The Benghazi debacle may yet make Mitt Romney president. Barely 10 days before the election, the persistent whiff of scandal surrounding Barack Obama exploded into the banner headlines of a cover-up – at least among certain press outlets. Everything changed Friday afternoon with the stunning revelations by Fox News that CIA operatives defending the embattled consulate in Benghazi, Libya, called three times for emergency assistance while the attack was in progress. Each time, they were shamefully turned down. One of those defenders, Navy SEAL Tyrone Woods, was apparently able to use a laser designator to pin-point
Three Urgent Requests for Military Back-Up Denied: Does Public Deserve to Know Who Told CIA Operators to 'Stand Down' During Benghazi Attack?
I believe each and every one of us should be hitting as many news outlets' websites as possible and make comments - even copy some of the wonderful comments on this page - I think every one of us should do this every day until the election results are announced. I think we should absolutely drown them in our comments - leave no doubt what we think of this travesty.
I believe we should be blistering to every comment that flatters the Administration until we KNOW what was and was not done and said. And I believe politeness has left us forever because no one in DC has earned one teeny bit of politeness.
Media must have SOME value. There will be more people hear us if we bang on THEIR door, and especially if we continually bang without letup.
Thank you for posting, OP. IMO, this should be a must read. One of the most shameful episodes in the history of this Country and yet the so-called "msm" refuses to report on it. The "press" will not question him because they are slavish-worshippers of all-things-obama and must protect the legacy of their cowardly-anti-American-commander-in-chief... Is there ANY doubt that President Bush would NOT have left our people to die at the hands of savages? Thank Heaven for heroes like Col. Allard who are speaking out.
"Now is the time for all good men (and women) to come to the aid of their country".
If it be true that calls for help went unheeded, if it be true that there has been a lie a day about the emerging "details", if its true that Moochelle is asking people to vote early before this dishonorable act has time to sink in and this shameless person is reelected with a distortion or denial of lying about the facts, then he should be removed from office.
I used to think the "Staged Consulate kidnapping" theory was just too way out there. But the more the facts roll in, and the events that transpired that night are unveiled, the more I must give such a scandal much higher levels of plausibility. This reminds me of the "The Incredibles" animated movie where the villain creates his own major fiendish villains so he can fly in as the hero and savior of mankind.
Why else would someone who'd probably sacrifice his own children to remain in power do something so STUPID!
Where are our flag officers? Congress? Are the only military willing to speak out and condemn this abandonment of our prople retired? Isn't there a single Patton or MacArthur left among our generals and admirals, willing to speak the truth instead of save his career? This is the most unconscionable action by our President and Pentagon and CIA I've ever seen. And no one, except a few retired military have the guts to call it what it is...dereliction of duty by our Commander in Chief.
You will not see/hear anything about this on ABC, CBS or NBC is my guess because it makes little barry look so bad. He would rather let Americans die than unleash the AC-130 gunship to kill a bunch of Muslim terrorists and have to admit his Middle East policy is a failure. What kind of American would act like this? Only one who is not really an American in spirit and one who has no soul.
"The president keeps trying to cover up his mistakes, and the press establishment is determined to look away, despite the cascading contradictions. Fortunately, Fox News, derided by the media establishment as Faux News, investigated what others ignored. And on a Friday afternoon, just when we were contemplating hurricanes, World Series and a deadlocked electoral race, they may have even changed American history."
The LSM and Obozo have smeared at FOX News. I'll bet they have more contempt for them now for their honest journalism than before. Jennifer Gtiffin and Catherine Herridge deserve Emmy's for their work in exposing this major coverup.
Petraeus is on Meet The Press this morning. Now that Obama has blamed the military for the Stand Down order... and articles like this & the NY Post have surfaced, I hope he defends his beloved troops and tells all.
Disturbing similarities with the disaster at the Little Big Horn, where Custer and his command were wiped out in 1876 by an overwhelming enemy force. No help came, and Congressional investigations followed.
My hope is that under a new administration, someone makes a movie about this. This story needs to be told. I cannot think of two more heroic men than the two Seals. They left safety to aid fellow Americans not only knowing they were outnumbered, but that they would be stripped of rank and ruined by politically correct officers if they survived.
