A federal judge on Tuesday refused to dismiss a case that could fatally cripple the Obamacare health insurance law. The Affordable Care Act forbids the federal government from enforcing the law in any state that opted out of setting up its own health care exchange, according to a group of small businesses whose lawsuit got a key hearing Monday in federal court. The Obama administration, according to their lawsuit, has ignored that language in the law, enforcing all of its provisions even in states where the federal government is operating the insurance marketplaces on the error-plagued Healthcare.gov website. Thirty-six states chose not to
Justices are filled with as much fear of the regime as our elected congress. If they have families, they will make their final decision carefully in order to keep them safe. Not one will have the courage of their convictions to go against the dark Won. Have faith, but keep in mind that the odds are not in favor of America. The deck is stacked.
Rubio is out there today trying to "defund" Obamacare while he, and every other Republican have simply ignored the IRS ruling that allow Federal operated exchanges to give subsidies even though the law clearly states that only state operated exchanges are eligible for the subsidies.
This clearly shows the cowardice and stupidity of the Repubs. I have been yelling about this since Roberts ruled a penalty a tax. I cannot imagine how the Supreme Court can get around the clear letter of the law, I´m sure they will find a way to delay it so long that itwill become a moot point.
Putting on my tinfoil hat. I smell a very big Lib Rat. U.S. District Judge Paul Friedman was a Clinton appointee. Could this be a set up, he strikes down the law and then they somehow push the meme that Conservatives destroyed the law.
I was wondering what happened to this approach. Since I had heard nothing about it for many months I just assumed a liberal judge had thrown out the case. Interesting that even now we only get an update from a foreign news source. Our gutless republicans should have been fighting Zippycare on all fronts, including this one.
Perhaps #8 is right. Now that the health control law is failing spectacularly and dragging the statists down with it, having it stopped this way would stop their slide down the bowl and they would forevermore claim that Zippycare would have been a great success if evil conservatives hadn´t gotten it ruled unconstitutional. I gladly pay that price though to avoid the nation wrecking disaster that is zippycare
They will absolutely blame Republicans if this law is stopped. So what? That is what we have been demanding that they do. I don´t care how they do it. The Republicans in Congress have obviously given up so let the lawyers give it a whirl.
If an injunction is issued so be it. It would be a great day to see the liberal´s favorite branch of government bite them in the *ss. Still, hanging hope on this feels a bit like looking for a pony or a bb gun after all the Christmas presents have been opened. I´m not holding my breath.
Once again, the Brits sending over the real deal. Even the Daily Mail, albeit a progressive rag, now doing its job. Indeed, if this one makes its way to the Supremes, that Roberts wakes up this time instead of going along to get along. None of this Stockholm Syndrome stuff next time, Judge Roberts. You to, pubbies.
The poison pill as been in the open all along, if you know the Constitution. This is a revenue (tax) bill that originated in the Senate and the Constitution requires ALL revenue bills to originate in the House. It´s called the Origination Clause.
I don´t understand why all of the "Constitutional Scholars" out there don´t seem to know this.
Suppose they dropped the ACA tomorrow...claimed it a failure or unconstitutional. THEN what? The Ins. companies have already retooled their policies, sent their "we´re sorry" letters, etc. All those folks cancelled would be in total limbo, still needing to get a policy, but now all the private policies COST more. We are screwed either way!!!
Every time a new way to stop this abomination pops up, I get my hopes up only to be disappointed when it comes to naught. Frankly, I doubt this will be any different but I can´t help myself, I hope it will be. I just can´t fathom this great country being brought down by these clowns.
Well maybe the Clinton appointed judge is going to do the Clintons a favor as the Arkansas duet don´t really like Obama? If it goes to the Supremes, that will be a home game for the democrats as in victory. As subjective as Roberts was before, he´ll do it again. The whole subsidy concept is laughable, especially applied to ACA. It might as well be a rebate on a Ford Pinto or Chevy truck with the side saddle gas tanks.
All the states had a high risk pool for uninsured with preexisting conditions. As part of ACA (Obamacare) a federal pool was created. The enrollment was predicted to reach 625,000 almost immediately, but growth was slow. The federal pool finally reached 100,000 around the first of the year, at which point they realized that the $5 billion might not stretch til 2014. This was the core group for whom Obamacare is a real savings. Somehow the Obamacare PCIP has managed to cost between 3 and 5 times the average cost of the state high risk pools. Now is the time to determine whether we need to continue to have a PCIP (preexisting conditions insurance pool) separate from healthy insured people in Obamacare.
