A Pennsylvania woman has appealed to the state Supreme Court in her suit against a home seller and real estate agent who failed to disclose that a murder-suicide had taken place in the home she purchased. When Janet Milliken, 59, moved from California after her husband died, she had hoped to start a new life with her two teenage children in Pennsylvania near her family. She bought a home in Thornton, Pa., for $610,000 in June 2007. She learned a few weeks after she moved in from a next-door neighbor that a murder-suicide had occurred the year before
Comments: She could have claimed it was haunted a la The Amityville Horror.
Reply 9 - Posted by:
get er done, 1/28/2013 7:59:10 PM (No. 9145199)
Will this case motivate home buyers to ask if anyone has died (or been murdered) in a home they intend to purchase? If a home is very old, it is more likely that a previous owner/resident died within the home, as people tended to die at home in their beds in the old days. Women also gave birth at home, and some died in childbirth. Newborns occasionally died in or soon after childbirth.
In the 80´s my daughter became friends with a kid who had just moved to our town from CA. We were discussing home values in Missouri vs. California and he said they were only paying $600 a month for an apartment before they moved because someone was murdered in the bathtub. I probably couldn´t do something like that. We had to give our little dog a tranquilizer pill so we could take her to the vet to be put down and when I came back home, I had to remove the rug she had layed on when she went to sleep because I kept seeing her there in my mind´s eye.
Some states require that the seller disclose if the house is alleged to be haunted. The first--and to date, only--house I ever bought was 125 years old at the time of purchase. (They don´t build them like that anymore.) I assume, given its age, that people died in the house, may have been laid out in what they would have called the parlor, and were born in the house. So? It´s life. It´s history.
Several months after I bought my house in 1997 one of my neighbors informed me that the previous owner had shot himself in the house. I don´t remember even wondering about such a thing happening in the house when I was sealing the deal. It was an elderly couple who had lived there and I understand the husband was quite ill and could no longer garden and move about, so he took his life. Anyway, a realtor friend told me in our state it was up to me to ask and then the seller would have to reveal the information, otherwise, caveat emptor regined. I never felt any bad juju until the day I began redoing the basement which had been this old man´s favorite place. As I was scraping paint off of the stairwell, a can of soup fell from a shelf in the pantry and made its way down the stairs toward me. Kinda wierd. No reason for the can Never felt anything after that. Was he pleased with the redo or not?
In California, it must be disclosed at the time of listing if someone has died in the house. But believe it or not, they have an exemption if someone died in the house due to AIDS. I´m not making it up.
It might be required in California but I am pretty sure that it is not a required disclosure by a seller under Pennsylvania law. She could have engaged her own buyers´ agent and directed him to research the history of the house and perhaps discovered what happened there, if its something she was concerned about. But if she did not ask, I don´t think the seller is obligated to tell her. I wouldn´t want to live in a house with that history, but she could have done some due diligence.
If the objection is of a spiritual nature, I believe most faiths have a way of sending a bad mojo on its way. Usually it is a blessing of some kind on the house, combined with something spirits find distasteful (like burning sage). It can get very elaborate sometimes but usually works. I bet if she found a local clergy type they would be willing to help her with that.
Under Georgia´s stimatized property law, the seller is not obligated to disclose such an event, UNLESS the buyer asks, and then they are required to tell the truth. Article states that Pennsylvania law does not demand disclosure. Why is she still fighting this after the appeals court ruled against her? At this point, her lawyer is the one making money here, not her.
Look, the woman did not do any research. She could have found out on the internet that the home had only been owned for a very short time and that would have led to her questioning why the price rose so much. At least then she wouldn´t have overpaid. But that was on her. PA doesn´t require such disclosures and a court shouldn´t add requirements to the law that aren´t there.
I was raised in an old NY house that had a history of one spouse shooting the other. The patched bullet holes were judged "really neat" by my high school buddies. Get a life, lady. You should have stayed in Kalifornia.