...this just in...from burned-out, liberal "entertainer", old Neil Young...who bravely wrote "Ohio" when Nixon was president (...but forgot to write a song when clinton 's hacks burned alive 77 men , women , and children in Waco....???)...
Ten parties and fun in Vegas So many celebs to see Al qaeda in Libya killing Four dead in Benghazi
Gonna get down to it Media covering his a** It's clear he doesn't know what to do What if you knew them And found them dead on the grass How can you vote for the fool?
3 AM and the phone is ringing He's gotta get back to sleep Have to play golf with Clooney Four dead in Benghazi
Gonna get down to it Start projecting the lies Blaming it all on You Tube Looks like he knew it And ignored all their cries How can you vote for the fool?
I sent the following to every local paper I know, here in MN and back home in Iowa:
"Our press has become so terribly biased that they'd see the country go down in flames before standing up to democrats. I'm including a link to an excellent article on the Bengazi nightmare written by Col. Ken Allard.
Here's a stunning line: "Each time, they were shamefully turned down. One of those defenders, Navy SEAL Tyrone Woods, was apparently able to use a laser designator to pin-point the location of the mortar that eventually killed him. It would have been an easy shot for American pilots had any been ordered to respond."
This administration stood by and let these brave Americans be slaughtered, even though we had resources, eager and capable, that could have stopped this. How do these people sleep at night?
If they were willing to let this go down, what else are they capable of? Why does the DHS have 1.4 billion rounds of ammo? Why is NASA now a muslim outreach program? Walks like a duck, quacks like a duck, might be a duck. The press is supposed to inform the public, not deceive it. The truth please, if not now, when? When it's too late? You live in the same country we do, and one of the first things totalitarians do is eliminate free press, oops, as if we have one. And, in AMERICA. How very sad and shameful."
I did commend the DesMoines Register for endorsing Romney.
My son was a drone operator while he was in the Army. Two tours Iraq, one Afrcrapistan. Those are real people flying those drones and I would not be surprised if somehow someway somehow some day this story comes out of the frustration of watching our brave heroes being attacked and not being able to assist.
I keep thinking that when Obama went to bed on 9/11/2012 he was thinking everything was going according to plan--Ambassador Stevens had been kidnapped. In the morning he discovered Stevens was actually dead.
Every time I hear Panetta say they wouldn't send more people ''into harm's way'' without more intelligence, it infuriates me. Isn't that what the military is all about? They do go into harm's way when needed. What if the NYC firemen said at the first 9/11 that they wouldn't go into harm's way to rescue people?
Don't forget to give Bret Baer from Fox New credit for his work on this. Bless the people there who are delving into the betrayal of those men who died.
This is making me physically sick. Yesterday I sent emails to all the networks and CNN. I demanded that they accurately and fairly cover this story. I urge everyone who feels the President and his minions are responsible for the death of these men do the same. Those Navy SEALS knew they were going to die and fought to the end. God bless them and their families.
It was a cloudy and windy day and I watched a lot of Fox News yesterday. Everybody to a person, with the exception of that obnoxious Alan Colmes, was UPset about the new details. Pat Caddell was furious, the woman liberal on the press show with John Scott? had nothing good to say and even argued a bit with Alan. He interrupted everyone the whole show so he knew he was defending the indefensible. There were military people on various shows and they were not holding back.
People have started openly declaring obama a liar and not mincing words. And, it's about time. This should not end if they lose the election and we have to make sure our Congresscritters don't allow it to end. This is one obama CANNOT get away with, not this time.
0bama is not a leader; he likes to brag about killing Osama Bin Laden, but he used intelligence gathered by water boarding (which he vehemently opposed), and he walked off the golf course to watch the seals go in and shoot Osama in the eye. Yet, when he is called upon to be a real leader and save an ambassador and three Navy seals, he is afraid to give the order. He probably worried that if it went badly, it would affect his reelection chances. No, 0bama shows no leadership qualities at all.
I finally heard a woman call in on Cspans Washington Journal and say that bammy should be impeached for the Benghazi disaster. She really ripped obama a new one and rightly so. How is it that the media so studiously ignores this and how do they get away with it?
Seemed like an out-there conspiracy paranoia but increasingly seems likely that the "Kidnap In Benghazi to trade for the blind Sheikh" plot was unfolding and brave Tyrone Wood was gumming up the works. This is high treason. No other word for it.