Like most here, I am extremely angry that John Roberts twisted the definitions of "tax" and "penalty" by trying to make them synonymous.
A penalty is punitive and is meant to be a punishment. That doesn´t make it a tax.
A tax, while burdensome to some, is not necessarily meant as punishment. A tax is a method of collecting a small sum of money from everyone to maintain things all citizens enjoy.
There are exceptions, though. When a person drives on a toll road, every vehicle has to pay the "toll" to use that road - it doesn´t matter how wealthy or poor the driver is. The toll is not meant to be punitive, it is merely a way to pay for the road over a period of years. The toll is generally a small charge and isn´t likely to bankrupt those who drive on the toll road.
However, if a driver decides he/she doesn´t want to pay to drive on said toll road and there is another road that will get the driver to the same place he is going, then the driver is free to make that choice. Just because the "other" road might not be as well maintained or might take a little longer to get to the final destination, the driver can make the choice to not pay the "toll" and to go the different route.
There is no penalty in not using the toll road. But in not buying health insurance, the non-buyer will be punished - small penalty for first year of not buying, but in ever-increasing amounts in subsequent years. Finally the non-buyer will either relent or he will go to the new debtor´s prison.
I would not get to excited about this ruling by a District Judge to allow the lawsuit to go forward as that does not mean that he will rule against the Obama crew in the end. Anyway it will take a long time for this to reach the US Supreme Court which would then have to accept the case. In the meantime look for the Obama crew to get the law changed and make all this moot.
Sorry for another comment, but just wanted to respond to #19´s rather defeatist comment: Suppose they dropped the ACA tomorrow...claimed it a failure or unconstitutional. THEN what? The Ins. companies have already retooled their policies, sent their "we´re sorry" letters, etc..
I imagine the insurance companies can come up with some sort of rollback pricing and opportunities to come back to their company. Once businesses feel a lot more secure that they will be able to continue, they will begin hiring again.
My point is, first and foremost, to have a "can do" attitude about our good fortune if the ACA is declared a failure or unconstitutional. We must think like Winston Churchill:
"A pessimist sees the difficulty in every opportunity; an optimist sees the opportunity in every difficulty.”
"Success is not final...Failure is not fatal...it´s the courage to continue that counts”
and above all:
"Never give in--never, never, never, never, in nothing great or small, large or petty, never give in except to convictions of honor and good sense. Never yield to force; never yield to the apparently overwhelming might of the enemy.”
Since there are far too many liberal judges sitting on the bench, I´m not too excited about this news. For some reason, liberal judges seem to be very happy and pleased to create law from the bench. And I don´t see any of them changing their strips with this one. As such, I´m just going to keep my power dry, buy more ammo, and wait as see what the outcome is.
No worries. If the case should make it to the Supreme Court, John Roberts will just read the litigation through a funhouse mirror, translate it into interpretive dance, and find further justification for raping our Constitution yet again....
I found the law suit and ehre are the re4ference from that law suit (public record)
§ 36B(b)(2)(A) (emphasis added). Therefore there is no premium-assistance subsidy under the Act unless the citizen pays for insurance obtained through a State-established Exchange. Confirming the point, the statute calculates the subsidy by looking to“coverage months,” defined as months in which the taxpayer “is covered by a qualified health plan described in subsection (b)(2)(A) that was enrolled in through an Exchange established bythe State under section 1311 of the Patient Protection and Affordable Care Act .” 26 U.S.C. §36B(c)(2)(A)(i) (emphasis added). Again, unless the citizen has enrolled in a plan through aState-created Exchange established under § 1311 of the ACA
#18 - Re originating in the House...As I recall, the Senate took a resolution passed by the House - I think it had to do with veteran housing - stripped out all the language, then inserted the language of the ACA. This was done because they could not muster 60 votes (Scott Brown) but needed only 51 for reconciliation.
Correct #39 and that is illegal too. Harry reid should be immediately removed from the Senate based on committing an unconstitutional high crime. As to what ever they have on Roberts if anything we the people should grant him immunity that allows him to escape from the Obama blackmail business if he outs that act against him.