People die in houses all the time from natural causes. However, when it´s not a natural cause, I think the buyer is entitled to know what went on there. It should be disclosed by the seller or his agent. Therefore, I´m on the side of Janet here.
When hubby and I were househunting last year, while we were looking at a possible home, a neighbor chatted with my hubby. Based on what neighbor said, hubby then checked the police records in that community for the past 10 years. Turns out that not only had a murder-suicide happened there, but the house was also a drug house. Needless to say, we did not buy. I can understand this lady. Based on my own experiences, I would not want to live in a house where recent incidents like that happened.
When money is involved, sellers and agents both have agendas that aren´t in the buyers best interest. Always Always Always do your research. You might get a big surprise if you don´t.
SOUTH ORANGE, N.J. -- The victim of a vicious knockout attack in New Jersey is speaking out for the first time. He was cold-cocked, and hit not just with a fist, but with a glove with hard plastic knuckles. Two of the four attackers are still on the run. "All of a sudden, I was trying to watch my back and these two came around front and punches my face," the victim said. The 36-year-old restaurant worker does not want his name or face on television, and who could blame him? He still has headaches from a concussion and six
Sears stock plummeted Wednesday as news came out that Edward Lampert, its stubborn billionaire chairman and CEO, had to surrender majority control of the 120-year-old big box retailer when investors in Lampert’s hedge fund pulled money out. With no end in sight for Lampert’s quixotic turnaround efforts, it’s time to question whether there’s any way to save Sears as long as he remains in charge. (Snip) Lampert began at Sears with the ill-fated $12 billion merger with Kmart in 2005. Sales have declined for 27 straight quarters and the company’s stock is down over 70% from its high in 2007.
The Internal Revenue Service (IRS) has no system in place to prevent fraud when individuals apply for tax credits under Obamacare, according to the Treasury Inspector General for Tax Administration (TIGTA). The IG said in an audit released Tuesday that the IRS has no plan to manage, monitor, or mitigate fraud risk when processing premium tax credits available under the Affordable Care Act (ACA). “The ACA Program has not yet completed a fraud mitigation strategy,” the audit found. “It is important for the IRS to thoroughly consider fraud threats and risks that could impact new ACA systems.” Politico reports: The
Around 100,000 Americans successfully signed up for health insurance in November through the troubled federal online marketplace, HealthCare.gov, a person familiar with the preliminary data confirmed to ABC News. The figure reflects a surge in enrollment as software and hardware fixes to the site were made over the course of the month. In October, only 26,000 people could successfully enroll in Obamacare plans, according to the Department of Health and Human Services. "We´ve been working 24/7 to make improvements, and more consumers are successfully shopping online and enrolling in a health plan each week," Health and Human Services Secretary
NEW HAVEN >> The jail cell death last weekend of Yale University professor Samuel See, known as a brilliant writer and rising star in academia, has shaken up the tight-knit college community. Now adding to the mystery of his unexpected death are apparent connections between the online profiles of See and several escort service websites that include a cache of sexually explicit photos. At least four websites advertising male escort services included a phone number connected to See. The website Ryan Cochran Escort Services includes the same phone number listed on an order of protection filed against See in September.