Benghazi is going viral on Facebook. People all over the country are posting articles and links for family and friends. Word IS getting out. Ironic how Facebook is figuring in this story. We must spread the word by any means possible to defeat Obama on November 6th.
Why would Obama and Biden do such a thing? Because to launch a military operation against an al-Qaida affiliate on the anniversary of 9/11 would have exposed the hollowness of their boast through convention week and the days thereafter – that Osama was dead, and al-Qaida was finished. And so Ty Woods, Glen Doherty, Sean Smith and Chris Stevens were left to die, and a decision taken to blame an entirely irrelevant video and, as Secretary Clinton threatened, "have that person arrested." And, in the weeks that followed, the government of the United States lied to its own citizens as thoroughly and energetically as any totalitarian state, complete with the midnight knock-on-the-door from not-so-secret policemen sent to haul the designated fall guy into custody.
This goes far beyond the instinctive secretiveness to which even democratic governments are prone.
The right thing to do today would be for each one from the President down to pack a suitcase and walk out of the WH and wait for impeachment to begin. But that would leave an incompetent VP with no class in charge. Therefore US voters will pack for all of them on November 6. Disgraceful that human beings could watch the murder of four Americans for hours and refuse help all for political gain and even more disgraceful is a MSM that would cover for them by pretending it didn't happen.
The media are colluding with this vile administration and are responsible for holding the truth hostage along with aiding in a cover up of this horrific scandal. We are tired of them shoveling out lies and distortions, especially when acts of terror have been committed. They are stonewalling the people from the knowing the truth. Thank God for FOX. Wouldn't it be great to see the Press prosecuted to the fullest extent of the law? One can dream.
Pravda(the press) is in full CYA mode. It's not on the mainland USA so they think they can ignore and cover for the willful disregard for American lives serving their country bravely exhibited by this coward called obama. Thank God for alternatives to his propaganda machine.
A question for any knowing Ldotters: What, if any, circumstances would allow the taxpayers to kick Zippy off of his perks after he's out of office? (Secret Service detail for life, retirement ? benefits, etc.) Would a successful impeachment do it? (not that I think the GOP could get that job done)
The only coherent timeline on the heroic fight and Betrayal in Benghazi I have found: http://www.powerlineblog.com/archives/2012/10/benghazi-a-reader-assesses-the-evidence.php
The complicit mainstream media promotes the confusion and Obama spins, lies and blame shifts under cover of it. Bottomline is that our soldiers in Benghazi fought for 7 hours, dozens of lives were saved. Support that would have saved Tyrone Woods and Glen Doherty was denied. Someone is lying.
Thanks for posting that link #56.. it is the best Ive seen and very thorough...down to the dress of the terrorist in the much publicized picture. This from one of us.. just someone who took it upon his own to find the truth. Nothing is classified. The MSM keeps forgetting that unlike in times of old.. we have resources to get our information. Pass this article on to you facebook page and to everyone in your contacts.
What this boils down to was that our President made a conscience choice to feed our people to terrorist animals perpetrating an organized attack on our country on the anniversary of 9/11, then blame it on anything but what it really was: A Conscience Choice on his part! Then yet another conscience choice to blame it on US causing this so-called muslim outrage which was nothing but a smoke screen for an armed attack on our country. I think there is a name for that kind of conscience choice! I'm really tired of fabricated, so-called muslim outrage. I'm really tired of fabricated, so-called liberal outrage. I'm really tired of fabricated, so-called Black outrage otherwise known as screaming "Racism" at the drop of a pin, particularly when this President is criticized. What we have here is nothing less that a conscience act of criminal negligence, something to be legitimately outraged about, yet it is all but ignored by the MSM Alphabets. Where is our outrage?
I have wondered why the WH blamed the attack on a video instead of calling it an attack. The answer now seem clear. If they say it was all about a video, the administration can blame America and say we deserved this. If it was an attack, the blame is on the Islamists.
poster 59 is correct. Theople were sacrificed. If one reads the record, Obie went to bed between waves of the attack. Probably told folks not to wake him. Maybe they were just ignored to death, but it was a deliberate thing, their dying. The dems are out of options now, and will have to begin eating each other.