Reply 42 - Posted by:
rock n robin, 10/24/2013 10:50:35 AM (No. 9580165)
Maybe this has been dealt with elsewhere, but: Since Roberts declared the penalty to be a tax and tax bills originate in the House, I´m not sure why the Repubs can´t legislate that the penalty=tax will be changed to, say, $10.00 and this amount can never be increased in future years. This might be a way of making the ACA toothless.
Berlin — The shadows deepen and lengthen, memories grow dim, and some of the survivors of the tragedies of World War II scramble to preserve the recollections before the colors fade to gray. There’s no shortage of ghosts prowling the cities and countryside of Europe. Remembrances of monstrous evil lie all about. None have tried harder than the progeny of the Germans who started it all to learn from the past, and recall without flinching the scourge and stain on history that is still unfathomable three-quarters of a century later. An exhibit of photographs of the Nazi era, with the
Amid workers alleging union-busting by an NBC Universal-owned company, MSNBC’s prime-time host Chris Hayes recently met privately with a group of them to hear their concerns, according to several people present at the meeting. Hayes is one of five prime-time MSNBC hosts – along with Rachel Maddow, Al Sharpton, Lawrence O’Donnell and Ed Schultz – whose support the Writers Guild of America–East is seeking in an ugly labor struggle with Peacock Productions, which is owned by NBC Universal and has produced programming for MSNBC. A petition posted by the AFL-CIO and hosted by MoveOn.org
No one can argue with the fact that Paul Ryan’s compromise budget bill raises taxes and increases spending. Show me one Republican who got elected on that platform. Spare America the Orwellian word games. If the government is taking money out of your pocket to fund its growing Big Brother operations, it’s a tax. Whether money is taken from you via your phone bill, your airline ticket, or your income, it’s a tax. If politicians can’t be honest about this, it’s time to go home. The TEA Party’s very acronym stands for “Taxed Enough Already.” We sent these politicians to Congress
New enrollment figures show health-insurance exchanges nationwide are attracting more customers, but the Obama administration said that it has more work to do to get enough younger, healthy people into the system. The administration said Wednesday that as of Nov. 30, nearly 365,000 people nationwide had selected private health plans in the exchanges created by the Affordable Care Act—sharply up from October, but still far from the seven million level officials are hoping to achieve by March 31. Health and Human Services Secretary Kathleen Sebelius faced renewed criticism of the health-care law´s rollout at a House hearing Wednesday. Republicans suggested the plans
New York — Big Brother could be at your favorite store. As CBS 2´s Don Champion reported, a growing number of stores are using discrete and sophisticated technology — including mannequins with facial-recognition cameras hidden in their eyes — to track shopper demographics in an effort to boost sales. Retailers say the marketing data technology allows them to cater their business to customers better, but it’s also raising privacy concerns. Alfonso Perez built a system called Shopperception that Walmart has utilized. It uses motion-sensored cameras to track a shopper’s product choice on a shelf and the time it takes to make a
The new debt run up by the federal government since House Speaker John Boehner cut his first spending deal with President Barack Obama has now topped $3 trillion—exceeding all the debt accumulated under all American presidents from George Washington through Ronald Reagan. Boehner became speaker in January 2011, after the Republicans won a majority of the House of Representatives in the 2010 elections. He cut his first spending deal with President Barack Obama on March 1, 2011, and that deal took effect after March 4, 2011 when the continuing resolution then funding the government expired. Since then, the federal
Moscow - Speak Russian or be silent. Nationalist lawmakers want to ban foreign languages at the workplace - a rule that would leave some foreigners speechless, from menial laborers from former Soviet states to Western business executives in suits and ties. Two deputies from flamboyant ultranationalist Vladimir Zhirinovsky´s party introduced a bill on Thursday that would bar Russians and foreigners from speaking foreign languages on the job during working hours, state-run RIA news agency reported. It cited a summary of the proposal as saying that many foreigners do not know Russian and "speak amongst themselves in their own language
Pyongyang, North Korea — North Korea said Friday that it had executed Kim Jong Un´s uncle as a traitor for trying to seize supreme power, a stunning end for the leader´s former mentor, long considered the country´s No. 2. In a sharp reversal of the popular image of Jang Song Thaek as a kindly uncle guiding leader Kim Jong Un as he consolidated power, the North´s official Korean Central News Agency indicated that Jang instead saw the death of Kim´s father, Kim Jong Il, in December 2011 as an opportunity to challenge his nephew and win power. Jang had been tried and
By the early 2020s, we will have the means to program our biology away from disease and aging. Up until recently, health and medicine was basically a hit or miss affair. We would discover interventions such as drugs that had benefits, but also many side effects. Until recently, we did not have the means to actually design interventions on computers. All of that has now changed, and will dramatically change clinical practice by the early 2020s. We now have the information code of the genome and are making exponential gains in modeling and simulating the information processes they give rise to. We also have