For many Ann Arborites, Thanksgiving is a day devoted to giving thanks, spending time with family, eating turkey and watching the Detroit Lions. This year, retail giants want that to change. (Snip) The early openings change the game for retail giants looking to boost profits through aggressive holiday sales. It also means millions of retail employees in the U.S. are working on the holiday, and it poses the question to consumers: Is a bargain on a 70-inch television or an Apple iPad worth ditching Thanksgiving dinner? “You couldn’t pay me to stand in a line in the cold on Thanksgiving
Macy´s Inc and a slew of other U.S. retailers are opening on Thanksgiving for the first time ever in a bare-knuckled brawl for a bigger slice of overall holiday sales. But it might not be so easy to lure most Americans from their turkey and football - particularly if the weather is foul. Department store rivals Kohl´s Corp and J.C. Penney Co Inc led a string of Thanksgiving opening announcements after Macy´s said it would open its U.S. stores on the popular holiday, ending a 155-year tradition. Sales trends, survey results and an online "Save Thanksgiving" backlash suggest that shoppers
The question all week long was this: Who are you going to believe, an illegal alien or the president of the United States of America? Obviously, if it’s a president who once went by an alias, Barry Soetoro, you go with Uncle Omar, 100 percent, no questions asked. And so it was that the White House finally admitted to another, uh, misstatement — despite previous denials, Barack/Barry did sleep on his beloved Uncle Omar’s couch in Cambridge when he first moved here to attend Harvard Law School (speaking of which, we’re still waiting to see the president’s grades and his LSAT scores). But the
More young men in California rise in pitch at the end of their sentences when talking, new research shows. This process is known as "uptalk" or "valleygirl speak" and has in the past been associated with young females, typically from California or Australia.But now a team says that this way of speaking is becoming more frequent among men.The findings were presented at the Meeting of the Acoustical Society of America in California. "We found use of uptalk in all of our speakers, despite their diverse backgrounds in socioeconomic status, ethnicity, bilingualism and gender," said Amanda Ritchart, a linguist at the University of
How do you get your arms around the catastrophe known as Obamacare? Is it even possible? At this point, I’m not sure it is. The list of individual disasters which threaten to ruin one-sixth of the U.S. economy and what has been, up until now, the best healthcare system in the world is exhaustive, and exhausting. The examples I will identify here barely scratch the surface. First but by no means foremost, we have the supposedly new and improved HealthCare.gov. Except it’s not, even the visible part. Stories still abound of people still failing to get in or to get through the enrollment
The National Highway Traffic Safety Administration has announced a new five-year strategic plan to improve safety for elderly drivers and passengers. Although they are statistically among the safest on the road, the number of older drivers is increasing dramatically — and with it, that group´s numbers of injuries and deaths. Since 2003, the population of older adults, defined as age 65 and older, has increased by 20% and the number of licensed older drivers increased by 21% to 35 million in 2012, according to NHTSA. Last year, NHTSA reported that 5,560 people older than 65 died and 214,000 were injured
Barack Obama did not tell the whole story this autumn when he tried to make the case that Bashar al-Assad was responsible for the chemical weapons attack near Damascus on 21 August. In some instances, he omitted important intelligence, and in others he presented assumptions as facts. Most significant, he failed to acknowledge something known to the US intelligence community: that the Syrian army is not the only party in the country’s civil war with access to sarin, the nerve agent that a UN study concluded – without assessing responsibility – had been used in the rocket attack. In the months before the attack,
Dr. Ezekiel Emanuel, the hapless, goalpost-shifting so-called "architect" of Obamacare, told Fox News´ Chris Wallace on Fox News Sunday that President Barack Obama´s promise "if you like your doctor, you can keep your doctor" was absolutely true--with one important caveat: if you like your doctor, "you can pay for it." Wallace grilled Dr. Emanuel, challenging his false claims that California´s enrollment was keeping pace with the percentage of the young population necessary to keep the system afloat, and pointing out that the president´s promise on doctors would collapse once people lost their insurance or their
President Barack Obama’s Facebook page on Saturday posted a message honoring the dead from Pearl Harbor—accompanied by a picture of Obama descending the stairs next to the Pearl Harbor Memorial. The picture barely fits the name of the Arizona Memorial so it can frame Obama in the foreground. The post´s statement reads: Today, with solemn pride and reverence, let us remember those who fought and died at Pearl Harbor, acknowledge everyone who carried their legacy forward, and reaffirm our commitment to upholding the ideals for which they served. President Obama The Obama Administration´s current shipbuilding plan shrinks the size of