It's clear there is crime taking place in the Obama, Holder, Reid, Puglosi, Jaret, Waxman, commie White House packed full of comrade conspirators. On the outside, protecting all of this terror business is the Diane Sawyer Anderson Cooper, Tom Brokaw TV Traitors to the Truth that keep these crimes out of the public eye. The almost dominating mainstream press, spews the Party Line in ways not unlike Stalin's KGB, Hitler's Goebells censored, restricted totally controlled "news". Tragic times made more tragic by the rich Diane Sawyers.
It should cost Obama, Clinton, Jarrett, hundreds, perhaps thousands, more than an election. They should have no chance for the rest of their lives - some of them very short - to enjoy the lucre they have made selling us out.
The combination of the "consulate" story in Benghazi combined with what is more and more clearly a blown CIA operation, a "Fast and Curious" gun-running operation to the Muslim Brotherhood confederates (aka "freedom fighters") in Syria via Turkey is beginning to peek through the "fog of war" rationalization of incompetence.
We are in the opening moves of the end game of the progressive coup d'etat that has been going on for the last 90 years. Obama is just the hand puppet in the empty suit, but he and his cohorts are not going to go quietly.
There are three possibilities: 1. Obama will win the election and drop any shred of pretense of constitutional government. 2. Obama will recognize that he is going to lose and engineer a dramatic escalation of the Libya fiasco into open war - within the next 10 days! 3. Obama will lose the election and try to accomplish #2 during his lame duck and try to justify refusing to cede the office to Romney on January 20.
In each case the outcome will eventually be decided by our military. We have already seen where the very top brass stand. The sacking of the top general and admiral in the area after Benghazi makes that clear.
Think this is paranoia? Is there a single example of Obama yielding to the constitution on any important point is his first four years?
The recognition that the CIC has abandoned the constitution does not relieve military officers from their own oaths of office. It makes their oath exponentially more binding, and that oath is not to the president - it is to the constitution!
Too bad this SCANDAL isnt being covered by the willing dupe corrupt enemedia hacks who are LAP DOG RUMP SWABS....I despise them as much as I despise what Barry Soetoro stands for AND FOR WHAT COMES OUT OF THE FILTHY MOUTH OF HIS PARTNER JoeBiteMe....They will be defeated and de-elected by the majority of good American voters who will save this country from their Marxist disastrous decisions! Go Mitt! Go Paul! Lets win! And thank you Col. Ken Allard, we need more like you to tell the people what the ass-press stubbornly and politically refuses to do.
Again obama was willing to see 30 Americans murdered. The 4 stayed behind and sacrificed their lives.
30 people dead and obama did not care. He does not care about the 300+ Mexicans or the US border guards or US ranchers killed by weapons he has been selling to the drug dealers either or the coming millions under obamacare where you will be denied medical care as they do in all the other socialist states.
Those who were saved best come out publically and testify.
I wonder why they have not?? Did obama state they will be prosecuted if they do?
55, not pretending to be knowledgeable on this, but I would think it would take special legislation to strip Obama of his perks. Then, of course, he and his army of shysters would just fight it all the way to the SCOTUS.
I haven't posted in a while. Consistently reading my favorite website but too busy to post. This really makes me angry. God bless these brave men who made the ultimate sacrifice. I will be praying for their families. Thanks to a few brave men including Col. Kenn Allard and the folks at FOX news for reporting the flipping truth. I absolutely hate the thought of a rescue being told to "stand down." I want to know who exactly gave those orders. And I want him to be revealed for their cowardice. I'm more convinced now than ever that there is a battle for good versus evil.
Thanks 74 for the info. It really sticks in my craw that obama and "catfish"*** biden will be drawing any sort of benefits from our country after they're gone from office. I'd gladly allow some tax dollars to fund a proper investigation and to purchase a time-share at Leavenworth for them all. ***"Catfish" -- All mouth and no brains.
Reply 2,3 "What sort of person could possibly vote for this president now?"
The sort of person who does not know who he really is and what he has done. Hence, the firewall of silence in the mainstream news media. But no firewall is completely fireproof. And, God is really, really good at bringing down walls. Remember Jericho? He was there when it was built and knew exactly what type of pressure it would take to bring it down. Pray.
"Journalistic Integrity" is an oxymoron when referring to the MSM. Don't look for them to question Barry, or to publish the answers if someone else does their job for them. They are nothing but political hacks. Thank God for Fox News!