Uruguay has become the first country in the world to make it legal to grow, sell and consume marijuana. After nearly 12 hours of debate, senators gave the government-sponsored bill their historic final approval. The law allowing registered Uruguayans over 18 to buy up to 40g (1,4oz) of the drug a month is not expected to come into force before April. The government hopes it will help tackle drug cartels, but critics say it will expose more people to drugs. Dozens of supporters of the bill proposed by the left-wing President Jose Mujica gathered outside the Congress in Montevideo to follow the vote. Presenting the
Nelson Mandela was an important man, a public man of native gravitas, certainly a patient man, and maybe a great man as our age measures greatness. It’s too soon to know. We’ll have to wait until we can get Mandela without the tears. It’s a characteristic of our age that we swing to and fro in measuring men, causes and events. An honorable death sometimes grants heads of state, kings, princesses, politicians and aspiring potentates a temporary idolatry that becomes embarrassing only later. Assassinations are a category unique, of course. John F. Kennedy, in the days following his death, was widely acclaimed
Ben Affleck might seem like a political junkie, but the actor appears to have soured on the political system. Asked by Playboy magazine to explain how he came about his interest in politics, Affleck said: “I grew up in a house with a mother who was a teacher and a Freedom Rider—very left-wing Democrats living in a heterogeneous working-class neighborhood. I picked up a lot of those values there, and I brought them with me when I showed up in Hollywood.” Affleck talked about having a connection to the presidential campaigns for former Vice President Al Gore and then-Sen. John Kerry —
New York — The anchor who might beat Bill O’Reilly gets her eyelash extensions applied one at a time, with tweezers and dabs of glue, about 90 minutes before showtime, right after a motorized gun sprays foundation over her face, neck, shoulders, collarbone and sternum, wiping out a galaxy of light freckles that spreads across her — Let me stop you right there. Photos of the day Uruguay legalizes marijuana, Kiev police pull back from protesters, aging U.S. prison population and more. Tuesday´s Photos of the day Would you write this way about a man? About O’Reilly himself? At least that’s what Megyn Kelly might ask at
In August 2013 I became very sick with what I thought was a cold. After a few days I lost vision in my left eye and I checked into the hospital. I soon found out that what I thought was a summer cold was actually Strep bacteria poisoning my blood stream. The bacteria blinded my left eye, ate a hole through my heart, caused five strokes on both sides of my brain and forced the removal of my prosthetic left knee. Dr. Lee was the surgeon assigned to perform open heart surgery. What was originally scheduled to last four hours ended
The health director who approved the release of President Obama’s birth certificate has died in a plane crash, Hawaiian officials said Thursday. Loretta Fuddy died after the Cessna Grand Caravan aircraft she was travelling on went down shortly after leaving Kalaupapa Airport at around 3:15 p.m. local time (10:15 a.m. ET) on Wednesday. The other eight people on board were rescued, Richard Schuman, president of Makani Kai Air, told NBC News early Thursday, adding that that there was no indication as to why the plane had crashed. Fuddy hit the headlines two years ago when she approved a waiver request allowing Obama to
Fox News host Megyn Kelly has made herself the center of a racial controversy by declaring that Jesus Christ and Santa Claus are white. On Wednesday night, Kelly was responding to an article by Slate writer Aisha Harris, who wrote an article entitled “ Santa Claus Should Not Be a White Man Anymore .” The popular news host told viewers of “The Kelly File,” her hit FNC program, “When I saw this headline, I kinda laughed and I said, ‘Oh, this is ridiculous. Yet another person claiming it´s racist to have a white Santa.’ And by the way, for all you kids
Views of the tea party are at all-time lows in a new poll, as primary challenges to establishment Republicans continue to heat up Washington. Just 30 percent of Americans view the tea party favorably in a new Gallup poll released Wednesday, the movement’s lowest point since Gallup began polling about it during its rise in 2010. Also in a first, a majority of Americans had an unfavorable view of the tea party, at 51 percent. Similar numbers of respondents described themselves as proponents or opponents of the tea party: Twenty-two percent identified themselves as tea party supporters, while 24 percent said they
Columnist Charles Krauthammer attacked new Obamacare rules unveiled by HHS Secretary Kathleen Sebelius in a late Thursday conference call, saying the Obama administration is “approach[ing] banana republic lawlessness” by issuing the decrees. Krauthammer spoke with Fox News’ Bret Baier on a panel with Juan Williams and Judge Andrew Napolitano, as the three reacted to Sebelius’ new directives for insurance companies. “This is exactly a reaction to a deep understanding among Democrats that [Obamacare] is a train wreck,” he said. “And it’s a panic reaction. As the judge said, this is utterly lawless. This now approaches banana republic lawlessness.
