus to revive the bid is the new movie, “Judas and the Black Messiah.” The movie details
Jill Biden, the Meghan Markle
in the WH, is egregiously
guilty of elder abuse
23 replies
Posted by Magnante 3/9/2021 4:40:38 AM Post Reply
“There must have been a moment, at the beginning, when we could have said –-no. But somehow we missed it.” Tom Stoppard The millions of Americans who were paying attention throughout the 2020 election campaign all became painfully aware of the fact that Joe Biden’s cognitive abilities were slipping and slipping fast. His wife, as the person closest to him, should have been the one to call the campaign quits in order to reduce stress on the man. Instead, apparently so anxious to become the First Lady by any means necessary, Mrs. Biden continued to push her failing husband’s campaign forward as if he were mentally qualified.
Post New Article