This incident is disturbingly similar to what happened to the USS Liberty during the 6 Day War. Look it up if you aren't familiar. The commander of the Liberty sent a coded message that went directly to the WH situation room and the Pentagon,among other places, when his ship was attacked by Israeli AF. The captain of the USS Kitty Hawk had fighters sitting on deck ready to launch, waiting for the command to proceed to come from the WH or the Pentagon. The order was NEVER sent, and dozens of US sailors were killed by our "ally." This, however, sounds like cold blooded murder.
Our government is staffed with traitors, from top to bottom, in the executive branch, and some in the legislative and judicial. It is sickening what is going on, and I'm very angry. I hope I speak for millions.
Today at church as I was passing along the hallway, a guy held up an Etch-a-Sketch left on a bench by a child, and pompously said, "look, this is what Mitt Romney is all about!", and waved it around. I kept on walking, but wish I had stopped and said, "do you assume everyone here agrees with YOU?" I guess he does. Disgusting.
I haven't had a chance to read all the blogs but an idea struck me rather hard. Look at the pictures of the four Americans Obama "allowed" to be killed. Had he unleashed the AC-130 on the attackers how many of the dead would have been muslim? Connect those dots and we have grounds for all sorts of legal activity. Obama is, indeed, a very subtle "card" player. SOB.
Thank you, Col. Allard, for coming forth and telling us what was happening. A great article! I cannot understand how honorable men can tolerate such as goes on within our government. If I worked there, I'd be fired the first day!
Americans who are buying insurance plans over online exchanges, under what is known as Obamacare, will have limited access to some of the nation’s leading hospitals, including two world-renowned cancer centres. Amid a drive by insurers to limit costs, the majority of insurance plans being sold on the new healthcare exchanges in New York, Texas, and California, for example, will not offer patients’ access to Memorial Sloan Kettering in Manhattan or MD Anderson Cancer Center in Houston, two top cancer centres, or Cedars-Sinai in Los Angeles, one of the top research and teaching hospitals in the country. High quality global
Konstantin Kakaes had a lot of good evidence to work with for his article debunking the promise of Amazon’s drone deliveries. The FAA doesn’t allow autonomous flight. Drones are too small and unreliable. They’ll cost Amazon a fortune to maintain and oversee. Kakaes had so many facts in his favor, but he left out a big one: Birds are going to hate these drones.(Snip)The difference for Amazon’s drones is that the birds will be chasing them. Unseen to us, the skies are checkered with fiercely defended bird territories. Open-country raptors—hawks, eagles, kites, harriers, etc.—don’t take kindly to interlopers on their
In a major rant at radio host Sway Calloway this week Kanye West went full tilt against the fashion establishment that is preventing him from unleashing his artistry-in-apparel on the world: “I am Warhol. I am the No. 1 most impactful artist of our generation. I am Shakespeare in the flesh. Walt Disney. Nike. Google. Now, who’s going to be the Medici family and stand up and let me create more? Or do you want to marginalize me til I’m out of my moment?” Dear Kanye Warhol-Shakespeare-Disney-Google-West, So you want to be a fashion designer! You actually did launch a
PHILADELPHIA--A horse pulling a buggy with an Amish family aboard in rural Pennsylvania was struck by a bullet fired from a moving car and later died, police said on Tuesday.(Snip)"At the time, they believed it was a firecracker," Weaver said. "They didn´t realize it was a gunshot." The family continued home, where they realized the animal had been injured. "When they got to the farm, the farmer noticed blood from the horse´s mouth," Weaver said. The horse died before a veterinarian arrived.
The Treasury Department said on Thursday that it would sell its remaining shares in General Motors by year’s end, allowing the government to finally sever ties to the bailed-out automaker a few months sooner than expected.(Snip)Barring a sudden jump in G.M.’s stock price, the government is on track to lose about $10 billion on its investment. So far, it has recovered about $38.4 billion. By contrast, other rescue efforts, including the bailout of the American International Group, have generated profits for taxpayers. But administration officials have long argued that the aim was not to make a profit from its investments
WASHINGTON — A mutiny has erupted among photographers who cover President Obama over what they say is the White House’s increasing practice of excluding them from events involving the president and then releasing its own photos or video.(Snip)“As surely as if they were placing a hand over a journalist’s camera lens,” the three-page letter said, “officials in this administration are blocking the public from having an independent view of important functions of the executive branch of government.” The Obama administration has embraced social media as a way to get its message to the public beyond the traditional news media.