WASHINGTON – It’s not exactly a ringing endorsement of the budget deal.“Embrace the suck,” House minority leader Rep. Nancy Pelosi told fellow Democrats Thursday morning, a source told Politico.“We need to get this off the table so we can go forward,” she added. It’s a way of telling her colleagues the budget deal negotiated with Republicans is the best they can get. Democrats are fuming that the bipartisan budget deal doesn’t extend unemployment benefits for more than a million Americans. One of Pelosi’s top lieutenants, Rep. Chris Van Hollen, the top Democrat on the House Budget Committee, said Thursday it
THE Internet has been abuzz over the spectacle of President Obama and the prime ministers of Britain and Denmark snapping a photo of themselves — a “selfie,” to use the mot du jour — with a smartphone at the memorial service for Nelson Mandela in South Africa on Tuesday. Leaving aside whether it was appropriate, the moment captured the democratization of image making that is a hallmark of our gadget-filled, technologically rich era. Manifestly undemocratic, in contrast, is the way Mr. Obama’s administration — in hypocritical defiance of the principles of openness and transparency he campaigned on — has systematically tried
If you go down on the ice today you´re sure of a big surprise - a rare glimpse of 20 polar bears gorging on a bloody midnight feast. These photographs show a rare cluster of males, females and cubs all dining out on the remains of a whale carcass. They spent a night and a day stripping every last morsel from the mammoth sea creature. Usually Polar bears are solitary and would never tolerate being so close to each other. But with food in plentiful supply and bellies dragging on the floor they seem too lethargic to fight.Wildlife photographer Michal
Fearing that many people will think they have health insurance coverage when they do not, Health and Human Services Secretary Kathleen Sebelius is "urging" insurance companies to "give consumers additional time to pay their first month´s premium and still have coverage beginning Jan. 1, 2014." Insurance companies should cover people who haven´t yet paid, in other words. With just a few weeks to go until Obamacare takes full effect, Sebelius announced additional changes on Thursday, some that tell insurance companies how to run their business and others that "strongly" encourage insurance companies to waive their rules -- on premium payments,
The Sexiest Man Alive is being enlisted to spice up Obamacare. Pop singer Adam Levine, who won the designation from People magazine last month, is among the celebrities who’ll be promoting enrollment in online health insurance exchanges as part of a social media campaign kicking off tomorrow. With enrollment totals behind administration projections after the botched start-up of the federal exchange, 17 state exchanges joined by an advocacy group are drawing on Obama administration allies in entertainment and sports to promote sign-ups, using social media such as Facebook and Twitter. Reprising a tactic President Barack Obama successfully employed in his 2012 re-election, organizers
A South African government minister has said that "a mistake happened" in the hiring of a sign language interpreter accused of gesticulating nonsense during the Nelson Mandela memorial service. Hendrietta Bogopane-Zulu said that officials have tried to track down the company that provided Thamsanqa Jantjie but that the owners "have vanished into thin air". Earlier on Thursday Jantjie claimed he is qualified but was hallucinating and hearing voices and said he is receiving treatment for schizophrenia. Millions of TV viewers saw Jantjie interpreting speeches by Barack Obama and other global leaders at the FNB stadium in Johannesburg. His gestures baffled and angered deaf