Secretary of State John Kerry just scrapped 190 years of U.S. foreign policy in Latin America, casually declaring the Monroe Doctrine is over.Why didn´t he just ring the dinner triangle for Russia, China, Iran and their terrorist catspaws to set up shop, too? "President James Monroe," Kerry told the Organization of American States in Washington Monday, "declared that the United States would unilaterally, and as a matter of fact, act as the protector of the region... And throughout our nation´s history, successive presidents have reinforced that doctrine and made a similar choice. "Today, however, we have made a different choice. The
New York — The anchor who might beat Bill O’Reilly gets her eyelash extensions applied one at a time, with tweezers and dabs of glue, about 90 minutes before showtime, right after a motorized gun sprays foundation over her face, neck, shoulders, collarbone and sternum, wiping out a galaxy of light freckles that spreads across her — Let me stop you right there. Photos of the day Uruguay legalizes marijuana, Kiev police pull back from protesters, aging U.S. prison population and more. Tuesday´s Photos of the day Would you write this way about a man? About O’Reilly himself? At least that’s what Megyn Kelly might ask at
In August 2013 I became very sick with what I thought was a cold. After a few days I lost vision in my left eye and I checked into the hospital. I soon found out that what I thought was a summer cold was actually Strep bacteria poisoning my blood stream. The bacteria blinded my left eye, ate a hole through my heart, caused five strokes on both sides of my brain and forced the removal of my prosthetic left knee. Dr. Lee was the surgeon assigned to perform open heart surgery. What was originally scheduled to last four hours ended
When I was a kid, I knew two different Santa Clauses. The first had a fat belly, rosy cheeks, a long white beard, and skin as pink as bubble gum. He was omnipresent, visiting my pre-school and the local mall, visible in all of my favorite Christmas specials. Then there was the Santa in my family’s household, in the form of ornaments, cards, and holiday figurines. A near-carbon copy of the first one—big belly, rosy cheeks, long white beard: check, check, check. But his skin was as dark as mine. Seeing two different Santas was bewildering. Eventually I asked my father what
The health director who approved the release of President Obama’s birth certificate has died in a plane crash, Hawaiian officials said Thursday. Loretta Fuddy died after the Cessna Grand Caravan aircraft she was travelling on went down shortly after leaving Kalaupapa Airport at around 3:15 p.m. local time (10:15 a.m. ET) on Wednesday. The other eight people on board were rescued, Richard Schuman, president of Makani Kai Air, told NBC News early Thursday, adding that that there was no indication as to why the plane had crashed. Fuddy hit the headlines two years ago when she approved a waiver request allowing Obama to
House Speaker John Boehner (R-Ohio) snapped at conservative groups that have come out in opposition to the budget deal reached Wednesday between Rep. Paul Ryan (R-Wis.) and Sen. Patty Murray (D-Wash.). "They´re using the American people for their own purposes. This is ridiculous," Boehner said at a press conference with other members of House Republican leadership on Wednesday. Over the past few days, a number of conservative groups have blasted the deal because it sets discretionary spending levels in the budget higher than previous levels under sequestration. In the past three days, the influential Heritage Action, Club for Growth, Americans
Fox News host Megyn Kelly has made herself the center of a racial controversy by declaring that Jesus Christ and Santa Claus are white. On Wednesday night, Kelly was responding to an article by Slate writer Aisha Harris, who wrote an article entitled “ Santa Claus Should Not Be a White Man Anymore .” The popular news host told viewers of “The Kelly File,” her hit FNC program, “When I saw this headline, I kinda laughed and I said, ‘Oh, this is ridiculous. Yet another person claiming it´s racist to have a white Santa.’ And by the way, for all you kids
Views of the tea party are at all-time lows in a new poll, as primary challenges to establishment Republicans continue to heat up Washington. Just 30 percent of Americans view the tea party favorably in a new Gallup poll released Wednesday, the movement’s lowest point since Gallup began polling about it during its rise in 2010. Also in a first, a majority of Americans had an unfavorable view of the tea party, at 51 percent. Similar numbers of respondents described themselves as proponents or opponents of the tea party: Twenty-two percent identified themselves as tea party supporters, while 24 percent said they